Please Be Mindful of Noise Between Walls - Reviews

Please Be Mindful of Noise Between Walls
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is absolutely razor-sharp. I've been re-reading certain exchanges because they hit so hard I needed to process them. Alkaid's line — "Making the impossible possible is what power is for. If there's just a pretext." — is the kind of line that makes you stop scrolling and just sit with it. It's cold, it's pragmatic, and it's completely true to who he is. He's not a man who relies on brute force alone. He uses leverage, paperwork, connections. The fact that Lepus's own friends turned against him because of guilt after hearing about Spica? Alkaid didn't just break Lepus physically, he dismantled his entire social structure. And he does it with three sentences. Then Lepus firing back: "Putting a noble lady in the adjutant position instead of a courtesan and fondling her." That's such a vicious thing to throw at someone, and the fact that it lands — Alkaid gets genuinely angry enough to try cutting off his tongue — tells us everything we need to know about what Lepus has inadvertently uncovered. Spica is the adjutant. Lepus just casually outed her role in front of his attacker, and Alkaid's reaction is pure, undiluted violence. The author doesn't need to explain why this specific accusation triggers him. We feel it. Spica's internal monologue as dialogue is also incredible. When she overhears Lepus and Alkaid through the wall — "Eavesdropping is a bit..." — and then decides NOT to press her ear despite having that history with the wall-incident. That self-aware joke about her past behavior is exactly the kind of thing that makes me fall in love with a character. She's reflexively curious, then immediately corrects herself. It's natural. Megrez is the dialogue queen of these chapters though. "I don't know how long he thinks he's fifteen years old, sheesh!" That line alone tells me everything about her relationship with Alkaid. She's exasperated, affectionate, and deeply protective, all in one sentence. And then: "You said it yourself, that he's a good person. Just remember that." She's feeding Spica information without giving it away, wrapping advice in casual conversation. That's masterful subtext. The banter between Spica and Megrez about whether they're really there for each other or just pretending is also so natural. It's the kind of friendship where you can tell the truth by saying the opposite. And Spica's quick observation — "Wasn't Dame Megrez also asking because she didn't know where he was?" — shows she's not naive. She pieces things together. Her voice is sharp even when she's confused. Alkaid himself barely speaks, but when he does, it cuts. "Stop looking. Don't pay attention to what trash says either." Five words. Five words that change the entire physical dynamic of the scene from Spica pulling him to both of them holding on equally. The author trusts the reader to understand the subtext without spelling it out. That's confidence in prose.
... Read More
I need to talk about Alkaid because this man is doing the MOST and pretending it's nothing. First, when Spica starts having a panic attack—righteous anger bubbling underneath all that calm exterior. He covers her mouth not because he's being controlling but because he literally recognizes the symptoms from battlefield experience. 'There were often those who collapsed like this after major battles.' He's seen this before, he knows how to handle it, and yet he still feels PATHETIC that all he can do is whisper and hold her hand down. But then the beast-human reveal changes everything. 'If your mate rejected you and ran away? I'd go insane.' This isn't some romantic fantasy language, Spica. This is a MAN WHOSE MOTHER CONFINED HIS FATHER BECAUSE REJECTION LED TO MADNESS. And he's looking at Spica—a human who can't even feel imprinting the way he does—and thinking about pressing foreheads together without a helmet between them. Then he says 'Whatever happens, I will gladly stand before you.' THAT'S not how a guy who's terrified of going mad talks about his mate. That's how a guy who genuinely, fiercely chooses someone despite knowing the stakes. He KNOWS what rejecting a beast-human mate means. He's seen his father's fate. And yet he's offering himself as her shield anyway. And Spica's note—'I happened to hear sounds... Please trust me too'—she caught on. She figured out the 'strange sounds' were HIM every night. And instead of running, she's offering to be his accomplice too.
