Nanke Yifu - Reviews

Nanke Yifu
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"Don't look," Yan Laixi said, lowering his head and clutching his cuff. That line DESTROYED me. Let me just sit with that for a second. This man — this man who had just woken up in someone else's house with no memory, who was clearly in some kind of psychological crisis — his FIRST instinct when Chi Fu noticed his self-harm marks was to HIDE them. To make an excuse. "I did it accidentally." ACCIDENTALLY. Sir, you have crescent-shaped PINCH MARKS from your own fingernails and teeth BITES on your arm. Those are not accidental. That is someone falling apart in a bathroom stall and trying to feel something other than panic. And the fact that Chi Fu — the person whose amnesiac self he apparently doesn't even remember — notices immediately and his heart literally aches? The author didn't even need dialogue for that moment. Just: "Seeing them made Chi Fu's heart ache as if he'd been stabbed." That's it. That's the entire relationship distilled into one sentence. They don't need to remember each other for their bodies to know. Chi Fu knew before he knew WHY he knew. And Yan Laixi? He's so broken that he can't even ask for help properly. He runs to the bathroom and retches. He bites himself. He won't let Chi Fu see his wounds. He's performing "I'm fine" like his life depends on it — because honestly, maybe it does. What does he have left if he can't even be vulnerable with the person who claims to love him? And yet he's there. At Chi Fu's door. In the morning. Still showing up.
... Read More
This conversation about Anomalies hit me in the chest. Yan Laixi laying out his fears so plainly — worried about the time running out, about losing what matters, about being cast into hell after twenty years of health — it's devastating because it's so vulnerable coming from someone who otherwise keeps everything controlled. And Chi Fu's response? 'You need to learn from me.' But here's the thing: Chi Fu's 'live in the moment' philosophy isn't just some carefree attitude. When he says 'the cart will find its way up the mountain,' there's this underlying awareness that he doesn't actually know what his own Anomaly is. He's performing optimism the way some people perform happiness — because the alternative is thinking about it too hard. But then Yan Laixi catches him and turns it around: 'What about when the bad situation actually happens?' And Chi Fu has to just... stall. He can't give a real answer. The scene where they're eating together and Yan Laixi is just talking nonstop about everything and nothing, and Chi Fu is following along perfectly, introducing new topics before the old ones run dry — that's intimacy without naming it. And the corn detail! Yan Laixi forgot to eat because he was too absorbed in conversation. That's the kind of small moment that tells you everything about how safe he feels with this person.
... Read More
There's this one scene — just the rain sound outside the window, two people passing time until it gets dark, cooking, eating, lounging — and it hits different because of what we know about their world. These two are holed up inside while rain won't stop, and somewhere beyond that wall — the literal WALL that encircles their entire continent — there's water that supposedly ends. That concept of The Wall, an invisible but tangible sphere surrounding everything, is so quietly devastating when you're sitting in a warm apartment with someone you care about. The Maglev Transit system, the district geography (Chaozhi, Chaoyuan, the four regions divided by straight lines across a circular continent), Yan Laixi's job writing novels despite studying Anomaly Control — it all layers in so naturally during what seems like casual conversation. The author doesn't info-dump; they let the world breathe through domestic moments. The rain isn't just weather, it's the reason Chi Fu stays. It's the excuse for proximity that neither of them would've asked for directly. Yan Laixi's line about never knowing what's outside The Wall even after he dies? That's the whole vibe of this story compressed into one sentence. We're all just living inside our walls, wondering.
... Read More
There are two scenes in this text that are so vividly rendered I can physically FEEL them. The first one: nighttime. Chi Fu and Yan Laixi sharing a bed, the temperature perfectly comfortable, the room dark except for that small desk lamp Chi Fu turns on to write in his diary. The author describes Yan Laixi sitting up against the headboard, watching Chi Fu move around in the dark — and then Yan Laixi slips out of bed onto the FLOOR. Just... sits on the floor beside the bed all night because he's terrified of losing this closeness the moment he falls asleep. That image of him on the cool floor, eyes struggling to stay open, hearing morning sounds through the blackout curtains — I literally got chills. The second scene hits even harder. Yan Laixi at Chi Fu's door in the early morning light, sitting on the FLOOR this time (parallel imagery, by the way — both of them on the ground, both of them broken in different ways), staring up at Chi Fu with eyes that go from hopeful to utterly shattered in one sentence. The bathroom retching sound through the wood. The damp collar and cuffs. The way Yan Laixi follows the warm water cup like a puppet on a string, eyes glazed, leaning forward until Chi Fu has to physically guide him back. These aren't just described scenes — they're cinematic. You can SEE the dim lamp light, the folded towels by the bathroom door, the rice porridge simmering on the stove that hasn't been pre-soaked. The world feels lived-in and real, and the emotional weight of every object in these rooms feels heavy with meaning.
