I Was Forced to Become a Regretful Villainess - Reviews

I Was Forced to Become a Regretful Villainess
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the wretched curse because it's everywhere and nowhere at the same time. It doesn't appear in this chapter as a dramatic threat or a ticking clock. It's not some monster under the bed. Instead, it's the shadow behind every choice Adelaide makes. She was thrown out at seventeen. She survived ten years of hardship. She came back with this curse attached to her. The Duke is furious because a scandal involving the Crown Prince could unravel everything. Cyril is visiting in disguise because the political landscape is so fragile that even a private meeting requires secrecy. "I share some responsibility for wandering through the riding grounds without permission." Adelaide says this line but her tone tells you she's already calculated the damage. She knows exactly what kind of trouble she's in. The Duke's leg bouncing nervously, Benjamin subtly offering nerve tonic, the whispered conversation about not minding His Majesty's hypothetical decapitation—this is all the author showing us stakes without ever raising the stakes explicitly. The riding accident is the perfect physical manifestation of Adelaide's situation. She's moving fast, trying to assert control, and someone she doesn't fully trust appears out of nowhere. She could have been killed. She COULD have killed someone. And yet the person who saves her is also the person whose presence threatens to destroy her family's carefully maintained position. Cyril catches her mid-fall—literally and figuratively. What makes this chapter so tense isn't that anything catastrophic happens. It's that everything feels like it COULD. Adelaide's past exile, her mysterious curse, her father's volatile temper, the Crown Prince's complicated position—every character is walking a tightrope. The Duke's allergy to flattery isn't just a joke, it's a survival mechanism in a court where honesty gets you killed. And Cyril's whispered admission at the end—"I think we'll get along"—is both a promise and a warning. Someone who can joke about regicide and genuinely mean it as a bonding gesture? That's not romance. That's alliance. And alliances in this world come with conditions.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how Adelaide is literally the worst at hiding her soft spot?? Like the entire chapter is just her saying one thing and doing another and I'm wheezing. She spends the whole scene berating Lionel — "You're filthy!" "You smell!" "Go back!" — meanwhile she's smoothing his hair, feeding him peppermint candy, wrapping his wounds with her own petticoat, retying his cravat, spraying perfume on him, ALL while claiming she went out there specifically to throw him out. And then when he quietly says "I dislike you so much that I tried to drive you away" — she's the one redoing his tie like nothing happened. The line that destroyed me was: "My lady... it's hard to take that seriously when you're retying my cravat..." Adelaide is trying SO hard to be mean and her body just won't cooperate because this cursed seventeen-year-old vessel has its own agenda. Meanwhile Lionel is over here looking at her with those shining eyes like she's some kind of saint. The misunderstanding is so thick you could cut it with a knife and he just keeps eating it up. And Amy! Poor Amy spreading "you're actually a kind person" rumors everywhere. Adelaide wants to murder her but also honestly? Yeah. That's kind of true. The strawberry comment had me dying too. "Your hair looks like a strawberry. It's pretty." Adelaide's entire face must have short-circuited. She's too busy being offended by the fruit comparison to process that he just called her pretty. I'm not okay. This is the good stuff. The tension is immaculate.