... Read More
Okay. The carriage scene. Let me just… sit with this for a moment. They're sitting across from each other in a moving carriage, and the entire chapter's emotional weight compresses into these few paragraphs where neither of them says what they mean. Spica's face going pale, then red, then pale again while Alkaid sits completely still. The streetlamp light “coming in through the slowly moving carriage window and darkened repeatedly”—that's not just atmosphere, that's the narrative itself blinking in and out, like these two can't sustain eye contact even when the world is literally dimming around them. And Spica's thoughts spiral into this ridiculous but devastating scenario: “When we arrive home like this, will Alkaid drop me off and go somewhere?” She doesn't want the carriage to stop. She actually hopes it won't. And when it does stop, when he walks her to the door instead of just dumping her, her whole world tilts again. She asks “Are you going to speak casually to me now too?” like she's testing whether this is real or some cruel dream. Then the stairway scene—oh god, the stairway scene. Alkaid following behind her, noticing every sound: “the step board lightly creaked under her feet as she lifted her heels slightly, her quiet breathing and the sound of her heart beating a little faster than usual.” He's memorizing her. And then his instincts kick in, that beast-human hunger rising, and Spica's heartbeat speeds up—not from desire, from fear. Because her father's gaze overlays onto his. That parallel just annihilated me. He stops himself. He says “It's late. Sleep well.” in a cracking voice. The man who could be savage holds back because she's afraid, and she has no idea. Absolutely no idea. And that's the most romantic thing I've ever read.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how ALIVE these characters sound when they talk? Because I have never related to dialogue this hard in my life. Spica's voice is perfection. She's nervous, awkward, trying to be brave but clearly overwhelmed, and her dialogue reflects that beautifully. Lines like "Th, that's not it!" and "Originally, I was supposed to touch you, um... you know" made me laugh out loud because THAT'S HOW PEOPLE ACT WHEN THEY'RE EMBARRASSED. She doesn't have some smooth, practiced romance speech—she stammers, she trails off, she gets flustered, and it's absolutely gorgeous. Alkaid's dialogue is a different kind of beautiful. He's more measured, more careful with his words, which makes sense given his position and his history of holding back. But when he says things like "If you liked the kiss, how about removing your hand first instead of just pouting" and "You're smiling now"—there's this dry wit underneath all his restraint that makes me fall harder for him every chapter. The most devastating line in this entire chapter though? "If I confess now, would you believe it? It would only sound like a cheap promise thrown out so I could sleep with you for one night." That's not dialogue—that's a wound laid bare. And the fact that Spica's response is to keep kissing him, to keep showing him rather than just telling him? Perfection. They communicate so much without words. Also, the m*ans and breathy sounds they make? Don't even get me started. The author lets us hear them through Spica's internal monologue and it's so effective. Every "Mmh...!" and "Ugh..." feels earned, natural, part of their unique language. These two have a voice that's entirely their own.
... Read More
The worldbuilding in these chapters is doing so much quiet heavy lifting and I need to appreciate it. First — the house Spica moved into. It has vines and flowers wrapping around pillars and walls at the entrance, and she specifically says 'Every time I open the door, it makes me feel good.' This isn't just set dressing; it's emotional architecture. After everything she's been through — leaving home under difficult circumstances, being indebted to the Knight Order, the injury that took her swordsmanship — this house is a small victory. A place that MAKES HER FEEL GOOD when she arrives. The author gives us this detail almost casually, like it's just part of Spica's morning routine, but it's actually profoundly important. She's building a life. A home. Something that belongs to HER. Then there's the dinner scene — 'a tremendous dinner feast that made her wonder how all this food had been prepared' — and the maids are smiling 'full of happy smiles' unlike their usual calm demeanor. Mrs. Hudson calls Spica 'our Miss' with genuine warmth, saying 'When you reach this age, sitting alone at the dining table can't be more lonely.' This is a woman who chose to care for Spica and is now genuinely invested in her happiness. The household feels alive, textured, real. These aren't background characters — they're a found family. But then the world shifts dramatically when Spica reads the newspaper. 'Disappearing Children — Children from the capital's slums and orphanages are disappearing?' And suddenly we understand why the square she walked through earlier felt empty. 'The flower-selling child, newspaper boy, shoe shiner. The children who had always existed like part of the square were nowhere to be seen.' This is how the author does worldbuilding — not with exposition dumps, but by having the protagonist notice what's MISSING. The absence tells the story. The Second Knight Order's role is established efficiently: they handle security outside the castle walls, unlike the Royal Guard (imperial family protection) and the First Knight Order (inside the castle). This gives us a clear sense of the city's power structure without a single info-dump paragraph. And then there's the visual of Alkaid's office door with WHITE FROST on it. 'From experience, when it was like this, it meant Dame Megrez was being broken inside.' This is such a brilliant detail — the magical atmosphere of this world manifests literally as temperature changes when Alkaid's emotional state shifts. The frost on the door is both a warning and a piece of character information: Alkaid's anger is cold, not hot. It's contained, controlled, and deeply unsettling. The contrast between the warm, sunlit domestic scenes (the house with vines, the breakfast feast, Mrs. Hudson's kindness) and the cold, shadowy political underworld (missing children, compromised investigations, the new capital guard commander who won't cooperate with Alkaid) creates a world that feels layered and dangerous beneath its pleasant surface.
