Now Is the Time to Love a Friend - Reviews

Now Is the Time to Love a Friend
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The vines in this chapter are doing SO much symbolic work. They cover the entrance to Theodora's hideout, hiding it from view — just like Adrian's true feelings are hidden behind his role as protector and friend. The dried-up vines outside contrast with the living, tended space inside, which mirrors how Adrian's relationship with Theodora appears dormant to the world but is actually thriving beneath the surface. There's also the recurring motif of Adrian's fear of losing her. "If there was one thing Adrian feared most in this world, it was the complete end of his relationship with Theodora." This isn't just plot motivation — it's the thematic core. Everything he does, every suitor he sabotages, every lie he tells, stems from this terror. But ironically, his fear is what keeps the truth trapped. If he confesses, he risks losing her. If he stays silent, he loses her to someone else. The paradox is suffocating. The rumor about his sexuality functions as a dark mirror to his real situation. Society sees him as defective because he won't marry or pursue women, just as he feels defective because he can't be honest with Theodora. Both are misunderstandings rooted in the same inability to speak truth. When Theodora accepts his imagined homosexuality, she's actually offering him something real — unconditional acceptance. The tragedy is that he can't accept it because accepting it means never being loved for who he truly is.
... Read More
Okay so this whole chapter sequence is basically one long tension-building machine and I love it. The structure here is so deliberate—the lunch scene sets up the obvious social game where everyone's playing against each other, then you have the garden walk as the 'adventure' that lets the real story breathe. What I found fascinating is how the author uses physical space to control pacing. The garden has this layout—small door, lawn, arch bridge, half-hour walk to the pavilion—and each location milestone marks a shift in how intimate the conversation gets. At the start they're performing for the parents, by the bridge they're kids again, and by the time they reach the pavilion, Adrian drops the bomb about choosing Melhem because she was there. That's a masterclass in plot architecture. The spy subplot at the very end? Classic misdirection. Just when I thought this was purely a slow-burn romance, boom, war intrigue enters the room.
... Read More
I need to talk about Adrian because my brain is still not processing him. On one hand, he's the guy who told Theo 'he doesn't suit you' with such concise subtlety that it basically amounted to a rejection of her romantic agency. On the other hand, he's the guy who spent three years systematically destroying her courtship options while pretending to be her friend. The scene where he sees her with Robert Huxley and his expression 'noticeably hardened'—that single physical detail tells us everything. He's not just protective, he's territorial. And then he lies to her face about Langham, calling him 'that idiot,' framing himself as the well-meaning friend who did background research. But the hesitation when Theo asks about the other two suitors? That's the real Adrian. That's the man who can't even lie convincingly to someone he claims to trust completely. And Theo trusting him anyway—'You're the only person in this world I can trust more than myself'—it makes my chest ache. She literally just learned he's been orchestrating her life and her first instinct is to absolve him. That's not love, that's something more complicated and more dangerous.
... Read More
The transition from the debut ball to 'about a month later' is one of those editorial choices that just works. The author could have lingered—dragged out the aftermath of that quadrille, showed more of Theodora's guilt, let us sit with the tension a beat longer—but they made the call to advance time and hit us with the consequences instead. And what consequences! In just a paragraph we go from one overwhelmed dancer to seven balls in two weeks, suitors swarming like it's a nature documentary, her parents sending mixed signals, Eloise completely checked out of the chaos. The pacing here compresses a whole arc of social escalation into a tight summary that actually reads faster than a single scene would. You feel the weight of it—the repetition, the exhaustion, the sheer volume of attention Theodora never asked for. Then, right as we settle into this new routine, the chapter drops us into a moment where Adrian corners her away from the suitors and the text cuts off mid-sentence: 'the Marquis of Devon. Second son of the Bachelet Ducal House, and currently the head of the Marquis of D' — And we're left hanging. That cliffhanger structure is ruthless and I appreciate it. Every chapter boundary feels like a door opening onto something you didn't expect.
