I Didn’t Want to Remember You Anymore - Reviews

I Didn’t Want to Remember You Anymore
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second. Because the stakes in this chapter are NOT what they appear to be on the surface. Yes, there's a pocket watch involved. Yes, there's a mysterious mage. But the real conflict here is layered so deeply you could dig through three strata and still be above ground. Layer one: Ariel's safety. She's trusting a stranger — possibly the most dangerous person in the known world — with a family heirloom. She's alone in a carriage. She just got publicly humiliated at that party. And this man appears out of nowhere offering help. The suspense isn't whether he'll steal the watch; it's whether he's actually helping her or setting something in motion she can't yet see. When he says "The consequences of failed magic are far greater than you think" — is that a promise or a threat? Layer two: Kylance's crumbling control. He's orchestrating the destruction of the Blanté family while simultaneously being physically repulsed by his own complicity. He's sending a million krang to pay off their debt — which means he's still involved, still controlling the narrative — but he's also losing his mind over Aster Magicos talking to her. The internal conflict is eating him alive and the external stakes (political ruin, family destruction, potential war) are rising alongside it. Layer three — and this is the one that keeps me up at night: what does Aster owe Ariel? "He even mentioned that he owed her a great debt." That line is doing SO much heavy lifting. A 9th Circle Archmage doesn't owe anything to anyone. Unless... unless Ariel has something he needs. Or unless something happened before the story even started that neither of them has fully acknowledged yet. The stakes aren't just rising, they're about to EXPLODE.
... Read More
I need to talk about Kylance because my blood is boiling. Let's be real — the man is doing everything WRONG. Ariel stabs herself OPENING a door to reach him, bleeding, sobbing, and his response is basically "go back to your room, I've only done what I had to do." WHAT does that even mean?? Is he playing some long con? Is he actually against the charges but powerless? Or did he genuinely turn on her father? The flashback sections make this SO much worse. Remember the hunting tournament? He was gentle. He said "letting go of something this small shouldn't be a problem" and helped her with her ankle. He whispered "you are my savior" and "I don't want to love anyone but you until the day I die." That version of him doesn't exist anymore. The text says his eyes used to be warm — now they're "filled with irritation" and his gaze is "sharp and predatory." But here's what gets me: Ariel KNOWS something has shifted. She says meeting his gaze "has become hard" and she can feel her skin growing colder. She's not deluding herself. The tragedy isn't that she's being fooled — it's that she REMEMBERS what he used to be and it's being ripped away. Their entire dynamic flipped from lovers to adversaries in the span of however-long-this-treason-case-has-been-ongoing. And she's still going to his office bleeding. That says something about either her love or her stubbornness, or both.
... Read More
The structural choice to split this chapter between Ariel's perspective and Kylance's is absolutely brilliant, and I think it deserves more credit than it's getting. The author doesn't just alternate chapters or sections — they intercut like cross-cutting in film. We're in the carriage with Ariel, feeling her cautious wonder, her gradual trust forming, the warmth of the moment as this mysterious mage gives her his seal. Then — bam — Kylance at his window, cold and bloody and unraveling. The temperature shift alone is jarring in the best way. Notice how the Ariel section moves? It's measured, deliberate. She observes, she doubts, she verifies, she accepts. The prose mirrors her thought process — circling back, testing theories, slowly landing on conclusions. "Could it be… No, it couldn't be." The hesitation IS the pacing. You feel every second of her suspicion dissolving into curiosity. Then Kylance's section hits like a car crash. Short sentences. Fragmented thoughts. Physical actions replacing internal monologue. He scrubs his lips. He laughs. He orders a million krang. The sentences get shorter as his mental state deteriorates. By the time he says "That cannot happen," the rhythm has shifted from flowing to stuttering. The pacing doesn't just serve the story — it IS the story. "My lord left… not long after, he got into the Marquis of Blanté's carriage and got off at Teiran Street. Then he disappeared with magic, and I couldn't follow him." Deryl's report is delivered in flat, clinical prose — and that's what makes it hit hardest. The reader now holds information that both Ariel and Kylance lack. We know Aster followed her. We know he disappeared with her. And Kylance is just sitting there, about to send money to the family he destroyed, completely blind to the fact that the most powerful mage in the world is now personally invested in Ariel's fate. The dramatic irony here is suffocating. I can't wait for the collision.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: the author does NOT play around with pacing. Chapter after chapter, it's just relentless forward momentum. Funeral → imperial knights arrive → lockdown declared → annulment delivered → Ariel signs → cut to Kylance clearing her room. Twenty pages and we've gone from grief to political exile to broken engagement to… what is happening?? What I appreciate most is how the author controls tension through scene transitions. The funeral scene starts slow, heavy, almost dreamlike — Ariel touching the cold gravestone, whispering to her dead father. Then BAM: "something terrible has happened!" — and suddenly we're in full crisis mode. That jarring shift mirrors exactly what Ariel is experiencing. She never gets a moment to process before the next disaster hits. And the dual POV structure? Brilliant. Just when you're fully inside Ariel's devastation, the chapter cuts to Kylance's perspective, and suddenly you see the other side of the same coin. He's not just some villain executing a cruel plan — there's something simmering underneath. Lowell's confusion about why his lord is acting this way creates its own kind of suspense. Who is Kylance really? The only risk I'd note: it moves SO fast that some emotional beats barely get room to breathe. But honestly? That works for this story. Ariel doesn't have time to grieve properly. The pacing IS the message.