... Read More
This chapter moves at a pace that feels exactly right for the subject matter. You've got the immediate crisis (amnesia!) but then the author deliberately slows down into these tiny, almost mundane interactions. The phone call. The walk to the consulting room. The question about birthdays. It's like the narrative is breathing alongside them, giving weight to every pause, every hesitation. What I appreciate most is how the tension builds not through big revelations but through what's withheld. We don't get a flashback to their past relationship. We don't get exposition about why Chi Fu lost his memory. We just get Yan Laixi's face, his voice, his careful distance. And that's more powerful. The structure mirrors Chi Fu's experience – he's moving forward blindly, gathering fragments, trying to assemble a whole from pieces. The chapter ends with him confessing his love all over again, which feels like both an ending and a beginning. It's circular in the best way. I found myself rereading sections because the pacing made me savor each exchange. This isn't a chapter that rushes; it's a chapter that lingers. And god, am I glad it does.
... Read More
So here's what's happening on the plot level and I need to process it: these two clearly had a previous relationship — maybe romantic, maybe something more complicated — and now they're reconnected, and the entire chapter is essentially YAN LAIXI TRYING TO BE A GOOD HOST WHILE CHU FU IS LOSING HIS MIND OVER HOW DOMESTIC THIS ALL FEELS. The structure is deceptively simple. Rain starts → Chi Fu comes over → they spend the day together → night falls → the overnight stay invitation → the shared bed scene. It's a slice-of-life chapter on the surface, but underneath every beat is loaded with unspoken history. When Yan Laixi says "See you next time" and Chi Fu echoes it, that's not just politeness — that's two people who already know this isn't the last time they'll see each other, but who are still savoring the certainty of it. The flashback/dream layer is what makes this plot genuinely interesting. Yan Laixi's whole reason for studying Anomaly Control was to try to control his Dream. His current novel-writing career grew out of that same curiosity. The entire narrative framework seems to be built on the idea that dreams and reality blur — and that whatever happened between these two before might have existed in a space that was neither fully one nor the other.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is either genius or cruel, possibly both. The author could've rushed this — Chi Fu shows up, they bond, he stays over, done. Instead we get an entire afternoon of rain sounds and grocery shopping and casual games, building this unbearable cozy atmosphere before the real tension hits at night. And that night sequence? Masterclass. The shower scene alone — Yan Laixi taking his time deliberately, Chi Fu sitting on the bed growing increasingly restless, the door finally opening — the author stretches three seconds of real time into pages of agonizing anticipation. Then immediately undercuts it with Chi Fu forgetting his bath towel because his brain has short-circuited. Perfect comedic relief right when you need it. The ending is what kills me though. "Yan Laixi heard silence outside the door, secretly peeked out, and seeing Chi Fu asleep, he quietly closed his bedroom door, moving as lightly as possible. For him, the night was just the beginning of the day." This man had Chi Fu asleep on his sofa, went back to his room, peeked out like a paranoid cat, and then — the night was just BEGINNING for him. While Chi Fu was having the most normal sleep he's had in who-knows-how-long, Yan Laixi was just getting started. The contrast between Chi Fu's peaceful domestic fantasy and Yan Laixi's actual nocturnal existence is the kind of structural irony that makes re-reading essential.
... Read More
The central metaphor of this entire work — that life itself is a dream (Nanke literally means 'dream' in classical Chinese) — hits different when you realize Yan Laixi is writing his own dream into books. Flying Mirror Separation is the key: a mirror reflects but also distorts, a reflection you can see but never truly touch. That's exactly what his dreams are — accessible through sleep but fundamentally separate from reality. And Feng Su, the person in his dream, exists in this liminal space between 'lover' and 'special person' and 'relative,' never fully categorized, never fully real. The twins motif across multiple characters isn't just coincidence — it speaks to identity, duality, the idea that somewhere out there is another version of someone you know intimately. Chi Fu not knowing his own Anomaly yet could symbolize the unformed self, the part of identity that hasn't crystallized. And Yan Laixi's food pickiness! Think about it — he won't eat shrimp meat (only shell-on), he avoids things 'troublesome to eat,' he has very specific preferences about sweetness and sourness. These aren't just character quirks, they're about control. When your whole existence feels like it could be interrupted by an unpredictable Anomaly, the things you put in your mouth become one of the few domains where you have absolute authority. The orange charm connecting him to Chi Fu — warm color, small object, something carried daily — that's the anchor in a world where everything else feels provisional. Beautiful.
