Okay so I need to talk about Alexion because this chapter completely flipped how I see him. Before reading this, I thought he was just your typical possessive alpha guy, right? But no. This scene? This is something way more complicated.
The line that got me was when he said "If you're thinking of running away from me, you'd better give up, Erna." That's not just lust talking - that's pure terror underneath all that aggression. He's terrified she's going to leave him, and instead of being vulnerable about it, he does THIS. He physically takes what he wants because apparently that's the only language he knows for "please stay."
And here's what actually made me sit with this for a bit - when Erna is lying there and her mind wanders to the fact that she "didn't belong to this world" and "someday she would have to return"... Alexion literally sees her face change. He asks "What are you thinking about?" like he has this instinctual awareness that she's mentally somewhere else. That's not a monster, people. That's someone who's deeply afraid of losing her.
The dynamic between them is so messy. He calls her "unseemly" and makes these crude comments, but then he also gently strokes her hair and tells her to breathe through the pain. He violates her boundaries but stays hyper-aware of her discomfort. It's not healthy - I'm not saying it is - but it's also not one-note villain energy. The author is showing us a man who wants to be good for her but literally doesn't know how to want anything without it turning into possession.
And Erna? She's complicated too. She could have said no earlier and clearly knows she could have. But she doesn't. And afterwards she's sitting alone thinking about how much she's gained in this world - the family, the friends, the people who cherish her. Like she's already planning her exit. She's using him even as he's using her, emotionally speaking. They're both trapped in this awful loop where neither can just... be honest.
I keep thinking about that line: "Her appearance, disheveled messily from pleasure, was maddeningly lovely." He's captivated by her. Not just her body - though that's part of it - but the way she falls apart. There's love in there somewhere, I think. Buried under all the desperation and entitlement. Or maybe the desperation IS the love, just twisted. Either way, I'm not mad at Alexion. I'm scared FOR Erna.