Love Under a Spell - Reviews

Love Under a Spell
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Sylvester for a minute because THIS MAN. The scene where he sponsors the orphanage and then immediately looks shy about it? That is the most character-revealing moment in the entire batch. Here's this extremely powerful mage and knight commander who just casually drops 'I wish to sponsor this place' like it's nothing, but the narration specifically calls out that shyness behind his cold exterior. AND Marianne notices. She *sees* it. But the real gem is their dynamic by the tree at sunset. The way he spreads his coat for her to sit on—even though it's already on the ground—is such a small detail but it says SO much. He's practically radiating this desperate need to take care of her, to give her something, and she keeps noticing these tiny details instead of the big declarations. When he admits he's not good at playing ball with kids and gets flustered about it? I nearly screamed. This man commands knight orders and casts powerful magic but couldn't handle a game of catch without his composure cracking. And Marianne? She's sitting there loving every version of him—the cool mage, the shy sponsor, the flustered ball-player.
... Read More
'Under moonlight brighter than the sun, I began to sing my love to you.' I am not okay. I literally had to stop reading and stare at the wall for ten minutes. The way this poem choice is positioned—right at the end of the chapter, right after all that buildup about the magic ending in five days, right after Sylvester asks her to share something she loves—it's devastating in the most beautiful way. Marianne is giving him a love poem while standing on the edge of losing him completely, and she doesn't even seem to realize what she's doing. And Sylvester? He's just sitting there, grayish-blue eyes sparkling, completely absorbed in whatever she's about to read. He has no idea that this might be one of his last real conversations with her before the magic erases everything. The tragedy of that moment is so thick you could cut it with a knife. But also—the beauty? The fact that she's sharing something tender with him RIGHT NOW, in this moment, unperturbed by the doom hanging over them? That's the kind of quiet, aching romance that lives in my head rent-free.
... Read More
There's a theme running through these chapters that I can't shake, and it's about visibility. Who gets seen? Who stays invisible? And what happens when magic forces the issue? Marianne is the most invisible person in this story. She's a trainee librarian from a village that doesn't exist on maps. The Marquis — one of the three most important people in the Arvid Empire — has passed her in hallways a half-dozen times without ever acknowledging she exists. She described their relationship as 'someone who had coincidentally crossed paths with him a few times.' That is the saddest way to describe your entire relationship with a human being. Meanwhile, Sylvester is so visible that the mages needed to steal his clothes and hair to do anything to him. He's the commander, a famous mage, platinum hair and gray-blue eyes that apparently make people stop and stare. But here's the twist: visibility isn't the same as being seen. He's been looking at Marianne from afar, stealing glances, and something about her caught his attention enough that a love spell wasn't even necessary — it just gave him an excuse. The magic circle itself is a symbol of forced connection. Love spells, in fantasy, are always questionable — they remove agency, they manufacture emotion. But this story seems to be asking a more interesting question: what if the spell didn't CREATE feelings but instead REMOVEDBARRIERS that were already there? What if Sylvester already admired Marianne and the spell just gave him the courage to act? Peter's line — 'You can't fall in love with someone you don't even know exists' — is the thematic key. It's about recognition. About two people finding each other in a world that keeps them apart. The red glow of the magic circle, the flowers, the sunlight — all of these are symbols of connection forcing its way through the cracks of a rigid social hierarchy.
... Read More
I need to talk about this line because it genuinely changed how I see Sylvester: "I've fallen for her." ... "That came out wrong... I've fallen for the dogs." HONESTLY. This single sentence does more character work than entire novels. Sylvester Amadeus, Marquis Velarc, commander of the Mage Division, a man so feared that knights turn pale when he gives them icy stares—he cannot, for the life of him, explain to a guard why he's asking about a librarian without sounding ridiculous. So he lies catastrophically and then awkwardly backpedals. And this is the same man who later confronts his research mages about following him while BEING FOLLOWED BY HIS RESEARCH MAGES. But what I find most fascinating is the contrast between how others see him and who he actually is. The guards think he might be a spy. His mages think he's doing secret research. Allen—his aide—just sees a man who smiles constantly now and correctly deduces it's love. Allen's diagnosis is painfully accurate: "What could be the reason for someone who barely smiled sincerely once a month to walk around all day with a contented face?" This man who burned his father's letter because he refuses to repeat the cycle of a loveless marriage—he's been perceived as emotionless his entire life, and the irony is that he's literally the most feeling person in the room. And then there's Marianne. We barely know her yet, but the way Sylvester describes her—"Her dark, curly hair sparkled as it caught the light, just like her laughter"—this isn't just attraction, this is someone who has been starved for warmth suddenly encountering it. The fact that he hurries away pretending indifference every single time, only to return, is both hilarious and achingly relatable.
