Love Under a Spell - Reviews

Love Under a Spell
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The sensory writing in this batch is genuinely elite and I'm here for it. Let me just list some moments that made me pause: The chilly autumn breeze messing up Marianne's curly hair as she steps out her door—that immediate grounding in physical sensation tells me exactly where we are seasonally and emotionally. She's flustered, rushing, and the wind won't even cooperate. Then there's the orphanage scene where Sylvester's 'dusty tips of his shoes' and 'dirtied white shirt' tell us everything about how he spent his afternoon without a single exposition dump. The author trusts us to understand that a high-ranking mage kneeling in the dirt for children says more than any description of his personality ever could. And the sunset scene—'the sunset had already dyed the sky red, painting the world in its hue'—that's the kind of line that makes you actually slow down and visualize. It frames their entire conversation in gold and crimson, turning a simple moment into something cinematic. The author doesn't over-describe the world but when they do paint a scene, it sticks with you.
... Read More
I want to talk about how this whole section reads like a beautiful tragedy that you can't look away from, even though you KNOW how it ends. The author has built this entire narrative around a deadline — five nights — and every single scene is filtered through that knowledge. It's the literary equivalent of watching something precious crack in slow motion. The pacing works on two levels. On the macro level, we have the countdown driving everything forward. On the micro level, individual scenes breathe at different speeds. The opening scene with Marianne reading the poem is slow and languid — almost meditative, like time itself is stretching. Then the hand-holding moment becomes this suspended, almost timeless beat where neither speaks and neither lets go. The date sequence moves quicker, almost breezily — restaurant, café, boat, theater — like the narrator is hurrying to fit as much joy as possible before the clock runs out. The transition into Chapter 6.1 with its heading 'The Day Love Comes to an End' is such a bold structural choice. It's basically announcing the ending in the chapter title and then making us sit with it. That's confidence. And then the Duke's arrival at the end of 6.2 hits like a ton of bricks after all that sweetness — it's the narrative equivalent of dropping a note in a love song and suddenly shifting to a completely different key. The chapter cuts off right as the conflict ignites, which is exactly where you want it to.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is deceptively simple — on the surface it's just two people being sweet to each other, but beneath every line there's this undercurrent of unspoken desperation. Look at how Sylvester speaks versus how Marianne speaks. His sentences tend to be shorter, more controlled ('It would be my honor.' 'Trust me.'). Even when he's being emotionally transparent, he frames it carefully. Marianne's dialogue, especially her internal monologue, is more fragmented and hesitant — ellipses everywhere, sentences trailing off, thoughts interrupting themselves. That contrast tells you everything about their personalities without any exposition. The most powerful dialogue moment is arguably the silent one. When they're walking toward the orphanage holding hands and neither says anything for a long stretch — just '...It was a beautiful poem and song.' / '...' / 'And it was a moment I'll remember for a long time.' The pauses ARE the dialogue. The author trusts us to understand that what's unsaid carries more weight than anything either of them could articulate. Marianne's internal voice is so distinct — 'I need to be brave' spoken to herself like a mantra, the way she rehearses what to say and then abandons the plan entirely when she sees him ('she skipped all the steps she had planned and thrust the bouquet toward Sylvester'). That impulse over strategy tells us so much about who she is. And Sylvester's sulk when she asks if she came to see Allen instead? Pure character. That's a man who's used to being prioritized and is momentarily startled to discover he actually cares.
... Read More
I keep thinking about that one moment — the split second when Marianne says 'Mage Peter Dolan' instead of whatever incantation was supposed to follow — and how it changes everything. On the surface, the stakes seem comically low. A group of mages is playing a prank. They wanted to embarrass their commander. Nothing life-or-death. But the story treats this moment with genuine tension, and I think that's because the author understands something fundamental about how life works: the smallest accidents create the biggest consequences. Look at what each character stands to lose. Peter loses his prank, his reputation among his colleagues (who are already glaring at him), and possibly his quarterly performance ranking since they left the magic circle active and the door unlocked. Erina loses face as the ringleader. The other mages lose whatever satisfaction they were getting from watching Sylvester suffer through a love spell. But Marianne? She walks into a room full of hostile, half-sober mages who are looking at her like she's the culprit. She has no allies in that room. Her only defense is politeness and confusion, and it's working barely. 'Did I… cause something to happen?' That question carries the weight of someone who has spent their whole life worrying about being a burden. And then Sylvester shows up with flowers, and the external conflict transforms into something entirely different. The real tension isn't 'will the spell work?' — it's 'will Marianne believe that someone like him actually wants something from someone like her?' That's a much deeper, more personal stakes, and the author nails it. The chapter ends with Marianne pinching herself and getting a red mark. Physical pain as proof that this is real. The stakes just went from magical prank to existential crisis in three sentences.
