I Thought It Was Okay to Abandon You Back Then - Reviews

I Thought It Was Okay to Abandon You Back Then
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The worldbuilding in these chapters is the kind that sneaks up on you. It doesn't dump exposition on your head—it just slips details into scenes like they're nothing, and then later you realize the author has built an entire society and you didn't even notice constructing it. The opening fight scene is set in this space that feels both brutal and controlled—stone floors, the sound of flesh hitting flesh, Matteo vomiting blood and teeth into what the narration specifically calls a "bright red foamy lump." The visceral details are doing heavy lifting here. You can HEAR the spit, SEE the teeth in the vomit, FEEL the damp stone under Adeline's bare foot when she realizes her shoe came off. The author doesn't need a paragraph of description—the sensory hits do the work. Then there's the school itself: "Ehrenroth Royal Advanced Academy where Kailen and Matteo were enrolled was the most prestigious higher education institution across the entire Arcadia Continent, a kind of genius training ground." One sentence. That's it. But it tells us everything—elite, continental scope, a pressure cooker for gifted kids from the highest social classes. And then immediately: "a small number of nouveau riche offspring and commoner scholarship students definitely existed." The class tension is baked into the world's DNA. The detail about the academy rules mandating respectful speech regardless of status, while an "invisible wall" of elitism exists underneath—that's such a specific, realistic touch. It mirrors how actual elite institutions work. The text even has Adeline noting that even HER gentle nature occasionally lets that consciousness slip, and she has to actively restrain herself. That's worldbuilding through character behavior, not infodumps. And the physical geography—the conservatory path where Belliche disappears, the dormitory, the lecture halls, the way Therese follows Adeline through thinning crowds to whisper secrets—this is a place you could navigate. It has rooms, corridors, hidden corners where conversations happen out of sight. The world feels lived-in. The scene of Adeline alone in her room with an ice pack, then Therese bursting in, then the long night of whispered curses about Matteo—domestic intimacy layered over political danger. That contrast is where this book's atmosphere really lives.
... Read More
What got me in this batch isn't the explicit content—it's the aftermath. The quiet, devastating aftermath. Adeline draws a boundary in the bathwater. She practices her words. She gets dressed. She sits across from him in morning light and asks for consideration. And he basically agrees with her and then stops listening. That's the conflict, isn't it? Not a dramatic fight. Not a shouting match. Just... dismissal wrapped in a nod. The stakes here are so intimate they're almost invisible. This isn't about life or death. It's about whether Adeline gets to exist as a person inside her own marriage. Whether her comfort matters. Whether she can say "that hurt me" and have it registered as evidence rather than inconvenience. And the novel makes you feel the crushing weight of each unanswered question because it doesn't resolve any of them. What also terrifies me is how small Adeline's requests are. She's not asking for freedom. She's not asking to leave. She's asking him to tell her when he'll be late so she doesn't fall asleep waiting. That's it. That's the entire ask. And even that feels like too much to request. The fact that the novel presents this as a dramatic confrontation rather than a reasonable expectation is exactly what makes the conflict so suffocating. She's negotiating for basic human decency and it still feels like she's begging.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes, because this batch is CRAMMED with them and they keep escalating. On the surface: a girl gets assaulted by her fiancé, another girl gets dragged into it, and a transfer student beats the fiancé half to death. That's already a lot. But the author doesn't stop there—no no no. The stakes multiply like it's a horror movie. Matteo's father—the Duke himself—wants to kill his own son. Not metaphorically. The text is explicit: "Since I sired you, I should collect you with my own hands! Something like you has no value in living." This isn't a disgruntled parent. This is a man who will literally murder his child to protect family honor. And then he does the practical thing: sends a representative to beg forgiveness while apparently plotting his son's half-death. The Duke is both a father and a politician, and both sides are terrifying. Adeline's letter to the Duke raises the stakes even higher. She's not just defending herself—she's issuing a threat. "If even a single disadvantage befalls" Belliche or his family, she'll go public with every detail of Matteo's abuse. This is a woman holding nuclear options and she's calm about it. The fact that she wrote this letter from her dorm bed, pen in hand, forehead furrowed, chewing the tip—that domestic image against the political weapon she's crafting is such good writing. But then the ground shifts again. Therese reveals the Belliche family funds the academy. So whose side is the school actually on? Is Adeline's letter going to land, or will money override justice? The stakes just got muddier and I loved every second of it. And the suspense! The text literally has Belliche walking away mid-sentence, leaving Adeline frozen. "Left alone in an instant, Adeline stood there dazed for a moment." What is his endgame? What does HE want from all this? The author withholds answers the way a cat plays with a mouse and I am SO DONE (in the best way). "There are limits to smearing sh*t on your father's face!" — the Duke. The man literally has a list of grievances against his own son.
