My Classmate Whom I Helped Seems to Be Mentally Sick, So I’ve Been Trying My Best to Hide My True Identity, But It Seems Like I’ve Been Found Out - Reviews

My Classmate Whom I Helped Seems to Be Mentally Sick, So I’ve Been Trying My Best to Hide My True Identity, But It Seems Like I’ve Been Found Out
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'I'll marry him.' Two words. That's all it took for me to realize this girl is absolutely, completely unhinged and I am somehow already invested. Let me just say this: Sumire Murasaki is the most terrifyingly vivid character I've encountered in a long time. The school calls her the most beautiful girl, and yeah, the descriptions are there — auburn waist-length hair, almond eyes like gemstones, the whole package. But it's her psychology that stops you cold. She saw a masked figure save her life, never saw his face, and immediately decides this is her destiny. Not 'I want to thank him.' Not 'I want to meet him.' She says she wants to lock him in her room forever. Forever. Forever. And the way she dismantles Maeda — the hottest guy in school, basketball star, confident to the point of insulting — in literally three sentences? 'Because the height of a person who can wear that mascot suit is between 165.2 cm and 166.7 cm.' She measured him. MEASURED HIM. With her eyes. From a distance. While wearing a ridiculous inflatable costume. This is a girl who doesn't just observe the world, she catalogues it. Then the glance. Just one. At the end, when she passes his classroom, she looks at Hayate. Not a stare. Not a recognition. Just... a glance. And then she walks away. Did she see him? Did she suspect? The ambiguity is maddening and I cannot stop thinking about it. Their dynamic, even before they've truly interacted, is set up like a collision course. She's obsession incarnate. He's a coward who ran from the scene. Neither of them is ready for what the other represents.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say this whole arc from chapters 54 to 60 is the kind of plot progression that makes you immediately regret closing the book for five minutes. Not because it skips anything, but because every little beat lands so perfectly that losing even a single page feels like a personal loss. The setup from the beginning—Takizawa-kun still reeling from that kiss, trying to act normal while his internal monologue is absolutely spiraling—is brilliant pacing. He opens a romantic comedy and can't even read it because every mention of "kiss" makes him look at her. That detail alone tells me everything I need to know about where his head is at without the author having to spell it out in some dramatic declaration. Then Sumire's POV drops us straight into her head, and holy hell. "I love him, I love him, I love him..." repeated like a mantra. It's almost funny, but also kind of terrifying? Because she's not some anime-style yandere caricature—she's genuinely sweet, she helped his mom with a recipe, she says she feels secure *because* he's frail, not in spite of it. And then she buys handcuffs on Amazon and casually shows up at his apartment. The plot twist that hit me hardest wasn't a revelation—it was the gradual escalation. She moves in, they start having dinner together, then she asks him to walk her home, then *insists* he come inside for tea, and suddenly he's chained to a bed frame because she needed him to use the bathroom. But here's the thing: the author never lets it tip into outright horror. Sumire apologizes, unchains him, looks embarrassed, and asks if he'll stay. And he... just agrees? Walks back into the room? The convenience store encounter with Mifune feels like the author winking at us—yes, there's a rival, yes, there will be more complications—but then immediately undercuts it by having Sumire casually toss desserts into the basket and insist on paying. She says she's "indebted" to him, which reframes everything: she's not just the aggressive pursuer, she's someone who needs to feel like she owes something so the relationship doesn't feel one-sided. And ending on them walking home holding hands, him worrying about whether she can hear his heartbeat—that's the payoff. The plot didn't resolve anything. Nothing is fixed. But something shifted, and I need to know what happens next. God, I need the next chapter.
... Read More
The settings in this section are doing some serious heavy lifting and I want to talk about that. Let's start with the clubroom. It's introduced as this bright, cheerful space where Murasaki is "happy-looking" and the atmosphere seems warm. But the moment the protagonist hesitates about joining, the room transforms. Her demeanor darkens, and the narration explicitly connects it to the weather outside—"just as clouds covered the sun." The clubroom isn't just a location; it's a barometer for her mental state. Every time she's in that room, the energy shifts. It's become her territory, and by extension, his now. Then there's the walk home. This is such a deceptively normal scene—two classmates walking together after school—and yet it's one of the most uncomfortable passages I've read. She's quiet, which the narrator admits is "nice" but also "eerie." The calm before the storm. The author makes you feel thatunease without saying anything overtly wrong is happening. Just two people walking. And yet the reader is already bracing. The rooftop scene is where everything peaks visually. Standing in the middle of the roof, arms spread wide, looking up at the sky like she's been freed—that's almost a beautiful image. Then the knife falls. The contrast between her peaceful posture and the instrument of death rolling across the ground is chilling. She picks it up casually, like it's a pen, and smiles at him. The mundanity of the gesture makes it worse. And the home economics prep room at the end—she's waiting for him there, in an empty classroom, pencil pointed at his throat. The ordinary school setting becomes a prison. Every corner of this school has been colonized by her instability. There's no safe space for the protagonist, and that's the point.