... Read More
That helmet is EVERYTHING. I've read a lot of fantasy romance and I can tell you with confidence: this is one of the most loaded symbolic objects I've encountered in recent memory. On the surface, it's a practical item—an identifying piece of gear for a beast-human commander in human spaces. But every scene involving it layers on more meaning until you can't look at it the same way. First layer: the helmet as barrier. Alkaid wears it around Spica specifically. He removes it in front of the manager, in front of his subordinates, in front of his own world. But around her, it stays on. This creates this absurd situation where the person she's closest to is also the person she can't fully see. The helmet becomes a metaphor for all the things keeping them apart—his status as her superior, his beast-human nature in a human-dominated society, his guarded emotional life, her own traumatized state after her father's betrayal. Second layer: the helmet as identity. When Spica finally sees his face, she says internally 'is being too handsome his complex?' This is hilarious but also deeply tragic because it reveals how she's been interpreting his constant covering through her own limited framework. She couldn't imagine that the helmet might be about PROTECTING HER, or protecting their dynamic, or protecting something between them that neither of them has named yet. Third layer—the helmet on the desk at the end. Placed there after Talitha's confrontation, left visible through the closing door gap. It's like Alkaid is saying something without saying it. Or maybe he forgot it. Or maybe he's testing whether she'll notice. The helmet goes from being worn to being observed, from shield to artifact, from something covering a face to something covering a feeling. And beneath all of this: the beast-human vs. human divide. Alkaid's line 'You wouldn't know since you're not a beast-human' spoken with that cold tone to his subordinate is the story's thesis statement in miniature. This world has structures of exclusion that run deeper than personal prejudice, and Spica—human, betrayed by her own father's choices, navigating a world where she's been called 'one-armed'—understands exclusion in her bones even if she doesn't understand his specifically.
... Read More
I need to talk about the night scenes because they completely wrecked me and I was NOT ready for this level of emotional devastation in what I thought was a light romantic fantasy. Spica wakes up at the same time as always, grips her throbbing right arm, and tries sword forms she can't physically perform anymore. 'The result was always like this. Spica herself knew it was a foolish act, so she attempted it away from other people's eyes and secretly suffered alone.' Just like that. Three sentences and I'm crying over a character who's hiding her pain because she's afraid that if she stops practicing, she'll be too weak when a miracle cure finally appears. 'Hope was always the most painful thing.' I AM SHAKING. That line should be framed. But then — and this is where it gets so beautifully layered — she hears sounds from the next room. Moaning. Every night. And instead of being creeped out, the narrative describes it like: 'A pleasant fragrance wrapped around Spica like it was tickling her back.' She's LISTENING for it. She's aware of it day by day. 'Not only could she clearly hear the sounds beyond the wall, but the tickling feeling was also growing bigger and bigger.' Growing. Bigger. This is becoming part of her nightly ritual. And then her mind goes to Alkaid's hands. His large hands. The way they brushed against hers when she put on his cufflinks. And she imagines — and I quote — 'If she had grabbed his hand before it moved away from her cheek and buried her lips in his firm palm while interlocking fingers.' I'm not okay. She's lying in bed at 3 AM fantasizing about her commander's HAND after he helped her put on cufflinks, and then HIS VOICE whispers in her ear: 'Does it bother you?' and her mind SNAPS awake 'like she had been doused with ice water.' The guilt that follows is devastating. Her face goes from flushed to 'pale with guilt enough to look whitish even in the darkness.' She's horrified at herself for having these thoughts about her superior officer. But the author doesn't judge her — the text makes it clear that this longing is natural, human, and completely understandable given how tenderly he treated her. The next morning, she can't sleep, barely rests, and goes to work with dark circles. She asks the maids if they heard 'bothersome sounds' at night and they say no — they're light sleepers but heard nothing. So either the sounds are incredibly faint, or Alkaid is somehow controlling them, or — and this is my theory — maybe she's been hearing things that aren't quite what they seem. Meanwhile, Mrs. Hudson keeps feeding her strawberries and saying 'he's been someone who never had a single minor illness since childhood.' Never sick. Never weak. So what is making those sounds? And why does Mrs. Hudson seem to know more than she's letting on? The romantic tension is exquisite because it's built on the smallest moments — a brush of fingers, a lowered voice, a shared secret — but it's also threaded through with genuine suffering. Spica's injured arm, her hidden practice sessions, her guilt over inappropriate thoughts. She's falling for someone while simultaneously punishing herself for existing. That contrast is what makes this story so emotionally rich.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the Diblin encounter because WOW. The way this scene is constructed is genuinely brilliant. Spica walks into Alkaid's office, already tense, and then Diblin appears in her Imperial Knight Order uniform. The narrative does something really clever here—it doesn't tell us immediately why Spica breaks. Instead, we get her physical reactions first: throat blocked, vision spinning, trembling. The reader is left guessing alongside her until Alkaid pieces it together later. That's proper dramatic irony done right. And then the flashback reveal! When Alkaid connects the dots—Diblin was her practicum leader in second year, the one who nearly took her arm off—it hits like a truck. The author had been planting breadcrumbs all along. Winterhold and Sobek families have bad blood, Diblin has an inferiority complex toward Alkaid, and now we understand why Spica's trauma runs so deep. It's not just random bullying; it's layered history, family rivalries, and personal failure all tangled together. The structure of the chapter itself mirrors Spica's mental state. It starts with external conflict (Diblin showing up), escalates to internal collapse (the panic attack), then moves into quiet intimacy (Alkaid comforting her), and ends with a note—literally—passing between rooms. That progression from chaos to tenderness to something almost hopeful? Chef's kiss. The pacing within the chapter is what made me sit up straighter each time.
