Is there anything wrong with Alpha marking Alpha? - Reviews

Is there anything wrong with Alpha marking Alpha?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say this: the infirmary is the single most important location in this entire novel and honestly it deserves its own character arc. Think about it—the first time we properly see Yu Chengsong and Yin Gu alone together, it's here. The doctor isn't even there. The curtains are drawn. It's just the two of them, a bag of snacks, and absolute silence that somehow feels more intimate than any romantic dinner scene ever could. The author builds this space so deliberately. The infirmary is removed from the chaos of the school, from the political maneuvering, from the violence that follows these characters everywhere. It's a liminal space—neither fully public nor private—and that's exactly why it works. Here, Yu Chengsong is not the tough guy who beats up gangsters. He's just... a guy with a fake wound eating white rabbit candy. And Yin Gu is not the cold transfer student who strikes fear into everyone. He's just... a guy who remembers his deskmate shouldn't skip meals. The sensory details are minimal but perfectly chosen. The plastic bag of snacks, the AD calcium bottles that 'was not cool at all' to drink, the cigarette lighter clicking on, the way Yin Gu leans against the wall laughing. None of these are glamorous images, and that's precisely why they work. This isn't a romance novel selling you fantasy—it's showing you something achingly real: two people finding a moment of peace in the most unglamorous setting possible. The worldbuilding here says everything about the tone of the story: this isn't a world of grand gestures and dramatic declarations. It's a world of stolen moments between classes, of shared snacks in empty rooms, of friendships that grow in the margins of violence.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is doing something really smart and I want to break it down. We start on the street—rain, Yin Gu's palm wound, this casual banter about Naruto clones and hiring hitmen. It's light, it's funny, it's slow-burn character building. Then Yu Chengsong says "let's go to the clinic first" and suddenly we're moving. The clinic scene is QUICK—bandage, pills, one line about being impulsive—and then they're heading upstairs. Here's where it gets GOOD. Yu Chengsong starts to say he has a "surprise" for Yin Gu, and Yin Gu literally guesses it's his parents BEFORE he even opens the door. Of COURSE he knows. The kid's been through enough to read a situation instantly. Then—the door opens, the mother is there, the screaming starts, and everything accelerates. The boyfriend lie happens in what, two sentences? And then they retreat to the bedroom and the pacing DELIBERATELY SLOWS DOWN. We get the stuffed animals, the clothes exchange, the orange cat reveal, the husky pillow moment. The author PULLS THE BRAKES right when things get tense and makes us sit in this weird intimate space. And then—Yu Chengsong starts taking off his soaked shirt, muscles and everything, and Yin Gu is WATCHING—cut to Yin Gu taking off his OWN bloody shirt, and we're left with both of them half-undressed in a hot humid room while the mentally unstable mom is literally downstairs. The tension here is so well-calibrated. It doesn't rush toward anything explicitly romantic but it also doesn't avoid the electricity. Perfect pacing.
... Read More
I need to talk about Yin Gu's dialogue, specifically the way he dismantles his own brother. While the rest of us are out here throwing hands, Yin Gu walks into a restaurant, sits down, and verbally eviscerates Yin He so thoroughly that his face looks like he ate something unmentionable. 'You flirt with an Omega female classmate and even frame them. People say you have bad behavior and you bring shame to our parents.' This is cold. Calculated. Weaponized family reputation. And the way Yu Chengsong responds—imitating Yin He's voice with that ridiculous 'Oh no! There's a bug!'—that's the kind of humor that only works because we've been watching these two build a rhythm together. Yu Chengsong's internal monologue is also a whole vibe: 'Social death.' 'This wave of Director Han is in the atmosphere layer.' The narration carries this dry, self-aware tone that makes everything funnier and sharper. Even the small talk has personality—the barbecue rice, the salad sauce, the 'Goodbye, air' bit with Zhou Zheyu. These two speak in a language entirely their own and I'm obsessed with how natural it sounds.
