If You Wish to Abandon Me - Reviews

If You Wish to Abandon Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay I need to just — Isabella. Oh my god. The way she treated Delia in that hallway absolutely made me want to throw the book across the room. She looked at her daughter-in-law the way someone would look at a rat they found in their kitchen, right? And then — and THEN — she switches completely when Evelyn walks in. The moment Evelyn arrives, Isabella is suddenly all soft smiles and delicate handkerchief dabbing. She even strokes Evelyn's hair like some kind of doting mother. But with Delia? Cold shoulders, sharp words, calling her a rat. It's not even subtle. The author didn't even TRY to make Isabella likable or complex here. She's just pure, unfiltered villain energy and honestly? That makes the tension so much more brutal because there's no gray area. Delia is completely alone in this and it breaks my heart every time. And Kallius — what is happening with him?? He's standing there silent while his own mother humiliates his wife and he doesn't say a single word. But then later, when Evelyn asks if he truly loves his wife, he says the most devastating line: "There will never come a day when I love my wife." Wait though — he also tells her he only tolerates her because of his mother's dignity. So is he playing some kind of game? Or is he just genuinely indifferent? I keep oscillating between thinking he's secretly still in love with Delia and thinking he's completely moved on. This relationship dynamic is torture.
... Read More
There are a few visual moments in this chapter that have been sticking with me like frames from a film, and I think the author is doing something really intentional with the imagery. The sunset scene where Delia watches the sky burn red across the horizon—and the narration explicitly says it 'mirrors the way her heart was slowly charring.' That's not subtle worldbuilding, that's poetry. The external landscape becoming an extension of internal devastation. I love it. Then there's the dining room scene, which is staged like a courtroom drama. Kallius reading a newspaper, the formal setting, the way he produces that letter like a prosecutor presenting evidence. Delia sitting there, having to compose her face, perform normalcy while her world collapses. The cold sheets beside him the morning after—they're such a small detail but they communicate the entire state of their marriage in one image. Empty. Cold. Unoccupied. Isabella's entrance into Delia's bedroom is another beautifully shot sequence. She doesn't knock properly—she just comes in and starts surveying the space like a predator inspecting territory. 'What a state this room is in.' The camera of the prose literally follows her around the room, cataloging flaws. And then the purple lilacs—she knocks over a vase and the flowers scatter on the floor. Delia hurries to pick them up after Isabella leaves. That's not an accident in the writing. Those crushed flowers are Delia herself. The bedroom itself feels significant too. It's her space, but it's also the Hildebrandt estate, which means it's not really hers. Isabella's presence there—prowling through it, criticizing it, claiming authority over it—reinforces that Delia has no sovereign ground anywhere. Every room she enters, every interaction she has, is already mapped by people who want her gone. And that purple brooch on the dress! The color keeps coming back—purple lilacs, purple brooch, the color of mourning and nobility both. The author is painting this whole world in shades of purple and I keep feeling like that's on purpose.
... Read More
I need to talk about Isabella because this woman is a MASTERCLASS in manipulating every room she walks into and I am simultaneously repulsed and impressed. The scene where she's going through those marriage profiles is so revealing—she doesn't even look at the women's faces. Lineage above all else. A plain face can be fixed with cosmetics, but "lineage—no amount of effort could alter that." Cold. Calculated. And then the moment Evelyn walks in and Isabella instantly transforms into the warm, welcoming mother figure—it's almost impressive how fast she switches masks. One second she's calling Delia a "sly vixen" and the next she's patting Evelyn's hand like they're best friends. But here's what really got me: when Isabella cries over Kallius and calls him her "poor son," I genuinely wonder if she means it. Does she feel real grief, or is this performance art at this point? She says she wants to prevent Kallius from suffering "something even worse," but isn't SHE the one orchestrating all of this? The irony is suffocating. And then—the absolute cherry on top—Delia hides behind a corridor wall and overhears them laughing together. Isabella asking "Do you like the girl?" and Kallius being all vague and dismissive. My stomach dropped. Delia just went through the worst morning of her life over divorce papers and her husband is casually chatting with his replacement like it's a normal Tuesday. I keep coming back to that line about Delia's love feeling like "a scream trapped inside her chest." That's not just poetic—that's a full diagnosis of a relationship where one person is bleeding out and the other doesn't even notice. Or worse, doesn't care.
