Judge of Souls - Reviews

Judge of Souls
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"I treated you as my only family!" I read that line four times. Four times. Because how do you even process someone yelling that at the people who abandoned you, and knowing they MEANT it? Luo Xiaomei is not a villain. She's not even really an anti-hero. She's a kid whose entire emotional world collapsed when her grandmother died, and then she spent over twenty years being told that her mother loved her but just didn't know how to express it. THAT LIE. The fact that she still wore that floral-padded jacket from when she was five—her life had ended from that moment on. Her grandmother was the last person who made her feel real. After that, she was just... surplus. And yet. She couldn't kill them. Even standing over them, even with all that power coursing through her, she froze. "She really was just that incompetent, really couldn't be a bad person." That line destroyed me. She wanted to be the monster they called her. She WANTED it to be true because it would've been easier. But she couldn't do it. She's good. She's been good her whole cursed life. The dynamic between her and Senior Brother Jiu Tian is also weirdly tender. He doesn't coddle her. He doesn't give her a hug or say "it'll be okay." He just heals her scars—the physical ones, the ones she's been hiding under—looks at her parents and says "It's human hearts that are monstrous," and sends her on her way. That's love in this story's language. Action, not words. And Jiang Feng's relationship with all of them? He's the anchor. Quiet, pragmatic, doesn't want the inheritance, doesn't want the drama. But he showed up. He always shows up.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is honestly masterful. It starts almost COMEDICALLY—Spicy Crayfish doing his fourth livestream, cracking jokes about whether the delivery guy will run away, the chat spamming jokes and insults. You lower your guard because this feels like typical internet horror content, right? Then the statue breaks and the temperature drops and the mood shifts so subtly you barely notice it happening. After that comes the Jiang Feng section, which operates on a completely different frequency—he's calm, almost bored, which creates this weird tension because you KNOW something is wrong but he doesn't seem to care. The author uses Liu Junlu as the emotional barometer throughout, starting with his bizarre kneeling scene, then having him trail behind Jiang Feng like a pathetic shadow, whispering warnings no one listens to. And the climax—the shadow hands grabbing him—lands with such force because every single beat before it was building toward that exact moment of irreversible danger. The chapter doesn't give you any breathing room. It just keeps tightening the screw.
... Read More
"I'm writing my thesis." She was standing at the edge of Half Moon Lake, ready to fall in, and her first instinct was to talk about William Delbert Gann and his 92.3% success rate. How do you process that emotional whiplash? This girl was so alone. So completely isolated in her obsession and her pain that the only person she could find was a delivery guy she'd never spoken to before, and her solution was to shove a suicide victim's revenge list into his hands and thank him politely. The most devastating part isn't the supernatural stuff—it's that she genuinely believed her work mattered. She cited Chan Zhongshuo's prediction about 2019, talked about how no one understood him until it was too late, and now look—here we are, almost 2019, and the world is tearing itself apart with trade wars and financial crashes, and she was RIGHT. She was RIGHT and she died alone and nobody even checked her thesis. And Chu Xuanliang finding out she jumped? "Such a pity," the dean says, like this is just another statistics point. "Every university has suicides." The casual way institutions brush away young lives chills me to the bone. Meanwhile Ma Shiluo's ghost is still out there, still fighting, still trying to warn these sixteen people because apparently even death didn't give her the peace to let go. That's not revenge—that's love. She cares about these people enough to haunt them into survival.