... Read More
I need to scream about Mrs. Lien. This woman is the quiet tragedy of the entire story and nobody seems to notice. So Dr. Lemon shows up with this brown bottle — no label, no explanation needed — and tells Mrs. Lien it's contraceptive. Mixed into food or tea, once a day. Lord Belliche's instruction. Don't tell the Countess. And Mrs. Lien just... stands there. Processing. The text literally says she was "somewhat confused about what to ask or how." Then she goes to Adeline's room and drops two drops into her tea while Adeline is smiling at her like a golden retriever. "Having you by my side is truly a great support." Do you hear this woman's soul leaving her body with every gulp? One sip, then another. Each swallowing sound making Mrs. Lien's anxiety spike. And yet she maintains her composure perfectly. "Have sweet dreams, madam." What kills me is that Mrs. Lien isn't even a villain here. She genuinely tries to comfort Adeline: "these days he comes home without fail even if late" — as if that small detail will make the loneliness bearable. She tells Adeline not to be disheartened. She knows exactly how pathetic this all looks from the outside and she's still the one pouring the poisoned tea. The stakes here are insane because everyone in this mansion is playing a role. Kailen is playing the absent husband who occasionally storms into bedrooms. Dr. Lemon is playing the dutiful physician delivering orders he didn't create. Mrs. Lien is playing the loyal servant executing something she morally opposes. And Adeline? She's playing the devoted wife who has no idea her devotion is being weaponized against her. Who actually wins here? Nobody. But Adeline loses the most because she doesn't even know the game is being played.
... Read More
I need to talk about the visual composition of this chapter because the author is a CINEMATIC DIRECTOR and I am here for it. The very first image that stuck with me is Adeline standing behind a linden tree blooming with pale yellow flowers, hiding from the gossip she's accidentally overhearing. Think about that framing: she's literally half-hidden behind a flowering tree, watching people discuss her future like she's an object being appraised. The yellow flowers against her concealed figure—it's almost poetic in how cruel it is. And then there's the outfit contrast scene, which I've read three times now and it just keeps getting better. Adeline is wearing 'a summer blouse allowing free movement with a light purple silk skirt' while 'only she had her shoulders and arms tightly wrapped up stuffily.' Everyone else is in 'lovely pastel-toned thin dresses revealing their shoulders and arm lines' with 'chiffon skirts like candy wrappers rustling lightly in the wind.' She describes herself as 'a lady who'd jumped out of a painting from decades ago, all by herself.' GIRL. YOU'RE A VICTorian GHOST haunting a summer garden party and I AM OBSESSED. The temperature detail is also doing SO MUCH work. 'She hadn't known Aurelia's summer would be this sweltering. In the muggy heat, Adeline naturally headed toward the shaded tree-lined street.' The heat isn't just weather—it's oppressive, it's suffocating, it mirrors her emotional state of being trapped in a situation she can't escape no matter how much she tries to find shade. Then we cut to the tennis court—'Thwack! Clang'—the sound design alone is impressive. Wet hair, a loosely unbuttoned shirt, water poured over his head. 'His skin revealed through the wetness gleamed particularly bright. Perhaps slightly tanned from summer, his complexion looked even better. Literally, he overflowed with vitality.' Meanwhile Adeline is standing frozen in the shade like 'all the color in the world died' and only Kailen remains 'the only color.' The visual metaphor is SO ON THE NOSE but I forgive it because it works.