... Read More
The dialogue in this text does something really specific: it makes Kallius sound completely different before and after the injury, and that's the whole tragedy compressed into speech patterns. Before the attack, his voice is protective and warm: "You need not be afraid." "As long as I am your husband, and you are my wife, there is no reason for you to tremble in fear." Even the flashback line at the funeral — "So weep freely. That your parents may close their eyes in peace." — is gentle, reverent, almost poetic. This is a man who chooses his words carefully and uses them to comfort. After the memory loss, his voice becomes cold and sharp: "I am so dumbfounded I cannot even laugh." "Was I blackmailed? Why would I hold a wedding with a woman I do not even love?" "You look as though you have been betrayed. How laughable." The same man who once knelt beside a crying stranger now twists Delia's chin and mocks her pain. The physical gesture — seizing her chin, twisting his mouth upward — paired with the verbal cruelty creates a voice that's not just harsh but actively dehumanizing. Delia's dialogue is mostly internal monologue and whispered questions, which makes sense for a character who has spent her life being polite to someone who doesn't deserve it. But her few spoken lines carry enormous weight: "Have you… forgotten me?" The ellipsis does so much work there — it's not just hesitation, it's the sound of someone's world breaking in real time. The masked attacker's silence is also worth noting. No dialogue at all — just a dagger and a shove. He's pure plot mechanism, and that anonymity makes him scarier. Sarah's voice is the only other distinct one: warm, practical, grounding. "My lady, you are already doing more than enough." She's the chorus figure, the voice of reason that Delia politely dismisses because hope is stronger than logic when you're in love.
... Read More
'You seem weaker than a child.' He catches her before she falls. Then he wipes his shoulder with a handkerchief like her touch contaminated him. I need to sit with this for a minute. This single gesture—this absolutely tiny, almost casual movement—contains more information about their entire relationship than a thousand pages of exposition. Let me unpack it because I can't stop thinking about it. Kallius just returned from a memory-wiping injury and immediately establishes a boundary. He helps her up because it's what a Duke does, not because he wants to. The coat he gives her afterward? Same thing. It's practical, not romantic. But here's the thing that gets me—the coat smells like him. And Delia wraps herself in it and feels like she's inside his embrace. The author doesn't even need to say 'she missed him.' We feel it. Then there's the handkerchief moment. He wipes his skin. Not dramatically. Not with disgust written across his face. Just... casually. Like dusting off a speck of pollen. That's what makes it hurt so much. If he were openly cruel, we'd understand him. But he's not. He's polite. He's distant. He's doing everything 'correctly' and it devastates her more than any insult could. And Isabella! Oh god, Isabella. She's the kind of villain who wins by being right. She's not some cackling antagonist—she's a mother who genuinely believes she knows what's best for her son. When she says 'You chose the wrong bride,' she means it as concern. That's what makes her so dangerous. She's not wrong about everything—Delia did come from an enemy house. The political reality is real. But the way she delivers it, like Delia is a mistake that needs correcting... The most heartbreaking beat though? Delia saying 'Even if you've lost your memory, I suppose some things don't change' while holding his coat. She's trying to trigger his memories, yes, but she's also acknowledging that the man who used to drape his coat over her is gone. The present Kallius wouldn't believe her. And she knows it.
