If You Wish to Have Me - Reviews

If You Wish to Have Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we talk about how Kisa's entire support system is actively failing her in this batch? I'm sitting here fuming. First, Melissa. Kisa's friend did something unforgivable — we know that much — and instead of genuinely trying to repair things, she's sending letters full of excuses. And the father's reaction? 'Make up with her.' Just like that. Like friendship is a transaction your father negotiates on your behalf. He doesn't even ASK what happened. To him, Kisa's feelings are 'trivial matters.' This man has raised her his whole life and still treats her like a political asset. Then the nanny. Oh god, the nanny. 'Miss, you've always liked dresses like this!' and just... takes the box away. Ignores her mistress's direct instruction. The author drops this devastating line: 'Though she was said to be like a mother to Kisa, the nanny was ultimately Count Vansfelt's employee.' I literally gasped. That's not a nanny. That's a guard in disguise. And Daniel — sending a gorgeous dress with a note that says 'show off your beautiful figure' and 'surely you're not still upset?' This man cannot process that Kisa is angry. He sends her clothes like love language is something you buy. 'That side of you is cute too' — what does that even mean? He's romanticizing her pain. But the most interesting relationship shift? Kisa comparing Seyard to Daniel internally: 'If only Daniel had inherited half of that temperament.' She's realizing what kindness looks like by watching someone else demonstrate it. That's huge. She rejected Seyard's proposal but is now measuring everyone else against the standard he set.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is absolutely vicious and I'm here for it. Let me just quote one exchange because it perfectly captures everything: "If you want to meet me, wait in the reception room." "...Kisa, are you joking with me right now?" "This isn't a joke, it's a matter of manners." The way Kisa strips Daniel of every advantage through polite, formal language is devastating. She uses etiquette as a weapon. "Does the Lowens family teach that it's acceptable to open someone else's door without permission?" She's not being rude—she's being MORE proper than anyone has a right to be, and that's what unravels him completely. And his responses? "Since when did we become the type to stand on ceremony?" "Don't push it." Classic deflection. He can't win because every move he makes, she reframes. When she says "I learned it from you," after he calls her speech rough—that's not just a comeback, that's a full recontextualization of their entire relationship. She's holding up a mirror and he hates what he sees. Daniel's voice throughout is all bluster and entitlement. He whistles when he wants attention, he wraps his arm around her shoulder like she's a prize, he throws gold coins to make points. Even his laughter at the end—"Ha ha"—is described as not sounding amused at all. The author gives each character a distinctly different speech pattern. Kisa is measured, precise, increasingly cold. Daniel is loud, reactive, escalating. The nanny is pure chaos and worry. And the Count? He doesn't speak much at all, which somehow makes him the most powerful person in every scene.
... Read More
Seyard. Oh my god, Seyard. From the moment he appears leaning against that bookshelf asking why she's crying, I was hooked. The way he approaches her — not with pity, not with judgment, but with genuine curiosity about what made her sad — that's such a contrast to everyone else in her life. Daniel mocked her intelligence. Her father raised her in a gilded cage. The nanny worries about propriety instead of her actual mind. But this random stranger at the library sees her struggling and says, 'You're not stupid, you just needed the right starting point.' He even recommends her a whole reading list! The chemistry between them is already there in just one conversation, and the best part? Kisa has no idea he's a duke. She literally thinks he might be a university student. Meanwhile, the reader is sitting there going 'NO, YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND WHO THIS MAN IS.' That layer of secret identity on top of the intellectual connection is so delicious. And then there's Daniel, who I absolutely despise after the way he and his mother treated Kisa. Their broken engagement feels like it's going to reshape everything. She grasped the doorknob.
