In The Basement Of Duke Ivanstein’s Mansion - Reviews

In The Basement Of Duke Ivanstein’s Mansion
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's a whole layer of symbolism running through this chapter that I don't think the author is being subtle about at all. First, the naming thing with Genoa. He's called the 'thirty-second young master' — an ordinal, a number, a position in line. But he calls himself Genoa, the name of the heir. In a family where survival is a competition and the dead don't get names, claiming a name is an act of defiance. 'The owner of that name was none other than Genoa himself.' He's literally naming himself into existence. That's huge. Then there's the slave who 'seemed human.' The servants dismiss it with a joke — 'Of course it's human. What else? A dog? A cat?' — but the fact that it unsettles them is telling. In this world, slaves aren't treated as human, and the mere suggestion that one might be is weird enough to discuss. Mel is the living proof that they're wrong. Her tenderness with her mother, her strategic thinking about the bread crumbs, her ability to lie protectively — all of that is unmistakably human. The locked cabin is also doing heavy symbolic work. These people are imprisoned in their own homes. The chains around the door handles, the complex padlocks — this isn't protection, it's confinement. And Mel has to climb out a window to escape it, which means the only freedom she has is dangerous and vertical. She literally has to reach outward and upward to find anything better. And Raon — caught between worlds. He's a noble who climbs walls and sneaks into forests. He's beautiful enough to frighten someone into thinking he's an angel. He's caught between the world of the Ivansteins and the world of the people they own. The moment where he reaches out his hand to Mel is probably going to mean more than either of them realizes right now.
... Read More
Okay, so this batch does something really interesting structurally — it pivots from Genoa's POV to Mel's POV without any warning chapter break or anything. You're just dropped into her world mid-conversation with her mother and you have to piece together who you're following. It's a bit disorienting at first but I think it works because the two threads are braided together deliberately. The big reveal here is that Mel's work assignment isn't what she's letting on. She tells her mom it's just warehouse organizing, but the bread crumbs she threw into the tree hole ended up in a different passage — meaning the space she's working in is underground, directly beneath that locked cabin. That's a proper hook. The author is playing with information asymmetry and I'm invested. Then there's Genoa's parallel storyline, which is basically him hunting for whatever secret the Duke is hiding. The way the servants' casual conversation about the slave 'seeming human' triggers his curiosity feels natural — it's not some dramatic confrontation, just a bored noble boy following a hunch. But it's tense because we know what kind of family he comes from. Six more siblings after him, twelve total still alive, the rest dead from the trial. The stakes are already implicit. And then — the fall. Classic scene. Mel leans out the window, sees Raon, drops, and he catches her. The cabin is locked from the outside with those heavy chains and padlocks. She's a slave and stepping outside without permission is apparently a capital offense. So now she's stuck outside with this mysterious noble boy while her mother is banging on the door inside, and morning hasn't come yet. That's a fantastic cliffhanger that makes you want to immediately click to the next chapter.
