Is My Dad a Villain? - Reviews

Is My Dad a Villain?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Jiang Qingshi because this man is a walking contradiction and I have SO many feelings about him. On one hand, he's genuinely brilliant—he invents a walker for his kid, he supports his wife's business, he's studying for exams to give them a better life. But then he does THIS thing where he puts a starving toddler in a walker, lectures him about being a real man, and just... keeps reading. Like bro, your son is literally pressing his belly and making noise and you're over there thinking he gained weight?? The man's mind is impenetrable even to the kid's beginner mind-reading ability, and honestly I think that's by design from the author. Jiang Qingshi is deep, yes, but he's also emotionally tone-deaf in ways that are almost comedic until you remember a TWO-YEAR-OLD is involved. But here's what gets me—the scene where Lin Guilan comes back and sees Jiang Zhimiao wailing and immediately shuts down any future babysitting attempts? That's not just comedy, that's a woman who knows exactly who she's married to. She loves him, she respects him, but she also knows his limits. And Jiang Qingshi? He genuinely doesn't see it. When he says "a true man should stand tall between heaven and earth" to a baby, he's applying Confucian scholar logic to a toddler who just wants rice porridge. It's almost endearing in its absurdity. The mind-reading detail is also fascinating—Jiang Zhimiao can read his parents' thoughts but only when they relate to HIM, and his father's mind is completely inaccessible. The kid interprets this as his father being profound, but I think it's more complicated than that. Jiang Qingshi's inner world is just... locked away. He's present physically but absent mentally in these parenting moments. And yet, the text also shows him as devoted—when he looks at Lin Guilan with that deepening gaze and tells her she'll reach greater heights, that's not nothing. He sees her. He just doesn't see the baby starving next to him.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or