... Read More
I have to say, the dialogue in this is surprisingly sharp for something that's doing so much worldbuilding at once. Let me pick out some moments because they stuck with me. First, the casual way Jiang Feng ends up commanding a ghost—'What grievance do you have?'—in this deep voice that's like 'the tolling of a great bell, shaking the soul.' He doesn't even know he's doing it. The ghost responds in 'an ancient literary style he had never spoken in before,' which is such a clever detail. It means the voice carries authority that bypasses Jiang Feng's conscious mind entirely. Then there's Liu Feng the ghost, wailing out his tragedy: 'My original name is Liu Feng. I had a virtuous wife, Lady Li.' The way he goes from terrified whisper to pouring out his whole story in classical Chinese register is beautiful—it shows that the Judge's presence awakens something in him, a formalized sense of justice he didn't know he had. And Fu Yuan's dialogue is so distinct from everyone else. 'What are you looking at? Get out of here!' vs. 'Master! Master, what should I do? Please save me!' Same woman, completely different vocal register depending on who's in power. The Taoist priest is the straight man throughout—calm, measured, the only adult in the room ('I've told you before, don't be too excessive in your actions'). His voice grounds the supernatural chaos. And Jiang Feng's internal narration? Dry, self-deprecating, observant. 'Nobody wants to go out to eat in this heat, it's all takeout orders' as he's watching a fat man with a vicious ghost aura walking around? Perfect tone. The author's narrative voice itself is also worth noting—it's restrained, almost understated, which lets the weird stuff land harder. When the golden light hits Fu Yuan and she's coughing blood, the prose doesn't get dramatic, it just… reports it. That restraint is what makes it work.
... Read More
Okay so this whole arc is giving me major conspiracy thriller vibes and I am here for it. The way the plot unfolds is really clever—first Tian Doudou gets her skin peeled off in class (absolute nightmare fuel), then Liu Jing disappears, and then Jiang Feng bumps into this raving girl by Half Moon Lake who shoves him a list of sixteen names. Sixteen people marked for something. And get this—the girl was talking about Gann theory and that Chan Zhongshuo guy who predicted the 2008 crash and died of cancer. Like, why is a college student muttering about stock market predictions while squatting by a lake about to jump in? The connection hasn't been made yet but I already know these things are linked. Then Chu Xuanliang comes in and connects the dots himself—he figures out the girl who gave Jiang Feng the list is actually the one who jumped to her death last semester. The fact that her soul is still out there handing out hit lists? Chef's kiss. The pacing in these chapters is relentless though. One moment you're laughing at Jiang Feng's deadpan reactions and the next you're like wait what just happened. I did not see the suicide reveal coming at all.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: chapters 47 through 54 read like the author knew EXACTLY when to hit the gas and when to ease off the brake. The opening of this section drops us straight into the confrontation—no warmup, no gentle preamble. Luo Xiaomei is already screaming, already shaking, already about to snap. That's fearless pacing. The author trusts the reader to keep up. Then the tension holds for a long, uncomfortable stretch. You're sitting there thinking she's gonna do it, she's gonna actually kill them, and then—BAM—Senior Brother arrives. But here's what I love: the author doesn't resolve the scene quickly. Luo Xiaomei's breakdown, her confession about her grandmother, the way she laughs when Mother Luo kowtows to Jiu Tian... it all lingers. The emotional beat gets its time. You feel every second of it. The transition to the netherworld is another pacing highlight. One moment you're in a blood-soaked courtyard, the next you're descending through white mist into a city of ghosts. It's jarring in the best way—like the ground literally shifts under you. And the Judge's courtroom scene? Short, efficient, absolutely devastating. No drawn-out trial, no dramatic monologues from the accused. Just: guilty, sentenced, gone. The brevity makes it feel more real, more inevitable. Then we cut to Jiang Feng's mundane problems—fired, harassed by debt collectors, summer vacation ending. It's a deliberate palate cleanser. After the supernatural intensity, we get grounded, almost boring reality. Which makes the group chat scene at the end land even harder, because suddenly the ordinary world feels charged with mystery again. The author never lets you get comfortable. Just when you think the story is winding down, it tilts on its axis again.