... Read More
"She's the daughter of the Marquis of Blanté in the Pentium Empire. Brother, the next time we go to the Empire, you must take me with you. I want to meet the Blanté girl again." I need to sit with this for a second. That's Aster remembering his younger sibling—the one who was bullied, the one who smiled for the first and last time because of a girl named Ariel, the one who then died in an accident and never got to meet her again. The emotional weight of that flashback hitting right after we see Aster carefully cradling a pocket watch like it's something sacred? Chilling. This changes everything about the pocket watch. It's not just an ancient magical artifact to him. It's a message. It's a debt. It's the only thing connecting him to the sibling he lost and the girl who once showed them kindness. When he says "it was never ours to keep," he's not being humble—he's making a vow. He's choosing to give Ariel something that could literally bring the dead back to life, without even testing if it works, because he believes she deserves protection, not experimentation. Meanwhile, Kylance is actively destroying her family while telling himself it has nothing to do with her. And Ariel is lying in bed, exhausted, heart physically aching, haunted by the image of him kissing Cier's hand. Three people, all carrying different kinds of love and grief, all orbiting the same broken girl. I am not okay. The tragedy here is layered like an onion made of knives.
... Read More
I need a minute. I genuinely need a minute. The emotional violence in this chapter is extraordinary and I don't use that word lightly. Let's talk about the kiss. Not the romantic kind — the grotesque, performative, politically calculated act of Kylance kissing Cier Bayern's hand IN FRONT OF Ariel. He does it deliberately. He does it to hurt her. And then he can't stop scrubbing his mouth afterward because apparently his body knows something his mind refuses to accept. "At least Cier Bayern hadn't taken anything directly from Ariel. Unlike him, who had taken everything from her." That right there. That single comparison. The author doesn't need another word. Cier is evil, yes, but she's openly evil. She's a villain you can point at. Kylance? He's the one who loved her, left her, destroyed her family, and is now watching her fall apart while his own heart breaks into a million pieces he refuses to acknowledge. He's the monster AND the victim and the chapter makes you feel BOTH things at once and that is emotional torture in the best possible way. And then there's Ariel, completely unaware of any of this. Sitting in that carriage, clutching a golden seal, holding a broken pocket watch, looking at a man who may be the most powerful being on the continent with nothing but trust in her green eyes. She has no idea that the man who ruined her life is watching her from somewhere, bleeding his lips raw. She has no idea that the mage helping her might be the key to everything she's lost. "Ha." Kylance's laugh. One syllable. One mocking, broken, desperate sound. And it wrecked me.
... Read More
There's a reason the Tower Master offers to guarantee a debt that's probably pocket change to him. It's not about the money. It's about being willing to put your name—your reputation, your power—behind someone else's survival. And Ariel, who spent the entire chapter refusing to hand over family heirlooms, who threatened bankruptcy before accepting ANY deal that required sacrificing her family's legacy... she lets HIM sign. Not because she's weak. Because she recognizes that this is about something bigger than creditors and contracts. The seal flashes blue—a magical element embedded in the paperwork, binding not just legally but almost ritually. And the confidentiality clause? 'Keep my role as guarantor strictly confidential.' He's protecting her pride. He's letting her maintain the appearance that her family can stand on its own, even as he quietly holds the entire structure up. That's the theme right there: dignity isn't about never needing help. It's about who you allow to help you.
... Read More
The Duchess of Viasteus is a fascinating character. She's not just an antagonist here — she's Kylance's aunt, raised him like a mother, and yet there's this terrifying power dynamic between them. When she says 'I may not have given birth to you, but I have raised you for over a decade,' it's supposed to sound maternal, but instead it feels like a threat wrapped in silk. What struck me most is how she PROBED him. She knew about the money sent to the Blante household. She had spies in the Grand Duke's mansion. That level of surveillance on someone you supposedly raised with love? That's not concern, that's control. And Kylance knows it — his reaction when she reveals she planted someone was literally described as 'a crack forming in his stoic expression.' But then the really painful moment: 'You still haven't really left Lady Blante behind. That foolish lingering attachment has shackled you.' The Duchess sees right through him. And Kylance? He has to DOUBLE DOWN on his commitment to revenge. He literally has to convince himself that destroying Ariel's family is the right choice, because if he admits he still cares, then everything he's done falls apart. The scene where he clenches his trembling fingers into a fist — that single detail says everything. This man who has maintained perfect composure his entire life is physically shaking because he's fighting himself.
