Shamilia - Reviews

Shamilia
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in this is so sharp I kept pausing to appreciate it. Let me just start with this exchange: "So what?" "So what?" He mirrors her but the tone is completely different. She's asking because she's confused and deflected. He's asking because he's genuinely challenging her to explain why his declaration should matter to her at all. The repetition with the shift in meaning—that's masterful. And earlier, when he says "I give you money, don't I?" and she replies "You want me to just stay home and wait for you?" and he says "Yes." Two words. That's it. That's the most chilling thing in the entire chapter and it's delivered like it's the most normal conversation ever. The author's voice is doing heavy lifting here too. Look at this line: "Her tongue darted out to moisten her dry lips." That's not dialogue, that's narration, but it tells us more about Shamilia's state than any internal monologue could. The narrative voice knows her body before she knows her mind. Lucberk's dialogue is always direct. Never ornamental. Never beating around the bush. "I love you." "What I'm saying is that every single emotion I can call 'love' is directed at you." He doesn't apologize, doesn't soften, doesn't use metaphors. He states things like facts. That's his voice—absolute, unyielding, terrifyingly clear. Shamilia's voice, by contrast, is full of hedging. "Well, uh..." "Of course." "Naturally." She qualifies everything. She reaches for explanations. Her speech patterns show us a woman trying to maintain control through language while the situation rapidly slips beyond her linguistic grasp.
... Read More
There's this recurring idea that Lucberk's behavior might just be because he's a wizard, and I think that's worth unpacking. Shamilia literally catches herself doing this—trying to brush it off as wizard eccentricity, the same way she'd excuse some odd habit from a customer at the bookstore. "Among their regular customers at the bookstore, many were eccentric in their own way, and in their world, such oddities were often seen as a badge of honor." It's a fascinating deflection. She wants to believe that his brokenness is just another symptom of his magical training, something external and temporary. But the text makes it clear: this isn't wizard craziness. This is something deeper and more personal. The wizards did go mad from magic—there's even a passing mention of it—but Lucberk seems more lucid than most. His logic is internally consistent, just morally incomprehensible. The isolation theme is huge too. Twice now the text circles back to the fact that it's only the two of them. "It's because you don't need anyone else but me." "And I don't need anyone else but you." This repeated emphasis on their solitude isn't accidental worldbuilding—it's the whole engine of the conflict. They've been each other's entire world since childhood, and that codependency has curdled into something toxic. The fact that he frames it as destiny rather than recognizing it as an unhealthy enmeshment says everything. And then there's the mythology reference. He brings up sibling marriages in mythology and ancient empires like that's a reasonable argument. "That's mythology!" she says. "That's ancient history!" And she's right—that's exactly what those references prove. They're stories of other people's taboos, not validation for theirs. The author is using Lucberk's selective reading of history to show how his isolation has warped his moral compass.
... Read More
Let me just say — the imagery in these chapters is something else entirely. I know I should probably not be appreciating the craftsmanship here, but as a reader, the sensory writing is genuinely extraordinary. The repeated use of color — blood red, violet eyes, flushed skin, pale thighs, crimson tongue — creates this almost painterly quality. Every scene feels like it could be a frame from a film. The metallic taste of blood mixing with saliva, the sticky sounds, the creaking bed, the warm breath against her ear — the author doesn't just describe what happens, they make you FEEL it through every sense. I found myself physically uncomfortable reading certain passages, which is either brilliant writing or deeply manipulative. Probably both. One scene that particularly stuck with me: when Lucberk stares at her unconscious face and a mirror slides out of the drawer. The casual way objects appear in this world — mirrors that slide out of drawers on command, the intimate setting of what seems to be a bedroom — it all feels grounded enough to be real, which makes the horror so much worse. You can picture this room. You can picture the bed, the sheets stained red, the mirror catching whatever light is in the room. The atmosphere throughout is suffocating. There's no escape valve, no moment of fresh air or visual relief. Even the aftermath — the quiet, the silence, the throbbing pain — continues the sensory overload in a different key. The author understands that horror isn't just in the violent moments but in the silence that follows. That ending image of Lucberk examining his tongue while she lies unconscious is one of the most cinematic, haunting closing images I've encountered in this entire novel.
... Read More
I don't even know what to say about this sibling dynamic. On the surface Lucberk acts like he's in love — the way he gazes at her, the gentle touches, the whispered sweet things — but it's all performative. He's not in love with Shamilia. He's obsessed with owning her. The most disturbing part for me personally was reading his internal monologue after everything. He's stroking her hair like some kind of twisted romance novel hero and thinking, "Maybe it'll be fine this time. Perhaps she had accepted it." ACCEPTED IT. He raped his sister twice and he's framing her compliance as consent because he needs to believe that. His delusion is so thick you could cut it with a knife. And Shamilia — god, she's trapped in the worst possible way. Every time she fights back, he just erases it from her mind. So she doesn't even get the satisfaction of remembering her own trauma. She just wakes up confused, ashamed, and unable to articulate why she feels so broken. The power dynamic is completely destroyed. There's no平等 here, no chance for her to genuinely choose anything because every choice is undermined by his control over her memory. When she's half awake at the end and reaches for him instinctively before her mind catches up, it breaks my heart. Part of her wants comfort from him even as the rest of her knows he's the source of her pain. That cognitive dissonance must be absolutely tearing her apart.