... Read More
I need to talk about Fu Yuan because THIS WOMAN is a whole energy. She walks into that shop looking like she owns the place—beautiful, sour expression, carrying a bone bowl full of wailing spirits like it's a grocery run. The way she snaps at Jiang Feng 'What are you looking at? Get out of here!' with total disdain? Chef's kiss. She's rude, she's powerful, she took on a case for an acquaintance without asking questions, and when the Judge—our amnesiac delivery boy, by the way—shows up and yanks her target's soul right out from under her, she gets HIT WITH SPIRITUAL BACKLASH. And her first instinct isn't to reconsider her life choices, it's to rage about someone interfering with HER case. Meanwhile the Taoist priest around her is just like 'cmon girl, maybe lay off the ambiguous ghost work for a bit?' She's kneeling and crying to her master like a scolded kid five minutes later. The contrast between her cold, commanding entrance and her sobbing 'Master, what should I do?' is everything. Also the fact that she called the ghost a 'fierce ghost' like that excuses all her behavior but then the text makes it clear she genuinely doesn't think she did anything wrong—she's a traditionalist who believes in exterminating evil spirits, period. That internal logic makes her so much more interesting than a simple 'toxic female lead' trope. She's just someone who genuinely believes her moral framework is correct, which makes the conflict with the Judge so much more layered. She's not evil, she's just incompatible with cosmic bureaucracy. And now she has to apologize to an ANCESTRAL MASTER? The tension here is insane. I'm already invested in whatever comes next between them.
... Read More
Okay so the way the author handles the resolution of the Luo Xiaomei arc is genuinely brilliant. Here's this girl who's been building toward this moment of violent revenge for what feels like an eternity, and just when you think it's gonna go full horror-movie, someone literally yanks the brakes. Senior Brother Jiu Tian shows up out of nowhere—no warning, no buildup—and slaps a talisman on Luo Xiaomei like it's nothing. But the real plot masterstroke is what happens NEXT. Instead of letting her kill her abusers and calling it a day, the story pivots into the netherworld. And I need to talk about that scene where they literally travel to the Ghost Gate Pass. Ninth Heaven breaking through thick white mist, the crows and birds wailing, those seven golden characters above the city gate—it reads like a film sequence. Then King Yama himself closing the great doors in their face? That's not just a plot device, that's a statement. The author is saying: even in death, the system has rules, and your revenge has to go through the proper channels. And then—plot twist number two—the Judge doesn't just let Luo Xiaomei off easy either. She served ten years in the Fifth Hall. She broke the law too. There's no pure victim here, no one gets a free pass. The Register of Merits and Demerits sentencing the Luo parents and Luo Haozhi to wander by the river and lose decades of lifespan? That's poetic justice served cold. Also, the subplot with Jiang Feng getting fired AND then the Liu family showing up at his shop? Classic escalation. Chu Xuanliang stepping in to negotiate feels like a setup for something bigger later. And that group chat revelation about Jiang Feng having a connection to the Judge? I am NOT over it. Who IS he really?
... Read More
I need a moment. I really do. The emotional gut-punch in these chapters is unreal. We spend all this time building up the mystery of who killed Liu Junlu, and then the story quietly slides into the saddest thing I've read in ages. Luo Xiaomei. She isn't scary. Not really. She's a girl who died violently and just wants to see her mom and dad one more time. When she says, 'I love them so much... they must be so pitiful,' my heart actually dropped. She's worried about *them*, even after being murdered by her husband and buried like trash by her own family. The scene where they finally arrive at the house is agonizing. She's flying ahead, excited, pointing the way, while her mother is just... washing dishes, complaining about her 'missing' daughter. The emotional whiplash is staggering. One second it's this hopeful reunion fantasy, and the next it's the mother calling her a 'slut' and saying she eloped. And the worst part? Luo Xiaomei just sits there. Smiling. 'You're still the same as before, my mother.' She knows. She knows they rejected her. She knows they sold her memory for a house. The author doesn't even have her scream or cry right away. She just gets quiet. And then when she finally breaks, it's not just anger—it's despair. 'It hurts so much... what did I do wrong?' That question destroys me. It's the question of every abused child, even decades after death. And then the mother hears her grandson cry and runs upstairs, abandoning the ghost daughter she claimed didn't exist. That indifference is worse than hatred. The emotional shift from Luo Xiaomei's sweet, childish excitement to the cold 'I'm angry' at the end is terrifying because it feels so earned. She tried. She wanted love. She got nothing. So now she gets violence. I am absolutely devastated for this character and furious at her family.