... Read More
Let me just say this much—this entire scene reads like a movie that I never want to end. The atmosphere is IMMACULATE. We start with Spica in her room, pretending to wash up but really just listening at the walls. The description of cool water on her face, stiff new pajamas, rubbing her nape—that's such a specific, relatable detail. You can feel her nervous energy radiating off the page. And then the sounds from next door... oh god, the sounds. The author doesn't even have to describe what he's making, just calling them "groans" and then Spica's mortified imagination does all the work. The bedroom scene itself is so vividly rendered. The half-open robe revealing his chest, the way the light catches him, the bed head creaking when she moves... I could see every frame. The sensory details are INSANE—her thumb tracing the shadows of his abs, the wet sounds as she moves her hands, his breath catching when she kisses his collarbone. It's intimate without being gratuitous, which is such a difficult balance to strike. What really sold it for me was the contrast between their positions. She's the one taking initiative, climbing onto his lap, but also the one who's nervous and inexperienced. He's tied up (literally and figuratively), vulnerable in a way we rarely see him, but also the one who keeps trying to protect her from his intensity. The power dynamic shifts so naturally throughout the scene. And that ending image—Spica's eyes widening as she sees him, then slowly closing because she's feeling good—cinematic doesn't even cover it. This is the kind of scene that makes you reread paragraphs just to soak in the atmosphere. Chef's kiss.
... Read More
There are so many layers underneath this seemingly sweet romance chapter and I want to dig into what the author is really saying. The cufflinks are the central symbol and they work on multiple levels. On the surface, they're a thank-you gift — red with white stripes like a tiger, matching Alkaid's eye color. But Spica bought them because she 'immediately wanted to give it to Alkaid when she saw it.' The color coordination isn't calculated; it's instinctive. She saw something and her mind went straight to HIM. That's the language of attachment. But the cufflinks also represent something darker: the boundary between professional and personal. Alkaid says 'a commander shouldn't accept private gifts from subordinate knights.' The rules exist. The hierarchy exists. And yet he makes an EXCEPTION. He creates a SECRET. The cufflinks become a talisman of their forbidden closeness — visible to the world as professional accessories, but charged with intimate meaning between them. He'll wear them every day, which means he'll be carrying her gift, her intention, her feelings, against his skin. That's not just gratitude. That's devotion dressed as duty. The white frost on Alkaid's door is another symbol that deserves attention. Frost is coldness, yes, but it's also something that PRESERVES. It freezes things in place. And Alkaid's anger — his fury at the compromised investigation — manifests as cold, not heat. This suggests that his power isn't destructive in a chaotic way; it's contained, controlled, almost crystalline. He doesn't explode; he freezes everything around him until the problem is addressed. Then there's the recurring motif of SOUND throughout these chapters. Spica hears the moaning next door. She hears the newspapers discussing disappearances. She hears Alkaid's laugh behind his helmet. She hears her own heartbeat. Sound becomes the thread connecting her to this world — and to Alkaid specifically. Even when she can't see him (helmet on, distance maintained), she CONNECTS through what she hears. The moaning next door might be Alkaid's pain, and she's the only one who notices it. She's attuned to him in a way no one else is. The missing children operate as the story's darkest symbol. These children — the flower seller, the newspaper boy, the shoe shiner — were 'part of the square' like furniture, like scenery. Their absence is what makes the world feel wrong. They were invisible to most people, and now they're GONE invisible. This mirrors Spica's own position: she's a subordinate knight, somewhat overlooked, whose value is only truly seen by one person. The children's disappearance and Spica's hidden struggle both speak to the same theme — those who are unseen are also most vulnerable. And hope itself — 'Hope was always the most painful thing' — is the overarching symbol. Spica practices sword forms she can't perform, hoping for a miracle that may never come. She gives a gift to a commander who may never reciprocate. She listens to the sounds next door and wonders if there's help available. Hope is what makes her keep going, and it's also what makes her suffer. The author isn't telling us whether hope is good or bad — she's showing us that it's BOTH, simultaneously, and that's what makes it so human.
