It Was Just a Clinical Trial - Reviews

It Was Just a Clinical Trial
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's something really interesting about how this section moves. Let me break down what I noticed because the pacing here is actually doing a LOT of heavy lifting. Chapter 14 starts in a relatively contained space — the lab, Erin and Ash talking, the contraceptive breakthrough. It's almost cozy. There's banter, there's warmth, there's the Ash-waist-touch moment that hits like a ton of bricks. The prose feels lighter here, bouncy even, matching Erin's excitement. Then — WHAM — Chapter 15 opens with her 'buried under a pile of documents' and the tone drops like a stone. The coffee-and-stew scene that follows is beautifully paced: a moment of peace, a moment of connection, then the crushing reality of zero volunteers hits. What I love is how the author uses Ash's dialogue to CONTROL the pacing. Every time Erin starts spiraling, Ash drops something that either calms her down or redirects her energy. The Duke speculation scene is a masterclass in this — he goes from 'maybe he'll pay you well' to 'maybe he'll hire you personally' to 'if it were me, I wouldn't let you go,' and each escalation pushes Erin closer to her decision without her even realizing it. Then Chapter 16 pivots HARD into the cafe meeting. One moment she's daydreaming about the Duke being a bald alchemy enthusiast, the next she's sitting across from a greasy volunteer who's already visualizing her naked. The contrast is JARRING in the best way. The pacing here deliberately makes YOU feel uncomfortable — Erin's internal monologue gets shorter, sharper, more panicked. The prose mirrors her declining patience. The structure also does this beautiful thing where Ash's presence lingers even after he leaves the scene. Erin's caught herself wondering about HIS lower half while evaluating a volunteer. That's not an accident — it's the author threading the needle between plot and character development simultaneously.
... Read More
"But... how will you prove it?" His eyes swept over her slowly, and something about his gaze felt mischievous. Whenever that languid look appeared on his face, there was an almost electric sensuality to it. Okay so I had a FULL reaction to this passage and I'm not even sure why I'm this worked up over fictional people. Let's talk about Erin and Ash because OH MY GOD. They've been working together for THREE YEARS. Three years of her falling asleep at her desk and him draping his clothes over her shoulders. Three years of her pretending she doesn't notice how unfairly attractive he is. And yet the moment his hand rests on her waist — just casually, probably meant to be helpful — her entire SYSTEM short-circuits. She steps away so fast. Her heart is Thumping. She's thinking dirty things about her ASSISTANT. Meanwhile Ash, this man who literally cooks her stew and remembers she doesn't eat carrots, is leaning in close enough to whisper in her ear while throwing out these phrases that sound innocuous but hit DIFFERENT. "If it were me, I wouldn't let you go." Excuse me???? Is this what passing notes in class felt like except somehow more devastating because they're literally adults working in a lab???? The fact that Erin keeps trying to box him into 'assistant' and 'junior' roles while simultaneously catching herself staring at his jawline and wondering if his clothes smell good — that's not oblivious, that's someone actively suppressing feelings and failing at it. And Ash?? He's playing 4D chess here. Feeding her stew, touching her hair, leaning in to whisper threats about the Duke hiring her personally — he knows EXACTLY what he's doing. The scene where he says 'I wouldn't let you go' and his expression 'subtly hardened' — author give me something I can LIVE with. This is the good stuff. The slow burn that makes you want to shake both of them.
... Read More
Here's what I keep coming back to: this book is fundamentally about labor. Erin didn't reincarnate into a fantasy world to find love or power or adventure. She reincarnated into a fantasy world where she could finally apply her expertise without being ground down by a corporation that treats researchers as disposable. The pharmaceutical company from her previous life had 'a reputation for grinding up researchers.' The Empire's academic and medical systems are equally exploitative — just with a different aesthetic. Her entire project is framed as productive labor with economic returns. She's not saving the heroine out of pure altruism (well, she is, but she ALSO frames it as a business opportunity). The 'blue ocean' metaphor she uses is pure corporate speak — she's identifying an underserved market and moving to capture it. Even her motivation to repay the Duke is couched in financial terms. But then there's the deeper layer. The original novel's plot — a heroine who is violated, becomes pregnant, dies in childbirth, and then becomes a ghost that haunts an empire — is essentially a story about women's bodies being sites of tragedy and male desire. Erin's intervention is small (contraception) but symbolically massive. She's introducing agency into a narrative where the heroine has none. Not through grand rebellion, but through a pill. The title 'background character' is also deeply ironic. In the original story, Erin is so insignificant she doesn't even have a name. But the fact that she exists outside the main plot is exactly what gives her the freedom to act. She's not trapped by the genre's expectations. The heroine must suffer because it's tragic romance. Erin can choose to do something else. And Ash — hidden behind a hood, his appearance so striking he needs to conceal it — is another symbol of someone existing outside the expected narrative role. What is he hiding? Why is he here? The text doesn't say, but every detail about him screams 'this character has a function in the story that hasn't been revealed yet.' This book is saying: the people on the margins — the background characters, the assistants, the researchers working in shabby labs — are the ones who can actually change things. Not the Crown Prince. Not the heroine. The woman with a chemistry degree and a mountain of debt.
