I Became the First Love of a Madman - Reviews

I Became the First Love of a Madman
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to address the dialogue because Young Master Nesferos has some of the most delightfully unhinged lines I've read in a while. Let's start with the prologue: "You're beautiful. Don't worry." Said while she's literally sobbing. And then the follow-up—"Sometimes the right answer is to follow your heart" while watching her cry? The man is a menace. But what's incredible is how natural it sounds. He's not reciting villain monologue; he's just... like this. Confident, slightly teasing, completely aware of the effect he has on her. His dialogue carries this weight where every line feels like it has two meanings—the surface meaning and the actual meaning—and Iberia (and we) are always catching up. Then in Chapter 1, his school dialogue is this PERFECT tonal shift. "Your glasses look nice." "Would you like them?" He's testing her, playing, and her response—completely deadpan, reflexive—is such a great character beat. She's not flirting; she's deflecting. And he LOVES it. The way he smiles even more deeply without even addressing her actual answer? That's dialogue doing serious character work. Cynthia's voice is also doing great things here. Her lines are quick, casual, grounded—"I'm starving to death right now. You know I didn't eat breakfast today." She's the normal-pressure valve in this increasingly strange environment, and her dialogue feels distinctly different from Iberia's measured responses. When she says "You're just weird" about Iberia studying on weekends, it's affectionate but pointed, and it tells us everything we need to know about their friendship. The narrative voice itself is interesting too—it's close third person centered on Iberia, but the author lets Nesferos's presence color the prose even when he's not speaking. Things like "his face filled her vision in an instant" or the way his "voice, asking for permission, was thick with emotion" shows how the narration itself becomes emotionally charged around him.
... Read More
I need everyone to sit down. Young Master Nesferos, casually leaning forward during dinner like it's no big deal, looking at Iberia with what the text literally calls 'an affectionate gaze' and saying 'I mean, I like seeing you eat well.' LET ME SCREAM. Because this man had been walking alongside her silently after their whole awkward apology exchange, and then he just... drops that? It's so casual but it's NOT casual at all. He noticed she's been eating properly. He noticed. And instead of making it weird or grandiose, he just says it like it's the most natural thing in the world. Meanwhile Iberia's ears turn red and she can't even look at him. The slow burn here is IMMACULATE. And the apology scene before that? She's so caught up in shame about how she reacted — about placing too much emotional weight on being runner-up, about her prejudices — and he literally tells her multiple times not to apologize for things that aren't her fault. The fact that he REMEMBERS saying that shows he was actually listening. Every time.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: the way this chapter builds tension is *chef's kiss*. We start with this tiny, almost throwaway exchange about the newspaper—Nesferos dropping a hint, Iberia stiffening—and it feels like nothing. But then it just keeps layering. Layer after layer. By the time she collapses in the walking path, you're like, of COURSE that was coming. The foreshadowing was brutal in the best way. And the Crown Prince scene? What is that? A two-minute encounter that changes EVERYTHING. He says things like "You won't be of any use to your future" and then—key detail—he notices something when their hands touch. Something Iberia doesn't even see. The author is playing 4D chess here and I am HERE for it. The parallel structure between Nesferos sleeping through class while Iberia is grinding herself into dust is also so intentional. He has everything handed to him and he's bored. She has nothing and she's running on fumes. Of course they end up in the same infirmary. Of course. My only question is: what does the newspaper article actually say about him? Because that's clearly a ticking time bomb and I need answers NOW.
... Read More
But then there's Nesferos and I can't decide if I'm rooting for them or screaming at them. Every interaction between them is this agonizing dance of almosts. He says "If I'm being presumptuous, will you forgive me?" and she deflects with "don't pay attention to my words." She's protecting herself from... what? His concern? His attention? The fact that every time he's near, something shifts in her chest? And he notices. Of course he notices. "His eyes, watching her face, curved slightly at the corners." That's not a smile of satisfaction. That's the smile of someone who realizes they've been let in, even a crack. The romance here isn't in grand gestures — it's in the silence between "Go ahead without me" and "If you don't eat, I won't either." It's in a boy who brings sweets to a girl who doesn't want them, sits in front of her like a child, rests his head on his hands, and says the truest sentence in the entire book.