... Read More
Okay, so this whole sequence starts with Sylvester literally throwing his father's marriage suggestion letter into the fireplace. I love how the author uses that moment as the inciting incident for everything that follows—it's not just a rejection of an arranged marriage, it's him burning away the life his family scripted for him. And then immediately after, he finds himself wandering to this secluded corner near the rear gate where he spots this strange scene: a woman feeding starving military dogs. The plot moves in such a natural, almost accidental way here. Sylvester didn't plan any of this. He just... drifted there. And then three days later, his subconscious literally walked him back. The pacing in these chapters is really interesting because on the surface nothing huge happens—no battles, no political intrigue, just a man repeatedly finding himself near a corner of a fortress. But the tension builds through his internal escalation. Day one: curiosity. Day two: he watches from afar. Day three: he returns and the dogs reject him. Then chapter 4.2 jumps to him already having fixed the dogs' situation, but still returning to the corner like a moth to flame. The author drops this line about him searching for "an epilogue after the conclusion" and I literally laughed out loud because that is SO him—someone who needs narrative satisfaction even in his own life. The rumor subplot is another smart layer. Everyone knows he's falling for someone but refuses to name who, and the mages are tailing him. Meanwhile he's worried about Marianne's reputation while completely oblivious to how transparent he is. The structure here mirrors how real infatuation works—you're simultaneously hyper-aware of every detail about the other person and completely blind to how visible your feelings are to everyone around you.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the dogs in this story are NOT just dogs. They are literally the first thing Sylvester notices about Marianne's world. An empty iron cage, chains wrapped around a steel post, scattered food and water bowls—these are the remnants of utility, of service, of creatures who were once valuable and are now forgotten. Five emaciated military dogs with no handlers, abandoned to starve in a corner nobody visits. And Marianne—small, frail, seemingly unremarkable to everyone else—sits on the ground with them. She's the one who notices what others ignore. The dogs, who are notoriously aggressive toward everyone except their assigned knights, close their eyes and purr under her touch. This is the author's way of telling us something fundamental about Marianne's character before we even know her name: she has a gift for seeing worth in things the world has discarded. Sylvester's reaction to this is equally symbolic. When he returns three days later and the dogs tuck their tails and flee from him, he kneels down to their level. A man who stands above everyone—literally and figuratively—in this moment he chooses to meet the abandoned creatures where they are. The parallel between the dogs and Marianne is almost too perfect: both are overlooked, both exist on the margins of the fortress hierarchy, both possess a quiet capacity for warmth that the powerful people around them fail to recognize. The fireplace where he burns his father's letter is another image that won't leave me. Fire as transformation. Fire as refusal. He doesn't just reject the arranged marriage—he destroys the mechanism of that rejection so there's no going back. And what emerges from that act of destruction is a man who will literally restructure an entire knight order's dog management system because he can't stop thinking about a woman with thick glasses and curly hair. The old life is ash. The new one hasn't even begun yet, and he's already head over heels.
