Marianne Lane. I need to sit with this character for a moment because she is genuinely one of the most interesting people I've encountered in a romance fantasy.
Here's a woman who has never been told she's pretty. Not even as a polite lie. She's a trainee librarian from a village that doesn't appear on maps, second daughter of poor farmers, doing rural recruitment exams. And yet — and this is the thing that hooked me — she doesn't seem bitter about any of it. She likes her job. She likes books. When she walks into the lab and catches everyone mid-spell, her first reaction isn't panic or anger; it's worry that SHE might have caused something bad. She's apologizing to PEOPLE who are glaring at her.
Then Sylvester shows up with flowers. His internal monologue is hilarious — 'What on earth did I just hear?' — and then he does something incredibly brave for someone who clearly never expected to ask anyone out: he follows up. 'I'd like to know why it's not okay for me to ask you on a date.' That line. That is not the dialogue of a character who's used to getting what he wants.
And Marianne's response? She systematically disqualifies herself on every metric — family, wealth, occupation, looks, intelligence, personality — and arrives at the conclusion that this must be a dream. Then she PINCHES HERSELF to check. Of course she does. That is such a Marianne thing to do.
What kills me is that Peter, who orchestrated the original prank, says the most devastatingly true line in these chapters: 'You can't fall in love with someone you don't even know exists.' He's relieved Marianne doesn't know Sylvester. He has no idea that the spell might have created something real, not manufactured. And Sylvester — did the spell make him feel this, or did it just give him the courage to finally act on something he already felt from afar?