One Night with the Abandoned Saint - Reviews

One Night with the Abandoned Saint
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about the letter scene because honestly it completely destroyed me. Lucilia sitting there with the quill, trying to write to her father, and she just can't even—ink spreads everywhere, tears falling, and she has to compose herself before she can even begin. That moment when she writes "I miss you"??? Like I wasn't expecting a hit that hard. All this time these two have been distant, right? She went to the monastery as a kid, her father's strict, no emotional expressiveness anywhere in sight, and now she's writing this vulnerable letter asking him to save her again. It's the first time she's ever openly admitted she needs him. And what about the father-daughter thing—there's this whole undercurrent of regret and unspoken love that hits differently when you realize she's completely alone in this castle except for him, even though he's not even there. She keeps thinking about Aaron too, wanting them to get closer, and that's just... achingly lonely. She's surrounded by people who distrust her, terrified of the baron, watched by servants, and her emotional anchor is literally a letter she seals with desperate feelings. The line where she says "I know you tried to save me. So please help me once more" gave me actual chills because it's her admitting she failed the first time, that she's back where it all started, and there's nowhere else to go.
... Read More
'Indeed, you are fundamentally different from ordinary people like us.' SAYING THE QUIET PART LOUD, AARON. I love him. I also want to shake him. The dialogue in this section is so sharp and loaded with subtext. Almost nothing is said directly. Aaron never tells Lucilia he's worried about her health—he says 'the terrain here is rough, making it difficult to rest.' He never says he felt bad seeing her knee bleeding—he scoops her onto his horse without explanation and grumbles about her being pampered the entire ride. His care is wrapped in layers of mockery and cold commands, and that's what makes his voice so distinctive. Lucilia's voice is almost the opposite. She's constantly performing—apologizing, smiling faintly, saying 'we can go now' even though she's in pain. Her dialogue is polished and deferential because that's all she's ever known. Even in crisis, she's stuck in saint mode. 'I'll try to be helpful'—as if she needs to earn her place by being useful. The knights' dialogue is sparse but telling. 'Shouldn't we inform the master of this news?' Rombon's suggestion feels genuinely well-intentioned, while the other knights just glare and spread rumors about soul-stealing eyes. They're the Greek chorus of this story, voicing what everyone's thinking but nobody's saying to Lucilia's face. Aaron's internal monologue breaks from the external dialogue completely. That's where the rawest material lives—'My life has truly become a mess,' 'what a headache,' 'just when he had finally proven his abilities, they demanded he carry that woman.' Outside, he's ice. Inside, he's a tornado. That gap between his spoken words and his thoughts is where the entire emotional engine of this story runs.
... Read More
I need to talk about Aaron because this chapter absolutely peeled him open and I'm not okay. On the surface, he's all clipped sentences and gruff commands. "Get up." "Stay lying down." "Drink it all in one go." He's the responsible commander, the cold-hearted superior, the guy who would literally threaten Rombon with farm life to make him move faster. But the narrative keeps sneaking in these tiny cracks — his fingertips trembling when he lifts her dress, his heart pounding like he's on a battlefield instead of in a tent with a sick girl, the way he stares at her exposed leg and then immediately looks away like he's been caught doing something wrong. And Lucilia! The way she tries to minimize herself throughout this entire exchange — "Have I delayed you?" "I'll get ready and come out right away" — it's devastating because we know she's not just being polite, she genuinely believes she's a burden now. Remember what she thinks to herself: "Like rotten fruit falling to the ground, divine blessing had abandoned her." That line hit me like a truck. She was a saint. She had divine power. Now she has a fever and can't even lift her own arm to take medicine. Of course she feels worthless. But the most electric moment is when he holds her up to feed her the medicine. One arm around her back, teeth removing the cork, spitting it aside. It's intimate without being romantic, forced without being tender — and that contradiction is exactly what makes their relationship feel so alive. He's doing this because she'd die otherwise, not because he wants to. And she's accepting it because she has no choice. Neither of them is being honest about what's happening between them, which is honestly the most realistic portrayal of a forced marriage setup I've ever read.