... Read More
I need a minute. Can we just talk about Kisa at the opera house, watching it recede from the carriage, and realizing she may never see Seyard again? Not because she doesn't want to. Not because of any drama or conflict between them. But because she doesn't KNOW him. She doesn't know his surname. She doesn't know where he lives. She doesn't know when he goes to the library. They had one proper conversation, he proposed and she refused, and then they just... went back to being strangers who borrowed books in the same room. The author writes: 'I had hoped to run into him after the performance, but it was too much to expect.' And then: 'Maybe I'll never see him again.' And the excitement that had filled her heart 'cooled bitterly.' I am NOT okay. This is the kind of quiet devastation that hits you in the chest. She doesn't even have a name for what she's feeling yet. She's not thinking 'I regret rejecting him' or 'I miss him.' She's thinking about whether she'll get to ask his opinion on the opera's ending. That's the thing — it's so small. So ordinary. And that's what makes it destroy me. Compare this to her relationship with Daniel, where everything is performative and loud and controlled. With Seyard, she wanted something simple: to share a thought. To talk about art. To be intellectually equal with someone who treats her like a person. And now even that might be impossible. The cruelty of this scene is that Kisa is free — she turned down a manipulative engagement, she stood up to her father, she went to the opera on her own terms — but her greatest emotional vulnerability is something she can't even name yet.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is deceptively plain. On the surface, it reads like a straightforward romance exchange. But read it twice and you'll notice every line is carrying something beneath it. Seyard's voice is remarkable because it's almost TOO composed. When he describes his own proposal to Kisa, he does it like he's narrating someone else's story: "It's quite an impulsive and reckless decision, but considering my background, it's not incomprehensible. Many people don't think I learned noble etiquette at the monastery." He's weaponizing self-deprecation. He knows exactly how he comes across and he's letting her draw the conclusions she wants to draw. Every time he says something casually dismissive about himself, he's actually performing control. Kisa's voice, by contrast, keeps retreating. She opens her mouth, closes it, says "It's nothing. Please forget it." She's the type of character who notices everything but speaks last. Her dialogue is full of half-finished sentences and swallowed questions. That's her signature — she thinks three steps ahead of what she actually says. Daniel's lines are almost parodic in their entitlement: "What nonsense are you talking about?" — wait, he's asking THAT? While he's the one assuming she's buying a gift for HIM? The sheer audacity in his voice is so distinctly different from Seyard's measured calm that you could tell them apart blindfolded. "Stop putting on airs. Don't I know you?" — This line is hilarious because he absolutely does NOT know her. But that's Daniel's entire brand: confidence without competence. The Count's dialogue has this compressed, formal quality that shifts imperceptibly throughout the chapter. He starts with bureaucratic distance and by the end he's almost... pleading? Without admitting it. The change is in the subtext, not in his words.
... Read More
There's a recurring question beneath all of this: what is Kisa worth? Not in money or status—in human terms. Daniel treats her as a placeholder, a suitable wife who exists to legitimize his position while he pursues something 'real' with Hazel. Her father treats her as a dynastic asset whose primary function is to maintain a useful alliance. Melissa treats her as someone whose emotional comfort is more important than her autonomy. Even the line about Kisa's mother—absent, mentioned only in passing, perhaps dead—adds weight to this. Who is Kisa when she's not being a daughter, a fiancée, a friend? The Count's casual framing of marriage as transaction—'a union of families'—is the thesis statement of the entire novel, repeated like a mantra. But Kisa's demand to break the engagement is the counter-thesis. She's saying: I am worth more than a contract. The 'rusty hinge' metaphor when Kisa tries to articulate her discomfort with Hazel's intellect is too perfect to ignore—it's the sound of a woman forcing open something long sealed shut. Her voice, her truth, her anger. All of it has been locked away, and now it's creaking open.
... Read More
Okay, so Melissa is probably one of the most interesting antagonists in this whole story and she's not even technically the villain. The scene in the carriage where Kisa finally confronts her? Chef's kiss. Everything about Melissa's energy — she genuinely believes she did the right thing. She told the princess about Kisa's problems because she was helping, obviously, and when Kisa calls her out, Melissa gets genuinely confused and defensive. That line "Why are you being like this? I really just wanted to lift your spirits" is so casually manipulative that I want to scream. But here's the thing that got me — Kisa's realization at the end. She starts connecting dots about her entire life: the friendship with Melissa was arranged by her father, the engagement to Daniel was orchestrated by the Count, and now even going to the library feels like a small act of rebellion. She says it out loud: "Everything in these hands was given to her by the Count. Not just material things but even relationships, nothing was truly her own." That hit different. It reframes everything. Melissa isn't just a bad friend — she's a product of the same system that's controlled Kisa since birth. And somehow, Kisa finding Seyard feels like the first truly autonomous relationship she's ever had. The fact that Seyard also has someone in mind when he says "there's just someone who comes to mind"? The parallel is delicious. Two people who've been maneuvered around by duty finding each other by choice.
... Read More
This section is a masterclass in controlled pacing. The author could have resolved the engagement drama in one explosive scene, but instead they stretch it out like taffy—pulling, twisting, letting it cool between pulls. Look at the structure: Chapter 60 starts with the handkerchief shopping, which seems like a mundane errand until Daniel shows up and the tension immediately spikes. Then there's a section break and we get the gossip magazine reveal, which recontextualizes everything that came before. The Count's line "I plan to send the formal engagement dissolution notice in exactly two days" is delivered with zero drama—just businesslike matter-of-factness—and that restraint is what makes it hit so hard. Then Chapter 61, "Breaking Off the Engagement"—the title alone is a statement. The confrontation with Daniel at the door stretches across what feels like an eternity. Two hours of waiting. She writes letters. Reads the newspaper. Reads the magazine. Plays with her violin. The nanny is losing her mind and Kisa is perfectly composed. The author is weaponizing time here, making the reader feel every single minute of Daniel's impotence. And then just when you think it's over, the chapter cuts off with Kisa picking up the magazine again, about to read Daniel's article in full detail. The pacing never rushes, never drags—it builds like pressure in a sealed container. Every scene transition serves the central question: how long can Daniel keep pretending he still has control?