... Read More
The stakes in this section went from zero to existential faster than I've ever seen in any novel. Let's trace the escalation because it's brutal. It starts with something almost comical—Murasasaki asking if he regrets joining the reading club. He wavers for a second and suddenly she's darkening like a thundercloud. The stakes at this point are social: he doesn't want to offend her, doesn't want to deal with the awkwardness. Low stakes. Then the LINE messages raise it to emotional manipulation. "Being left on read is kind of painful." He's now responsible for her feelings, and he doesn't know how to handle that. The stakes are psychological—will he say the wrong thing and trigger something? Then Mifune appears and Murasaki is clearly watching him. The stakes become surveillance. He's not just interacting with her; he's being monitored. "I am in the home economics prep room." She's positioning herself as both victim and captor. And then the rooftop. A knife. A suggestion of mutual death. The stakes are literally life and death. "With this, I was thinking of dying here with you, Takizawa-kun, but I'm glad I stopped." She stopped. For now. But the implication is clear—if he crosses her again, next time she might not stop. What makes this work is that the protagonist fully understands the stakes even when he can't escape them. His internal monologue is where the real terror lives. "It's like living with a knife pressed against my back." "I don't want this, I don't want to die." He's not a hero. He's a kid who wanted to join a book club and now he's trapped in something he can't get out of because leaving would mean admitting he lied about saving her, and she'd kill him for that too. The genius is that there's no winning condition. Every choice leads to disaster. That's peak survival horror writing disguised as a romance comedy.
... Read More
Honestly, I can't stop thinking about how smoothly this chapter escalates from bizarre to full-blown nightmare without ever losing its veneer of normalcy. We start with the protagonist being tied up for curry, which is already unhinged, but then it just keeps going—Sumire holds his hand after untying him, they walk home together, she invites him inside, he almost tries to escape while she's bathing, and she reveals she had a CAMERA watching him the whole time. The author plays with pacing so cleverly here. Every time I think the scene will spiral into outright violence or a dramatic confrontation, it deflates back into something almost tender. The mother's return is the perfect tonal pivot—this woman who just restrained a guy in her kitchen is suddenly flipping dishes and joking around. That moment where the protagonist realizes he won't tell his mom what happened? That's when the trap truly closes. He's not just physically stuck; he's complicit now. And ending with 'I feel like I'm going crazy' while panting? Chef's kiss. The plot doesn't need explosions or cliffhangers when it can do this kind of quiet, suffocating escalation. One thing still bugs me though—what exactly is Sumire's endgame here? Is this some elaborate game, or does she genuinely believe she's being kind?
... Read More
Let's talk about dialogue in this section, because the author clearly has a very specific rhythm that I'm obsessed with. Sumire's lines are deceptively simple. On the surface, she sounds like a normal—well, slightly eccentric—girl. "Takizawa-kun, can I come over to your house again today? That's okay, right?" That's it. That's the opener. Polite. Innocent. The kind of thing any girl might say. But it's followed by internal monologue that completely subverts it: "If she tries to interfere again, I'll crush her with all my might. After all, he's mine now. Both his body and his heart belongs to me." The gap between what she says out loud and what she thinks is where the comedy and the tension live. And the author never lets them converge. She never drops the mask completely in conversation, even when she's being her most unhinged self. Then there's this exchange: "So, Takizawa-kun, I'm going to take a bath and rinse off the sweat. Do you want to use the bathroom?" "...If I say I want to, will you unchain me?" "Mmm, I'll be preparing properly for that." That "Mmm"? That's not just a sound. That's a weapon. She's toying with him, and she knows it, and the fact that she phrases it as if she's being helpful—"preparing properly"—while literally keeping him hostage is peak comedy writing. But the dialogue that wrecked me was later, when she's actually vulnerable: "Hey, are you mad at me?" "Because... I was a bit mean. I really just didn't want you to go anywhere." "You won't leave, right? You'll stay, right?" Notice how she doesn't say "I love you" or any grand declaration. She says, in the smallest, most childlike way possible, that she doesn't want him to go. That's the kind of dialogue that sticks with you because it's true. People who are truly afraid of abandonment don't announce it dramatically. They ask stupid, repetitive questions and hope the answer is yes. And Takizawa-kun's internal voice throughout is this perfect balance of panicked resignation and reluctant affection. He knows he's in over his head. He knows he should probably be thinking about escape. But his thoughts keep circling back to her. The narrative voice carries that contradiction effortlessly. Also, hot take: the part where Mifune says "...So, this is why you asked about my part-time job" and Takizawa-kun responds with the most awkward deflection in literary history is the funniest moment in this entire batch. Pure gold.