... Read More
Oh my god, can we talk about how painfully oblivious Erin is here? She's literally lying next to Ash at night, sharing all these personal stories about her childhood, and she's like "we really feel like lovers... wait no, he's just a good assistant." A GOOD ASSISTANT doesn't say "I sleep better when you're here, Doctor" with that playful smile. A good assistant doesn't mean "this is for my future too" while buying her clothes. Meanwhile Ash is out here silently ruining people's lives because some asshole talked to Erin disrespectfully. He didn't kill him, okay?? That's mercy! He basically destroyed Earl Alto's entire family and then felt bad about it because Erin might find out. This man is absolutely unhinged and I love it. The dynamic where Erin keeps trying to remind herself this is just an experiment while simultaneously calculating her ovulation cycle to be extra careful during risky times because she wants to make sure the contraceptive works (and also maybe she's subconsciously hoping?) is both hilarious and sort of devastating. She genuinely thinks Ash doesn't know how she feels. Like babe, he's the one who orchestrated getting you that extra room so you could have a private space for your "research." Also the part where she told him everything except the reincarnation thing? That's such a classic. She shared her childhood, her likes and dislikes, every trivial story, but the ONE thing that actually matters stays hidden. Meanwhile Ash listens to all of it like it's the most important thing in the world.
... Read More
Can we just talk about Ash for a second? Because this guy is absolutely fascinating and I have so many thoughts. On the surface, he's the perfect assistant—cooking for Erin after late nights, bringing her furniture, volunteering as a test subject. But the second he starts kissing her out of nowhere and calling it 'experiment work,' you realize this is way more complicated than employment. What I love is how Ash plays it both ways. He's genuinely kind—he learned to cook for her, he covers her with blankets, he moved all that furniture himself. But he's also calculating. Every 'accidental' kiss, every 'cosmetic' upgrade to the lab, every massage that goes just a little too far—it's all deliberate. He knows exactly what he's doing. And somehow, that makes him even more compelling. Erin's resistance is equally interesting. She keeps trying to maintain professional boundaries, telling herself she shouldn't read into his gestures. But then she gets flustered when he calls her beautiful, and her body betrays her anyway. The whole 'I'm just his senior, I can't lead him on' excuse falls apart the moment she's blushing and twisting her hair. Their power dynamic is constantly shifting too. In the lab, she's the boss. But emotionally? Ash holds all the cards. He decides when they kiss, when to bring gifts, when to push further. And Erin, despite being the researcher, seems to have lost control of the situation long ago. The recommendation letter subplot adds another layer. Erin knows this arrangement can't last forever. Once the experiment ends, Ash will move on and she'll have to watch him go. That ache in her chest—the one she feels just thinking about losing him—suggests she's already fallen harder than she intended. I also noticed how Erin's living situation reveals her emotional state. She's sleeping at the lab instead of her townhouse because she can't face being alone in that empty, dusty space. Meanwhile, Ash has somehow turned their workplace into something warm and inviting. He's literally building them a home while she's still pretending this is just research. This relationship is going to be the death of me.