... Read More
Okay so let me just talk about the absolute GENIUS of how this author writes the relationship between Yu Chengsong and Yin Gu without ever actually making them say anything real to each other. Think about it. Yin Gu literally reads Yu Chengsong's mind when he's too sleepy to function—he notices he doesn't have a rubber band for his hair, and what does he do? Nothing obvious. But then later, when Yu Chengsong is all defensive and threatening him with the pen, Yin Gu just... produces a can of Wangzai milk like some kind of calm, collected snack-based peacekeeper. That's not just sweet, that's deeply observant in a way that says he pays attention to Yu Chengsong constantly. And Yu Chengsong's response? He hesitates for two seconds between suspecting poisoning and being dumbstruck by the gesture. Two seconds! That is the emotional whiplash of someone who has no framework for receiving kindness except through the lens of threat or deception. And Lao Li literally says it out loud—you need to learn how to control your emotions and kindness from him. As if Yin Gu is some moral paragon! Meanwhile Yu Chengsong's whole posture is rebellion against being managed, against being told who to be friends with. The fact that they're deskmates and Lao Li is practically tying them together with a rope is the funniest bit. And Yin Gu's amused expression when Yu Chengsong says "he wants me to stop screwing you"—that line, god, it's so casually devastating because it reveals everything. Yin Gu finds it funny that someone would even think Yu Chengsong needs protection from him. Who does that? Who gets that much misread by the people trying to help them? I keep coming back to the hand-touching moment. Yu Chengsong catches himself literally staring at Yin Gu's fingers while half-asleep and thinks about how different the sensation would be depending on which part of the hand was touching him. Knuckles vs fingertips vs palms. This is not a person who is casually flirtatious. This is a person who has absolutely no defense mechanisms when it comes to this particular someone.
... Read More
I keep coming back to a single detail from this chapter and I can't shake it. There's this video Yin Gu watches - freshman year, Yu Chengsong on the track, hair in a bun, doing warmups lazily. The person filming is clearly part of the screaming crowd, phone shaking with excitement, and yet even through all that chaos, Yu Chengsong's face is impeccable. He notices someone is taking a photo, glances over, and just... doesn't care. The caption says the surrounding girls were screaming so hard some lost their voices. Twenty-five yuan. That's what Yin Gu paid for access to this entire universe of people who are obsessed with Yu Chengsong. And he saved every single file. But what actually broke me was the contrast between Yu Chengsong's public legend and his private reality. At home, he's dealing with a mother who wishes his father would die in a car accident. At school, he's a phenomenon that makes strangers lose their voices screaming his name. And in between those two worlds, there's just... Yin Gu, waiting for him at breakfast, texting him to meet up, buying him photos of himself that other people sold for profit. The scene where Yin Gu shows Yu Chengsong the listing from Bro. Song's Big Baby is funny on the surface but underneath it's weirdly tender. This stranger is cataloguing every detail of Yu Chengsong's life - combing his hair, various sports moments, editing photos to wallpaper quality. And Yin Gu is reading all of it, seeing how much of his boyfriend exists in other people's pockets, and instead of feeling threatened, he just buys it all. I think what got me most was the Zhou Zheyu detail - he was so angry that someone bundled Yu Chengsong photos with his own that he didn't eat for a whole day. The fact that this subplot exists at all tells you everything about how deeply these characters are entangled in each other's emotional worlds.
... Read More
'Three steps out of the school gate, all kinds of carts selling cold noodles, fried skewers, and fried rice are pushed in front of them one after another. Not to mention the hygiene, the strong smell of seasoning and oil smoke alone would make the top alpha with a keen sense of smell frown.' RIGHT. From the very first paragraph we know EXACTLY where we are. This isn't some shiny academy with marble halls — this is the urban-rural fringe of Xiyuan City, where the school was founded poor and the geography chose violence. The setting is doing SO MUCH WORK here. March in the north, wind making faces hurt, heating already turned off inside the house while the mom is wearing summery pink silk pajamas like a disturbed ghost. The contrast between the chaotic street outside (bright billboards, 'blingbling' milk tea shops) and the cold, dark interior where abuse happens — it's cinematographic. And that Dongchuan Street detail? 'The land is unfamiliar' from Yu Chengsong's inner monologue hits different when you realize he's just trying to buy MILK TEA for a toddler and can't even do that right. The world feels alive because it's consistently hostile. Every location in this story seems designed to inconvenience the protagonist.