... Read More
I need to talk about the scene where Adeline is alone after everyone leaves. After Matteo stomps away like an enraged boar (and honestly that simile stuck with me for days, I keep seeing it), after Belliche vanishes down the conservatory path, after her cheek is bruised and her ear is ringing and she's just... standing there. "What kind of situation is this even?" she thinks. And the narration follows her internal state: "If not for her stinging cheek, Adeline would have almost thought the previous events were a dream throughout her walk." This is the moment where all the performance drops. She spent the whole scene calculating, strategizing, using the word 'honor' and 'Regenstadt name' like weapons. She slapped her own face to manufacture evidence. She bowed to Belliche and lied about her understanding of customs. She wrote a letter that was basically a declaration of war in polite language. And then—silence. Just her, her swollen face, and the realization that none of it was as under control as she needed everyone to believe. The friendship thread with Therese is what keeps this chapter from going completely dark. The way Therese bursts into the room and immediately goes into protective mode—"That bastard deserves to die. He's a waste of air. How dare he lay hands on someone!"—it's sharp and warm and real. And then she stays. All night. Sharing a bed, whispering curses, being present. "Though sharing a bed with someone was slightly uncomfortable, strangely it wasn't unpleasant." That last line wrecked me. Adeline, who has been navigating this treacherous world alone for so long, finds comfort in another person's presence and the narration doesn't even apologize for it. It just... states it. "Strangely it wasn't unpleasant." And the Belliche thing—ugh. The way he watches her self-harm with applause, makes a dry comment about her tactics, then walks away without a backward glance. Is he manipulating her? Is he genuinely intrigued? Is there something underneath that cold exterior? I don't know and I'm suffering beautifully. "Her left cheek burned so intensely it went numb. For a princess raised delicately, it was pain intense enough to bring tears to her eyes." She doesn't cry though. She just keeps going. That's the thing about Adeline that keeps pulling me in—she's breaking and she won't stop.
... Read More
There's a whole language of objects in this passage and I'm obsessed with how carefully the author builds it. The tea set first. Edelweiss & John porcelain—Maria Theresia Line. Only three pieces exist on the entire continent. Kailen chose it specifically for her mother. It represents everything he thinks he can offer: rarity, thoughtfulness, an understanding of taste that proves his worth. And her mother shatters it. Not just rejects it—literally knocks it off the table. The crack in that porcelain mirrors the crack in Adeline's face. Physical object, emotional fracture, described in the same sentence. That's not accidental writing. Then there's the window imagery. Adeline waits by windows repeatedly. First at the hotel, staring at the dark Varsen streets. Then at the cafe on Train Street, fourth day now, breaking a tart with her fork, watching streetcars draw white smoke trails. Windows are barriers—she can see the world moving but she's separate from it. She's trapped in observation mode, which is basically her entire life. The person she wants is always on the other side of glass. And the contract itself—this thick folder with the royal emblem on the cover. It's presented like a relic, divided neatly in two. Both of them get a half. The word 'royal' is added like a stamp of ownership over something that should be personal. Marriage becomes legal architecture instead of two people choosing each other. Oh and the hotel room. She stayed there the first time with Kailen (separate hotels, because they weren't married yet and people were watching) and she stayed there AGAIN alone after everything fell apart. The same room, different version of her. The building doesn't change—she does.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this breakfast scene because my brain is still reeling. Adeline is sitting there trying so hard to have a civilized conversation with her husband about basic human decency, and Kailen just absolutely dismantles her with the calmest voice ever. He says something like "I was too harsh, I'm sorry for being sensitive" and she's like oh thank god we're good — until the next second he's touching her in the most inappropriate way possible right there at the table. "Keep waiting from now on, dear. Until I come to your bedroom." I am literally screaming. This man cannot be real. He toys with her emotions like she's his personal stress ball and she keeps falling for it because he drops these little crumbs of warmth. Remember that flashback where he told her he'd accept anyone the Emperor chose, but then pivots to "would you believe me if I said I was sincerely happy it was you?" One moment he drops you into the abyss, the next he's making you fly. Adeline's own narration of that is so painfully accurate. And yet she still waits for him. She still tries. The fact that she's the one apologizing after HE's the one being cruel says everything about their dynamic. She whispers "I really don't want to fight with you" with trembling hands and honestly? My heart broke a little for her. She's giving him everything and getting emotional whiplash in return. Then later she's making sandwiches from scratch at 5 PM because she wants to send something to him, claiming it's about sincerity and nostalgia and those academy days. Meanwhile he's not coming home again. Mrs. Lien has to practically stop her from going into the actual kitchen like some kind of noblewoman who's never touched a cooking pot. The contrast between Adeline's earnest hope and Kailen's calculated distance is just... achingly painful to watch.