... Read More
I need to talk about the abandoned vineyard and the hidden shed. This place is everything. "Following her inside, the place was as dark as a cave. Only after Theodora skillfully lit a lantern did Adrian realize it was an old shed, hidden by grapevines and wisteria." The visual of vines and wisteria masking a secret door, then the warm glow of a lantern revealing swept floors and wooden chairs—it reads like a film scene. You can literally see it. What makes it work is that this is THEODORA'S space, not Adrian's. She built this alone, without telling him, and called it "our" hideout. When she says "Originally, the leader prepares a secret base, don't they?" it's playful but also reveals how much thought she put into reserving a place for him even while he was away. The contrast between the dead, dried vines outside and the cozy, cared-for interior mirrors their relationship perfectly—surface-level stillness hiding something that has been actively tended. The chapter opens at a ball too, with all its artificial lighting and social performance, but the vineyard feels infinitely more real. Theodora riding a chestnut horse alone, hood pulled low, breeches and boots peeking out—she's shedding the constraints of nobility to come somewhere authentic. Adrian notices the unfamiliarity of seeing her like this and it unsettles him because she's always been predictable to him in her kindness and warmth. Here she's dangerous, independent, secret-keeping just like him.
... Read More
There's something so rich going on with the glove motif throughout this entire passage. On the surface it's literally about removing gloves to feel bare skin contact—but symbolically, it's about every mask these characters wear. Adrian pretends his motivation is helping Theodora find a husband when really he's just greedy for her presence. Theodora pretends she's not affected by their intimacy when clearly she's just as unravelled. Even their "practice" is a performance—both of them playing roles they don't believe in. The gloves represent everything that stands between genuine human connection: social custom, self-imposed isolation, fear, duty, the whole oppressive weight of their world. When Adrian unpicks that button at the wrist with his long fingers, he's not just removing a glove—he's peeling back a layer of the fiction they've built around themselves. And then there's Adrian's belief that he's cursed, that his fate is to destroy everything precious to him. That's basically a metaphor for trauma itself—the way it convinces you that your very nature is destructive, that proximity to love will only lead to ruin. The tragedy is that he might be right about the danger, but he's absolutely wrong about deserving it. The novel keeps asking: can someone who believes they're poisoned still let themselves be touched?
... Read More
Okay so the way this section is structured is genuinely impressive. We open with Adrian's internal monologue—pure devastation, self-loathing, the works—and then immediately pivot to this almost comedic montage of Theodora listing marriage candidates like she's ordering at a menu. "Claudia Burlington." "No." "Charlotte Ogilvy." "Not interested." I was laughing out loud. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it WORKS. Then the pacing slows down significantly for the garden scene. We go from rapid-fire dialogue to these long, aching moments where nothing happens and everything happens simultaneously. Three days of buildup compressed into a single conversation, then the glove-removal sequence takes FOREVER in the best way possible—every tiny action stretches out, every breath matters. And that cliffhanger? Adrian finding Theodora surrounded by shady men including Robert Huxley? Perfect. Just perfect. He resolves to enjoy the party freely, tells himself he's just checking on her, and then immediately abandons all of that when he sees her with Robert. The irony is brutal and I loved every second of it.
... Read More
This one scene. Just one quadrille dance, and I was emotionally compromised. Let me walk you through it. Theodora is already spiraling—watching Adrian and Eloise look like the perfect couple, feeling guilty about her jealousy, trying to force herself to enjoy Andrew's company—and then Adrian switches partners mid-dance and pulls her into the formation. The physical description alone is enough to make anyone weak-kneed: his arm around her waist, his hand gripping hers, 'his body, which was too close for a quadrille... certainly much firmer and hotter than Andrew's.' And then he drops this on her: 'It should look like we're overly intimate. That's why I'm doing this.' Wait. WAIT. He is intentionally creating the appearance of romantic closeness while standing inside it, touching her, smelling her, breathing the same air—and he's doing it for HER benefit. For her social advantage. The man is weaponizing his own charisma as a public service and I am not okay with this. Theodora's internal monologue during this dance is a masterpiece of denied feeling. She catches herself thinking about Adrian while dancing with ANOTHER MAN and immediately berates herself for it. 'Truly, it was a pathetic action and something she shouldn't do to her marriage partner.' But here's the thing—Andrew isn't doing anything wrong. He's perfect. And that's what makes it hurt. The love interest who loves you back the healthiest way is always the most painful plot device.