... Read More
The pacing here is BRUTAL in the best way. We go from a laid-back scene of Yu Chengsong listening to music and texting his best friend — totally chill, wholesome energy, 'I miss you till my heart and liver are shattered already' — and then in the NEXT PARAGRAPH we're at his house watching a ten-year-old with swollen knees try to change his shoes. The shift is so sudden it made me actually stop reading for a second. One moment everything's fine, next moment: 'Her voice was hoarse after being sharp, with undisguised decadence and hatred: Yuanyuan wants to drink milk tea from the new store on Dongchuan Street.' No warning. Just escalation. And then the chapter basically ends on this weird note with the 'Deskmate?' line and Yu Chengsong's internal monologue about fate playing in 3D in his head — which feels like the author is deliberately pivoting us toward whatever romantic subplot is coming, while leaving the family trauma unresolved. That cliffhanger energy? Chef's kiss. The section about the milk tea shop being closed is almost comedic relief before the next act, but it doesn't fully land because we're still sitting with the image of Yu Chengdi trembling. Perfect tension management — never lets you breathe too long, never lets you forget what's at stake.
... Read More
I genuinely cannot get over Yin Gu's energy in this chapter. The man goes from being completely composed—watching his boyfriend get violent on his behalf—to making finger hearts and saying "I love you more" like a lovesick teenager. There's this one line that wrecked me: "It's not wrong. I'm just asking you a question in return. You can choose not to answer, and I still love you." What kind of emotionally intelligent person does that??? And Yu Chengsong's response—grabbing his wrist, confessing immediately—shows exactly why they work. He doesn't play games. But here's what really got me: Yu Chengsong feeling conflicted because Yin Gu never fought back against Yin He. He realizes that Yin Gu's restraint comes from "the last bit of affection for his family" or whatever twisted blood bond the author keeps referencing. Meanwhile Yu Chengsong is over here ready to beat up Yin He AGAIN and planning escape routes. Their dynamic is equal parts protective and silly. Yin Gu teasing him about being childishly romantic, Yu Chengsong getting flustered about Yin Gu's looks mid-conversation about violence—it's chaotic and perfect. Also the pheromone mention? They live in some weird universe and I am HERE FOR IT.
... Read More
Let's talk about stakes, because this passage is a masterclass in how internal conflict can be just as devastating as any external confrontation. On the surface, nothing 'happens' for most of this section. Two guys chat in class. They go smoke on the stairs. A guy shows up looking for someone. But underneath? Yu Chengsong is actively wrestling with something huge — the fear that their physical incompatibility could destroy their relationship. And this isn't framed as some crisis point. It's framed as a casual question: 'When Yin Gu and I stand together, I look like…?' The normalcy of the setting makes the vulnerability hit harder. Zhou Zheyu's stakes are equally compelling but operating on a different frequency. He's clearly devastated about his own romantic situation — the 'sad face,' the forced nonchalance, the way he deflects by asking about Yu Chengsong first. His advice to Yu Chengsong ('at worst you can give it to yourself the first time and return it to him the second time') is genuinely helpful but also reads as someone who's been hurt and doesn't want his friend to suffer the same fate. Then Yin He arrives and external stakes materialize instantly. Who is he? What does he want? The text deliberately withholds answers, which means every reader's imagination fills in the worst possibilities. The narrator's attitude toward him — 'maxed out his skills in courting death' — suggests this isn't just a neutral development. Something bad is coming, and the stakes have shifted from 'will their relationship survive internal doubt' to 'what external threat is about to test everything they've built.' The brilliance is how these layers compound. Internal doubt + friend's hidden pain + mysterious outsider = a pressure cooker that's about to detonate. I am not ready but I also cannot stop reading.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely relentless in the best way. You start with this almost slapstick comedy—Yu Chengsong being called cute by his own boyfriend, the whole Yu Chengdi-and-Zheyu setup, the domestic violence banter that goes absolutely nowhere. It's light, it's fun, it makes you smile. And then, out of nowhere, Yin Gu drops the father conversation and the entire tone shifts. No warning. One second they're joking about who gets thrown out of the house, the next second we're in territory about parental expectations and sexual identity and years of emotional suppression. That whiplash is intentional and it works. The author doesn't slow down to ease us into the serious stuff—they just pivot hard, which mirrors exactly how real conversations with people you love work. You're laughing and then suddenly you're not, and there's no commercial break. And then after all that emotional weight, we get Yu Chengsong's incoherent babbling about being a hedonist and wanting to make Yin Gu happy, which immediately deflates the tension back into something warm and human. The chapter ends on that interrupted intimate scene with the boom boom boom and then... they both just freeze. I am still processing what happens next but I have to keep reading.
