I Was Once a Hollow Saint - Reviews

I Was Once a Hollow Saint
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is SO good it actually made me read it twice. Let me just hit the highlights because every single exchange between Tiana and Felix is doing three things at once. First, the opening exchange where Felix asks about the attack and Tiana apologizes: "So that's why he dismissed the servants. I answered his questions as honestly as I could. It would be bad for someone like me, someone from the kingdom, to earn his suspicion by lying to him." That internal narration alongside the dialogue is perfect. She's being honest, yes, but the subtext is clear — she's calculating exactly how much truth to reveal. And Felix? He's reading her like a book but pretending he isn't. Then there's the magic conversation, which is basically the most polite interrogation in literary history: "Is it true that you can use magic?" "I don't know what you've heard about me, but I can use magic, yes." "Is that so? Forgive my impertinence then." "It's fine." Two people who have absolutely NO reason to trust each other, having the most restrained conversation of their lives while their entire relationship is being rebuilt in real time. The tension here is unreal. And then Felix's line: "Just keep in mind that I won't be able to return you home even if you wanted to." WHAT DOES THAT MEAN. Is it a threat? A promise? A confession? The ambiguity IS the point. Every line Felix speaks is layered with at least two meanings, and that's what makes their dynamic so electric. Tiana's final question — "Felix, do you have a woman that you love?" — cuts through all of that calculated politeness like a knife. One moment of raw honesty from her, and the chapter ends on his stunned silence. Perfection.
... Read More
This book starts with multiple layers of conflict stacked on top of each other and it never lets up. On the surface: Tiana is a 'hollow saint' with no magic in a world that worships magic users. That's her personal stake — survival, dignity, basic human treatment. But the political stakes are enormous. The Reavis Empire is called 'the cursed land.' No saints born, demons rising, plagues spreading. They're desperate enough to accept a装饰品 saint and crown her empress. Meanwhile Fallon is using Tiana as diplomatic currency — 'even if the empire is in trouble, it won't affect us.' That's chilling. They're sending someone to die for political gain. Then there's Sylvia's abuse — personal, daily, escalating. The rod that Tiana polished with her failing magic is now just a tool of torture. When Sylvia says 'for the first time you'll be useful to our country. Rejoice!' — that's not just cruel, it's the moment Tiana's entire world collapses. But the BIGGEST conflict is the one that changes everything. That scream at the end of Chapter 3. 'I don't want to die in a place like this.' It's not just Tiana fighting for her life — it's Else Reese fighting back through whatever mechanism brought her back. The stakes just went from 'will this girl survive an assassination' to 'what happens when a legendary saintess wakes up inside a hollow shell?' I am physically incapable of not turning the page.
... Read More
Can we talk about how distinct everyone's voice is? Because it's actually impressive. Felix in the prologue is all clipped and controlled. 'I see.' 'Yes, I am, and I'm serious about it.' Even when Byron is losing his mind, Felix stays cool. His dialogue is sparse but weighted — every word carries authority. And then that line 'Till the end of my days, I shall only love Else Reese' which is formal almost to the point of archaic. It tells you he's a man who doesn't speak lightly. Byron is the opposite — all frustration and clenched hands and sharp questions. 'You really don't need to worry about that' is Felix deflecting, but Byron keeps pushing. Their dynamic reads like a real friendship where one person cares too much. Tiana's internal voice is its own thing entirely. So many ellipses, so many apologies, so many parentheses of self-loathing. 'I am helpless and weak, I can only apologize, I can only endure in this way.' Her thoughts aren't declarations — they're submissions. But then in Chapter 3 when the sword is at her throat: '[I don't want to die in a place like this…!]' — that exclamation mark! That's the first time her inner voice has RAISED ITS VOICE and it hit different. Sylvia's dialogue is pure venom wrapped in polite laughter. 'fufufu' and 'our Tiana here' — she talks about Tiana like she's not even a person. And Marielle? Her kindness sounds genuine, not performative. 'Please don't apologize. And you don't have to use honorifics with me.' Small choice of words that makes her feel like a real human being in a story full of people who treat Tiana like furniture.