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is almost deceptive. It opens with what reads like a standard military morning — Aaron giving orders, checking on his people, the routine stuff. Then it narrows gradually into the tent, and by the time he's crouched beside Lucilia feeding her medicine, we're in such intimate proximity that the outside world completely disappears. That compression is masterful. The author controls the tempo through physical space. We start wide — camp, knights, the whole expedition — and slowly the frame tightens until the only things that exist are two people in a cramped tent with a feverish girl and a bowl of bitter medicine. By the time Aaron exits and catches his breath outside, the release feels earned because we've been trapped in that small space alongside him. Rombon's comic relief scenes are strategically placed too. They give you a breath between the heavier moments, but they never let you forget the urgency. When Rombon suggests wiping her body with wet cloths and Aaron nearly breaks his neck with frustration, it's funny, yes, but it also reinforces how out of his depth Aaron is. The chapter never lets the reader get too comfortable emotionally. The final lines are where the pacing really pays off. After all that clinical detail about the wound, the medicine, the fever — it ends on pure sensory impression. Her warmth against his chest, the silver-white hair, the scent. The prose shifts from action to sensation, and that transition is what makes the ending linger. It's not a question or a dramatic statement. It's just him, standing outside a tent, trying to process something he can't articulate. Perfect.
... Read More
'Hold on tight, won't you?' And just like that, Aaron wraps his arm around this woman who literally five seconds ago he was coldly ordering around—what is that?? I swear every time I read this I have to stop and just stare at my ceiling. The way he mocks her right after, calling her pampered and spoiled, but then physically holds her waist so she doesn't fall off the horse? That's not carelessness, that's something else entirely. And Lucilia—can we talk about how she's basically been stripped of everything and her instinct is still to apologize? She says 'I'll try to be helpful' to a man who clearly resents her. The power dynamic here is so messed up. He's angry about the arranged marriage. She's guilty for 'causing trouble.' Neither of them is being honest with each other, and that's what makes it so electric. The knights' reactions too—they're giving her looks 'filled with curiosity and resentment, sticky like wax and sharp like arrowheads.' She's completely isolated. No allies. Just Aaron, who might hate her but also seems torn up about the whole situation himself. When Rombon suggests telling the Marquis, Aaron refuses, and I'm convinced he's protecting Lucilia in his own twisted way. This is not a healthy relationship by any standard, but oh my god is it compelling.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this moment. Aaron sees Lucilia naked — actually, he FALLS INTO THE TUB WITH HER trying to save her — and his entire body betrays him. And then he's sitting there like a madman, throwing rosary pearls onto the bed like they personally offended him. The man is physically suffering over a woman he swore he'd treat coldly. And what kills me is Lucilia's side too — she's standing at the altar about to marry this guy who clearly can't decide if he wants to protect her or throw her to the wolves, and her palms are SWEATING because she still has feelings for him after ALL of this. She says in her head stuff like 'gratitude for saving her life and his rational charm had simultaneously entered her heart' — that is honestly the most devastating line. She knows exactly what he's doing (marrying her for surveillance) and she STILL can't stop caring. Meanwhile Aaron is trying so hard to be the stoic commander but his body won't even cooperate with his own plans. The tension between them is INSANE and it's not even resolved yet. I'm not okay.