... Read More
I need to talk about this specific passage because it genuinely wrecked me. When Yu Chengsong thinks about how he'd rather cry holding a beer bottle five or ten years from now, thinking about this person, than live with no story at all - that is the most devastatingly honest thing I have ever read about what it means to be young and in love. The author just laid it out so plainly. No metaphor, no fancy language, just a guy admitting that he would choose pain over emptiness any day. And I keep coming back to the phrase 'youth without pain.' Is that even a thing? The text literally asks this question, and I don't think it's rhetorical. Because what Yu Chengsong is describing isn't some romanticized version of first love. It's him accepting that this feeling is going to hurt, that it might not work out, that he could end up heartbroken, and that he's choosing it anyway. That's not naive. That's actually incredibly brave in a way that most stories don't capture. Most romance novels make the confession feel like a triumph, like the moment everything gets easier. But here, Yu Chengsong is fully aware that saying what he feels might not change anything. Yin Gu might not feel the same. But as the text says, 'The fact that he likes Yin Gu has nothing to do with how much Yin Gu likes him.' That sentence hit me like a truck. It's so simple but it reframes everything. His feelings aren't conditional. They're not a transaction. He likes this person regardless of the outcome, and that changes the entire emotional texture of the scene. The part where he's calculating a seventy to eighty percent chance of success and Zhou Zheyu loses his mind because that seems too low - that's Yu Chengsong being Yu Chengsong. He's already accepted that he could fail, and he's still going forward. That's the emotional core of this entire section, and it's what makes me want to reread it repeatedly.
... Read More
Okay, can we just talk about the YIN GU AND YU CHENGSONG dynamic because this chapter? This chapter really said 'we are messy and we are proud.' The whole thing started with Yu Chengsong in pain, literally describing how f*cking much it hurts, and Yin Gu is there pinch-his-ear-and-frown caring. Classic Yin Gu—shows affection through physical touch and minimal words. But then Yu Chengsong just kisses him. No warning, no buildup, just 'I wanted to so I did.' And Yin Gu doesn't dodge. He just... lets it happen. Then later bites his earlobe while Yu Chengsong is recovering? The power dynamics in this relationship are absolutely delicious. Yu Chengsong calls him out: 'Deskmate, were you bullying me just now?' And Yin Gu's face says it all—he wants to kiss but won't admit it. The scene where Yin Gu helps Yu Chengsong fix his collar before they go back to class? That's the kind of intimate gesture that says more than any romance scene ever could. He's taking care of him, practically, and then plays it off like it's nothing. Meanwhile Yu Chengsong is over there internally screaming about how handsome Yin Gu is even when his face says 'thank you for the compliment' like a robot. And Zhou Zheyu's reaction when he realizes Yu Chengsong has been 'particularly ignoring me since you got him'—ouch. The friend group dynamics are shifting, and it's happening in real time. Yu Chengsong's response about keeping things short until after 'your second aunt leaves tomorrow' shows he's thinking ahead, protecting their privacy while still planning social interaction. That's growth, people. The bike scene at the end? Yin Gu offering to carry him while Yu Chengsong tries not to fall asleep? That's partnership. That's 'I've got you' without saying those words. And Yu Chengsong's final line 'I will definitely not fall alone' is oddly touching when you think about it. He's acknowledging he might fall, but he won't face it solo. That's the relationship arc right there.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or