... Read More
This scene hit me like a punch. Let me get one thing straight: the author just did something incredibly clever with the thousand-krang cheque. On the surface, it looks like Kylance is being magnanimous — paying off the Blante estate's debts after the annulment. But read it again, and every word tastes different. He didn't just send money. He sent THE exact amount of their biggest debt. That's not generosity, that's surveillance. He spent time investigating their financial ruin, calculating precisely what would make her accept it while also reminding her he knows exactly how desperate she is. And then there's the timing. The annulment happened at her father's funeral — the lowest, most vulnerable moment of her life. Now he's sending payment like she's some unfortunate widow he's taking pity on. The parallel Aster draws earlier about his own regrets with Faelin? Brilliant narrative mirroring. Both men are trying to atone through third parties, both are blind to how their gestures land as cruelty. What made me actually gasp was when Ariel realizes the trap. She can't refuse — not because she wants the money, but because without it, the estate falls. "It was either take the money or face ruin." That's not a choice. That's coercion wrapped in an envelope. And she knows it. The author doesn't even need to say it outright — they just show her clenching her fists and forcing herself to remain calm, and suddenly every polite word she spoke to Lowell reads as battlefield strategy. Also loving how the Kuno Trading Company thread got planted here. Ariel claims she already resolved things with them, which means Aster's guarantee may have been unnecessary OR it means she found another route entirely. Either way, the author is setting up a tension where Kylance thinks he's holding all the cards while something else is moving underneath his notice. This is plot construction that respects the reader's intelligence. No exposition dumps, no over-explaining. Just a cheque on a table and the entire power dynamic of two people who used to be engaged laid bare.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Kylance because WOW. The way he literally couldn't look at Ariel once? That's not just cold — that's calculated. He stood there while Cier threw a fit, and the moment Cier grabbed his wrist and basically clung to him, he didn't push her away. DIDN'T PUSH HER AWAY. Ariel noticed this and I felt my heart crack along with hers. This man who despises anyone touching him suddenly allows it from Cier? That connection is REAL and it's devastating. But then — and this is the thing that has me genuinely shook — the Duchess of Viasteus. She raised Kylance, she's always considered Ariel unworthy, and yet the second this mysterious man appears, she completely changes her behavior. She apologizes to ARIEL. The Duchess. Who had icy, black eyes "one that reminded Ariel of Kylance." Who just moments ago was accusing Ariel of causing a scene. She drops it like nothing. And I am convinced this man knows something about her that makes her back down. Then there's the mysterious man himself. He literally saves Ariel from being socially destroyed, holds out his hand like some romance novel hero, and then later admits in the carriage: "I actually had fun. I felt like the hero of a romance novel." BRO. He's self-aware enough to know what he's doing AND he's already hinting that they've met before. When he says "We're not meeting for the first time, are we?" my brain short-circuited. And his offer to fix the pocket watch — not just to help, but as a condition for revealing who he is — feels like manipulation and rescue simultaneously. I can't trust him and I can't look away.
... Read More
There are so many doors and containers in this chapter it's almost comical. Kylance turns over documents so no one else can see them. Aster hides inside a wardrobe—a literal enclosed space—using illusion magic. Seoden tracks red lights that narrow down to a single point before the wardrobe opens. Ariel is trapped by the closed gates of her family's estate and the closing deadline of the Kuno debt. Even the pocket watch is a container, a sealed vessel holding ancient magic that can't be used until it's returned to the right hands. The wardrobe especially struck me. Aster choosing to hide inside furniture rather than simply apparate elsewhere? It's oddly vulnerable for someone who could level a building. There's something symbolic about the Head of the Mage Tower—the most powerful mage probably alive—crouching in a wooden closet, waiting to be found. Maybe he's not hiding from the world. Maybe he's preserving something. Protecting something. The same instinct that makes him want to give Ariel the watch instead of studying it. And the watch itself—sealed magic that could resurrect the dead but remains trapped until it reaches its rightful owner. That's the central metaphor of the entire passage. Power without connection is useless. Gifts without recipients are just objects. Magic, love, purpose—they all need to be given to the right person to unlock their meaning. Aster knows this intuitively. Ariel is learning it the hard way. And Kylance? He's currently proving the opposite by trying to destroy what he claims he wants to protect.
... Read More
The setting in this chapter is deceptively simple — a garden conversation between Kylance and his aunt — but the atmosphere is incredibly dense. Let me paint the picture for you: Kylance pouring tea with 'unshaken composure' while having this explosive conversation. The Duchess slamming her hand on the table. Kylance freezing mid-pour. These small physical details create such a vivid scene. You can practically feel the tension in that room. But then there's the ending — Kylance alone in the garden after the Duchess leaves. The imagery shifts completely. He's 'staring at the brittle, empty branches above' and that 'last trembling leaf' falls. This garden becomes this haunting space where his internal conflict mirrors the dying landscape around him. The emptiness of the branches reflects the emptiness he's trying to create in the Blante family. There's also this recurring visual motif of shattered things — the carriage that killed his parents, the 'shattered carriage tumbling off the cliff, the unrecognisable remains of his parents' mangled bodies inside.' That memory is 'burned into his mind.' It's not just backstory; it's the foundation of everything he does. The violence is always present, always underneath the polite conversation about tea. The contrast between the refined, controlled exterior of noble society and the raw violence beneath it is what makes this world feel so real. Everyone is drinking tea while plotting destruction.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or