I Reincarnated Into Another World With the Theory of an Idle Game, Can I Become the Strongest? - Reviews

is it still ongoing?

so i'm just here to warn people to read the fucking genre's before thinking that the MC will be some cold blooded killer who spares no one cause there's a romance genre so the woman is going to be a really annoying bitch thats just how ruthless MC works when there's a romance genre, k i've said my piece about how this is probably going to be shit and will now go back to reading the other dumpster fire i was reading a moment ago.

I like this one. It could be a gem; emphasis on could.

Even giving it a 2 is already very, very, very generous on my part. So what gives? Well, it's the grammar.

No, not the grammar of the original (I don't know Japanese well enough for that), but the "translated/edited" version we're reading here is the problem.

It is mentally exhausting how many times I had to correct the grammar in my head. It's depleting my mental energy faster than I anticipated.

[**Edit: I think I was deluded into thinking this was actually edited, and now correctly realize that this was just a machine translation that was slightly polished. They (whether solo or a group) patted themselves on the back and called it a day. My points below make more sense in light of this MTL revelation.]

My biggest gripe with the grammar issues is that the main character’s name changes 2-3 times, and the increasing difficulty in identifying who is currently speaking. This is compounded by the lack of cues indicating whether the speaker is engaging in internal monologue or external dialogue.

And perhaps the worst atrocity of all is the simultaneous use of first and third-person sentence structures, making it seem like everyone is suddenly schizophrenic and a company of two has turned into a group of 3-4 people. This is made even more egregious by the boastful addition of "editor" all over the place, often alongside "author," despite this clearly being a translation—now that’s an ego check if I’ve ever seen one.

But I digress. Despite my generosity and the valid criticisms I've pointed out, I still stand by my opinion that this could be a (niche) gem if it were cleaned up by an actual editor. In that case, I could give this a 3 or 4 stars (though a 4.5 would be necessary).

Main story is honestly just good stacking material, a bit aggravating because of the author being basically an amnesiac but alt ending is extremely good..

0 Views!!!! Lets gooooo!!!

I was hoping for at least a little romance, but it should be fine either way.

Sure, here is the rewritten content:

---

Basically, the protagonist is an idle game developer who has been reincarnated. He tries to create magic that operates similarly to an idle game, so he summons puppets in the form of humans and wolves and lets them kill monsters while he levels up without doing anything, just like in an idle game. He mentions that he plans to head to a dungeon in the future to farm experience and power-level, but I haven’t reached that part yet. The world has levels and skills, which are different from magic, but it also has magic.

I got to the chapter where his female friend is lost in the forest, and he goes looking for her, summoning lots of wolf puppets. I couldn’t continue from there. It’s too bad; it’s not my cup of tea. However, the premise is very interesting.

I really enjoy this novel because it’s quite engaging and interesting. The reason I rated it 3 stars is due to the translation quality.

The translation was acceptable in the early chapters, but it has deteriorated significantly by the latest chapter. In the beginning, only minor corrections were needed, but now it feels like it’s a direct machine translation with no editing at all.

It’s particularly frustrating to see repeated paragraphs and inconsistent character names, especially the main character’s name. Additionally, the use of pronouns is often confusing, which makes the narrative messy, especially since the story is primarily told from the main character’s perspective.

It seems like the translator hasn’t reviewed the novel after translating it. They could improve the quality by asking readers for feedback, as many are willing to point out errors and suggest corrections. This way, the translator or machine translations can be refined to enhance the overall reading experience.

The novel has an interesting premise, and I enjoy the relationship between the two main characters. Unfortunately, the translation is far from satisfactory compared to the original text, which I find to be a very enjoyable read. It seems this group churns out machine-translated works with little to no effort in ensuring their quality.

Here are a few examples:

- Character and place names are consistently mistranslated or changed without explanation. The translators probably use machine translation and never bother to edit or proofread. This issue could be easily resolved by maintaining a sheet of character and place information as a reference guide.
- In the original text, it's clear who is speaking to whom. However, the translators have made this aspect very confusing, making for a frustrating reading experience. It seems they lack a strong command of English, which exacerbates the problem.
- They also frequently repeat sentences, sometimes even tripling them. This appears to be the result of hasty editing where old sentences were not removed. A simple double-check would easily catch these issues, so it’s disappointing that they don’t take the time to do so.

I have read several of their other translations, and they all suffer from the same flaws. If you’re considering reading another story translated by this group, I would advise against it unless you’re extremely bored—really, really bored.

I hope someone will take over this project and salvage an otherwise promising novel that deserves to be read.

It's a pleasant and straightforward adventure novel. Each volume consists of around 20 chapters, following Sieg as he travels to new places to level up. Although he claims to be creating an idle game within the world, he is quite actively engaged in his own progression, and the author often skips over the monotonous grinding periods. , the plot doesn't have much drama because the main characters become so overpowered by the third volume, making it a relaxing tale of two individuals exploring, disrupting local monster ecosystems, and then moving on to the next destination.