... Read More
I've been thinking about what this chapter is really saying beneath all the surface drama, and I keep coming back to food as the central symbol. Food appears in three forms here, each representing a different kind of control. First, the meal they're having at the start — shared food, interrupted by Kailen's departure. He leaves her eating alone. Then there's the contraceptive in the brown bottle — medicine disguised as care, secretly administered through food and tea. This is control through concealment. And finally, Adeline's sandwiches — food made with stated "sincerity," an attempt to connect through nourishment, to recreate a taste from their academy days behind that neglected greenhouse. The greenhouse! That detail hit me hard. The old greenhouse that was "neglected to the point of being desolate" — that's where they used to eat together. Now Adeline's in a mansion kitchen trying to recreate that feeling with ingredients she barely knows how to use, while Mrs. Lien watches, knowing Adeline will never get to share those sandwiches with the man she's making them for. There's also the water glass motif. Kailen puts the glass in Adeline's hand during their argument — a gesture that looks almost tender but is actually a power move. She's holding his water, drinking from his space, and telling herself she won against him when she clearly hasn't. Later, Mrs. Lien hands Adeline her tea, and the act of drinking becomes an act of submission she doesn't understand. The brown bottle without any markings is perhaps the most chilling symbol. No name, no dosage written out, just a plain vessel for something that will alter Adeline's body without her consent. The anonymity of it mirrors how invisible her suffering is — nobody sees what's happening because it's disguised as normalcy, as care, as routine. What is this story really about? I think it's about how power operates in intimate spaces — not through violence but through the small, accepted gestures between husband and wife, servant and mistress, doctor and patient. The most dangerous things aren't the dramatic confrontations, they're the quiet moments where someone decides your body is theirs to manage.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is brutal in the best way. Let me break down the rhythm because it's so deliberate. It starts IN MEDIA RES essentially—Adeline already cast out, already driving away from her mother's estate at sunset. No slow build, we drop right into the aftermath. She's in the hotel, Tanya is helping her change, food arrives and she can't eat. This is the emotional low point and it's handled with such restraint—the silence, the untouched food, her disappearing into the bathroom without explanation. The author trusts us to feel it without narration telling us how sad she is. Then Kailen calls. The phone call scene has this gorgeous slow-unwinding quality. We get the flashback woven INTO the conversation naturally—her remembering the tea set incident while listening to his voice. Past and present collapse into each other. Then back to present: 'I'll send a driver by 11:30 tomorrow morning.' Next morning: she arrives in Varsen. Sees torchlight, hears slogans, looks for his face in the window reflection. He's not there. 'He was, as always, a busy person.' Transition to the cafe. FOUR DAYS pass. Just... four days of her sitting at the same window, same seat, watching streetcars. The author doesn't speed through this. We feel every single one of those days. 'Words like reform and royal finances appeared in newspaper headlines, but Adeline's interests these days were always fixed.' Fixed on him. On the building across the street with Belliche's crest. Then chapter 14. The contract meeting. Nine o'clock sharp. And Kailen walks in. The entire chapter builds to this single entrance. 