... Read More
I cannot stop thinking about Jiang Feng telling the prankster his name is Cao Nima. THE AUDACITY. Like the guy is literally walking into a haunted building and his response to being provoking is to insult them through his name. That's such a perfectly calibrated moment of character voice—deadpan, dry, and absolutely unhinged in the best way. Then there's Spicy Crayfish's whole streaming persona: 'Tonight let's have an all-night rave!' while preparing occult materials, treating supernatural danger like content. The comments section dialogue is also hilarious in its own right—the chat arguing about Door Gods versus Yama, someone calling the police, the usual internet chaos. But what really stood out was Liu Junlu's desperation in his dialogue. He literally stutters between sentences, repeats himself, offers his entire fortune like he's haggling at a market. 'Great Immortal, wait—Great Immortal, listen to me—Great Immortal!' His voice was so distinctly different from Jiang Feng's clipped, cold responses. And Jiang Feng's only real lines are things like 'Shut up' and 'Don't follow me'—which somehow carry more weight than any monologue could. The author's dialogue writing is sharp and each character occupies their own sonic space.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Liu Junlu because honestly this guy wrecked me in the weirdest way possible. Let me start with this line: "I know I'm a worthless person, but do you know how frightening crowds are? Aren't ghosts just transformed humans?" — I literally stopped reading and stared at my phone. Here's a man who just died, has come back as a ghost, and his biggest concern is that there are OVER A HUNDRED ghosts in this building. That is such a specific, vulnerable, human fear. It wasn't about vengeance or justice or any of that big stuff. It was just... being scared of being around other people. Even dead, he's still socially anxious. That hit me harder than any death scene in any novel. And then the whole thing with the female ghost where she's running UPSTAIRS away from something, not chasing Liu Junlu at all — she's fleeing in terror herself. That reversal where Liu Junlu feels smug for a second like he's safer near Jiang Feng, and then realizes everyone is running from something worse? The vulnerability in that moment was so sharp. He's already dead and broken apart and still trying to protect Jiang Feng, still waving his arms telling him to stay back. That's the thing that got me — he's this pathetic little ghost who can barely hold himself together and yet he's still trying to be useful, still caring about someone else. Also the dynamic between Jiang Feng and Liu Junlu has this weird warmth to it. Jiang Feng could just leave him but he doesn't. He stays. He listens. And Liu Junlu, despite being a walking mess, still tries to crack jokes about it. There's this whole thread of loneliness running through the chapter — ghosts who can't move on, people trapped in stairwells, Liu Junlu terrified of his own corpse being eaten by dogs. It made me think about how all these characters are fundamentally alone, even when they're surrounded by other spirits.
... Read More
Can we talk about Liu Junlu?? Like in the span of these chapters this guy went from some generic creepy businessman to someone whose entire worldview just imploded. Two days ago he was probably a confident, powerful person and now he's KNEELING in front of a delivery rider begging for his life because some unknown force just ate twenty years off his lifespan overnight. The author did something really smart here though—they didn't just make him pathetic, they made him genuinely scared in a way that's almost sympathetic. He's offering inheritance documents, companies, billions, all while his body is deteriorating in real time. And then he follows Jiang Feng to the haunted building anyway, screaming warnings about ghosts while he himself is clearly being hunted by something. That final scene where his shadow starts moving on its own and TWO EXTRA HANDS emerge from it just to strangle his neck—it was terrifying because for the first time Liu Junlu's fears were no longer theoretical. He was absolutely right about the ghosts, but it wasn't too late for him. Meanwhile Jiang Feng is just... there. Walking into danger like it's a Tuesday. The contrast between these two men—one terrified and one completely unreadable—created this whole dynamic I couldn't stop thinking about.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or