... Read More
I need to talk about Duke Berthier because this man is the single most emotionally destructive force in this entire story and he barely does anything. Think about it. He brings home an illegitimate child and declares him his heir. Not because he loves the boy. Not because it's wise. Just... because. And that one decision rips apart his own family, destroys the empire, kills the mage's friends, and dooms Cyril to a lifetime of abuse. The emperor, meanwhile, is this terrifying portrait of cold cruelty—he marries a woman from a weak family specifically because he doesn't want noise, tells her to raise another man's bastard as crown prince, and when she begs, he shuts her down with two sentences. 'You talk too much. I chose you because I dislike noise.' That's it. That's the most chilling line I've read in forever. The empress's silent suffering while she raises a child who isn't hers, while the emperor watches, is some of the most painful imagery in these chapters. And Cyril—poor, scarred Cyril, who accepts his own destruction with this quiet resignation. 'My life is finished either way. Even if Albert does not wish it, the empress and Marquis Ferithid will not be able to stop themselves from killing me.' He's not afraid. He's just... tired. And the mage's desperation at Adelaide's grave—kneeling in the rain, bones aching, one final spell left—she's mourning everyone she ever loved and there's nothing left to lose except hope. The emotional core of this story isn't romance. It's the devastating weight of family betrayal. Every parent figure in this book is either absent, cruel, or using someone. The one genuine moment of tenderness is Albert, Cyril's half-brother, who genuinely tries to bridge the gap between Cyril and the empress and only makes things worse because the empress despises him for it. Nobody wins here. That's what makes it hurt so good.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment for the kitchen scene because the atmospheric writing in that entire passage is *chef's kiss*? Let me paint it for you: dark house, everyone asleep, Adelaide creeping through like some haunted noblewoman, moonlight pouring through the windows like it's in a period drama, and she's bargaining with her own stomach like it's a separate rebellious organism. "You're nothing but a stomach trapped inside my body." — I'm not okay. The personification of her hunger as this defiant little creature grumbling back at her is both hilarious and vividly sensory. You can hear it. Grumble. Grumble. GRUMBLE GRUMBLE GRUMBLE. It's everywhere. And then the kitchen itself—spotless,月光 through the windows, the secret stash of bread hidden INSIDE THE STOVE. Who hides bread in a stove? Nobody normal, that's who. But Lionel knows because he's lived like this. The contrast between Adelaide's world (cupboards full of useless silverware, no idea where food lives) and Lionel's world (knows exactly where the staff hides their secret snacks) tells you everything about these two characters without a single exposition dump. The line about Lionel's eyes being "like a frozen lake" in the moonlight? That's the kind of description that stops you mid-scroll. Cold. Clear. Dangerous but beautiful. Perfect.
... Read More
"I have eyes. I don't see why I should keep them closed." That line. That is the entire thesis of Adelaide's character voice in one sentence. Sharp, defiant, literally about vision and perception, and delivered with zero hesitation. This woman has had ten years of poverty-hardened snark and she is NOT leaving it at the gate. The dialogue in this chapter is phenomenal because everyone sounds completely distinct. Adelaide's voice is quick, cutting, layered with sarcasm that masks genuine hurt. When she tells the footman "I thought only your face was oiled up, but your tongue is just as well-greased. Don't speak to me without permission from now on. You turn my stomach."—that's not just mean. That's precise. She's weaponizing politeness against someone who uses politeness as a tool of control. Classic Adelaide. Amy's dialogue is the perfect counterweight. "Oh, I got carried away. I'm sorry. Is this better?" "You're so funny, my lady. That was a joke, wasn't it?" She speaks in questions and exclamation points, always slightly out of step, always recovering from her own momentum. It's endearing and slightly exhausting and I can totally see why Adelaide warns her: "I'm saying don't let your guard down and go around grinning just because someone was decent to you once or twice." Duke Berthier appears for literally two minutes and his dialogue is iconic. "Adelaide Charlotte Berthier!" —using her full name like a weapon. "How dare you look me in the eye and talk back!" The privilege in his voice, the entitlement, the sheer inability to comprehend that his daughter is a person with opinions—he's perfectly drawn in just a few lines. And the narration itself has this wonderful voice that sometimes breaks into Adelaide's internal monologue with single quotes: 'I have to hold myself together if I'm going to put Lionel in his place.' It's immediate, it's raw, and it creates this intimate distance between the narrator and the character that makes every thought feel earned. The author's voice overall is dry, observant, and unafraid of letting silence do work. When Adelaide shouts at the empty air and gets no answer? That silence speaks volumes.
... Read More
Violet gifting Adelaide a dragon is probably one of the most emotionally perfect moments I've read recently. Think about it—Violet remembered Adelaide saying she wanted a dragon as a kid. She went through her cousin who knows a mage at the mage tower who happened to have a baby dragon. And Adelaide's response is just... she reaches through the bars and the baby dragon rubs its face against her fingers and she whispers 'So adorable I could eat it up.' I swear to god if this isn't the moment that broke the curse I don't know what is. The text literally says 'After receiving nothing but cheap ribbons, cubic zirconia, and pebbles, getting a dragon felt like floating on air.' And then Adelaide says the most important words in the entire chapter: 'Let's bathe.' She initiates it. She, who was trying to set boundaries, says yes to the thing she'd been resisting. And Violet throws herself at Adelaide and Adelaide catches her while still staring at the dragon. This is friendship at its most raw and joyful and I am not okay. The cursed touch—Adelaide couldn't help but accept gifts, couldn't throw things away—and yet this dragon gift feels earned, genuine, something that wasn't forced by magic. Or maybe it IS, and that's what makes it even more beautiful.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lionel because OH MY GOD. This boy. He's been here a WEEK and already I am completely, utterly ruined for him. Let me just say: the kitchen scene. The absolute kitchen scene. Adelaide storms in looking like a vengeful ghost at midnight, finds HIM also raiding the kitchen like some tragic stray cat, and he hands her HALF HIS BREAD. Not because he has extra. Because he found it and immediately thought of her. And then—he keeps breaking off pieces of his own tiny portion and giving them to her until his is basically crumbs, and she keeps refusing and then accepting and then refusing again and I was literally screaming into my pillow. But the real gut punch? When he starts crying after she yells at him about his nosebleed? Not because he's hurt. Because she was so cruel to him even while being kind. He says 'because my lady is, so, truly so, so kind to me' and then HICCOUPS through it. And I—I can't. He's so broken and so soft and he looks at her like she hung the moon when all she's doing is trying not to murder him with her eyes. The fact that she's physically incapable of being mean to him without the curse hijacking her body? That's not just comedic. That's genuinely heartbreaking when you think about it. She WANTS to be mean. She has every reason to be mean. But her body betrays her every.single.time. And he just... accepts it. Takes it. Thinks it's real kindness. And maybe a part of her believes it too, which is the whole tragedy, isn't it?