'Someone filled her sparkling eyes.' That's the line. Not 'he arrived.' He FILLED her eyes. Everything else disappears. The royal appointees, the documents, the scribe—all of it fades when he appears. The structure makes us wait with her, wait and wait, so that when he finally shows up, we feel the relief she feels. But here's what worries me about the structure: the prenup meeting ends on a cliffhanger disguised as calm. We're reading Article 1 and Article 2 of the contract and the text cuts off mid-sentence about succession rights. I am NOT READY for what comes next.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how Kailen speaks compared to everyone else in this book? Because his voice is SO distinct and I will die on this hill. While every other character is either being formal, nervous, or gossiping in that polite-but-cutthroat noble way, Kailen talks like a guy who genuinely does not care about social consequences and finds the whole exercise amusing. His dialogue reads like he's narrating his own life as a comedy. 'I'm a bit clumsy at such high-class hobbies.' — Said while literally destroying the tennis match with one throw. This is the verbal equivalent of shrugging while holding a detonator. 'The level of refined conversation from the distinguished gentlemen I could hear from the side was too absurd.' — He didn't even try to be subtle about it. He walked up to four angry boys and literally quoted their conversation back to them with a review. And his internal monologue when talking to Adeline? 'Since this much time had passed, he was curious whether her situational judgment had gotten faster than before.' He's not even pretending to be sweet. He's running a DIAGNOSTIC on her personality. 'Watching Adeline repeatedly clench and unclench the hand he'd released, he gauged a few answers in advance.' This man is taking NOTES on her micro-expressions like she's a case study. Compare this to Adeline's dialogue, which is almost entirely: '...so... I'm sorry.' / 'Because I'm inadequate...' Her speech patterns show someone who has internalized blame so deeply that even when she's NOT being blamed, her default mode is apology. It's heartbreaking and the author never wastes a single word on making it obvious. The male students' dialogue is also well-differentiated—they have that specific wealthy-boys-who-think-they're-smarter-than-they-are cadence. 'I heard this time, the princess's home country Krauben also extracted a fortune from Regenstadt.' 'It's a matter of amount—if you have enough money, nothing seems impossible.' They sound like they're reading from a capitalism textbook. Which, thematically, is kind of on the nose but it WORKS. And Belliche's 'Ah, my bad' after nearly hitting someone in the face with a tennis ball? The most Kailen line ever written.
... Read More
Let me just say this chapter sequence is a PATTERN. The author builds this incredibly slow, tense opening—Adeline caught mid-action, embarrassed, confused—and then it just ESCALATES. Like a car accelerating and never letting off the gas. You start with whispered dialogue, light touching, and within paragraphs it's full-on physical domination. No brakes. The transition is brutal and brilliant. One moment she's thinking about whether he's drunk and the next she's completely overwhelmed. The pacing mirrors her own loss of control. She tries to grab his wrist and stop him—"W-wait!"—and he literally just ignores it. "Ignoring the wrist she'd grabbed, he now thrust his tongue inside..." That's the pacing of the scene itself: she resists, he overrides, and the narrative won't let you catch your breath. Then—cut to morning. The abrupt transition from the fever dream of the night to the cold, awkward sunlight is jarring. Perfectly jarring. It's like the author knows you're exhausted from the intensity and deliberately yanks you back to reality. Eleven o'clock. He's gone. Mrs. Lien at the door. The ending cliffhanger with Mrs. Lien walking in on Adeline in her post-wedding-night state is the kind of beat that makes you immediately click to the next chapter. There's no gentle landing here—just hard cuts, relentless momentum, and a woman utterly exposed (literally and figuratively).

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or