Listening to a Secret Crush in the Midsummer - Reviews

Listening to a Secret Crush in the Midsummer
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The title of Chapter 1 is basically the thesis statement of the whole novel: "I Don't Like the Obedient Type." And then Sang Mang — who has been obediently pining for six years, who wrote "I'm a coward" in her notebook, who can't even ask for his WeChat — tries to break that mold in her dream by lunging at him. The dream is her rebellion against her own nature. But here's the irony — in the dream, HE still controls the outcome. He tilts his head. He decides where the kiss lands. Even in her fantasy of being bold, he's still the one directing the scene. That's such a sharp commentary on how unrequited love works — you think you're taking control but you're still performing for an audience that isn't watching. The suitcase is another symbol that got me. It's pastel-yellow, 24-inch, packed to the brim — just like her heart, right? Full of feelings she's been carrying around for six years, too heavy for one person to manage, and she's about to drop it on her own head. He catches it effortlessly. Metaphor much? And the line "a girl changes eighteen times before adulthood" — that's her trying to convince herself that it's okay he doesn't recognize her, that she's a different person now. But has she really changed, or is she still the same girl who wrote that she's a coward? The whole novel seems to be asking: can you truly reinvent yourself for someone, and if they still don't see you, what then? The red bead on her silver chain, the pastel-yellow suitcase, the violet and orange sky — all these colors feel deliberate. Warm tones for her emotions, cool tones for his detachment. I'm here for it.
... Read More
"Sang Mang is a coward." She wrote that on her notebook. That one sentence broke me. Six years of loving someone and she still can't even say hello to their face on a train. The internal monologue about unrequited love being this one-sided storm is so accurate it hurts — "every action of the other person could stir up storms in the admirer's heart, while the one being admired rarely resonates, perhaps only causing faint ripples." And the dream! The dream is basically her subconscious processing everything she couldn't say in reality. The fact that in the dream SHE initiates, she lunges forward, she tries to kiss him — that's the bold Sang Mang that exists only in her head. In reality she's blushing and looking at the floor and mumbling thank yous. But here's what's making my heart race — that moment when he catches the suitcase and presses against her back. The text describes it like: "their skin touched, sending a scorching heat that seemed to seep into her bones." And then he says "Step out first" in that lazy voice. Is he feeling it too? Or is it just her? The ambiguity is killing me. The CP chemistry right now is all on her side but that's the whole point of the setup, right? She's been pining for six years and now they're in the same university. I need to know if he's going to realize who she is and if she's ever going to find the courage to stop being the "obedient type" he claims to dislike. That dream line is going to come back to haunt me I can feel it.
... Read More
The opening imagery is so cinematic I could literally see this as a drama. "The cicadas' drone pierced through the heart of the city as the sun dipped below the horizon, painting the sky with layers of violet and orange clouds. High above at seven thousand meters, a passing plane left a trail of contrails in its wake." That's not just description, that's MOOD. The contrast between the grounded cicadas and the distant plane already sets up this theme of someone reaching for something just out of reach. Then the train scene — "Jianghuai East Station. This is the final destination of this journey." The announcement feels symbolic, like her life is literally boarding now. And the way the author describes Fu Qingyan's ear with that tiny red mole on the cartilage "like a perfectly matched accessory" — such a specific detail that makes him feel real, not just a romance novel archetype. The university station scene is chaos in the best way. Megaphones, vendors, flyers, even dogs getting leaflets stuffed in their faces. It's so vividly overwhelming and then Sang Mang finds "a strange sense of peace" in all that noise. That's such a character-revealing moment — she's an observer, she finds calm in chaos. And the BYD car scene? The contrast between Song Siyang's cheap car and the Mercedes that drives by, plus the whole rich kid flexing about Fu Qingyan driving himself to enroll — it paints this whole social hierarchy of the university world that Sang Mang is now entering. The world feels alive and layered.
... Read More
The structure here is actually really smart. Chapter 1 opens with a DREAM sequence that's basically a self-contained mini-story — confession, rejection, a almost-kiss, his line about not liking obedient types. It's dramatic, it's complete, and then BOOM she wakes up on a train. That whiplash from intense romantic dream to mundane reality is exactly the emotional experience of having a crush — your mind is living a whole movie and the other person has no idea you exist. Then Chapter 2 slows down. We get Fu Qingyan's viral fame backstory, the forum posts, the ID photo thing. This is exposition but it's woven in naturally through Sang Mang's perspective — she's watching him from a distance, literally and figuratively. The suitcase scene is the emotional peak of this chapter, and it's brief. Three paragraphs of physical proximity and then he lets go. Perfect. Not too much, not too little. Chapter 3 introduces the conflict with Song Siyang and it comes FAST. She's just trying to get to her dorm and this guy is already being creepy. The pacing here is almost comedic in how quickly things escalate — he snaps a photo, makes comments, she goes from polite to "I'm getting off now" in like two exchanges. And then her little speech at the window: "Fu Qingyan isn't the kind of person you described. He's a really good person." She's defending someone who doesn't even know she exists. The chapter ends on that note of her walking away while he's honking and cursing behind her. Strong ending, sets up her agency even though she's still shy around HIM. The only thing I'd say — the transition between chapters feels a bit abrupt at times, like we drop scenes quickly. But honestly that works for this kind of light romance. You don't need heavy transitions when the emotional beats are landing.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this opening dream sequence is EVERYTHING. The way Sang Mang throws herself at Fu Qingyan and he tilts his head so she kisses his cheek instead? That is such a specific kind of rejection that hits different. And then his line — "Why are you nuzzling like a puppy?" — it's cruel but also weirdly intimate at the same time. Like he's teasing her but also keeping her at arm's length. That duality is already setting up their whole dynamic. Then she wakes up and it's six years later and he literally does NOT recognize her. Oof. The text says "a girl changes eighteen times before adulthood" and honestly that's the most painful line in the whole chapter because it's both true AND it's his excuse for not knowing her. She worked SO hard to get into his university and he looks at her like she's a stranger. But here's what got me — when he helps her with the suitcase, the narration specifically notes how his broad shoulders envelop her and she feels the sandalwood scent. And then he teases her about carrying a bomb. That's actually kind of sweet in his own weird way. He's not being mean, he's just... Fu Qingyan. The contrast between the dream version (cold, dismissive) and the real version (teasing, helpful but still aloof) is already making me wonder if he's going to soft-en up or if this is just his baseline personality. Also Song Siyang is already giving me major villain energy. The way he secretly photographs Sang Mang and sends it to a group chat? Immediate red flag. And then he starts trashing Fu Qingyan's reputation like some insecure upperclassman. Sang Mang defending him to a stranger is such a tell about where her heart is.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or