There's a layer of meaning in that sound-guessing scene that I can't shake. Dong Ling Ce hears sex and defecation—two things that reduce a woman's voice to something base, something to be consumed or dismissed. Bao Ye's answer—slapping—is violence, yes, but it's also agency. It's the sound of someone fighting back. The progression from single slap to double to "as I please" mirrors Bao Ye's whole existence: restrained, imagined, desired, but not yet acted upon. Dong Ling Ce even says it—"you only dare to think about it but don't dare to do it." The observation cuts both ways though, doesn't it? Because Bao Ye IS doing things. He's just doing them carefully, strategically, in the spaces where he has leverage.
And then the label "ugly slave"—how many times does it get thrown around? It's used as an insult, but it's also becoming a reputation. People are seeking him out at Fengyue Pavilion specifically. The deacon calls him that with contempt, but the car full of people calls him that with desperation. The label stays the same; the meaning shifts entirely depending on who's saying it and why. That's the book's thesis right there—identity is whatever the powerful say it is, until the powerless start proving them wrong.
The nine-color flower vine is another symbol I'm sitting with. Nine colors. A vine—something that climbs, that reaches, that binds. He weaves it into jewelry, into accessories that press against skin. Beauty made from something wild, shaped by careful hands, given freely. It's everything Bao Ye is trying to be in a world that keeps telling him he's nothing.