Is there anything wrong with Alpha marking Alpha? - Reviews

Is there anything wrong with Alpha marking Alpha?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in this chapter is something I need to sit with for a minute because the author is doing controlled demolition on reader expectations and I respect it enormously. The first third of the chapter is deliberately slow, almost lazily so. Yu Chengsong riding his bike, arriving late, dodging chalk, sitting down, receiving porridge. These are pages that feel like filler. They feel like the calm before a storm that might never come. A lesser author would pad these sections with internal monologue or exposition. This author does something braver: they trust the rhythm of ordinary moments. The humor lands naturally. The dialogue snaps. You laugh at Yu Chengsong's calligraphy excuse and then immediately forget about it because the next paragraph is about essay word counts and the Chinese teacher's八百字 requirement. Then the shift happens and it's almost instantaneous. One moment Yu Chengsong is drinking porridge, the next he's walking toward the bathroom, and then Jia Feisong is there and Wu Xiaoyuan is crying and the violence arrives without warning. There's no chapter break. There's no scene divider. The author just pivots the camera and the genre changes mid-sentence. But here's what makes the pacing genuinely brilliant rather than merely effective: the chapter doesn't end on the action. It ends on the psychological aftertaste. Yu Chengsong retreats to the toilet, not because he's hurt or shaken, but because he's been emotionally dismantled by two sentences whispered across a desk. The bathroom raid is the climax, sure, but the real resolution happens in silence, in the space between two people who have just seen each other clearly for the first time. The structural choice to bookend the chapter with classroom comedy and then dump the reader into violence and then withdraw into introspection creates a rhythm that mirrors Yu Chengsong's own life: perform, react, retreat, process. The chapter doesn't just tell this story. It makes the reader experience it. I also want to flag the use of the ellipsis. The scene transitions from the classroom to the bathroom with a simple "……" — one punctuation mark carrying the weight of a scene change that could have taken three paragraphs to establish. The author respects the reader's intelligence enough to trust that gesture.
... Read More
Student Yin: Deskmate, the back of my head feels a little hot. / Is a good person: You should be thankful that my eyes can't spit fire; otherwise, you would have at least two holes in your body now. Is a good person: good boy, I buy fifty cents worth of help. This exchange is everything. It is ridiculous and tender and so perfectly Yu Chengsong—sarcastic, dramatic, but ultimately helpful. The fact that he is complaining about pheromone pressure while simultaneously negotiating a fifty-cent service fee? That is character work at its finest. And Yin Gu's voice throughout is this calm, sparse counterpoint. He barely speaks, but when he does, it lands. Is a good person versus Student Yin—these nicknames on their phones tell you more about their relationship than any exposition could. The gossip kids on the sixth floor also deserve praise. Their dialogue is fast, crude, and hilarious: You know sh*t! I was so scared by the thing I heard this morning that I didn't even do well on my Chinese exam! This is how people actually talk. The author never lets dialogue become polished or artificial, even in the most intense scenes.
... Read More
Okay we need to talk about Yu Chengsong because this boy is deeply complicated and I have STRONG opinions. Out in the world he's untouchable. Top A, pheromones that make grown men retreat, throws candy at people like it's no big deal, calls his friend stupid with affection. But then he walks through that door and everything changes. The moment he sees Yu Chengdi's bruised face, the text says his smile didn't reach his eyes. That's it. Two sentences and you understand everything about this character. He pretends not to care. He teases his little brother, calls him cute, makes jokes. But then he's already on the phone with the bully's brother making sure consequences actually happen. "Whether you did it or not last time, you clearly know it in your heart." That line — cold, precise, and absolutely ruthless. This is someone who operates on a completely different moral frequency than the people around him. He protects Yu Chengdi with the same intensity he used to intimidate thugs, but nobody gets to see it. Not even his brother, apparently. And what about the mother-son dynamic? She screams that Yu Chengsong is a jinx, that the family would be better without him, and he just... stands there. Makes a joke about the dead brother. Deliberately triggers her. It's not defiance — it's something darker and sadder. He's learned that existing is an offense in this house and he's just... making peace with it. Or maybe trying to punch back the only way he knows how.