... Read More
I need to talk about Sylvester for a moment because THIS MAN. The scene where he asks Marianne 'Would you grant me the honor... of holding your hand?' literally made me stop reading and stare at my phone. Not because it's dramatic in a loud way, but because it's so quietly devastating. Here's this incredibly powerful man — Marquis, Knight Order, all that — who could probably command anyone to do anything, and yet he's trembling when he asks for basic physical closeness. His voice is shaking. She can't even tell if it's hers or his or both. And Marianne — oh, Marianne. She's the one who grabs HIS hand first when he tries to pull away. She initiates. Her internal monologue reveals something heartbreaking: she's terrified that if she lets go, she'll regret it. 'Marianne thought she would regret it if Sylvester's warmth left her.' That's not just romantic longing — that's someone who knows their time is limited and is desperate to memorize every sensation. Their dynamic is fascinating because neither of them is playing games consciously, yet the power imbalance is SO visible. Sylvester could leave anytime. He doesn't have to pretend to be enchanted — he knows the spell exists. But the writing makes you wonder: has the spell made him feel genuine emotions, or has genuine emotion overridden the spell? The line between truth and enchantment is blurring, and that's what makes their relationship so compelling. When he deflects with humor ('Let's go before Allen eats our share too'), it feels like a genuinely sweet moment between two people who've found comfort in each other, regardless of why.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that's been eating at me since I finished this chunk. The magic untangling in five days is basically a plot bomb ticking under every single scene, and the author is so good about never actually acknowledging it outright. Everyone just… moves on like normal? Marianne counts the days on her fingers, sure, but then she goes and volunteers at an orphanage like her heart isn't literally breaking? And Sylvester? He's just completely oblivious, dropping these huge emotional bombs like 'I'll engrave the best teachings I can into their hearts' while she's over there mentally preparing to lose him. What I love is how the plot doesn't even treat this as a mystery. Peter already told her that everyone except the caster and Marianne would have hazy memories. So there's this weird asymmetry where Marianne knows exactly what's coming and no one else does. That dramatic irony is *chef's kiss*. The chapter structure itself mirrors the countdown—starting with 'five days,' moving through a seemingly normal day, ending on a poem about love under moonlight. It's almost cruel how beautiful things get right before they end.
... Read More
Let me just say—the imagery in these chapters is *chef's kiss*. There are two scenes that have been living in my head rent-free. First: the back gate of the Knight Order Fortress. Marianne sneaks in on her only day off with a picnic basket, not for romance or adventure, but to feed five ancient search dogs who've been abandoned and left to starve. The description of these dogs—emaciated, spines visible, fur dirty, chained loosely, too exhausted to even react when she approaches—is brutal. And then the moment they sniff the wind and start drooling because they smell bread? My heart literally broke. The guards don't care. No one cares. These were war dogs who served their country and now they're forgotten in a corner, and Marianne—this tiny, overworked trainee librarian making next-to-nothing—decides she'll feed them anyway. Second: the office window scene. After Sylvester makes the flower and they share this incredibly tender moment, the text says: 'The sky beyond the office window was turning a beautiful shade of purple.' Just that. One sentence. But it frames the entire emotional climax against a twilight backdrop like a painting. It's serene, it's quiet, it's the kind of moment that exists outside of time. Marianne thinks 'something wonderful happened' and the purple sky just... witnesses it. The contrast between the grim reality of the neglected dogs and the magical warmth of the Seluvia creation is what makes this world feel so lived-in. It's not all grand magic and political intrigue—there are forgotten dogs at back gates and librarians who sneak bread to them on their days off. That's the kind of detail that makes you feel like you could actually walk through this world.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Sylvester for a sec because THIS man is everything. Here's this guy who's basically the Empire's most powerful mage, feared and respected by everyone, and his BIGGEST secret is that he can make flowers bloom with magic and he's TERRIFIED of being seen as childish for it. When Marianne finds out, she doesn't mock him or treat him weird—she just says 'I'll keep your secret' and then LIGHTS UP like a kid at Christmas when he shows her the magic. "You're the first person I've seen who looks at magic with such shining eyes." And that sentence absolutely wrecked me. But here's what really got me—the scene where he confesses he made the bouquet she got before. He literally couldn't lie for ten seconds. TEN SECONDS. That's not just bad lying, that's a man whose entire demeanor screams guilt the moment someone asks him anything related to her. And Marianne? She calls him "a kind god" and tells him his ability to make people laugh is MORE valuable than making flowers. She reframes his entire sense of self-worth in one conversation. The dynamic shift between them is so gradual but SO palpable. He goes from nervous and awkward to genuinely laughing—a real bright laugh that "beautifully illuminated his entire face." And Marianne thinks to herself that if the mages ask what happened, she'll say something wonderful happened. That's not just friendship energy. That's the sound of someone falling and not even trying to stop it.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author handles the pacing here because it's genuinely masterful. On the surface this is a rom-com setup—young librarian meets handsome noble under magical circumstances—but the author keeps THIS fact hanging over every single scene like a guillotine. Remember when Peter and Erina tell Marianne that the spell will likely break in two weeks and a day, and she'll probably only see the Commander three or four more times? And Marianne just mutters "three or four times" like she's trying to calculate something, and then quickly decides to think lightly and move on? That is SO much richer than just saying "oh well, our time is limited." The author lets us feel the weight of those three or four remaining visits while also showing us that Sylvester promised to share one thing about himself each day. He hasn't said it lightly. He's genuinely trying to give her these moments before—before what, exactly? Before the spell breaks? Before he goes back to being just the Marquis who doesn't remember any of this? And the chapter transitions are interesting too. We go from this tender walk in the park, them almost accidentally calling each other by their real names, small laughter escaping both their lips—and then CUT to Peter and Erina waiting outside the library, immediately dropping the bomb about the timeline. It's almost cruel how the author does that. The warmth of one scene gets immediately undercut by the cold reality of the next. But then Sylvester appears in the library, and the pacing slows down again, lingering on small details—the book in her hands, his gaze on the illustration, the indoor breeze that shouldn't have been there. The author knows exactly when to rush and when to stretch a moment out. It's very controlled.