... Read More
Okay, let me just process what I just read because my jaw is basically on the floor. Twelve siblings. Only ONE gets recognized as the true heir. The rest... become 'pitiful blood clots that were never born.' GENOA, what did you sign up for?! And the way this is layered is chef's kiss. You've got Genoa sneaking into that cursed tower while simultaneously we're getting Mel's whole subplot about being a slave girl who accidentally ends up in some underground passage filling tiny gaps with daggers and axes and survival supplies. Two completely separate threads but somehow they feel like they're converging toward the same nightmare, right? Like the duke is running TWO versions of the same horror at once—one for his own kids and one using slaves as pawns. And that line 'They're all aiming for my neck first, so I'm the most likely to become a corpse first'—Genoa said it so casually but I was over here having an existential crisis. He knows he's the prime target among the siblings AND he's still going after the testing ground anyway. The man has zero survival instinct or he's just that confident. Also, the subplot about the slave auction house fire and Marquis Trixia's crackdown is apparently connected because Genoa specifically calls him out as a fanatic who wouldn't move without the duke's permission. So the duke orchestrated a fire to cover something? Or to test something? I genuinely cannot tell yet but I NEED to know.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this thing is SO thick you could cut it with one of the daggers Mel was storing. Let me just... the tower. The forbidden tower where the mad duchess supposedly burned. The testing ground that the duke personally visited. The underground passage with iron walls where a blindfolded eight-year-old is stuffing tools into tiny holes. And that tree! The tree with the hole where Mel throws bread crumbs and somehow those same bread crumbs end up falling from a crevice in the ceiling of the underground room. THAT is how you connect two scenes across literally different locations. I'm not even sure if the author planned that or if it just happened organically but it gave me chills. The visual of the silver-haired Genoa jumping out a window 'like a rat along the walls' while his father's eyes and ears are supposedly on every surface of the mansion—that's such a specific, cinematic image. And Mel's cabin being the first place she's ever had a WINDOW is this devastating little detail. A WINDOW. For a child who's never had anything. The author doesn't even have to say 'she's poor and oppressed' because they just show us this tiny sliver of light and her mother lifting her up to see birds in a tree, and I was already writing fan fiction in my head about those two. The world feels lived-in and genuinely dangerous. Not the fake-dangerous kind where everything is dramatic for no reason, but the kind where danger is just... mundane. Like breathing.
... Read More
I've been turning over a few threads from this chapter and I think the author is weaving something much bigger than a simple revenge plot here. Let me lay out what I'm seeing. Sleep. That's the first symbol that won't leave me. Genoa hasn't slept properly in fifteen years — not since whatever happened that changed him. And yet here he is, having fallen into a deep slumber while sitting next to the very person whose betrayal once destroyed his ability to rest. What does that mean? Is Mel somehow the antidote to his trauma? Or is this sleep a sign that his body is finally allowing itself to process something he's been running from? The author keeps coming back to this: 'The only time such a Genoa could get a long, sound sleep was in the middle of a battlefield. Only when his whole body was soaked in the blood of the enemy could Genoa sleep deeply.' That line is doing heavy thematic lifting. Sleep = peace. Peace = earned through violence. But Mel didn't fight him. She just... existed beside him. And somehow that was enough. That's either the most hopeful thing this book has ever said or the most dangerous. Then there's the body as prison. Mel's physical body is literally confined — chains, gag, blindfold, locked in a warehouse. But her mind? Her mind is constantly escaping. She imagines different scenarios, rehearses responses, calculates every possible outcome. The boy's moment of kindness outside the window is the only time her body moves freely — and even that freedom is an illusion because it turns out to be Genoa testing her. The real prison isn't the warehouse. It's the inability to trust anyone's intentions. And the dual identity theme — this is the big one. Three layers of disguise in one chapter: Mel pretending to be a princess, Genoa pretending to be a kind boy, Bane pretending to be polite while serving a monster. Everyone is performing. Everyone is hiding. The question the book keeps asking is: which version is the real one? And more importantly — does it matter? I keep thinking about that final image of Genoa lifting Mel's chin with his toe and saying 'this expression suits that face.' He's looking at her face — the face of the girl he once knew, the girl who betrayed him — and seeing something that both confirms and confuses him. The face is the same. The person underneath is not. And neither is he.