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about this one line because I AM STILL NOT OVER IT. So Kisa goes through literally the worst morning of her life, right? She hears this crazy rumor about her fiancé, goes to confirm it, sees him on ONE KNEE swearing a knight's oath to some woman, and she confronts him expecting maybe an apology, maybe shame, maybe anything human. And what does Daniel do? He calls her stupid. Not mean, not cruel in some dramatic way — just casually drops this word like it's a factual observation, like she's a mildly disappointing student. "You're too... stupid to be my soulmate." The condescension is absolutely murderous. I literally threw my phone across the room when I read that. And the worst part? The narration tells us right after: "Over a decade of affection had been one-sided, belonging only to Kisa." ONE SIDED. Ten years. She trusted him, defended him to a stranger, risked going to that street against her conservative father's expectations, and his response is basically "you're intellectually inadequate so I get to do whatever I want." What a piece of work. And Hazel standing there, trying to play the reasonable third party — "my relationship with your fiancé is purely platonic" — while her arm is being protected by the man who just told his fiancée she's stupid. I need a minute.
... Read More
I need to talk about this walking scene because it stays with me. "Isn't it quite plausible? A rookie duke who happens to visit the opera house, encounters the most beautiful woman he's ever seen in his life, falls completely for her, and ends up proposing." He says this so casually. So matter-of-fact. And Kisa's entire reaction is just internally short-circuiting because calling her beautiful sounds like a line everyone has heard before, but coming from him it felt like a statement of geological fact, like he was reporting the weather. "Occasionally, there were those who tried to seduce naturally, as if adding water to water. However, in such cases, the persuasive words usually had metaphorical aspects, but his earlier statement was too direct and even obvious." That line right there — that's the moment I realized this isn't a love story where two people figure things out. This is two people who already know exactly what they want and are navigating around each other's awareness of it. Seyard knows she knows he planned it. She knows he's doing this. But they're still walking side by side and having a perfectly normal conversation about the weather after someone just proposed. Then the contract discussion hits and suddenly the emotional layering gets insane. He offers terms that are generous and fair and completely non-pressure, and she... she accepts. Not because she's given up but because she sees the logic. And when he walks away saying "Everything will work out," the power dynamic has completely shifted. He made the proposal. He set the terms. He leaves her standing there thinking about it. "Looking at the back of the man who walked ahead with such composure, she wondered what his intention was in saying such things. Not that watching his back would reveal his true thoughts." This man operates on a frequency I don't think Kisa is calibrated to yet.
... Read More
The world-building in these chapters is so subtle but effective. It starts with the black carriage at the main gate—no crest, but luxurious enough to signal nobility. That visual cue tells us everything about the visitor's status before a single word is spoken. Then the office scene: Kisa presses her ear to the door, hearing muffled voices, and the secretary blocks her with bureaucratic threats. The confined space of the doorway versus the open garden later creates a perfect metaphor for her transition from eavesdropper to participant. And the garden! Count Vansfelt insists they walk there ‘so it looks like a real stroll,' but his real motive is surveillance—he can watch from his office window. Seyard immediately picks up on this and agrees gracefully, showing his social intelligence. The description of spring flowers ‘welcoming them' feels ironic given the tension. The author uses setting to mirror power dynamics: the Count controls the house, Seyard controls the narrative, and Kisa is caught between both. Even small details matter, like servants giving Seyard ‘quick glances' before bowing, indicating his identity is still unknown locally. This world feels lived-in, with its own rules of visibility and concealment. The unmarked carriage, the guarded doors, the watched garden—all reinforce a society where information is currency and space is contested.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this because honestly my heart was pounding the entire time. Kisa throwing away that dress—she literally told Daniel through the door that she already got rid of it. And Daniel? He just waved his hand like, "sure, sure," completely missing the point. That moment? I wanted to shake him. But also... I kind of wanted to shake Kisa too, because she was sitting there smiling like a maniac while making him wait for TWO HOURS. Two hours! She literally read the whole newspaper and then the gossip magazine after that. The nanny was having a stroke over there and Kisa was like "time moves slowly, unexpectedly" with a smile on her face. The most satisfying part was when she hummed while writing her replies, completely unbothered. All those letters from people who were just gossiping about her? She said they seemed lovely this time. That's not just moving on, that's a full psychological transformation. And the worst part—the best part—is that Daniel has no idea what's happening. He thinks she's playing hard to get, that she'll eventually come running. The engagement is already dead, her father sent the notice, and he's still operating on the delusion that he's in control. The contrast between Kisa's inner calm and her outward performance is so intense. She's not just rejecting him, she's rewiring every interaction they've ever had.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or