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Sumire's dialogue because honestly it's the standout feature of this entire chapter and maybe the whole novel. 'You do lie, Takizawa-kun. Isn't that also a lie?'—said while holding his hand after tying him up. This is such a casual, almost playful delivery for what is essentially an accusation. She's not angry. She's not threatening. She's just... stating facts, the way you'd comment on the weather. That's what makes her voice so distinctive. She never raises her volume, never threatens explicitly, never loses her pleasant tone. The menace is entirely in what she does, not what she says. Compare that to the protagonist's internal monologue, which is all fragmented and reactive—'O-okay,' 'Th-That's might be true,' 'Y-Yeah, I get it.' His speech collapses under pressure. He stammers. He can't form complete arguments. Sumire, meanwhile, speaks in complete, flowing sentences even when she's doing terrifying things. The mother's dialogue is perfectly sketched in just a few exchanges: 'Oh, you're a lifesaver. Really, I wish Sumire-chan could become our child.' 'Don't tease me, Auntie! I'm washing dishes, so please go ahead and take a bath.' This is such warm, ordinary, Japanese domestic dialogue—and it makes everything that happens around it feel even more wrong, because it's embedded in genuine warmth. And then there's the line that stopped me cold: 'Hey, doesn't it hurt?' She just tied him up. She literally fed him against his will. And she's asking with genuine concern if the ropes hurt. The dissonance between her tone and her actions is the author's secret weapon.
... Read More
I've been thinking about the handcuffs for days after reading this. They're introduced almost casually—Sumire just pulls them out like they're a normal household item, saying they're "to make sure Takizawa-kun doesn't wander around on his own." But the symbolism here is so layered I can't stop unpacking it. On the surface, they represent obsession and control. A young woman restricting a man's freedom under the guise of romance. That reading is valid and important—the story doesn't shy away from how unhealthy this dynamic is. But then the author complicates it immediately by having Sumire *apologize* for using them. She doesn't double down on the power move. She feels shame. She removes them herself and asks, essentially, to be trusted instead of chained. So the handcuffs become a symbol of two competing truths at once: love as possession, and love as surrender. Sumire wants both. She wants to keep him close, but she also wants him to choose to stay. The moment she offers him the choice—that's the real turning point of the entire arc. And the bathroom incident, which could have been purely comedic or purely horrifying, becomes something else entirely when you consider what it represents: total vulnerability. Takizawa-kun is at his most helpless, and Sumire holds all the power. But instead of using that power cruelly, she sets him free. She chooses mercy over dominance. That's the thematic core of this whole section—love isn't about control, even when it feels like it. Other symbols I noticed: the heart-shaped water stain on the ceiling. It appears right when Takizawa-kun is questioning whether he's happy. The universe, represented by a mold spot in a bathroom ceiling, is asking the same question back at him. The night breeze that cools his sweat-soaked body right before Sumire emerges from the shower—nature intervening at the moment of maximum tension, almost like a director's cue. And the convenience store itself, lit by sparse fluorescent lights in an otherwise dark street, functioning as a liminal space where the ordinary rules of their world briefly pause and something new can happen between them. The story keeps asking: what does it mean to belong to someone? And it doesn't give a clean answer. Which is exactly right.
... Read More
Every conversation in these chapters is a loaded gun disguised as small talk. Murasaki's voice is bright, probing, deceptively light. 'Do you read light novels?' 'You also like yandere-type?' She's not asking; she's placing breadcrumbs. Takizawa's responses are hesitant, self-deprecating, full of ellipses and qualifiers. 'Well, yeah, but…' 'I wouldn't say I like it, but…' He's trying to sound normal while his internal monologue screams. The narrative voice stays close to his perspective, so we hear his doubts directly: 'I have a bad feeling,' 'I was convinced,' 'I really want to believe.' That proximity makes the dialogue even more tense—we know he's suspicious, but he can't prove it. The teacher's lines are blunt, functional, almost comedic in their directness ('Just make time after school'), which contrasts with Murasaki's playful evasiveness. The best exchange is the bread sharing. She offers half; he accepts. Simple, but the subtext screams: she's feeding him information, he's swallowing it. The author lets silence do the work. What's not said—the secret identity, the stalking history, the unacknowledged attraction—fills every gap. Dialogue here isn't communication; it's combat with politeness.