... Read More
Let me just start by saying—this author knows how to build atmosphere. I mean, the opening paragraph of the flashback gives us: 'The slave storage of a human auction house, which could be considered the bottom of the continent.' That's it. That's the thesis statement for this entire underworld. The BOTTOM of the continent. Not just geographically, but morally, socially, existentially. And then the sensory details just pile up on top of each other like bricks. 'Crammed into a space so narrow they could barely stretch out an arm.' The dust. The coughing. The sound of the guard 'scratching his ears like a madman' while blood pools under his nails. This isn't just worldbuilding—this is Hellscape Architecture. You can SMELL this place. You can feel the lack of oxygen. You can hear the guard's voice: 'Who is it, who's tormenting me? Who is it, who?' with that broken repetition that tells you everything about his psychological state without the author having to explain it. The four categories of slaves—male, female, particularly good-looking, and those with unique characteristics. This isn't just casual mention. The author is showing us the entire economy of human suffering mapped out in one sentence. Mel knows these categories because she was BORN into them. 'She also knew that she and her mother would be separated into different categories.' Children shouldn't know this vocabulary. Ten-year-olds shouldn't be doing mental calculations about what fate awaits them based on physical categorization. Then we cut to the carriage scene and the contrast is jaw-dropping. The imperial carriage enchanted with ancient magic, 'increasing the stamina and strength of the horses, allowing them to reach their destination at a constant speed without tiring even after long hours of travel.' The technology exists. The magic exists. And yet people are still packed into underground cages like livestock. The Empire is clearly advanced—imperial carriages, enchanted transport, messenger birds arriving in half a day across vast distances—but the moral foundation is rotten to its core. The ending of the flashback is pure cinematic. Duke Lionel's carriage window opening slightly, the knight saying 'This place needs to be cleaned up,' the figures in black emerging from darkness, and then—'Tonight, the largest slave auction house in the Kingdom of Raon will disappear without a trace.' Not closed. Not reformed. Erased. This is a world where justice comes through fire and blood, and that's somehow both horrifying and deeply satisfying. The Ivanstein mansion with its forbidden spaces—the tower, the incinerator, the test chamber where 'the bloodlines of the deceased members of the ducal family' were disposed of. This isn't just a setting. It's a character. A dark, breathing entity that watches everything from the shadows.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter just escalated from 'princess might get humiliated' to 'entire geopolitical landscape has shifted' and I am not okay. Externally: the emperor is dead. The empire is in flux. Genoa controls the conquered Reibritton but is also doing the emperor's old job. Other nobles are circling, wanting what the emperor couldn't have. There's a whole line of people waiting for the princess to fall into their hands. She's now more valuable than ever — which means more dangerous, not less. Internally: Mel is trapped between two identities. As a princess, she's powerless. As the slave who abandoned Genoa, she's guilty. She literally says 'It would have been better if she had died at the hands of Genoa' — she'd rather face his wrath directly than this limbo. And yet she chooses to live. 'I'll try.' That's the highest-stakes moment in the entire chapter. She's赌着 her life on proving she's useful to the one man who has every reason to kill her. Genoa's conflict is even juicier — he could execute her cleanly and end it, but he doesn't. He says 'I might be able to enjoy watching you struggle to survive a little.' But is that really what he wants? Or is he punishing himself by keeping her close? The tension between what he says and what he does is ELECTRIC. And that ending — cut off mid-word, mid-thought — the stakes haven't even peaked yet. What was he regretting? What did she betray? I need the next chapter RIGHT NOW.
... Read More
There are some really heavy symbolic threads running through this chapter and I need to unpack them. The insomnia. This has been building since the beginning — Genoa can only sleep deeply when covered in blood, and the archbishop literally says 'I wonder how much blood of how many people Duke Ivanstein had to be covered in to sleep so deeply!' Blood as payment for rest. Blood as the only thing that lets him escape his own mind. And then he sleeps soundly after meeting the princess, which the archbishop can't explain. Was it her? Or was it something else? The blood theme ties directly to his violence, his trauma, and whatever inexplicable connection he has to her. Then there's Mel's name — or lack of it. She's called 'the princess' by everyone except when Genoa looks at her and sees the slave she used to be. Her identity is being stripped layer by layer. First she was Mel the slave who ran away. Now she's Princess Amelia of Reibritton, a political object. But Genoa sees both simultaneously, which is why his gaze goes 'somewhere beyond her face.' She doesn't get to just BE a princess. She can't escape what she was. And the messenger pigeon — golden feathers dyed onto a black bird. Death carried on something that looks like hope. The emperor dies and the princess's fate changes, all delivered by a bird. There's something so haunting about that image.