... Read More
The scene where the teacher is late and the class erupts into absolute bedlam — you can practically hear the chairs scraping, the laughter bouncing off the walls, the phone notifications going off. And then Yin Gu cuts through all that noise with one quiet sentence: 'Deskmate, you're injured.' The contrast between the chaotic public space and that sudden moment of private intensity is chef's kiss. I also love how the ABO worldbuilding is woven in so naturally. We don't get info dumps about alpha biology or social hierarchy. We just see it happening: Yu Chengsong releases pressure without meaning to, the guy in front scratches his neck and turns red trying not to react, and Yin Gu recognizes 'top A' status like it's common knowledge. The hallway scene with Lao Li and the teacup is similarly vivid — thermos tea, disposable cups, the chemistry teacher nearly getting tripped by Yu Chengsong's long legs propped everywhere. This isn't a generic high school setting. This is a place with texture, hierarchy, smell, and pressure that you can feel in your bones. Even the details like 'yellow life-saving button' for ordering food show a world where technology and daily life are seamlessly integrated. Can't wait to see where else this story takes me.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Zhou Zheyu for a second because this guy is genuinely one of the most interesting supporting characters in the whole novel and honestly? He steals every scene he's in. The way he goes from teasing Yu Chengsong relentlessly — slapping the desk, demanding gossip, saying things like 'confess and I will give you leniency' — and then this hard cut to him standing alone on the stairs smoking with that 'look of indifference' while his inside voice is absolutely spiraling about his own love life... it's chef's kiss. The dynamic between the three of them is so naturally layered. Yu Chengsong trusts Zhou Zheyu enough to actually voice his deepest insecurities — the whole thing about whether he looks like the bottom, the fear that their physical dynamic could break them — and Zhou Zheyu, despite being wrecked about his own situation, still shows up and gives him a straight answer. 'You are even worse. You are not an Alaska Husky in front of others or behind their backs.' That line hit me so hard. It's both brutally honest and deeply affectionate, the kind of thing only a real friend says. And then there's Yin He showing up out of nowhere. The contrast with Yin Gu is almost comical — same metal-rimmed glasses, completely opposite energy. The narrator's description of him as 'a fool who tries hard to be cool but has no aura to support it at all' had me laughing out loud. But also… what does he want? Why is he looking for Yin Gu? That entrance feels like the start of something big and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how Yu Chengsong says "I like you the way you are now" and it absolutely wrecked me in the best way? Like, Yin Gu has just unloaded this entire traumatic childhood on him—wall-standing punishments, palm-beating until he couldn't hold chopsticks, writing thousands of words of self-reflection—and his immediate response isn't pity or awkward silence, it's genuine acceptance. That's rare. That's the kind of friend you actually want. And then their dynamic just flips perfectly. Yu Chengsong goes full protective mode over Yin Gu's situation, suggesting that Yin He "really needs a beating from society" and then bargaining down a hypothetical hitman fee from five hundred to four ninety. The friendship is worth exactly ten yuan apparently. This banter is everything—it's how they process heavy stuff without making it heavy. Yin Gu says "Our friendship is too fragile, it's only worth ten yuan" and honestly? That's the most affectionate thing either of them has said. The twin relationship is equally fascinating though. Yin He kept Yin Gu's first place ranking a secret for him, which is loyalty, but then sold him out by telling their parents about the fight. A brother who protects your grades but reports your violence. That contradiction says so much about him—he's the "obedient, sensible, methodical" one who nonetheless operates through manipulation and betrayal when it suits him. Yin Gu laughs it off but there's clearly hurt underneath. "He's been beaten" is said with this strange satisfaction, like karma finally arrived.
... Read More
I need to talk about this office visit because it's actually a masterclass in layered plotting. On the surface, Yu Chengsong drags Yin Gu to see Lao Li — supposedly because Yin Gu missed the teacher. But as the scene unfolds, you realize Yu Chengsong is doing something much more deliberate. He's testing something, or perhaps proving a point, and Yin Gu is his unwitting prop. The structure here is brilliant because every beat operates on two levels. When Lao Li says "the friends you make at your age are the purest ones," he thinks he's talking about genuine friendship. But the reader sees the irony — Yu Chengsong and Yin Gu's relationship is clearly something more complex, and the whole 'inseparable' exchange feels charged with unspoken meaning. Then Lao Li brings up the Jia Feisong incident — the alpha who got beaten up — and suddenly the plot tightens. Yu Chengsong's alibi (internet cafe) vs. his mother chasing him with a knife. The story is building this picture of a character who is constantly navigating between different worlds, and the teacher's office is ground zero for that tension. The homework detail is the perfect structural choice — Lao Li gives papers but Yu Chengsong ignores them, proving he doesn't need to follow rules, while Yin Gu "pretends to be very serious." The plot is telling us who these people are through action, not exposition.
... Read More
This is the most psychologically violent thing I have ever encountered in fiction and I need to discuss it immediately. Let me be clear about the stakes here. Yu Chengsong wasn't just neglected — he was systematically erased. His mother took a tragic accident, invented a narrative where her six-year-old son was a calculating killer, and then made him LIVE inside that story every single day. Not once. Not repeatedly. EVERY DAY. Until she had another child and then redirected the abuse. "She raised a murderer and said that I had been abnormal since I was young." This line should be required reading for anyone who thinks emotional abuse doesn't count because there are no visible wounds. But the stakes go deeper than just Yu Chengsong's suffering — they cascade into Yu Chengdi, born disabled because his mother smoked and drank during pregnancy, born looking too much like the brother who died, named by someone who clearly wanted no part of him. And then she kept going back for more, dragging Yuanyuan into this twisted ritual of replacement and blame. Yin Gu's response to all of this isn't dramatic. He just holds Yu Chengsong's hand tighter and says: "This matter was not your fault from the beginning to the end." The stakes have never been higher, and the comfort has never been quieter. That contrast is what makes this scene devastating and healing at the same time.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is doing SO much work and I need to break it down because the voices are so distinct. Yu Chengsong's lines are razor-sharp. Short, cutting, delivered with this deadpan precision: 'I've been pissing her off everyday, yet she hasn't collapsed yet.' — THIS LINE. I almost screamed. It's so perfectly Yu Chengsong, who's clearly been provoking his father deliberately as some kind of dark protest, and now he's weaponizing that information against the father's moral high ground. 'Are you dead? Or am I dead?' — Another one that got me. One breath, maximum devastation. His father? Oh man. His father's voice is pure deflection and rage: 'You can't be a person without conscience!' 'Whose child didn't get beaten when they grew up? Can you be beaten to death?' 'You really think you are a piece of gold or silver?' These lines are so memorably terrible. They capture that specific brand of abusive parenting where the abuser reframes abuse as discipline and frames resistance as ingratitude. The repetition of 'you two' and 'spoiled you guys' shows he's stuck in a loop of his own justification. And then there's the background dialogue — the cultural committee member yelling 'I will not show mercy!' about not violating discipline by relying on good looks. That scene with Yin Gu makes me laugh out loud every time. The tonal whiplash between these two worlds in the same chapter is wild. I also love how Yu Chengsong's dialogue with Yin Gu is so different — casual, teasing, comfortable. 'Even the pigs in the production team are not fed the way you do.' Versus the home conversations which are all tension and loaded silences.