... Read More
There's this moment around midnight where Sumire is in the kitchen wearing an apron, and the narration just lingers on it for a second. She moves smoothly, knows exactly where everything is, and Takizawa watches her silhouette. It sounds domestic, right? Cozy even. But you can feel the wrongness underneath it because we already know she was in his room looking through his stuff. And then—boom—the apron detail hits: "It looks exactly like the one I sewed during home economics class in middle school." That's when everything clicks into place. His room was touched. His personal items were accessed. And she's wearing proof of it while cooking curry like nothing happened. The whole chapter plays out in these tight, contained spaces—his house, the clubroom, the walk to school. None of it is grand or cinematic. It's claustrophobic on purpose. You're locked in a room with people who seem normal but aren't, and the world feels suffocating because every location is a trap waiting to spring. I also love the Momo-nyan campaign detail at the station front. It's such a mundane, slice-of-life event that contrasts with everything else going on. The author uses these cozy, everyday details to make the darkness underneath feel even more jarring when it surfaces.
... Read More
I need to talk about Sumire Murasaki because wow. This girl is simultaneously the most dangerous person I've ever encountered in fiction and the most tragically written character. Let's break this down because my brain is still spinning. She goes from sunshine club president who asks if he regrets joining to full-blown yandere in like three seconds. One moment she's happy, the next her gaze is "gloomy and moist, just as clouds covered the sun outside." The weather description mirrors her mood shift so perfectly it's almost poetic. And then she steps toward him and he panics and says the most obsequious thing ever—"I'm looking forward to the activities every day!"—and she immediately resets. Like a switch flipped. This is someone who can go from threat to sweet in an instant, and that unpredictability is what makes her so terrifying. But here's what gets me—the LINE message scene. She sends one nice message and then suddenly it's five rapid-fire check-ins: "Hey, what are you doing?" "Hey, is there someone at your house?" "Hey, being left on read is kind of painful." The repetition of "hey" is so telling. She's not angry, she's anxious. She's reaching out and grasping. The fact that the protagonist feels warmth at first—"it's the first LINE message I had ever received from a girl"—before remembering she's basically a ticking bomb? That's the tragedy. She wants connection. She just has no idea how to get it without suffocating the person she wants. And then Mifune enters the picture. "Light hair color, big droopy eyes, adorable duck lips." The protagonist notices all these details about another girl while being terrified of Murasaki. That contrast is everything. Mifune is described as beautiful but with a "gloomy atmosphere" too—two dark girls orbiting one guy who just wants to read books in peace.
... Read More
The dialogue writing in this section is deceptively simple, and I want to highlight why it works so well. Murasaki's lines are almost never complex. They're short, repetitive, and punchy. "Really?" "Then, you'll come properly from tomorrow?" "Shall we go home together?" There's no elaborate speech-making, no philosophical monologues about love or obsession. Just plain questions that somehow feel heavier than any dramatic soliloquy could. The LINE messages are where the voice really shines. Look at how she writes: "Hey, what are you doing right now?" "Hey, are you actually looking for the book?" "Hey, is there someone at your house, by any chance?" "Hey, being left on read is kind of painful." The escalating use of "hey" is brilliant. It's not angry—it's desperate. She's tapping on his phone screen like she's knocking on a door he won't open. And then the final line before he replies: "Hey, being left on read is kind of painful." That's not a threat. That's a child saying they're hurt. And that's what makes it so unsettling coming from someone who later produces a knife. The protagonist's voice, by contrast, is full of hedging and stammering. "Th-thank you for creating the reading club!" "Of, of course!" "S-sure." He's not a confident speaker at all—he's constantly backpedaling, making excuses, lying. His dialogue reveals his cowardice as much as his fear. And yet there's a strange honesty in his internal monologue that balances it out. When he thinks "I had not been harmed in any way, but I had an intuition that this was dangerous," that's the narrative voice cutting through all the fake politeness. Mifune's one line—"We're classmates, so it's not weird to know, right? Anyway, answer my question"—has a totally different energy. Sharp, impatient, no filler. She doesn't play the same game.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or