... Read More
I need to talk about the scene construction here because the author knows EXACTLY what they're doing with settings. The cafe opening is deliberately bright and public — 'a young man entered, whose solid build and the lower half of his face visible beneath his hood radiated unusual good looks. Women throughout the cafe, and even some men, let out unconscious sighs of admiration.' It's almost comedic in its over-the-top romance-novel energy. Everyone notices this mysterious handsome stranger. This is the SETUP. Then the violent eruption — envelopes flying, bread scattering, menus bending — shatters that romantic comedy veneer completely. The cafe goes from 'sigh-worthy romance entrance' to 'crime scene' in seconds. And Erin's thought about the wasted bread? That's the author telling us this woman is so numbed by her daily grind that even chaos doesn't override her bakery devotion. Brilliant character work through setting response. But the REAL masterpiece is the alley. 'A chilly voice dropped from above her head.' Dark, confined, shadow engulfing her small frame. The alley is literally between two extremes — between the public cafe and the private lab, between restraint and explosion, between professional distance and total surrender. And then sunlight streams between the alley walls 'landing on his proud nose like a spotlight on an actor.' The sudden light on Ash's face is the visual punchline — after three years of hood mystery, the reader AND Erin finally SEE him properly. Then the lab itself becomes the third act setting, and it's PERFECTly chosen. It's where she feels comfortable, where she works every day, where she's in control. The modified examination chair, the cabinet with the pink contraceptive vial, the desk he sweeps clean — every object in that lab has been part of their three-year dynamic. The lab isn't just a location; it's a CHARACTER. It holds all their unspoken history.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about this scene because it is EVERYTHING. Erin is literally piecing together evidence that Ash might be a spy or someone with noble backing, right? She finds this ruby ring on his finger—deep pink stone, looks genuinely expensive, definitely not something a common lab assistant would own—and her whole world tilts. "If that's a real gemstone... That kind of thing could only be obtained working under a noble." And then instead of confronting him, instead of pulling away, she just... melts. Into him. Because apparently when your brain can't process the betrayal, your body just decides to surrender anyway. And Ash! Oh my god, Ash is playing a different game here. He's clearly jealous—he assumes she tried to sleep with that reporter to fill in some "incomplete section" of her report (which is hilariously dramatic and also maybe a little insane). But what's beautiful and terrifying is that he starts using their arrangement as an excuse to be possessive in a way that goes beyond the contract. "Until you get pregnant, I'll keep filling you." That is NOT the words of a man who's just doing his job as a lab subject. That's a man who wants to keep her, lock her down, make sure there's no room for anyone else. But here's what kills me: Erin realizes her own feelings in the middle of all this. "It'd be stranger not to like him." THREE YEARS. They've been together for three years, he's handsome, he's kind, he's devastating in bed, and she just... lets herself admit it. Right during sex. While worried he's a spy. While he's literally pinning her down. The timing is so perfectly chaotic. The power dynamic here is also SO interesting. She's the doctor, he's the assistant, but in this moment—maybe always—he's the one in control. He decides when they talk, when they touch, when they stop. And she's been falling for him despite trying NOT to, because as she says: "people's hearts don't always cooperate."
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is absolutely delicious. Let me just start with Ash's lines because wow. 'This experiment is important work too'—said while clearly not talking about the experiment at all. 'Think of it as work' while holding out a vial of pink medicine. The man is a poet, and his medium is manipulation. What I love is how Ash's voice contrasts with Erin's. He speaks in short, confident statements with that rich smile behind every word. 'It's fine.' 'Don't worry about budget.' 'You're beautiful, Doctor.' Each line is calibrated to get exactly the reaction he wants. And Erin? She's all fragmented responses—'Huh?' 'Ah!' 'Ash!'—her dialogue breaking down as her resolve does. The internal monologue is where the real voice shines though. Erin's thoughts are so distinct from her spoken words. She'll say 'I think just a shower booth would've been enough' but think 'why do I always just go along with things?' That gap between what she says and what she thinks is where the comedy and pathos live. And the humor! The author doesn't take themselves too seriously. Lines like 'Is it really a lab, or just a front for embezzlement?' and 'The salesman was so charming, there was no resisting' show the author's willingness to poke fun at the situation while still delivering the romance. What's remarkable is how every character has a distinct voice even in third-person narration. Ash's confidence comes through in complete sentences and smooth transitions. Erin's anxiety shows in her fragmented thoughts and rapid questions. Even secondary characters like the reporter rumors have a voice—the sensationalistic headlines perfectly capture that tabloid gossip tone. The dialogue also reveals character through what's not said. Ash never admits he's doing this out of affection. Erin never admits she wants this to be more than work. But the subtext screams so loudly it's almost comical. That's masterful writing.