... Read More
I've been sitting with this chapter for a while now and the symbolism keeps coming back to blood. Not just as a visual detail but as this thick, recurring motif that ties everything together. The blood appears everywhere — on her cheeks mixing with tears, on his tongue, on her calf leaving crimson lines, pooling between them. Blood represents their sibling bond literally (shared blood) but also their violated bond (her blood from the act itself). It's the physical proof that this connection, this family tie, has been twisted into something unrecognizable. "We're both soaked in blood, aren't we?" — this line is so loaded. Blood becomes the great equalizer here. Despite all the power imbalance, despite all the violation, they are physically joined by it. It's intimate in the most perverse way possible. The mirror scene at the end — Lucberk looking at his reflection, examining the damage to his own body while hers lies unconscious — this feels deeply symbolic. He's seeing himself as a participant, as someone marked by what he's done. The mirror is usually a symbol of truth and self-reflection, and here it shows him as someone who has crossed an irredeemable line but doesn't seem to regret it. The title of this entire novel arc (or at least this section) could probably be "What blood makes us" — because that's what the story seems to be asking. What does shared blood mean? What bonds does it create, and what happens when those bonds are violated? The author isn't shy about making us uncomfortable with these questions.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment for the visual composition of this novel because the author is NOT playing around. The bookstore scene. The sunset catching the silver frames of Lucberk's glasses. His jet-black hair shining faintly in that reddish light. The way the text slows down and actually lets us LOOK at him—those long elegant fingers, the violet eyes described with such deliberate weight. It reads like a painting at that point. I literally stopped and re-read that passage three times because it was THAT vivid. And then the house. Dark windows. Unlit. Shamilia thinking about what it would mean if their long-passed parents were waiting for them inside. Lucberk snaps his fingers and suddenly there's a soft glow—someone welcome them home. It's such a small detail but it does so much work. The house feels empty without that magic, and yet it also feels too full with him in it. There's this haunting quality to their shared home that makes the world feel lived-in and layered. The bookstore itself is described as the only one in the capital specializing in magic tomes. That single detail tells me everything I need to know about the world—a place where magic is real, regulated, commodified. Books are weapons and tools and artifacts. Arun delivers them. There's an economy of knowledge here that feels tangible. What I love most is how the atmosphere shifts between scenes. The warm, almost domestic sunset glow of the bookstore contrasts sharply with the cold tension of Lucberk standing over Shamilia as she reads. The physical spaces mirror the emotional landscape. When he corners her by the sofa, the world seems to shrink until there's only his gaze and her inability to look away.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the stakes in this novel have gone from psychological to literally life-threatening in one chapter and I am shook. Before this, the conflict was contained to memory erasure and coerced intimacy, which is already incredibly dark. But Lucberk cutting his own artery? That raises the stakes to whether he survives this, whether Shamilia will ever forgive him, whether their relationship can even exist after something this violent. The worst part is how casually he treats his own life. "Even if it means living only a short life... if I could spend it with Shamilia, that would be enough." He's not even considering his own death as a real barrier—it's just a trade he's willing to make. And Shamilia, meanwhile, is the one breaking down, scooping his blood off the floor like she can put it back in him. The imagery of her hands stained crimson pressing against his wound is one of the most visceral scenes I've read. Her fear isn't just about what he did to her—it's terror that he might actually die. And yet, when the bleeding stops and she finally looks at him, her eyes are full of fury. That shift from panic to rage to... whatever comes next? That's where the real conflict lives now. Not in whether they'll be together, but in whether she'll ever look at him the same way again.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter sequence really shows Lucberk's escalation pattern and I need to talk about it. He literally tries soft approach first — the pitiful puppy eyes, the begging, the forehead kiss — and when that doesn't work he just shifts gears entirely. "I can't persuade you by begging" and then immediately proceeds to do the exact same thing with physical force. That transition from desperate brother to cold predator is genuinely chilling. But here's what actually kept me up at night: the memory wipe implication. Lucberk literally thinks about locking away her memories like, "It'd be a waste if I locked away her memories." And earlier he says "You won't remember any of this anyway." So this has happened before. Multiple times apparently. She doesn't remember past encounters but he does. That's not a plot twist, that's a damn horror reveal hiding inside a romance chapter. The structure of this whole sequence is also interesting — it starts with him cornering her, escalates to her being physically overpowered, then at the end when she wakes up partially conscious and he's already inside her again, and she says the word "no" — and his response is literally "Is it a no" trailing off like he's considering her answer. But we both know how that ends. The narrative arc here is brutal because we've now seen this happen at least twice and the pattern is clear: he takes, she resists, he plans to erase her memory, repeat. The fact that Shamilia is starting to have moments of clarity — the chapter ends with her asking Luc... and then the cliffhanger — makes me worry she's going to break through this cycle. Or worse, that she won't.