... Read More
Mizar dropping that bomb about Lepus and Diblin having an affair is genuinely one of those moments where the entire narrative pivots on a single conversation. Think about it: Spica just survived a public incident where the Crown Prince's banquet nearly became a diplomatic crisis, she's standing there feeling grateful that Alkaid protected her, and then her senior casually mentions “The person Lepus Arneb had an affair with” like he's commenting on the weather. And Spica's reaction isn't dramatic. She just… puts down her plate with trembling hands. The narration says “betrayal piled on betrayal made her head dizzy” but she doesn't “opibly breathe fire.” She's so numb she can't even be properly furious. The question she asks next is chillingly calm: “From your perspective, Senior, do those two seem to have imprinted?” She's not thinking about her own pain—she's analyzing whether Lepus found someone else to imprint with. That's not closure. That's dissociation. What's brilliant about this reveal is how it retroactively colors everything. Diblin's obsession with Spica suddenly has a completely different texture—it's not just spite, it's territorial jealousy from a woman who stole another woman's partner. And Alkaid's protective behavior? It's not just duty. The Crown Prince called him in specifically. He knew about the Lepus situation. He's been orchestrating this entire protection from the start, and Spica still has no idea how deep it goes. The author also threads in this delicious irony: Spica keeps wondering why Diblin cares about her at all, and the answer was staring her in the face the whole time. She's the ex. The one who got away before she even knew she was “away.”
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how NATURAL every single line of dialogue feels in these chapters? Because I've read so many novels where characters sound like they're reading from a script, and this author writes like they've actually listened to people talk. Spica's internal voice is immediately distinct. When she's nervous around Alkaid, her thoughts fragment: 'B-but right now the Commander doesn't have free hands.' The stutter, the half-formed protest — it's exactly how someone talks when they're trying to be professional but their brain is screaming. And then later, when she's trying to downplay the cufflink moment: 'Th-they're not that good. The original ones were pretty too, so how about using various ones...' This is such a specific kind of flustered speech — proposing alternatives when you actually mean 'please tell me this meant something.' Alkaid's dialogue is deceptively simple. He says very little, and what he says is often understated to the point of being devastating. 'I'd like to make an exception just this once. Will you keep it a secret?' Casual. Polite. Loaded with meaning. 'Then now we're accomplices.' Three words that change the entire relationship. 'I'll wear them every day.' No fanfare, no dramatic declaration — just a quiet statement that lands like a hammer. And the way he teases her: 'Does it bother you?' After helping her put on the cufflinks, knowing EXACTLY what effect it had on her, asking if she's bothered. He laughs and walks away listening to her heartbeat quicken. This is a man who understands power and uses it with precision, but never cruelly. The teasing comes from affection, not mockery. Mrs. Hudson's dialogue is a masterclass in SUBTEXT. She never directly answers Spica's questions about the young master next door. Instead she deflects: 'The young master is so busy...' Then pivots to food: 'The strawberries look particularly fresh today. Go ahead and try one.' And when Spica finally asks if he's uncomfortable anywhere, Mrs. Hudson says 'He's been someone who never had a single minor illness since childhood' and immediately changes the subject again. She KNOWS something. She's been hiding something. And she's feeding Spica strawberries while doing it like some kind of culinary mystery novel host. Megrez's lines are perfect comic relief with genuine warmth: 'Ah really, I almost froze to death. Didn't he sleep? He's 100 times more irritable than usual.' She's reporting on Alkaid's emotional state with the casual concern of someone who's seen this before. The exclamation marks, the rhetorical questions — she sounds like a real person. Even the newspaper headline — 'Disappearing Children' — serves as dialogue with the world. It's jarring, blunt, and immediately raises the stakes without a single character needing to explain the plot.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or