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about how the author handles pacing here because honestly it's sneaky. You've got this massive setup—Adelaide's going riding, Amy insists on coming along, they walk across the supposedly vast Berthier estate grounds—and on paper this is all dead air. Nothing happens. No drama, no reveals, no stakes. And yet I was glued to it. Why? Because the author uses the walk as a pressure-release valve between scenes. Adelaide had just dealt with the emotional fallout of yesterday's party, today's morning confrontation, the headache of preparing to meet the Crown Prince... and then BOOM, she's on a horse at full gallop chasing Cherry down the track. The walk is the calm before the storm. It's the author giving us air to breathe before dropping the pacing into overdrive. Then watch what happens once they hit the stables: CHERRY IS SULking, Adelaide snaps at a horse, tells it to be grateful for its free hay—immediately establishes her personality without a single narrator explanation. The stable hand delivers exposition about Cherry being excited through action. The riding course description? Brief but vivid, layered with history about the late Duchess, then immediately we're in motion. The accident itself? One paragraph of setup—"A gleaming head of hair appeared out of nowhere"—and then it's chaos. Adelaide's internal monologue: "I've never actually killed anyone before!" The throw, the catch, the safety—done in three sentences. The author doesn't linger on the physics or the danger for dramatic effect. They move FAST because that's what falling off a horse actually feels like. Everything happens in real time. And then immediately after the adrenaline dump? Quiet drawing room scene. Tea. Polite conversation that reads like a chess match. The Duke drinking nerve tonic. This ebb and flow—high energy, explosion, then deliberate calm—is exactly why I couldn't put the book down. The author understands that exhaustion is a pacing tool. We need to catch our breath so the next surge hits harder.
... Read More
"Tell them to move the buttons to the front on a few of them." This sentence hit me harder than I expected. Adelaide is asking for a structural change to women's clothing—not for convenience as a luxury, but as practical necessity. She refuses to stand frozen like a cloth doll while someone dresses her, unable to act independently. In a world where every noblewoman is bound by layers of silk and expectation, she's literally redesigning the bindings. The corset conversation is equally loaded. Amy asks whether she should wear one to meet the Crown Prince. Adelaide says no. Not because she doesn't care about propriety, but because a corset would make her feel suffocated. This is the same woman who was thrown out of her home at seventeen, survived ten years of hardship, and returned carrying a wretched curse that threatens to undo everything. She will not voluntarily tighten another constraint around her ribs. Then there's the handkerchief. Cyril keeps the blood-stained one tied around his leg as proof of the accident. When Adelaide offers to replace it, he pushes back—not because he needs it, but because the gesture itself matters. In this world, handkerchiefs are tokens, offerings, symbols of connection between people who don't yet have words for what they're feeling. His refusal of her replacement and her eventual acceptance of his gift isn't about fabric. It's about the unspoken contract forming between them. The riding itself is another loaded symbol. Riding is freedom, movement, control over one's own body and direction. Adelaide has spent most of this narrative being acted upon—exiled, cursed, manipulated, rescued. The horse is the one place where SHE is in charge. Where SHE decides when to gallop, when to jump, when to pull hard on the reins. Even the accident is hers—she chooses to ride, she chooses to chase Cherry, she chooses to face Amy's fear head-on. Everything around her is imposed; the ride is the one thing she claims. And the button placement request? That's Adelaide telling the world, in the quietest possible way: I will not be dressed for appearances. I will dress myself.