... Read More
There's something SO cinematic about the scene where Marianne is just standing there holding this bouquet of flowers while her whole world gets turned upside down. The imagery is deceptively simple but it works so well. The flowers themselves are a whole symbol I can't stop thinking about. Peter reveals that Sylvester enchanted them with an advanced spell to prevent wilting. Advanced magic. From a man who is apparently supposed to be affected by love potion. And Marianne can feel the cold spreading through her fingertips from the spell, but she can't bring herself to pull away. There's this tension between the physical coldness of the enchanted flowers and the warmth of what they represent—which is, you know, technically a magically-induced infatuation but ALSO genuine care on his part because HE chose to enchant them himself. Then we cut to the library scene with Anna and Marianne watching Sylvester from a distance. The fact that he's not in his usual uniform but in what passes for "casual" noble attire changes how he looks entirely. And he's reading a BEGINNER'S magic book. Of course. The top three mage in the empire, reviewing fundamentals. This is such a small detail but it tells us so much about who he actually is beneath whatever spell is supposedly on him. The library setting itself is interesting too. Anna points out how unusual it is for someone of his status to visit a public library when his private collection must dwarf theirs. But he comes anyway. Why? Before the revelation, we might assume it's fate pulling him toward Marianne. After, it becomes even more haunting—is this him seeking her out deliberately, or is the spell making him cling to wherever he last saw her? The imperial setting details are woven in so naturally too—the Knight Order, the nobility system, the hierarchy between commoners and marquis-level nobles. You get the sense of this world's social structure without it ever feeling like a textbook dump. Everything feels lived-in and real.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author uses light and darkness across these chapters because it's not accidental at all. Chapter 1 starts in a tavern at night, drunk mages stumbling through dim corridors, and then — dawn breaks with 'a bluish light.' That color choice is deliberate. Blue is cold, clinical, the color of magic research. The lab itself becomes a stage where something almost sacred happens: six hours when everyone gathers, rare as a solar eclipse for this department. Peter closing the curtains because 'we'll be last in performance again this quarter' — that single detail tells me so much about this world. There are quarterly performance rankings for a magic research division. Bureaucracy and magic are equally absurd here. Then Chapter 2 opens with sunlight. Actual, warm, cinematic sunlight. 'Although she and everyone else in the area were standing under the same sun, it strangely seemed as though only he was glowing.' Okay. That's not just description — that's the entire romantic premise of the book visualized in one sentence. The red flowers, the bluish dawn light from the first scene, the suddenly golden Plaza scene — the color palette shifts from cold magic to warm romance, and I noticed it subconsciously but it affected my entire reading experience. The central square statue of the Arvid Empire's second Emperor is mentioned in passing at the very beginning. A background detail? Maybe. Or maybe it's the kind of worldbuilding that will matter later. The Imperial Library, the Knight Order laundry room, the magic research lab — every location feels lived-in, not just set-dressing.
... Read More
I have to appreciate Allen because this guy is carrying the comedic weight of the entire batch and he doesn't even know it. The moment he introduces himself with this full title—'Aide to Marquis Velarc and Commander of the Mage Order, Sylvester'—and then immediately tries to establish familiarity by telling Marianne to call him Allen? That's peak assistant energy. And then Sylvester just ignores him completely to ask Marianne to coffee? And later drags him along to the orphanage despite Allen clearly not wanting to be there? The dynamic between these three is SO well written. But the dialogue that really got me was Sylvester's exchange with Marianne by the tree. His responses are short, almost halting—'...I enjoyed it. Though I wasn't very good at it.' That ellipsis usage throughout is doing so much emotional work. He's not a man who speaks in long flowing sentences; his words come out carefully measured, and when they're measured even further with pauses, you know something's underneath. Marianne's internal monologue is equally distinctive. 'I spent the day thinking about you over and over' nearly escaping her lips? That's such a natural, relatable thought pattern—the almost-confession that gets caught in your throat. The author gives each character a voice that's immediately recognizable.