... Read More
I have been sitting here trying to figure out why Delia's emotions hit me so hard. It's not just the unrequited vibe—it's the sheer desperation wrapped in such quiet dignity. She steps back from the window because her heart is pounding, terrified he saw her spying. Then he comes to her room himself, and instead of comfort, she gets a command: "Come here." And she obeys. Of course she obeys. The power dynamic is so brutal it makes my teeth ache. But then she says, "I will never let you be taken from me." That line. Not a plea, a vow. She's armed with nothing but her own devotion. And when she removes the ring, she's not giving up—she's making a bet. All of it. The text says her heart felt torn into dozens of pieces when he mentions the months with no memories returned. I read that slowly. Twice. Because that's the emotional core of this whole tangled mess: love persisting in the face of evidence that it might be invisible. Kallius, meanwhile, is having his own quiet crisis—he's irritated that her kiss drove away his headaches, that her presence unsettles him. He calls himself cold, rational, yet he keeps watching her. There's this subliminal thread of tension between them, physical and emotional, that the author doesn't spell out but lets hum under every interaction. Delia's love is loud in its silence; Kallius's confusion is quiet in its cruelty. I'm emotionally compromised.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in controlled suffocation. The author doesn't rush anything, but every single scene ramps up the pressure until you can barely breathe by the end. It opens with Delia alone in bed, touching the cold sheets. That's a quiet moment—almost meditative—but it immediately establishes the isolation. Then Sara brings the dress news, which is a tiny spike of warmth before the next hammer fall. The dining room confrontation with Kallius is the first major escalation, and it's written with this relentless forward momentum. Each of his lines lands like a punch, and there's no breathing room between them. But here's what I find fascinating about the pacing: after the Kallius scene, instead of resolving the emotional tension, the author immediately pivots to Isabella. Same pressure, different face. It's like the book is saying 'you thought THAT was bad? Hold my beer.' The transition from Kallius's 'I will never love you' to Isabella walking into Delia's bedroom uninvited is seamless because Delia has no recovery time. She's still shaking from one attack when the next one begins. The chapter structure is essentially three acts of deterioration: Kallius (emotional devastation), Isabella (social humiliation), and then Jeremy's letter (political threat). Each one attacks a different vulnerability, and by the time we reach the end, Delia has been stripped of every possible support system. But the pacing choice I appreciate most is the ending. After all that chaos—the confrontations, the threats, the verbal violence—Delia just sits down and writes a calm, formal reply to her brother. 'I cannot provide details. He is well and merely focused on ducal affairs.' The chapter doesn't end with a breakdown or a dramatic declaration. It ends with composure. That's such a powerful structural choice because it tells us everything about who Delia is. She doesn't have the luxury of falling apart. She just... writes the letter and moves on. The tension here never releases. It compresses. And by the end, it's so dense you could cut it with a knife.
... Read More
Let me just sit with the question Delia faces at the end of this section, because it's the entire novel compressed into one moment. 'Please answer me. Do you truly intend to bring another woman into this house, as she suggested?' She's asking because she needs to know. Not just about the marriage—that's surface level. She's asking because if Kallius truly intends to replace her, then everything she's endured is pointless. The kneeling. The tea. The humiliation in front of his mother. All of it was for nothing if he's ready to move on that easily. But here's what makes the stakes so devastating: Delia already lost everything once. The text tells us her family treated her as expendable. 'A fool cast out by her own family,' Isabella calls her, and it cuts deep because it's not entirely wrong. Delia has no safety net. If she leaves this marriage, she goes back to people who never wanted her. The divorce Isabella threatens isn't a solution—it's an execution. So Delia stays. She takes the tea. She accepts the coldness. She stands against the wall waiting for a husband who treats her like a stranger. And when he offers her his coat—the coat of the man she loved, the coat that smells like him—she wraps herself in it because it's the closest thing to warmth she has. Kallius, meanwhile, has his own stakes. He doesn't remember her, but his body does. He catches her when she falters. He gives her his coat. He gets irritated when she's persistent—not indifferent, irritated. There's a difference. His headaches, his confusion, the hand to his lips when he remembers a kiss he can't place... he's fighting something too. The conflict isn't just external (Isabella, politics, reputation). It's internal. Who is he when he doesn't remember why he loves her? And the biggest stakes of all: what happens when the memories return? Will he remember everything and be able to unsee what he's done to her? Or will the gap between who he was and who he is now create an irreparable distance?