... Read More
"I won't return to that country even if you ask me to." I keep coming back to this line. It's so simple. So quiet. But it's the moment that changes absolutely everything between these two characters. Up until this point, their relationship has been defined by power imbalances and political necessity. She's the pawn. He's the player. She's the pretend saint. He's the suspicious emperor. There's a contract, there are terms, there are obligations. But none of that matters anymore because Tiana just looked him in the eye and chose HIM. Not because she has to. Because she wants to. And Felix's reaction — that strange, almost cruel line about not being able to send her back — it's not cruel at all. I swear to you it's not. It's the closest thing to vulnerability this man will ever show. He's saying: "Don't you dare leave me." But he can't say that directly, so he wraps it in a threat. The emotional arc of this entire chapter is Tiana going from someone who sees herself as disposable — "Tiana must've really been discarded as a pawn" — to someone who realizes she has agency. She's not being sent to the empire as a sacrifice. She's choosing to stay. The empire isn't her prison. It's her sanctuary. And Felix? He's the guy who's been surrounded by politics his entire life, who can't trust anyone, who has to calculate every word — and suddenly this girl he barely knows looks at him and says, essentially, "I'm yours, and I'm staying." The fact that the chapter ends with her asking if he loves someone else? That's not random. That's a girl who just realized she has nothing to lose, asking the one question that could change everything. And I am emotionally compromised.
... Read More
Let me just say — the author knows how to paint a room and make you FEEL it. Chapter 1 opens with Tiana on her knees on a COLD floor. Not just cold, chilly. The temperature of the room itself seems designed to punish her. And Sylvia's red lips arched in a smile that Tiana has NEVER seen directed at her. That single detail — the unsmiling saintess — tells you everything about their fifteen-year relationship without a single exposition dump. Then there's the contrast when Tiana leaves the temple and sees the outside world for the first time: 'beautiful fields of flowers and buildings spread out all around me.' Everything was 'new and sparkly.' She'd never traveled because she was useless. The world literally didn't include her. And you can feel her trying to memorize it because she knows it might be her last chance. The carriage scene is gorgeous too — not just the scenery, but the inn food making her 'cheeks almost fall off' compared to leftovers at the temple. Small sensory details that make the world feel REAL. And then BAM — ambush in the forest, swords colliding, blood spreading on the carriage floor. The shift from wonder to terror in three paragraphs is masterful. That sword tip at her neck, the icy awareness of 'death' — I genuinely held my breath.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this ONE moment from the prologue because it completely wrecked me. Felix touching that scarred rod and saying 'Till the end of my days, I shall only love Else Reese.' That's it. That's the tweet. seventeen years and he's STILL devoted to his dead wife?? Meanwhile Tiana is over there getting stepped on by heels and treated like garbage and I was already team Tiana but now I'm also deeply invested in Felix's emotional availability. And then Chapter 2 has this soft little moment with Marielle-san where she touches Tiana's cheek and says she's beautiful. Tiana's entire world is abuse and neglect, so kindness literally confuses her. She kept apologizing for existing and felt guilty just EATING food. I wanted to shake her and also hug her at the same time. The CP tension hasn't even properly started yet and I'm already emotional. Felix is mourning while Tiana is surviving, and somehow these two broken people are heading toward each other. Also Marielle saying 'I think our citizens will be very happy if you become our empress' — Tiana's entire personality shattered into a million pieces and I love it here.
... Read More
What is WRONG with this author's pacing because I CANNOT STOP READING. Let me break down why this works so well. Chapter 1 establishes Tiana's hell — daily abuse, zero power, trapped. We know her stakes immediately. Then Chapter 2 is essentially a palate cleanser: four days of travel, nice food, gentle Marielle-san, pretty flowers. It's almost TOO nice. And that's the trap, isn't it? The author lets you relax right before the knife comes out. I was enjoying those inn stops and fruit snacks and thinking 'aww this is sweet' and then Chapter 3 hits like a freight train. The ambush doesn't even give you time to process the empress revelation before swords are at your throat. Cabman shouting, knights fighting, blood on the carriage floor — all within a handful of paragraphs. And that ending... 'an unfamiliar memory poured into my mind.' The cliffhanger isn't just 'will she survive' but 'WHO IS SHE?' The reincarnation reveal in Chapter 4 lands perfectly because we've spent three chapters believing Tiana is helpless, making the transition to 'Yes, I am Else... the Great Saintess' hit like a thunderclap. This book understands that tension needs breathing room. The sweet interlude makes the violence hurt more.