... Read More
I know it is a comedy scene but the stakes feel REAL. When Yu Chengsong gets kicked? He actually screams. F*ck---. Tears. Trembling. The pain is so vividly described that I winced reading it. But the emotional stakes are higher - he was just trying to touch Yin Gu's lips and got punished for it. The power dynamic flips instantly from romantic tension to physical suffering. I was genuinely concerned: would he be crippled? The author balances humor and genuine tension so well. And then Yin Gu's reaction - laughing while apologizing - adds another layer. It is not malicious but it is not entirely remorseful either. The conflict here is about boundaries, consent, and the physical consequences of desire. Messy and funny and real all at once.
... Read More
The sensory texture of this chapter is extraordinary, and I want to talk about how the author builds atmosphere in three very different environments within the span of twenty pages. The classroom is rendered in specific, almost comedic detail: the piece of chalk that flies like lightning, the half-open back door through which Yu Chengsong slips, the desk where Yin Gu reaches under and produces a cup of unopened millet porridge like a magician pulling a coin from someone's ear. The Chinese teacher pointing at the desk and commanding Yu Chengsong to explain his lateness — this is a living, breathing classroom with institutional memory. The teacher has been holding a grudge. She remembers everything. This world has bureaucracy and history and the author treats it with the respect a fantasy writer would give a dragon's lair. Then the bathroom scene hits and the atmosphere shifts so dramatically it feels like stepping into a different building entirely. Jia Feisong with his head gauze still wrapped, acting like a hooligan, the four lackeys posted at the door like bouncers at a club that shouldn't exist in a school. Wu Xiaoyuan crying, legs giving out, the visual of her almost collapsing into Yu Chengsong's arms — this scene is written with the urgency of an action sequence but the claustrophobia of a thriller. The toilet cubicle as a trap. The door as the only exit. Orange-red pheromones bursting through the space like a chemical weapon. Every element in this scene serves the atmosphere of danger contained within an ordinary building. What strikes me most is how the author uses the mundane to heighten the extraordinary. The essay assignment. The porridge. The chalk. These ordinary school objects become charged with meaning in each context. The essay that Yin Gu wrote but which has "nothing to do with the truth at all" becomes a metaphor for everything Yu Chengsong is tired of performing. The porridge that Yu Chengsong drinks happily while the teacher rants about word counts becomes an island of normalcy in a chapter that keeps pulling the floor out from under the reader. The final image of Yu Chengsong leaning against the bathroom door with arms folded, whistling casually while chaos explodes behind him, is one of the most visually striking scenes I've read in this genre. The author paints it like a film still: the posture, the expression, the orange-red energy flaring outward. You can see this. You can hear the whistling. You can feel the cold tile on Yu Chengsong's back.
... Read More
I need to talk about the sensory world-building here because the author is doing something really subtle but effective. Hotpot steam fogging up the window, the morning bustle of a snack street, the particular brand of local insecurity about neighborhood security. These aren't backdrop details — they're woven into the characters' experiences. The tattoo shop observation alone is iconic. "Among a bunch of clothing stores that were about to go bankrupt, there was a tattoo shop with craftsmanship comparable to that of Peppa Pig." This line is doing SO much work. It tells us about the neighborhood's economic state, gives us visual comedy, and establishes Yu Chengsong's voice as a narrator who notices everything. And then the pivot to the maternity hospital right after — the realization that this street has no folk customs, only prosperous descendants. I laughed out loud. The morning bun shop scene is similarly vivid. Fifty meters away and he can recognize Yin Gu's back. The soy milk that isn't sweet because the old man is being stingy. Riding the bike one-handed with a bun in one hand and soy milk in the other. This is the kind of writing that makes you feel like you could walk down this street yourself. The world has texture. You can smell the hotpot on Yu Chengsong's clothes. You can hear the street vendors. It's not lavish description — it's precise, lived-in detail. That's what makes it work.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or