... Read More
I need to appreciate how the author uses pacing across these chapters because the structure is SCULPTED. You start with the Violet meet-cute that's chaotic and funny and slightly uncomfortable (the bathing thing, the table flip), then you get the fallout where Adelaide wants to leave but Violet's already spreading goodwill, which leads to the invitation avalanche. THEN you get Duke Berthier at the dinner table—which is where the real dramatic tension lives for this whole book—and the Crown Prince invitation drops like a bomb. And the LAST beat? A baby dragon that chooses Adelaide as its owner. That's chapter escalation at its finest. The breakfast scene with Duke Berthier is where the pacing really shows its teeth though. 'Farmers in the field' → 'Is there some rule that only farmers in the field talk during meals?' → BAM, conversation over. Duke Berthier's entire monologue about his youth gets dismissed in three lines and then he has to cool his 'burning curiosity with a glass of cold water.' The author knows exactly when to end scenes for maximum impact. Violet's visit starts with Adelaide's internal migraine and ends with a dragon and a 'yes, let's bathe.' That's the kind of character journey that makes pacing matter—every scene moves the emotional needle forward. No filler. Just momentum.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment for Amy? Like, when did THIS version of Amy become a thing? Remember earlier when she was just your typical devoted maid who existed solely to serve Adelaide? Yeah, gone. Poof. Instead we get this absolute unit who refuses to back down, literally charges into fear head-on, and then argues WITH Adelaide about whether she should ride too. "I don't even know yet whether I'll be scared or not. I have to face it head-on and overcome it." That line absolutely made me stop scrolling. This is the kind of character growth that sneaks up on you. And then the whole head-patting system between Adelaide and her companions? Chef's kiss. Adelaide explicitly says Lionel gets patted because he's shameless enough to ask, while Amy doesn't have that nerve. Then Adelaide weaponizes that knowledge by dangling daily head pats as a reward for compliance. Is it manipulative? Sure. But it's also kind of tender in its own twisted way, right? Like, she IS paying attention to who needs what kind of affection. Then there's the moment with the Duke and the corset—"If you keep enjoying talking back the way you do, I might fire you." Amy's immediate pout though, the fact that Adelaide notices it and backs off? These tiny beats tell you SO much about their relationship. It's not a master-servant thing anymore. It's something messier and warmer. Oh and the Adelaide-Cyril dynamic? So complicated. He catches her mid-fall, they exchange polite apologies that are basically verbal swords clashing, and then he leans in close enough that she can see himself in his eyes. The whispered line about not being fond of His Majesty either, but still feeling unsettled if his head were to fall off? Adelaide's response—"I think we'll get along"—hitting different. They're both people who survive by being honest in a world that rewards performance. No wonder they click.
... Read More
What gets me about this chapter is the layered conflict. On the surface, it's a comedic misunderstanding romance. But underneath? Adelaide is in genuine danger and doesn't fully understand it yet. Let's talk about the external stakes first. She's seventeen, she's been cursed into this body, and she knows — from her past life — that this is THE year everything falls apart. Lionel appears, she's told to make him the next Duke, she pushes him down the stairs, she gets expelled. She knows the script. And now she's trying to rewrite it, but her body keeps sabotaging her plan. The basting pins on her back aren't just a cute injury — they're evidence that someone in this house is actively hurting her. The Duke's rage, the household rules, the fact that she collapsed from physical pain combined with the curse taking its toll. She's physically fragile in a world that punishes weakness. Every step she takes could be her last in terms of social standing. But the INTERNAL conflict is where it really hits. Adelaide is a twenty-seven-year-old woman trapped in a girl's body that has its own instincts and impulses. Her hand smooths Lionel's hair while her mouth calls him filthy. She offers her pinky to Amy while complaining about promises. She claims she dislikes Lionel desperately but keeps doing kind things. Who is she even when her body betrays her thoughts? And that voice in the fog — "I'll give you your past life back. Try living differently." What does that mean? Is she being given a chance or a punishment? The stakes keep rising because we don't know what the curse truly wants from her. The blood on her back, the worsening injuries, the fact that she can barely walk without collapsing — her body is failing her in real time. And through all of this, she's supposed to outsmart everyone, change her fate, and protect herself from a household that's actively hostile. No wonder she's exhausted. The suspense here isn't just "what happens next" — it's "can she even survive long enough to change anything?" And that's terrifying in the best way.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or