I’m a Saintess, but I’m Also a Villain - Reviews

I’m a Saintess, but I’m Also a Villain
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the voice in this novel because it's genuinely distinctive and I don't say that lightly. The narration has this sharp, darkly comedic edge that never takes itself too seriously but also never insults the reader's intelligence. Take the opening exchange: 'Excuse me, but have you lost your mind?' followed by Lilith physically manhandling Dietrich's head to check for concussions. The dialogue is snappy, natural, and reveals character instantly — Lilith is pragmatic to the point of absurdity, while Dietrich is all repressed intensity. But what really impressed me was how the internal monologue contrasts with the spoken dialogue. Eunice's outer voice is the model trainee — polite, submissive, carefully measured. Her inner voice is pure venom and dark humor: 'Has he finally gone mad?' 'Should I just kill him?' 'A better revenge method than physical pain had occurred to her.' This gap between what she says and what she thinks is where the novel's real voice lives. And the humor! 'Even a passing dog wouldn't believe such a confession.' That's not just a funny line — it's the author winking at the reader, acknowledging the absurdity while still making the emotional beats land. The Theodore scenes are particularly well-done dialogue-wise because every line he speaks reveals his character: the manipulation, the false authority, the cowardice masked as righteousness. 'You said you decided to become a saintess because of your mother's dying wish!' — this isn't just an insult; it's a man who knows exactly which buttons to press because he's spent months learning them. The narrative voice never lets us forget that this is a story about a woman who smiled through three months of abuse and then decided to burn it all down. Bravo.
... Read More
Let me just say — Father Theodore is one of the most有效地 written antagonists I've encountered in a short span. Not because he's some grand evil overlord, but because his cruelty is so BANALLY human. He doesn't want to destroy the world. He wants a PROMOTION. And he'll destroy people to get it. The stakes escalate beautifully across two levels simultaneously. On the personal level: Eunice is fighting for her dignity, her mother's memory, and eventually her freedom from an abusive system. When Theodore brings up her dead mother, that's the line. That's when the reader stops being neutral and starts demanding consequences. On the institutional level: the Saintess system itself is clearly flawed — three failed exams, lifetime of abuse, the expectation that suffering equals holiness. Eunice's rebellion through becoming Lilith isn't just petty revenge; it's a direct challenge to the entire monastery power structure. And here's the thing that makes the stakes feel real: Eunice isn't some omnipotent hero. She's overworked, underestimated, repeatedly told she's a disgrace, and she still finds the will to fight back — just in her own way. The Phantom Thief persona gives her agency the monastery systematically denied her. The tension between her two identities creates constant dramatic irony that keeps you hooked. What does Dietrich think when he talks about the 'evil villain Lilith'? What happens when he discovers the truth? The suspense isn't just 'will they figure it out' — it's 'what will it cost them when they do?' The author understands that the best conflict isn't just external obstacles; it's the collision between who characters pretend to be and who they actually are.
... Read More
Okay so this opening arc is genuinely clever and I need to talk about it because wow. Let me backtrack because the way this narrative unfolds is actually pretty sophisticated for a webnovel. We start with what seems like a straightforward (if chaotic) confession scene between Dietrich and Lilith, and my initial read was just 'haha this paladin has issues.' Then the flashback drops and suddenly EVERYTHING recontextualizes. Eunice isn't just some random monastery trainee — she's the phantom thief Lilith. The same person Dietrich is confessing to. The dual identity reveal happens organically through the flashback structure rather than some clunky exposition dump, which honestly surprised me. The arson incident that started last spring? That's not just backstory flavor — it's the inciting incident of the entire plot. Eunice snapping at Theodore and deciding to burn his documents is literally the moment our villain-protagonist is born. And then the cruel irony of it all: Dietrich says he gave up on Eunice because he 'harbors feelings for two people at once,' not realizing those two people are literally the same person. The author set up this beautiful tragicomic dramatic irony where we know something none of the characters fully understand yet. The plot doesn't feel rushed either — we get enough of Eunice's daily abuse to understand why she snapped, but not so much that it drags. The Theodore confrontation escalates naturally from budget complaints to personal attacks to the mother comment, and by the time Eunice decides to commit arson, we're right there with her. The structure is tight. Three-year pining on Lilith's side, the monastery introduction, the breaking point, the phantom thief reveal — all woven together without feeling forced.
... Read More
'I like you, Lilith.' Three words that should have been the moment of Eunice's life and instead became a triple whammy of emotional destruction. Can we just sit with this for a second? LILITH HAS LIKED DIETRICH FOR THREE YEARS. THREE YEARS. And when the moment finally comes — the Paladin himself, confessing! — he's not actually confessing romantic feelings at all. He's BLAMING HIM. The emotional whiplash is absolutely brutal and I love it. But what really got me wasn't even that twist — it was Eunice's internal monologue during the Theodore scene. That moment when she thinks 'Should I just kill him?' and then literally calculates 'This would end it in 3 seconds.' The pen in her hand, her muscles tensing, the darkness just BREATHING out of her — and then 'promotion' snaps her back. Not because she's weak. Because she chose REVENGE over murder. That's a character who had every reason to break and chose something far more complicated instead. The CP energy here is fascinating because it's built on complete asymmetry: Eunice/Lilith knows everything about Dietrich (three years of pining), but Dietrich knows... nothing. He liked Eunice from afar, apparently, and now he's confessing to the person who was literally disguised as Eunice during those years. The unrequited love triangle that's actually a unrequited love dueling with itself. And Dietrich's line about being unworthy of the Saintess because he has 'sinful feelings' for a villain — that's genuine emotional vulnerability disguised as self-loathing. This author knows how to make you feel things.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or