... Read More
There are two rooms in this chapter that live in my head rent-free now and they couldn't be more different. The first is that moment outside the cabin at night. The author doesn't give us a single line of landscape description but the scene paints itself anyway: moonlight on purple eyes, a boy's long fingers reaching down to pull a slave girl up, the sound of his voice — 'Here, step on my shoulder.' It's quiet. Intimate. There's a warmth to it that feels almost protective, like something out of a picture book except everything about Mel's body language screams wariness. 'Is this a new way to torment slaves? Do the nobles here enjoy this kind of amusement?' That single thought — her immediate assumption that kindness must be a trick — is the most worldbuilding sentence in the entire chapter. You don't need a paragraph about the slave trade to understand how cruel this world is. One line tells you everything. Then the chapter pivots and we're in a warehouse. Just one sentence to establish it: 'In the old warehouse, only the regular dripping sound of water leaking could be heard.' That's it. That's all they gave me and somehow it was more terrifying than any gothic description ever could be. Dripping. Chains. Gag. Hood. No light, no warmth, no mercy. A girl who hasn't had water in a full day, sitting in her own filth, waiting to be dragged out. And then Genoa arrives. 'Now you look a bit more presentable,' he says while lifting her chin with his toe. The contrast between the boy's gentle hands and the Duke's cold foot — same person, two faces, two worlds — is something I can't stop thinking about. What I love about the worldbuilding here is that it never stops at setting. Harttenberun is described in exactly three sentences: a free trade city, midpoint between two powers, where 'the duke was the emperor and his word was law.' That's all we get and suddenly this whole political landscape has weight. Mel could disappear here and no one would care. The old emperor 'would not be able to say anything.' That's how thoroughly the Ivanstein duchy operates above the law. The world feels dangerous not because the author tells us it is, but because every detail proves it.
... Read More
I need a minute. I need to just sit with what I just read about Mel as a ten-year-old in that slave storage room. 'The third time Mel and her mother had entered this auction house as merchandise.' Three times. THREE TIMES these two have been forced through hell and they haven't given up on each other. And Mel's mother is 'panting, unable to breathe properly' in this 'stuffy, dust-filled space' and Mel is literally covering her mouth because noise equals violence in this place. This is a child making impossible choices to protect her mother and the author makes it feel so immediate and suffocating. The guard scene—oh god the guard scene. 'His ears had long since lost their shape, and where they should have been were now just hollow cavities.' He's scratching his own ears until blood pools between his fingernails. And Mel? She picks up a stone. A fucking stone. Throws it at the wall to redirect his attention away from her mom. She's ten. TEN. And she's already calculating survival like it's second nature. But the moment that absolutely DESTROYED me was right after. The manager comes in, starts whipping the guard, blood splatters on the merchandise, and Mel's thought is just 'If anyone touches mother, I'll kill them all.' This is a ten-year-old girl having the full weight of the world on her shoulders and she's still standing between her mother and whatever nightmare comes next. And then—then her mother embraces her. 'Just that warmth and affectionate embrace was enough to calm her tension. Even though her body couldn't keep up and she had to rely on her young daughter, a mother was still a mother.' I am not okay. The roles reversed. The child is the protector. The mother is frail but still manages to give her daughter comfort. That line hit me like a truck. Later in the carriage, Mel realizes Genoa believes she betrayed him. 'She had never betrayed Genoa. Of course, they weren't even close enough for betrayal to be possible.' And then she thinks about how she helped him survive, how she was satisfied that he could become Duke thanks to her help. That's not betrayal. That's love. That's someone who gave everything and expected nothing back. And now she's bound to the person she loved as a child, and he thinks she abandoned him. The irony is so sharp I can feel it cutting me.