... Read More
I'm not ready for how soft this becomes after everything. We go from one of the most intense scenes I've ever read to Erin waking up on a guest sofa that definitely wasn't there yesterday, wrapped in a blanket that smells like Ash, and the whole atmosphere shifts. It's domestic. It's gentle. And then Ash casually mentions he borrowed it from the professor across the hall and cleaned it himself, and I just— that's the kind of detail that makes my heart ache. This man went out of his way to make sure she was comfortable even after... after everything. Then comes the breakfast scene where she tries to leave and immediately realizes there's physical evidence everywhere, and Ash just casually offers to clean her up while looking at her with this expression that says he absolutely wants to do it again. The shift from raw desire to tender care and back to desire in the span of ten pages is unmatched. My heart can't take it. Also, the way Erin catches herself wanting him to ACT different—more awkward, more affected by what happened—and then feeling guilty for wanting that? That's so real. She's fighting her own feelings and I was right there with her.
... Read More
What struck me most is how the author weaponizes Erin's own scientific language against her rationality. The entire encounter is framed through the lens of an experiment—'you need to be properly wet,' 'we need to prove it,' 'multiple angles.' She's trying to reduce this moment to clinical procedure, to maintain the distance that her profession demands, and Ash systematically dismantles every excuse. But the deeper symbolism goes further. The lab itself—the shabby, underfunded space that can't even afford a proper chair—becomes the site of this intimate transgression. Their bodies, their desires, their messiness all invade the space of rationality and control. And the sofa, borrowed from across the hall and cleaned by Ash's own hands, represents this weird liminal space where work and desire blur together. Even the title of the chapter—something about 'strange'—hints that what they're doing violates some unspoken rule. But the book doesn't moralize about it. It just lets the imagery speak for itself: warmth, heat, leaking, swallowing, the body as both subject and object of study. So grounded in flesh but reaching for something almost philosophical. That's the kind of writing that stays with you.
... Read More
Let's break down what these characters are actually betting here, because it's way more than just a romance experiment. For Erin, the stakes are enormous. She has a deadline from Duke Aston - ten months total, and she's on month eight. If this contraceptive doesn't work or can't be presented properly, she loses everything. She was already in a precarious position before, and now she has a whole month left to wrap up. The fact that her report has a blank section for "Subject Diversity" because they're the only two volunteers adds this layer of vulnerability - what if the Duke demands more data? For Ash, the stakes seem to operate on a completely different level. He's not just an assistant. The way he handles the Earl Alto situation, the professional attendant showing up, his knowledge of business deals and mercenary bands - this man is clearly connected to power structures Erin probably doesn't fully understand yet. And he's protecting her while simultaneously operating in a world where a single wrong word can destroy someone's family. The external conflict is clear: the Duke Aston meeting is approaching, reporters are sniffing around, and Marquis Phrine wants in on the experiment. But the internal conflict is what gets me. Erin wants to be with Ash longer but thinks he sees this as purely professional. Ash clearly wants more but she doesn't know it. Meanwhile, there's this underlying danger - whatever secrets Ash is keeping, and that NOTE at the end suggests everything is about to get more complicated.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely INSANE and I need to unpack why it works so well. It starts at MAXIMUM velocity. The creepy noble is already saying inappropriate things BEFORE we even finish Chapter 9's opening paragraph. Erin's internal panic about whether she can use him as a test subject? That's established in the first few lines. Then Ash appears and the action escalates FAST — Whack! Whack! Whack! Four onomatopoeia words in a row mimicking the menu strikes. The author doesn't slow down for description; we get the violence in brutal shorthand and it hits like a punch. Then — immediate pivot. They flee the cafe (unpaid tea, by the way, which is such a delicious character detail) and the pace DROPs into that tense alley conversation. This is where the author forces you to slow down. Longer dialogue, internal monologue, the heavy silence between lines. 'Then let me do it.' Huh? Let you do WHAT? The reader is pulled along with Erin's confusion. And then the pace ACCELERATES again but in a completely different way — not action-chaos this time but INTIMACY-rush. The kiss descends on Erin like a wave. Every sentence gets shorter, breathier. 'Click. Click.' Sounds replacing full descriptions. The undone buttons become a drumroll. And then — 'You're distracted, ag' — CUT TO BLACK right as Erin realizes she's jealous. That cliffhanger is MASTERFUL. It doesn't end on a kiss or a confession or even a physical moment — it ends on an EMOTIONAL realization that's still forming. The word is cut off mid-sentence, which means the chapter ends on the precipice of something, and you NEED to keep reading to find out what Erin was about to admit to herself. The structural genius here is that the chapter moves from EXTERNAL conflict (the creepy noble) to INTERPERSONAL tension (the alley confrontation) to INTERNAL revelation (the jealousy) — three layers of conflict compressed into one breathless sequence.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or