So The Duchess Wants To Die - Reviews

So The Duchess Wants To Die
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about Leilia and Carlisle because WOW. This author really knows how to make you feel trapped in the worst relationship ever while also making you obsessed with watching it unfold. I literally sat here fuming for twenty minutes after their confrontation scene. The way Carlisle reduces Leilia to a pet - "A dog without an owner is that much easier to train" - it's infuriating. But what gets me is that this isn't the first time he's treated her like this. We get glimpses into her past life where he apparently played the hero, sweeping in after her fall at a banquet. She thought he was saving her, but really? He was just reinforcing that hierarchy. "Don't make yourself worthless." That's not love, that's ownership. And here's the thing that destroys me - Leilia has literally experienced four lifetimes. Four whole lives of possibly experiencing different outcomes with him, and here she is again, trying to survive. She's detached now, almost clinical about it: "Leilia didn't feel pain so much as a cold, distant curiosity." That line just broke my heart. She's survived so much that she's numbed herself to protect her sanity. Then you have Claudia and Igret on the flip side, and I'm not gonna lie, it made me uncomfortable. On paper, it's the sweet couple - he wipes her tears, she brings him tea, they talk about having a baby. But something feels OFF. The emptiness in Claudia's question about children, the way she smiles through tears like she's performing happiness, the hollow birdcage imagery - it's like the author is whispering "this isn't real" through every page. Meanwhile, back with Leilia and Carlisle, the tension is UNMATCHED. When Timo walks in and Carlisle grabs her by the throat, and Leilia has to watch? That's trauma layered on top of existing trauma. And Carlisle's response when Leilia protests? "Try not to cry—or bark—too much." He's weaponizing her own dehumanization against her. But here's what keeps me coming back - there's this weird intimacy in their power struggle. Even as he tries to break her, she bites back: "You really are a son of a b*tch." She won't let him have total psychological victory. That spark, however small, is why I can't look away. The wedding reception scene where Carlisle puts on this fake display of devotion - wrapping his arm around her, calling her "too pretty" - while Leilia internally checks out? That contrast between public performance and private reality is chef's kiss. I literally gasped when she thought "How could he lie so convincingly without even blinking?" This relationship is toxic, destructive, and I cannot stop thinking about it. Four lifetimes of regression and Leilia still hasn't found peace with this man. What happens next? I need to know.
... Read More
The way this author builds atmosphere is insane. From the very first paragraph, I felt like I was suffocating. The Marquis's icy gaze, the servants bowing and trying to read his mood—that's not just description, that's a whole world of power dynamics compressed into one scene. "The closed door swung open, and countless shadows stretched along the long hallway." I love how the author uses light and shadow to show Leilia's mental state. She's watching from behind, her glazed golden eyes trailing after her father's footsteps like a ghost. She's already dead inside. The attic scene where she prepares the poison is haunting. She's drumming her thin fingers on the table, waiting, humming to herself while uncovering white cloths. The contrast between her manic energy and the dark purpose is chilling. And then the transformation of the liquid—clear to red to blue to black—each color shift marking her descent into despair. The chapter transitions are masterful. One moment she's drinking the poison, burning heat surging down her throat, and the next we're hearing familiar voices. "For the best, for my lady? What are you talking about?" The dialogue bleeds into her waking consciousness before she even opens her eyes. That sensory detail—voices growing clearer as if speaking right beside her—is perfect. The guest room scene with Carlisle is so tense. The once-warm tea going cold, the chill filling the room, his crimson eyes gleaming like a predator. "Slicked-back black hair, squared shoulders with not a wrinkle on his crisp suit, eyes sharp and expressionless, crimson irises devoid of warmth." The author paints him like a villain from a Gothic novel, and that's exactly what he is. But what really struck me was the pocket watch scene. "A pocket watch, rare even within the Empire, glittering faintly against his scarred knuckles under the crisp white shirt." The scars from his mercenary days juxtaposed with aristocratic elegance—this man is a walking contradiction, and the author makes that tangible through objects and setting.
... Read More
There's so much symbolism packed into these chapters that I keep finding new layers every time I reread. Let me start with the most obvious one — the bird figurine. A carved bird, sent as a wedding gift, containing horror inside its hollow chest. Birds traditionally symbolize freedom, song, elevation. This one is all of those things PERVERTED — it's frozen in wood, incapable of song, and instead of carrying something beautiful inside, it harbors death. It's the perfect metaphor for Leilia's situation: she's supposed to be the celebrated bride, the honored duchess, but she's actually a prisoner wearing a gilded cage. And smashing it? That's not just destruction — that's refused complicity. In her previous life, she broke it and saw the curse and broke down sobbing. This time, she recognizes it instantly and smashes it with cold precision. The bird was never meant to sing for her — it was meant to imprison her. Then there's the recurring motif of the number five — 'after five repetitions, something would finally be different.' Five cycles of hell, and the Empire keeps sending the same gift, the same curse, the same betrayal. It's ritualistic. It's fate trying to repeat itself. And Leilia's question at the end — 'Why did it sound so sweet back then?' when Carlisle mocked her during their first intimate encounter — that's about the distortion of memory itself. Time loops don't just repeat events, they reshape how we feel about them. The past becomes unreliable. Hope becomes a trap. And the theme that ties all of this together is the question of agency: in a world where your suffering is scripted and your gifts are curses, what does it mean to choose? Leilia choosing to smash the statue, choosing to negotiate, choosing her reactions — that's her rebellion. Small, quiet, but hers.
... Read More
I've been thinking about this sugar jar scene for hours and I can't stop coming back to it. Leilia standing at the window, the dusk painting the sky, deliberately dropping sugar into her tea. 'With a set expression.' That word haunted me. Set. Like her face is a mask she has to consciously hold in place. And then — Marie brings her the scone. Earl Grey. Warm. Exactly what Leilia used to love before all this. Before the body swap, before everything fell apart. And the text explicitly tells us: 'There was a time when she'd been foolish enough to be taken in by such kindness.' That's not just backstory. That's the entire theme of this novel condensed into one moment. Trust is dangerous. Kindness is a weapon. Even sweet tea can betray you. The Night Rabbit appears again — not literally but as absence, as loss, as something that's been taken and needs to be found. Gridana. The alibu fruit. Liston's territory. Every object in this story seems to point toward something else, like nothing exists on its own. And the body itself — that's the biggest symbol of all. Her body responding to Carlisle's touch while her mind screams in protest. 'Base release' vs. the sophisticated, controlled version of intimacy she tries to perform. Who is she, really, when her body doesn't belong to her mind? The milk tea, the sugar, the scones — all these domestic details that once represented safety and now represent manipulation. That's the rot at the center of everything.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or