... Read More
Okay I need to unpack some of the symbolism here because this author is NOT playing around. Let's start with the most obvious one: the PEN. Genoa has been signing documents when Mel wakes up. He uses the NIB of the pen to threaten her throat. Think about that for a second. A tool of bureaucracy, of administration, of legal authority—turned into a weapon. The Duke doesn't need a sword or a knife. He needs a fountain pen. Power in this world is paper and ink and signatures, and the same instrument that builds empires can end a life with a single prick. That's not accidental. That's the author telling us something fundamental about how power works in this society. Then there's the eye motif, which is everywhere. The guard who is blind but has 'very sensitive ears.' Genoa with his 'mysterious eyes resembling purple sapphires.' Mel's 'vivid green eyes' that trigger something in him. The Princess has a cloth 'tied under her eyes' to prevent her face from bothering him—which is actually hilarious because the text immediately tells us 'He should have covered her eyes, not just below them.' Eyes are the window to identity, and everyone in this text is either losing them, hiding them, or being haunted by them. Genoa can't look at the Princess without seeing the dead slave girl. Mel can't see anything because she's blindfolded, navigating by voice and memory alone. The blind guard perceives through sound rather than sight, which ironically makes him more perceptive about threats than anyone else. The slave categorization system itself is a symbol of dehumanization. Mel and her mother aren't people—they're merchandise sorted into categories based on utility and aesthetics. 'Male slaves, female slaves, particularly good-looking male and female slaves, and slaves with unique characteristics.' This taxonomy reduces human beings to inventory. And yet Mel USES this system. She understands it. She navigates it. She becomes a good 'item' not because she's broken, but because she's smart enough to play the game. The system that tries to reduce her actually becomes the tool she weaponizes. The concept of promises hangs over the entire text like a ghost. 'If she hadn't run away like that, Genoa would have promised Mel a peaceful life.' What kind of promise does a ten-year-old make to another child? A promise born from genuine connection, not obligation. And Mel's reflection: 'That didn't mean she didn't understand loyalty. It was clearly her mistake that she had to leave.' The tension between what loyalty means to different people—Mel sees her actions as protection and sacrifice; Genoa interprets her absence as betrayal. Neither is wrong. Both are heartbreaking. And finally, the basement. The test chamber. The tower. The incinerator. These are all symbols of what this family—and this empire—keeps hidden. The Duke Lionel destroyed a slave auction house not through reform or law but through complete annihilation. 'Don't leave even a single rat alive, erase everything.' The language of extermination used against traffickers. The author is asking: when the system itself is built on human suffering, what does justice look like? And the answer in this text is neither clean nor comfortable. It's fire and blood and disappeared bodies, and it sits uncomfortably alongside the imperial carriage and enchanted magic that makes the surface world so civilized.
... Read More
Okay so let me just breathe for a second because THIS CHAPTER. The emperor is dead. Dead. And it comes in like a fucking landmine — one minute Genoa is minding his business handling post-war paperwork, Bane is complaining about insomnia, the princess is moping in her room — and then a black messenger pigeon with golden feathers shows up and HE IS GONE. No warning, no dramatic buildup, just a one-line message: [Helius Vervan de Raon II. Deceased.] And suddenly every power dynamic in this entire story just gets thrown out the window. What I love about how this plot twist lands is that it doesn't feel manufactured. The author had us simmering for weeks — the emperor waiting impatiently, the princess dreading being handed over to him, all these rumors about what he'd do to a captive princess — and then BOOM, the man she was supposed to face never gets to touch her at all. But here's the thing: her value just INCREASED instead of decreased. Nobles who couldn't get their hands on the emperor's prize are now circling like sharks. Genoa could just execute her and call it done, but he doesn't. Instead he tells her she has to prove her usefulness. The Reibritton royal palace falling, the empire consolidating power, Genoa doing ALL the emperor's work anyway — it's all converging toward something huge and I am HERE FOR IT. The plot is tight, the cause-and-effect chain is solid, and that ending? Pure chef's kiss.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or