... Read More
"Why do you care?" "Am I not allowed to?" I keep coming back to this exchange. It's everything. Iberia asks it impulsively, almost against her will, and Nesferos just... deflected with that infuriating calmness. But here's what gets me—the subtext. He notices she's not eating. He comments on how thin she's gotten. He tells her to keep up with the newspapers like he knows something she doesn't. And yet when she pushes back, he disappears behind a smile again. The emotional push-and-pull between these two is unreal. Every time I think Iberia has figured him out, he does something that completely reframes everything. One minute he's mocking her chances of beating him, the next he's watching her eat like he's actually worried. Is it pity? Is it something else? Or is he just good at manipulation and she's walking right into it? What kills me is that Iberia KNOWS most of her feelings toward him are negative, yet there are these flickers—pity, maybe even gratitude—mixed in there. She's fighting herself. And the worst part? She can't even afford to process any of this because exams are coming and she's running on five hours of sleep and stress potions.
... Read More
This guy's dialogue is SO specific. Let me just read you this exchange: "What do you do when there's something you don't want to do?" "If it's something I must do, I do it." "Then, what if it's something you must do, but you absolutely despise it?" "I'd still do it." "Hmm, I see. That's how you are." And then his own philosophy drops: "I never do things I don't want to do, no matter what consequences I have to face." Every single sentence Nesferos speaks feels like it has two meanings. He's asking her questions that are really about himself, or testing her, or both. His voice is described as "slightly husky" and "tinged with a peculiar hint of amusement" and "as light as ever" while carrying "a strange weight." The man literally cannot just say something plain—EVER. Meanwhile Iberia's responses are so dry and minimal. "Yes." "Pardon?" "You can." She's surviving on sarcasm and forced politeness at this point. Their verbal sparring is basically a duel where one person is wielding a scalpel and the other is just trying not to bleed.
... Read More
Let's talk about how effortlessly natural the dialogue is here. I know it sounds like a basic compliment but hear me out — the way Young Master Nesferos pivots from serious to playful in the span of two sentences is so distinctly HIM. 'In that case, would you like to have lunch with me from now on?' — said as a joke, but Iberia's reaction? Pure fear. And then 'Just kidding.' The author doesn't even need to add 'he smiled' because the beat itself does the work. Same with the dinner scene. 'Is something going on these days?' — such an innocent opener, but his gaze never leaves her the entire time. The silence between lines is where the actual conversation lives. And Iberia's internal voice? Perfectly dry and self-deprecating. Her thought about Nesferos probably not killing her easily after he becomes 'slightly less intimidating' — that's comedy gold wrapped in genuine fear. The author knows exactly when to let dialogue hang and when to fill the silence. 'Oh.' / 'I see.' Those single-word responses carry more weight than entire paragraphs of exposition.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes for a second, because on the surface this seems like a low-key academy romance setup — two students paired for a project, awkward interactions, romantic tension building. But if you actually look at what Iberia has to lose, the pressure is REAL. She's a commoner at a noble academy. Her entire identity is built on academic excellence — she's the top student, she has scholarships, she has a trajectory that depends on her performing flawlessly. And now Nesferos, who is literally described as 'a genius noble,' is coming for her space. Not just her study spot — her independence, her autonomy, her ability to manage her own schedule and avoid people who make her uncomfortable. The internal conflict is brutal: she WANTS to hate him, she WANTS him to be the villain she can easily dismiss, but every time she looks at him, something else happens. His face shows 'genuine concern.' He asks if she's feeling well. He brings her to a library she could only dream of accessing. These small kindnesses — or are they? — make it impossible to file him away as simple antagonist. Meanwhile, the external stakes are quietly compounding. The gossip about him confronting a professor. The rumors about donations and humiliation. What kind of person was he before she entered his orbit? The author never tells us directly, and that deliberate withholding of information IS the tension. Every unanswered question is a loose thread that could unravel something huge.