... Read More
Let me just say this pacing is immaculate and I need to unpack why. The author starts us in media res with Lucilia already having threatened a maid with a knife to her throat—which is wild, right? We're immediately thrown into this version of her that doesn't match the saint we thought we knew. Then it pivots to the Baron's bedroom scene, which operates on a completely different frequency: slow, heavy, suffocating with herb scents and labored breathing. The Baron lays down his one condition—don't show your abilities—and suddenly the wedding date drops like a bombshell. Three days. That's it. Three days until she marries the man who seems to have made peace with using her as a shield. And then Karen comes in, cool as ice, telling her the tailor's coming, and Lucilia is just trying to hold onto some normalcy by mentioning mass. The scene where she almost goes to worship and then talks herself out of it? Genius structural choice. It shows her mental unraveling in real time—she gets all fired up about attending, then immediately deflates because she's imagining the chaos she'd cause. Then she pivots to requesting parchment and by the time she's writing that letter, she's completely fallen apart. Every transition is doing double duty: advancing the plot AND deepening her psychological state. The chapter basically functions as a countdown with no relief. I literally couldn't stop reading because I needed to know what happens next but also I was too emotionally exhausted and needed a break. Best kind of pacing problem to have.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about how this author constructs tension because honestly it's masterclass level. The opening drops us right into the middle of a situation — five days married, not consummated, both of them confused — and we don't get any exposition dumps. We just FEEL the discomfort. Every line from that first paragraph is doing double duty: it's advancing the plot AND establishing the emotional stakes simultaneously. The structure here is basically three movements, and each oneescalates the tension in a completely different direction. First, you've got the marital tension — the partition, the avoidance, the question that finally explodes: "Why won't you spend the night with me?" That's the personal stakes. Then you've got the consummation scene which is equal parts intimate and violent, and it's clear this isn't going to be a normal romance — something is wrong with Aaron, something physical, something that might actually be fatal. And then BAM — the flashback to the chase sequence, which reframes everything. All of a sudden you understand why he's so desperate, why he risked everything to save her, why his marriage to a former Saint is politically explosive. The chapter ends on one of the best plot twists I've read in a while. Up until that point, you assume Lucilia ran to Aaron because he was some kind of childhood protector figure — the nun told her a savior would be waiting at the end of the road. But then Aaron delivers this line: "What man would hand his wife over to the enemy?" And the reader, along with Lucilia, is just standing there processing what that means. The Pope's knights weren't just chasing a witch — they were chasing the wife of Young Baron Artnal, and the King himself has already issued a marriage permit. The political implications of this are HUGE. The King has officially taken a side in a conflict between the Pope and the Marquis, and Lucilia is now the pawn that seals that alliance. What I love most about the pacing is that the author never lets you breathe. Just when you think the scene is about intimacy, it becomes about survival. Just when you think it's about survival, it becomes about politics. Just when you think you understand the characters, the next paragraph reveals something that completely recontextualizes everything. I stayed up WAY too late reading this and I have zero regrets.
... Read More
I need to talk about Aaron and Lucilia together because this chapter absolutely destroyed me. They stand side by side at the head table, physically closest to each other they've ever been, and they might as well be on different planets. While Lucilia is frantically scanning the room looking for that nun — her only possible lifeline, her only connection to someone who might actually WANT to help her — Aaron is completely absorbed in his own thoughts about the Pope's agent crossing the border. TWO PEOPLE AT THEIR WEDDING BANQUET AND NEITHER IS LOOKING AT THE OTHER. The tragedy of it is so sharp. And then the moment that really got me: Aaron asks if she's hungry, she says she's eaten enough, and he casually suggests they go upstairs. The knights lose their minds celebrating while Lucilia sits there mentally short-circuiting. He's being bold and direct — which is SO out of character for him, and honestly kind of terrifying — but beneath that boldness, he's still reading her like a puzzle he hasn't solved. Earlier when she tried to look at the nun, he pulled her hand. He was protecting her, or controlling her, or both. It's impossible to tell which, and that ambiguity is what makes their relationship so compelling. "A pale woman without blood color is a bit frightening." He says this line and everyone laughs, but it's clearly meant as an observation, not a joke. He notices EVERYTHING about her. The fact that she's barely eating, the fact that her hands are trembling, the way she flinches when he mentions the bedroom. Meanwhile Lucilia is over here trying to survive the moment, convinced she has no right to refuse him, convincing herself he'll be her first and last man regardless. She's rationalizing her submission so beautifully and it breaks my heart. These two are locked in this dance where neither knows what the other is thinking, and the wedding night is supposed to bring them closer instead it just highlights how far apart they are.