... Read More
The imagery in this section is absolutely film-worthy. Let me start with the very first scene — the sunset transitioning from crimson to soft and deep blue while Marianne reads aloud. That color palette shift mirrors their emotional arc perfectly: the warmth of connection bleeding into the melancholy of something ending. And then the moon. The full moon. 'A faintly colored moon hung shyly in the still-pale night sky.' The word 'shyly' is doing so much work there — the moon itself seems embarrassed to witness such vulnerability. The orphanage setting is interesting too. It's this humble place where a marquis and a commoner volunteer together, where the social hierarchy temporarily dissolves. 'Since I started volunteering here with Librarian Anna, I've never skipped a meal' — Marianne's comment about the food being delicious is deceptively simple. It's her way of saying this place matters to her, and by extension, the time she's spending there with Sylvester matters. But the theater scene! The Verden Theater is described as empire-managed, affordable for citizens, yet secretly a noble gathering place. That contradiction is such a smart worldbuilding detail — it shows how class divisions persist even in spaces designed to be inclusive. Marianne feeling out of place among 'extravagant attire' while everyone else is scrutinizing HER presence there... it's a perfect microcosm of the central conflict. And those flowers Sylvester creates with his magic — wilting if the spell breaks? What a devastating visual metaphor for their entire situation.
... Read More
I need to process what just happened in this chapter because my heart can't handle it. So Sylvester creates a Seluvia flower for Marianne. A flower that NO LONGER EXISTS in the world. And the text explicitly says: 'Perhaps it's because the person who made it is filled with love.' He made it for someone who wanted to see it—out of love, he revealed his deepest secret and brought something extinct back to life. And then he hands it to Marianne like it's nothing. Like he's not literally offering her a piece of his soul wrapped in petals. Marianne's internal reaction? "He's not just giving me a flower… he's giving me his love." And she feels unworthy. She KNOWS she's not worthy. But she can't reject it. The flower passes from his hand to hers and the sweet fragrance envelops her. This is literally the love language scene we've been waiting for and I am NOT OKAY. And then the bouquet confession hits like a truck. Peter mentioned it was enchanted, Marianne asks casually if he made it, and this man who can probably reshape reality with a thought just crumbles after ten seconds. "...I did make it." The embarrassment on his face, the way his eyes waver—it's so painfully endearing. He's the strongest mage in the Empire and he cannot maintain eye contact when caught doing something nice for someone he likes. Marianne's response to all of this? She tells him he made her laugh and that should be enough reason to be proud. She doesn't gush about the flower's beauty or the magic itself—she focuses on WHAT IT MEANS. That he chose to make HER laugh. That's the emotional core of the entire scene and it hit me like a freight train.
... Read More
Marianne Lane. I need to sit with this character for a moment because she is genuinely one of the most interesting people I've encountered in a romance fantasy. Here's a woman who has never been told she's pretty. Not even as a polite lie. She's a trainee librarian from a village that doesn't appear on maps, second daughter of poor farmers, doing rural recruitment exams. And yet — and this is the thing that hooked me — she doesn't seem bitter about any of it. She likes her job. She likes books. When she walks into the lab and catches everyone mid-spell, her first reaction isn't panic or anger; it's worry that SHE might have caused something bad. She's apologizing to PEOPLE who are glaring at her. Then Sylvester shows up with flowers. His internal monologue is hilarious — 'What on earth did I just hear?' — and then he does something incredibly brave for someone who clearly never expected to ask anyone out: he follows up. 'I'd like to know why it's not okay for me to ask you on a date.' That line. That is not the dialogue of a character who's used to getting what he wants. And Marianne's response? She systematically disqualifies herself on every metric — family, wealth, occupation, looks, intelligence, personality — and arrives at the conclusion that this must be a dream. Then she PINCHES HERSELF to check. Of course she does. That is such a Marianne thing to do. What kills me is that Peter, who orchestrated the original prank, says the most devastatingly true line in these chapters: 'You can't fall in love with someone you don't even know exists.' He's relieved Marianne doesn't know Sylvester. He has no idea that the spell might have created something real, not manufactured. And Sylvester — did the spell make him feel this, or did it just give him the courage to finally act on something he already felt from afar?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or