... Read More
What really gets me is the structure of the confrontation between them. They're circling each other like predators who are also desperately lonely. He asks the question that should end everything — "Is there any guarantee that your efforts will yield results?" And she answers like a soldier: "It's better than doing nothing. I have nothing to lose." And then he hits her with "And what if, in the end, you gain nothing?" and she just... stops. That moment where the narrative itself seems to hold its breath. I swear the author knows exactly what they're doing here. The exams themselves are this looming shadow — the professors conspiring against perfect scores, as if they personally resent excellence. Iberia writes answers for everything but has no idea if they're correct. The plot isn't just moving forward; it's tightening.
... Read More
So I need to talk about the setting because this whole academy vibe is *chef's kiss*. The prologue alone sets this incredibly intimate, almost suffocatingly tender scene—like, you're there, you can feel the dampness of Iberia's tears on her palms, the stiff fabric of his clothes beneath her grip. The author doesn't just tell us it's emotional, they make you feel the salt-and-sweet tension in every breath. Then we cut to Chapter 1 and the shift is wild. Iberia folding that newspaper by the library entrance, casually scanning through noble debutante gossip before her world flips with that headline about Young Master Nesferos. The visual of her reading about him before actually seeing him? That's some master-level dramatic staging right there. And the academy itself—Lacanel Academy, where the Empire's talents and nobles gather—feels lived-in without being over-explained. We get the purple second-year badge, the library, the self-study room, the imperial history classroom with its coveted second-row middle seat that Iberia treats like sacred ground. None of it is a massive info-dump; the world reveals itself through her daily routines. That's how you do fantasy-adjacent worldbuilding without boring readers to tears. The world feels real because Iberia's relationship to it feels real—she navigates it strategically, protectively, like someone who knows the terrain matters for survival. What really stuck with me though was how the spaces escalate in significance. It starts with a hallway encounter, moves to a shared classroom (which for Iberia is basically a territorial violation), and I'm already sensing that certain locations are going to become charged territory throughout this whole story. The author knows exactly which rooms matter.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: the group project twist is genuinely brilliant plot machinery. Not because it's original — oh no, we've all seen the forced-collaboration trope before — but because of HOW the author wields it. Nesferos doesn't just happen to end up in Iberia's group. He INTERRUPTS the professor to change the grouping system itself. 'Can't we just go with the current seating arrangement?' — apparently he has enough social capital that the PROFESSOR caves. That detail alone tells you everything about his status and the power imbalance in this world. But here's where it gets really interesting: the narrative never resolves the tension between them. Every scene builds it further. He sits next to her. He makes her walk beside him. He takes her to the nobles-only library. Each step is an escalation disguised as casual friendliness. The author is methodically closing Iberia's escape routes while keeping Nesferos's true intentions completely opaque. The library scene especially works on two levels — it's both a genuine plot advancement (they need research for the project) and a psychological maneuver (he's bringing her into his world, into spaces she can't access as a commoner). It's subtle worldbuilding disguised as character interaction. And that ending line — 'Is there something wrong?' — cut off mid-conversation? That's a cliffhanger that makes you immediately want to keep reading. The author knows exactly how to hold your attention.
... Read More
And then there's the contrast with the exam hall — fluorescent, tense, the sound of pens scratching, Iberia leaning against a wall afterward muttering "These cruel people..." while Cynthia doodles aimlessly, eyes dead. The world of this academy is layered: you have the pristine library where knowledge is quiet and golden, and then you have the examination rooms where knowledge becomes a weapon turned against you. The professors actively conspiring to prevent perfect scores — "Do you think we can allow perfect scores?" — that detail alone makes the whole institution feel alive and slightly sinister. It's not just a school; it's a pressure cooker with people inside it who were designed to break you. And Iberia walks through both worlds, exhausted, forgetting names, still showing up.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or