... Read More
This chapter is soaked in imagery about decay and loss of status, and I think the central metaphor is right there in Lucilia's own thoughts: "Like rotten fruit falling to the ground, divine blessing had abandoned her." The agricultural metaphor is interesting because it frames her fall from grace as something natural but still tragic — fruit rots, that's just what happens. But calling herself rotten fruit is also her internalizing the prejudice of everyone around her. She's not just losing power; she's losing her sense of worth. Then there's the wound itself as symbol. A flesh wound that should have healed properly but didn't, because she couldn't tend to it. Because she fell — literally and figuratively — and no one was there to help. The infection represents everything that happens when someone who's used to being protected is suddenly alone. Her body is betraying her in the most basic way, and for someone whose identity was built on divine favor, that betrayal runs deep. Aaron's discomfort with touching her is also thematically loaded. His hands, which have handled countless battlefield wounds and grotesque injuries without flinching, tremble around her. Not because her wound is worse — Rombon practically laughs at the idea — but because she's a woman, because she's supposed to be a saint, because this intimacy is unwelcome and unavoidable. The tent becomes a liminal space where all the social rules don't quite apply, and in that space, something real almost happens. The fever itself is symbolic too. It's a fire consuming her from within, mirroring the way her reputation has consumed her social standing. Hot on the outside, hollowed out on the inside.
... Read More
Let me just say—the stakes here are NOT subtle. Lucilia has been branded a witch, her father orchestrated a forced marriage as 'protection,' and she's trapped in a body that won't even let her walk properly. The external conflict is obvious: survive the accusation, survive the journey, survive living with a man who views her as a burden. But the internal conflict is what's really got me. Lucilia spent her entire life being told she was sacred, chosen, perfect—and now she's been reduced to a woman with a bloody knee and no one to look at without fear. 'Were those who served the divine any different?' she asks, and that's the question, isn't it? The faith that made her a saint is the same system that now wants to kill her. Aaron's conflict is equally rich. He's resentful of the Marquis for treating him like a 'stray dog,' resentful of the king for demanding loyalty, and resentful of Lucilia for being the collateral damage in all of this. But he also can't just abandon her. He carried her onto his horse. He arranged the camp. He sent someone to bring her soup despite visibly dreading it. Every action contradicts his words, and that contradiction IS the conflict. The knights represent another layer—their hostility isn't just personal, it's systemic. They believe the rumors that looking at her will steal their souls. They're not just mean; they're genuinely afraid, and fear makes people cruel. And nobody has told Lucilia the actual truth about why she's accused of being a witch. She doesn't know what she's fighting. That ignorance is its own kind of stakes—she's trying to prove her innocence while having no idea what the accusation even is.
... Read More
There's so much symbolism packed into these chapters and I can't unsee it now. Water is EVERYWHERE — Lucilia falling into the bath, the pond at sunset, Aaron remembering the 'orange glow spread across the pond,' and then the wedding where they're essentially drowning in lies. Water represents truth in this story, and also danger. When Aaron jumps into the tub to save Lucilia, he's literally and figuratively submerged in feelings he can't control. And then there are the pearl rosary beads he throws onto the bed — pearls formed through irritation inside an oyster, just like his resentment and desire are forming something beautiful and painful inside him. The contrast between the sparkling pearls and the 'water scales reflecting sunlight' on Lucilia's body is almost religious imagery, which makes sense because the whole conflict is between the Church and the Crown. Another symbol I can't stop thinking about: the greenhouse. Lucilia goes there instead of her room because it's the one place she feels free, where she can just be curious and alive. But Aaron follows her there secretly — he's spying even when he's trying to indulge himself. The white dress at the wedding, the pure white fabric covering a woman branded a witch... that's the central irony of the whole thing. She's dressed as a bride but she's really a prisoner. And Aaron is dressed as a loving husband but he's really her jailer. Both of them wearing costumes, both of them drowning.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or