... Read More
The chapter structure here is actually really clever when you step back and look at it. We start with this intimate dinner scene—the kind where everything clicks between two people—and then the author SLAMS the brakes. Six days. That's how long passes before we cut to Chapter 7, and those six days are split perfectly: three days of Chi Fu living in pure joy, then three days of him being so ecstatic he forgets to set a meeting location while Yan Laixi is over here mentally spiraling. "The reality was that Chi Fu was so focused on his excitement that he completely forgot they had only set a time but not a location. Yan Laixi spent his days clutching his phone, waiting for a message, but the red dot never appeared." This is peak miscommunication setup and I am HERE for it. The author doesn't even make it dramatic on purpose—it's just human nature. Chi Fu's so happy he doesn't think to follow up, and Yan Laixi is too polite/anxious to push. Then on Saturday NIGHT, Yan Laixi texts first, and the reply comes instantly with a string of panicked messages. The scene transitions from warm and golden to slightly anxious in one beat, which is exactly the kind of tension pivot that makes you want to keep reading. Also, the whole "you input yours too" phone exchange moment—two people simultaneously realizing they should add each other as friends, the mutual hesitation, the six-character descriptive nickname Chi Fu adds. It's such a small plot point but it does SO MUCH character work.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is genuinely some of the best I've read. Every line serves dual purpose — advancing the scene AND revealing character — and sometimes both at once in ways that caught me off guard. Chi Fu's voice is loud, impulsive, self-deprecating in the funniest way. "My birthday is late, so I'm nineteen now. I can't be ninety, so I'm nine." This man will literally argue with arithmetic to avoid growing up. And then immediately follows it with "I'm a prodigy" like he just solved a Nobel-level problem. Yan Laixi's deadpan response — "Then, prodigy, please solve the research topic that I failed to make any substantial progress on throughout high school" — is peak older-brother energy and I lived for it. But the real dialogue gold is in what goes UNsaid. When Yan Laixi says "Your pajamas and bath towel are by the door. Grab them when you're done" and the narrator immediately comments on how thoughtful yet distant that is — the dialogue itself is perfectly normal, which is exactly what makes it ache. These two know each other so well that their ordinary conversation becomes a minefield of nostalgia and longing. And Chi Fu's bare-knuckle honesty: "Of course I do!" when asked if he wants to sleep with Yan Laixi. No filtering, no hesitation. Just pure id operating at maximum velocity. That's a character voice I will NEVER forget.
... Read More
I need to talk about the name Chi Fu chose for himself in Yan Laixi's contacts: "Chi Fu, (Tomato Hotpot Boiled Cilantro)." This is not funny. This is not just a cute detail. This is the thematic CORE of the entire relationship compressed into one parenthetical. Chi Fu is literally the cilantro in someone else's hotpot—someone who seems random, maybe even polarizing to the outside world, but who belongs there in a way that transforms the whole experience. And the fact that he ADDED it deliberately, saying "the impression I left on you by saying I wanted to boil cilantro to eat should be much deeper than the simple two characters Chi Fu"—that's him announcing himself as someone unforgettable, someone who brings strong flavor to someone else's life. He's basically saying: I'm not going to be forgettable. I'm going to be the thing you taste and immediately remember. Then there's the little orange dog charm Yan Laixi gave him versus the cat charm on Yan Laixi's own phone. Dog and cat. Hotpot and cold drink. They're opposites that somehow fit together. And the cat charm's origin story—that it was passed down through layers of people, from a cat cafe to a flower shop friend to whoever drew the MV art to Yan Laixi himself—feels like a metaphor for how connections work in this story. Things travel through people. Nothing is direct. Everything is layered and accidental and somehow still reaches the right hands. "It's amazing that it could even reach the end of the line after being passed through so many layers." Yeah. That's literally this whole relationship.
... Read More
You know that moment when someone corrects how you address them and it changes everything? Yan Laixi telling Chi Fu to stop calling him “Mr. Yan” and just use his name? That's the whole story in one sentence. It's not just about politeness – it's about intimacy, about claiming a place in each other's lives that amnesia can't touch. And Chi Fu's response (“Then, come on. Laixi.”) – god, he just slides into it like it's natural, like his body remembers even if his brain doesn't. That's the thing I keep coming back to: these two have this history written in muscle memory. Chi Fu reaching for Yan Laixi's hand without thinking, Yan Laixi's nervous habit of hovering before pulling away, the way they fall into conversation about birthdays and food preferences like they've done it a thousand times before. But there's this undercurrent of fear too – Yan Laixi's apology after calling Chi Fu “get lost,” his willingness to sleep in the study just in case Chi Fu needs space. He's terrified of burdening him, of being the ghost of a relationship that only exists in one person's mind. Meanwhile Chi Fu is all in, saying “I fell in love with you again as soon as I opened my eyes” like it's the simplest truth in the world. I'm not okay with this dynamic.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or