... Read More
'She was staring at a java plant pot drying up under excessive sunlight.' I'm not even sure the author intended this as emotional shorthand but it hit me like a freight train. Theo hiding behind a plant pot, wilting in too much sun, while men circle around her like vultures at a social event—there's something so devastatingly accurate about that image. And then Robert approaches her and mentions her love of plants. For the first time, someone sees HER, not the Marquis's project. And Theo catches herself mid-thought and thinks: would Adrian welcome someone like Robert as a husband? That moment of immediately checking everything against Adrian's approval—it's the most heartbreaking sentence in this entire batch. She's so conditioned to live in his shadow that she can't even imagine choosing without him. But then Langham ruins it all with the truth about the withdrawn proposal. And Theo's internal monologue does this incredible dance—her heart wants to defend Adrian, her mind recognizes the manipulations, and she just says 'Yes, I trust you' because the truth is too heavy to carry in a single evening. The emotional whiplash is real.
... Read More
The pacing of this section is genuinely masterful. Let me explain why. In roughly two chapters, the author handles a FIVE-YEAR time jump without making me feel like I missed anything. How?! First there's this whole opening scene at the breakfast table establishing Theodora's daily misery and family dynamics, then we get the letter arriving, then the quiet interior monologue where she clutches Adrian's old letter ('Your eternal friend')—and that's where the flashbacks happen. Just a couple of paragraphs really, the coming-of-age ceremony memory, his clean expression, those words about being friends until death. And then BAM we're back in the present, a month later, the carriage arriving. No 'meanwhile' headings, no awkward time markers, it just flows. The scene transitions are seamless. What really sells it though is the emotional pacing. The moment Adrian steps out of the carriage—Theodora 'momentarily forgot to breathe'—that single beat is everything. Five years of pining compressed into one breathless second. Then the dinner scene where her father tries to set her up with her crush? That's where the tension really builds and then Adrian saves the moment with that deflection about the Duke. The chapter ends right when her father's hope is piqued and she's feeling 'empty and bitter' despite being captivated by his stories. I want to know what happens next immediately.
... Read More
This chapter is soaked in symbolic imagery and I can't stop thinking about it. The garden itself is a massive symbol—the Hazel family's landscape garden, personally tended by Theodora, representing her private world and her agency in a society where noble ladies had 'little else permitted.' But there's also the small door connecting the mansion to the garden, which feels like a threshold between two versions of her life: the dutiful daughter performing for her parents versus the girl who used to run free with Adrian. And then there's that line Adrian drops that wrecked me: 'I'm really glad you haven't changed, Theo.' Theodora interprets it as a compliment but the narration immediately reframes it—she feels like 'a pond that had turned sour,' stagnant. This is the book quietly asking: what does it mean to remain 'good' and unchanged when the world expects women, especially noblewomen, to stay fixed in place? Her gardening isn't just a hobby; it's the one domain where she exercises control and taste. The pavilion they reach after crossing the stream—their 'secret hideout' from childhood—symbolizes a space outside time, outside social expectation, where they can be themselves. But even there, Lucas the aide keeps reappearing, a reminder that the real world won't let them stay in that bubble. And the very last line about the spy dressed as a woman? That's the book's thesis statement about identity, performance, and how people disguise their true selves to survive. Beautifully layered.
... Read More
The pacing in this batch is genuinely exceptional. We start with what feels like a routine social scene—Theodora escaping the marriage market, dodging suitors, finding a quiet corner. It's almost meditative in its sadness. Then Robert appears and suddenly there's hope, however faint. She's engaging with someone new, talking about plants, placing her hand on his arm. The energy shifts. Readers feel it. Then Langham arrives and everything detonates. The transition from that fragile moment of connection to the terrace confrontation is so abrupt it mimics what Theo is experiencing. She doesn't get to process Robert before the ground shifts under her feet again. What's brilliant is how the author uses Adrian's chapter at the end. We're already in crisis mode with Theo, and then we cut to Adrian—cold, furious, reading a letter in a cipher—and instead of resolving the tension, it amplifies it. The short sentences, the clipped dialogue with Lucas, the way he can't answer Theo's question from three days ago... all of this delays the confrontation we desperately want while making us need it more. The final image of him staring at the garden, the letter in his hand, is a perfect cliffhanger that doesn't scream for attention but quietly demands you turn the page.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or