... Read More
There are so many symbols working in these chapters that I keep finding myself circling back to certain images. The wax seal on Delia's letter is everything. She presses her signet into hot wax to close words she may not even fully believe herself. It's a performance of devotion to a man who no longer remembers her, sent to a brother who despises her, through a game orchestrated by her husband. The seal is meant to signify authenticity, but nothing about this exchange is authentic. 'This should be more than enough for him to draw his own conclusions.' Kallius knows the letter is a lie and uses it anyway. The wax becomes a metaphor for the entire marriage—beautiful, rigid, designed to keep things contained, but ultimately artificial. Then there's the sugar cube. Jeremy crushing it in his hand. 'Crack—!' White crystals turning to dust between his fingers. He's doing this while talking about Delia's 'useless luck,' while reconstructing the night their parents died as if she planned it. The sugar cube represents everything fragile about their family—the sweetness that once existed, now pulverized by resentment. He could have left it whole. He chose destruction. The coat Kallius offers Delia at the end is another loaded symbol. 'If you fail to take care of yourself and collapse again, what will the servants think of me?' On the surface it's about appearances. But he's giving her his warmth, his protection, his outer layer. He won't admit he cares, so he frames it as image management. The coat is his way of being tender without having to be honest. And the fading sunlight—'It's already grown dark.' Day turning to night mirrors Delia's situation: she's been operating in the light of hope that her husband might remember her, and now that light is gone. The lamps in the garden are artificial, placed deliberately, casting enough light to navigate but not enough to see clearly. She's learning to walk in this new darkness, one careful step at a time.
... Read More
The wager is the single most dangerous moment in this entire arc and I am SHOOK. Evelyn proposes it so casually, like she's ordering tea, but the stakes are literally Delia's entire existence in this marriage. Three months to win Kallius's heart or she leaves. Or rather — three months and if Evelyn FAILS, she withdraws. Which means if she succeeds, Delia loses everything. What makes this so terrifying is that Delia actually agrees to it. Not with words, but with a nod. She's so exhausted, so defeated, that she can't even bring herself to refuse. The power imbalance is grotesque. Evelyn gets to set the terms, propose the challenge, and Delia just accepts it like she has no choice. Which, honestly, she doesn't. But here's what keeps me up at night — the ending of this section. Kallius looking directly at Delia's window. Did he know she was watching? If he did, then everything changes. Is he letting her see them together as some kind of psychological punishment? Or is there something else going on? Because earlier he told Evelyn plainly that he'll never love his wife, yet he's also not rejecting Evelyn outright. The fact that he permitted this entire situation to unfold while Delia watched from the shadows — that's not indifference. That's something much more complicated and I cannot handle it.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment for Jeffrey Gellern because this man is carrying the entire emotional weight of this chapter on his back and Kallius doesn't even notice. He watches his boss treat a woman who literally refused food and rest while he was dying, and he can't bring himself to say 'you were in love with her.' He says 'Her Grace loves you, Your Grace' like it's a theory he's testing, not a fact. And Kallius shuts him down with 'What nonsense.' Buddy. YOU were there. YOU saw the smiles. The text literally says 'the only moments Kallius ever smiled were when Delia stood before him.' Jeffrey has evidence and he's sitting on it like abomb that could restart this marriage. But here's what I can't stop thinking about—Kallius's line: 'You have stood at my side all these years, and yet you know nothing of that woman?' That's not anger. That's genuine bewilderment. The man who built his identity around knowing everything about his enemies, about his territory, about strategy... can't name the person he shared a bed with for years. That's tragic. That's a man who had love handed to him and didn't realize what it was until it was sliding through his fingers. Delia though—Delia chose silence. She could've told him everything that day. Instead she said 'Let us speak of this later' and walked out. What is she protecting him from? Herself? Their past? The truth that might make him hate her more?
... Read More
I can't stop thinking about Delia's silver hair. It comes up AGAIN in this section — Evelyn specifically calls it out, saying it's something you don't see every day. But what does it actually mean in the story? Silver hair seems to be this marker of Delia's difference, her otherness in a world of normal nobles. It's beautiful but also isolating. Everyone notices it. Everyone comments on it. Even Evelyn uses it as a way to diminish Delia — framing her uniqueness as something exotic rather than just part of who she is. There's also the whole motif of eyes and seeing. Kallius stares at Delia but doesn't really see her. Evelyn examines Delia's face closely, studying her like a specimen. And Delia watches through the window — literally viewing her own life from behind glass, separated from it. The imagery of looking without being seen, of being seen but not understood, runs throughout this entire passage. The biting of lips is another symbol that keeps appearing. Delia bites her lip when she's angry, when she's hurting, when she's trying to hold herself together. It's her body's way of expressing what she won't say out loud. And Kallius noticing it — even in his detached state — feels like the closest thing to intimacy she's had with him in this entire section.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or