... Read More
OK so. Lucberk. LUCBERK. What do I even say about this character? On one hand, he is the most terrifying person I have ever encountered in fiction. On the other hand, the author clearly put enormous care into making him feel real — and that's what makes him so disturbing. "If I were going to stop, I wouldn't have started in the first place." That's not a villain monologue. That's someone who genuinely believes their logic. He's not cackling or being theatrical — he's calm, almost conversational. That casual confidence is so much worse than any cartoonish evil. He truly believes he loves her, and he truly believes she'll learn to love him too. The tragedy is that this might be real love in his head, which makes it infinitely more horrifying. And Shamilia — her internal monologue is devastating. She keeps trying to convince herself it's because of the blood, that it's not really her body responding, that this is a dream. Her mind is actively protecting her by dissociating, and the fact that she simultaneously can't forgive herself for feeling pleasure is the most realistic portrayal of trauma I've read. "She loved her brother, but there were boundaries that should never be crossed" — this line broke me. She's still thinking about the relationship, about family, about MORALS in the middle of something this violent. Their dynamic has this twisted intimacy — they're siblings, they share blood literally and figuratively, and now their bodies are involved in the most violating way possible. The scene where she bites his tongue and he LAUGHS and drives deeper is a moment that will live in my nightmares. This relationship is so damaged and the author writes it so well that I actually feel confused about what I'm supposed to feel. Which I think is the point.
... Read More
Let's talk about stakes because this book is playing a dangerous game with what it asks readers to tolerate. On the surface, Shamilia's conflict is clear: her brother is violating her repeatedly and she can't stop him. But the real conflict — the one that keeps you turning pages at 2am — is internal. She's fighting herself. Her body responds. Her mind fractures. And the memory erasure means she can't even build a case against him in her own head. What does she stand to lose? Her autonomy. Her memories. Her sense of self. Her trust in the one person she should be able to trust. And God help me, possibly her sanity, because when your body betrays your mind consistently enough, you start questioning whether any of it was real. Lucberk's stakes are different but equally high. He needs her acceptance — not just physically but emotionally. He begs, he pleads, he tries the pitiful act. When it doesn't work, he escalates. His fear of rejection is what drives the violence. That's the tragedy nobody wants to admit: he's not just a monster, he's a desperate one. And desperation is far more dangerous than calculated evil. The suspense works because we don't know how this ends. Will she break free? Will she remember? Will she somehow turn the tables? Or will she eventually stop fighting and just... survive? The author knows exactly how to string us along, and I hate myself for watching.
... Read More
let me just say this: the author has absolutely zero mercy when it comes to pacing, and I respect it. you start in what is essentially an explicit intimate scene — full throttle, no preamble, just immediate immersion into Shamilia's internal panic and physical response. the prose moves fast here, staccato breaths, fragmented thoughts, 'Hngh! Ah! No—' — it mimics exactly what's happening to her nervous system. you're not observing this, you're suffocating through it alongside her. then — and this is where I gasped out loud — the author just CUTS to the next morning. like, straight to him watching her sleep, making that comment about her body adapting. no time to process, no chapter break to breathe. and then the screaming starts. she wakes up and it's a full breakdown, and he just... silences her with magic. that transition from sexual violation to psychological terror to outright physical horror happens across three paragraphs and it hit me like a truck. the axe scene arrives as another pivot, but this time the pacing changes again. it's slower, deliberate. he rolls up his sleeve. she asks what he's doing. the blade gleams. he brings it down. the author lingers here the way a camera would — close-ups on the blood, the bone, his calm expression, her panic. it's almost meditative in its dread. and then he asks HER to cut off his arm. that's the cliffhanger that broke me. the structure of these chapters is basically one escalation after another with no release valve. and somehow, impossibly, it holds together because the emotional logic is so relentless. by the time the text cuts off mid-sentence ('Stop?' Shamilia... suddenly fell silent.), I was genuinely shaking.
... Read More
OK I need to just sit with what I just read for a second. Lucberk literally slit his own throat in this chapter. Not metaphorically. Not dramatically. He cut his neck open so deep that she had to stitch him up with a needle and thread. And do you know what pissed me off more than the act itself? He did it with this calm, almost cheerful attitude. Like it was nothing. Like he was fixing a leaky faucet. And the plot logic here is actually genius in the most disturbing way possible. Shamilia had said it would be fine if they weren't blood relatives anymore. And Lucberk—obsessive maniac that he is—decides the solution is to literally drain himself of blood. When that doesn't work, he escalates. He tries to replace his blood with mana. Each failure just makes him more desperate, more unhinged. But the story keeps pulling the rug out from under him. Every time he thinks he's found the answer, she says no. The whole scene where she's stitching his wound and he's just... smiling? That's peak manipulation. He's using his own suffering as a weapon. "You don't get to die without my permission, Sister." What does that even mean?? The control fantasy is off the charts. And then the ending—where he's staring at his reflection, blood on the glass, violet eyes looking crimson, thinking about how he wants the scar to stay permanent so she'll never forget him? That's not a character who wants love. That's a character who wants ownership. The plot is barreling toward something incredibly dark and I am NOT OK with it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or