... Read More
The atmospheric shift between these two parts of the chapter is honestly chef's kiss. We go from grim political intrigue in a dim study room — cursed lakes, miasma, monsters, captured men under spells — to a sunlit dining room where Tiana is getting dressed in mint green and people are calling her a goddess. The Nightly Lake description alone is worth the read: "It turned black and muddy, spawning miasma and a swarm of monsters that slaughtered animals and plants." This isn't just some aesthetic curse. This is ecological horror. The land itself is dying. And then it's purified overnight, completely restored. The contrast between that image and the beauty of the clean lake now is almost painful. And then — mint green ribbon. Mint green dress. Maids saying she looks like a goddess. The luxurious breakfast. The cut fruits for dessert. Tiana going from someone who used to wash her face with well water to someone surrounded by silk and silverware, and the way the narrative treats this is so understated it almost hurts. She just... notices it. "When was the last time I had such a peaceful morning?" The worldbuilding here is doing heavy lifting without ever feeling like infodumps. The empire has four other cursed areas. There's a Great Saint position. Political marriages between kingdoms. Knights who praise Tiana without knowing the truth. The contract system governing her duties. It all just... exists, woven naturally into the scenes, and somehow makes the world feel huge and lived-in without ever stopping the story to explain itself. The visual contrast between the dark, rotting lake and the bright, mint-green-clad empress-to-be is basically the thesis statement of this entire novel. Darkness purified. Incompetence revealed as power. Sacrifice mistaken for weakness. I'm obsessed.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that's been driving me absolutely nuts this entire arc — Nightly Lake got purified, everyone is crediting Saint Tiana for the miracle, but the narrator (Felix, obviously) has this internal monologue that just shatters the whole official narrative: "Meanwhile, that said incompetent saint was about to be killed at the time." Let me just sit with that for a second. The "incompetent" saint who couldn't even cast a basic spell was out there being hunted down and nearly killed — and the lake got purified at the exact same time? Felix is clearly connecting dots that don't match the official story, and he's NOT wrong. Someone used Tiana as a scapegoat for something she didn't do, and the Fallon Kingdom knew exactly what they were signing up for. This is such a clever plot thread because it does double duty — it's simultaneously advancing the conspiracy against Tiana while also being the key to understanding what she's truly capable of. The curse in this country isn't just background worldbuilding; it's the ticking clock. Four cursed areas. One purified lake. And Tiana walking right into the middle of it all as a pretend saint who might actually be the real deal. And then — get this — Felix lets her off the hook after she admits she can use magic. "Even if I can use some magic, Felix has promised not to ask for anything more than what's written on the contract." Like he's giving her space to figure things out on her own. Which makes his final question at the end hit even harder, because suddenly all this political maneuvering gets personal in a way I didn't expect. Who purified the lake? What happened to Tiana's original powers? And why does Felix seem to be protecting her without letting her know he's doing it?
... Read More
I need to talk about how this chapter is structured because the pacing is absolutely ruthless in the best possible way. It starts in media res with political tension — captured men, curses, conspiracy — and within a few paragraphs we've established the central mystery (did Tiana really purify the lake?). Then it transitions to the next morning, which could've been a boring "wake up and get ready" scene, but instead becomes the emotional core of the entire chapter. The breakfast scene alone does MORE narrative work than most full chapters. Felix dismisses the servants. They talk about the attack. He asks about the magic. She asks for library access. He gives it to her with a cryptic warning. She reveals she won't go back. And then — boom — the love question. All in one meal. ONE MEAL. What I love most is how the author uses time compression. We literally hear "time flew by as I listened to my future schedule" and then we're suddenly at dessert. The wedding gown, the ball in two weeks, the etiquette lessons — all summarized in a few lines that still make the pressure feel real. We're not given the luxury of dwelling on any single moment, and that urgency mirrors exactly how Tiana must feel: everything is happening too fast, and she's barely keeping up. The chapter ends on a question mark that isn't even answered before the next one begins. Felix's reaction to "Do you have a woman that you love?" — we get NOTHING. Just his stunned silence. And I am NOT OKAY with this. This is the kind of pacing that makes you immediately open the next chapter and forget to sleep.
... Read More
Can we just talk about Felix for a moment because this man is doing the emotional equivalent of a controlled demolition and I am HERE FOR IT. The scene where he dismisses ALL the servants just to talk to her alone? That's not just political caution. That's someone who needs to hear the truth without an audience. And then he asks her point-blank about the magic. No softening it. No beating around the bush. Just: "Is it true that you can use magic?" And Tiana's internal reaction says everything — she's SURPRISED he asked directly. She's braced herself for judgment and instead gets... nothing but quiet acceptance. "Forgive my impertinence then." "It's fine." And then he backs off because he SENSED she didn't want to go into detail. That kind of emotional calibration is not something most people manage, let alone a ruler dealing with a political hostage situation. But then — and this is the part that wrecked me — he follows it up with: "Just keep in mind that I won't be able to return you home even if you wanted to." What. A. Line. Is he threatening her? Is he confessing? Is he trying to sound cruel and failing because underneath it all he's genuinely worried about her? I swear Felix has never once said anything straightforward in his entire life and I need answers. And then Tiana drops this bombshell of her own: "I won't return to that country even if you ask me to." She's choosing him. Not because she's coerced, not because it's in the contract — but because she genuinely doesn't want to go back to the people who threw her away. That's a character moment that recontextualizes their entire dynamic. She's not his prisoner. She never was. Also side note: the way Byron acts like he's about to spit when Tiana's name comes up? Love to see the supporting cast having opinions.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or