... Read More
This section moves like a rollercoaster and I am HERE for it. It starts intimate—just two people, a healing spell, a tender moment. Very slow, very soft. Then BAM, trauma flashback hits you in the face. Marianne's internal monologue shifts from confusion to suspicion to defensive anger, and you feel her walls going up in real time. The author doesn't rush this—she lets the memory breathe, lets us feel why Marianne would jump to the worst conclusion. Then Sylvester's reaction to her accusation is masterful pacing. His face darkens. He actually looks sad. He backs off. He says something almost poetic—"We should have taken time to get to know each other first"—and then offers this ridiculous-but-kind act of introducing himself properly, one fact per day. The pivot from romantic tension to this almost childlike awkwardness is chef's kiss. And then the mages arrive like a scene from a chaotic sitcom. Peter and Erina come sprinting over, apologizing for spying, blurting out the entire magical disaster in one breath. The tonal whiplash from the tender moment to "oh my god we accidentally cursed you" is both hilarious and deeply stressful. Peter going from panicked to enthusiastic about Marianne having power over the commander in one conversation is comedy gold. The chapter then cuts to a time skip—"a few months ago"—and we're in the library watching Sylvester from afar. This structural choice is smart because it gives us breathing room after the emotional intensity of the confession scene while simultaneously deepening the mystery. Is he really under a spell? Or is some of this real? The pacing here is slower, more observational, which contrasts nicely with the chaos of the previous scene. The ending hangs on this question about beginner magic books that makes you want to keep turning pages. What is he really doing here? The structural tension between "we know it's magic" and "but what if it's not entirely magic" keeps you hooked.
... Read More
I want to talk about the structural choice here because it's genuinely clever. The author takes us from one of the saddest, most grounding scenes in the entire novel—Marianne discovering those starving dogs—and pivots straight into one of the most romantically charged moments between the leads. That's not accidental pacing. That's craftsmanship. Chapter 3.3 opens with worldbuilding about Marianne's exhausting work schedule. Three days a week, 7 PM to 7 AM shifts. Her ONLY day off is Thursday and she still heads to the west side of the capital. We get her backstory with the dogs told in a flashback woven naturally into the narrative—half a year ago she got lost, found the back gate, saw the dogs, and the rest is history. This section moves at a deliberate, almost documentary pace. You feel her weight, her exhaustion, her quiet compassion. It's slow because it needs to be—you need to feel how much she doesn't have to give, so her decision to give it anyway means something. Then Chapter 3.4 drops Sylvester into that same scene like a plot device disguised as fate. He appears while she's crouching among the dogs, and the tone immediately lightens. The transition from the grayscale sadness of abandoned war animals to the warm purple-sky romance of a magic flower exchange is jarring—in the best way. The author uses the dogs as an emotional bridge: both Marianne and Sylvester are drawn to vulnerable things that others have abandoned. He's the mage with a 'useless' secret ability; they're the retired dogs no one wants. The parallel isn't stated outright but it's there, and it makes the romantic payoff land harder because we've already seen what kind of person she is before we see what kind of person HE is. The pacing here is a masterclass in emotional whiplash. Sad → tender → romantic → funny (the ten-second lie breakdown) → philosophical (the god comment) → warm (the purple sky). Eight emotional beats in roughly two chapters and none of them feel rushed.
... Read More
Let me reframe what I think is happening beneath the surface of these chapters because the stakes are deeper than they appear. On the surface, this is a rom-com moment: guy makes flower, girl gets flustered, cute confession ensues. But the underlying conflict is about two people who have spent their entire lives being told their deepest qualities are worthless. Sylvester was FORBIDDEN from learning about his magic. He was told it was 'useless and ridiculous.' Marianne is a trainee librarian—literally the lowest rung—caring for retired dogs that the Knight Order abandoned because they're 'no longer useful.' Both of them are surviving in systems that tell them they don't matter. The real stakes here aren't about whether they'll hold hands or exchange glances. It's about whether these two people will continue believing the lies others told them about themselves, or whether they'll find someone who sees them clearly. When Sylvester says 'I was forbidden from gaining any related knowledge,' that's not just worldbuilding—that's trauma. He was punished for his gift. And Marianne's response reframes his entire identity: 'You managed to do that difficult thing. You made me laugh.' She takes the thing he was told was childish and elevates it to something sacred. The external conflict is simmering beneath every interaction—the mages who will come for answers tomorrow, the Knight Order that abandoned those dogs, the political machinery that treats people as tools. But the INTIMATE conflict is what makes this hurt: both of them feel unworthy of the affection the other offers. Marianne thinks she's not worthy of his love. Sylvester thinks his magic isn't worthy of recognition. And the scene where he breaks down after ten seconds isn't just cute—it's the moment he stops hiding because someone finally looked at him like he was worth seeing. That's the real tension. Not will they or won't they—but will they believe they deserve each other?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or