OLD-WORLD EXTRA - Reviews

What can i say expect boi......

this is be fking good

still need an improvement but the characters are good for me it's just that the plot and story still need more push

Hello readers.

This will be my last self-review for this novel as I can only afford to lightly spoil the first volume, the rest you must experience on your own.

The first volume has finally ended everyone, it's been a blast to edit and add many things to this version of my story, I believe I've written the best first volume I possibly could.

And although this is an 'Extra' novel, it isn't even close to how others with the same name are written, because while I enjoy this type of novel I wanted to write it differently, unlike the others where the weapon selection chapter is always 20 kek.

So expect a longer introduction to the world in the first two volumes and only then, when the MC establishes himself as someone proper in the story will the Academy arc truly begin.

The text below contains spoilers so only read this if you have doubts about reading this novel.

For now, I'll answer a few of the questions I've received so far.

I haven't started the first chapter yet.
but just seeing the author's involvement and emotions in the comments, the author update and the illustrations, I want to leave a good rating and try this novel.
To be seen for the quality of the work itself, but for now i am hopeful.

Honestly, a great read that keeps you captivated. I won't delve into any spoilers, but it's gives a nice fresh of breath air into the apocalypse and "isakai" genre (from what I've read do far).Progression is satisfying as the MC doesn't abide by clichès and continues to surprise.

I've been stuck on this book's early chapters  for a quite long time already. And  i think now is the time for us to part ways.

The pros :


-  The mc's backstory is unknown yet he is likeable and understandable on a certain level.

-  The world is original.

-  Some might like the rather slow pace .

-  The mc's reaction to his reincarnation is really realistic .

- A promising plot slowly unravels .


- The author 's writing quality is above average( the style is not very eye-catching but it manages to keep you intrigued and  there aren't many mistakes ( if any) ).

- I don't know the chapters' lenght , but i can tell it must be longer than your average 1000 words on webnovel.


The cons :

- The characters are  bland.
The Mc  is likeable yet somehow , he is uninteresting enough.
If i'm being honest , i simply don't care enough about him , even though i know him( i've read 23 chapters already).
I think  this comes from two facts  :

First , the Mc doesn't really have any flaw he should work on( egoism , dishonesty...).
Him being insecure makes me empathize with him but that's all. I do not feel really tied to him , nor does he seems realistic , since he has no bad side.

And second , the mc's personality is melancholic and cold.
Contrary to what people think , writing about a cold mc  is really difficult , since it's hard to make him engaging.
But not only did the author make him cold , he/she also used an omniscient pov , which further distances readers  from the Mc.

If only he had funny thoughts despite having a cold demeanor, it would have still been fine.
But as i said earlier , he is melancholic. So don't expect rejoicing thoughts from him.


On another point , i also don't really like how the Mc acted( in the 23rd chapter ) as though Killing was forced upon him.

Emir  had a choice. He could have let the hitmen go. So i don't understand  why  he lamented and acted as if it was forced upon him. If he acts in a certain way , he has to uphold his responsabilities. This all whinning time discredited him highly and it was even the final push for me to  definetely stop reading this book.

All in  all , he is not irritating nor engaging. He is fine and just fine.


Now for the side characters...
They are forgetable( even the Mc's mother and his sister).


-  The pace is slow.
As i said above , the pace is rather slow.
And this together with the characters makes the story feels dragging.


-  I don't really like the book's general vibe .
The book's ambiance is the reflection of the Mc : cold and melancholic.  It doesn’t change one bit , and this ends up making the whole reading experience underwhelming.



Finally , I pray for your improvement author and hope that my honest review does help you.

Giving myself five stars is shameless, but I think I deserve it.

I've put a lot of thought into this novel, many future events are already planned with foreshadowing in the current chapters, so look out for them.

In this review, I will highlight what you can expect from my novel, although I'm a newbie novelist, I can guarantee you that my novel has excellent writing, and character design.

This novel's story is based on a mix of many genres and novels, novels such as Rebuild world, TOPAV, and small elements from Legendary mechanic, and genres such as Sci-Fi ; Fantasy.

The world it self is a mix of futuristic and post apocalyptic, so a cyberpunk like world.

I'll plan to update atleast once a day, everyday, for a while, only missing days when I'm too busy.

As for the many of you who ask if there is going to be a harem or not, let me answer you now.

Probably not, it depends on how the story would go tbh, since I'm not set yet on the female characters he will be meeting and how their stories would go.

The romance will start later into the story and no it wont be the focus, not in the least, so for now atleast, harem haters don't worry too much, as there is one FL in mind.

The story starts of slow, with big revelations about the world at the end of the first volume, I'm republishing my novel, so if you are a reader coming back from my old one, then hello, good to see you again, and for new readers, welcome and I hope you enjoy reading my story.

As soon as I read the synopsis, I had a feeling this novel would be impressive. Once I delved into the initial chapters, the writing completely drew me in, and the original concept (in the first chapter) cemented my curiosity to see what else the author has in store for us. The first chapter was truly unforgettable and well-written. I'm only a few chapters into the novel, but I'm excited to experience the story and will continue following it.

I added this novel to my collection after seeing the like. I decided to give it a read and omg it's freaking amazing after reading some few chapters. I love everything about this novel. I promise to continue to read more.

So my reason for stopping this book is probably not why others would stop reading it and honestly I only made it to about chapter 45 but here’s my take… first the things I like: the first few chapters really drew me in there was a little humor making fun of other novels and cliches along with a decent sense of mystery making me look forward to what was going to happen. I like that the power system off the bat wasn’t the same thing I’ve read a million times. Although a little slow to start you can kind of see the MC struggle with him not actually being the son and instead an invader to this family even if it’s not his choice.. the few battles that we see are decently well written and not to over the top… heres where the book lost me and maybe for some of you this isn’t an issue.. very quickly we find out the MC can,is ,and mostly likely will be in the future unable to control himself and I mean literally someone badically takes over his body and I’m completely uninterested in an MC that may or may not lose his free will or ability to control himself in any form complete turn off now anytime I’m reading I will foreve wonder when it’s gonna happen again and be just as uninterested

the description was a mouthful to read out loud but it got me interested

None much would come to my mind in accord to this piece — purely, it’s fantastic!