I Became the Academy's Medicine Genius - Reviews

I Became the Academy's Medicine Genius
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'Can't use magic, but I can handle potions freely?' — this line from the protagonist hits way harder than it should, and I've been thinking about it nonstop since I finished reading. The central irony of this story is baked into its premise from the very first chapter. The protagonist spent 4,821 hours mastering something that the game world considers worthless — potion-making. In a world where magic is everything, where students are sorted by their magical aptitude, where a mana stat of 1 makes you practically useless, the protagonist's greatest achievement is something that requires zero magical ability. It's knowledge-based, craft-based, patience-based. And yet, THAT is what saves his life. This is a story about the value of what the world overlooks. The Herbology Department itself is a symbol of this — the "slightly worn" building surrounded by flashier alternatives, the department with only one student, the professor who's been trying to prove himself against a system that doesn't believe in him. The protagonist and the Herbology Department are mirroring each other. Both are undervalued. Both are dismissed. Both are about to prove everyone wrong. The 451 medicines he crafted represent something deeper than gameplay accomplishment. They represent persistence. They represent the willingness to do something tedious, repetitive, and apparently pointless until you've done it completely. In a culture that celebrates the flashy and the immediate — the fireballs and the lightning bolts — the protagonist chose the slow path. And now that slow path is the only thing standing between him and death. There's also a fascinating theme running through the protagonist's backstory about his real life. The loneliness, the failed job interviews, the growing sense of falling behind his peers. These aren't just character details — they're thematic setup. The protagonist is someone who existed on the margins of the real world, and now he's on the margins of the game world too. But here's the thing: the margins are where he's strongest. In both worlds, his perceived weakness is actually his advantage. The hidden challenge quest itself is rich with symbolic meaning. It's a quest that nobody believed in, nobody could complete, nobody thought was worth pursuing. And he did it anyway. The message seems clear: the things we're told are impossible or pointless are often the very things that define us. The quest didn't just earn him an achievement — it earned him a new world, a new identity, and a second chance. I'm also struck by the theme of identity. Who is he now? He's no longer the lonely gamer in a messy apartment. He's Aaron Taylor, Herbology student, someone with a mission and a purpose. But he's also still himself — the same knowledge, the same personality, the same dark sense of humor. The question of whether he can or should return to his old life hangs over everything. If he goes back, does he lose this new identity? If he stays, does he lose the old one? This duality feels like it'll be central to the story's emotional core.
... Read More
'I have ears to hear and eyes to see too. Professors.' That line. Just that line. It's polite on the surface but the underneath is doing so much work - it's respect wrapped in steel. Aaron's dialogue throughout this entire section is a masterclass in character voice. He never raises his voice unnecessarily, never loses composure, but every line carries weight. When he says 'Magic's fundamental principle 1! Mana is essential to use magic!' he's not being dramatic - he's weaponizing their own doctrine against them. And then 'All of this was possible with herbs I made myself, and I can prove all of this right here.' That's not arrogance. That's someone who knows exactly what tools they have and isn't afraid to use them. The professors' dialogue is equally effective in its own way - they're loud, reactive, jumping between suspicion and frustration. But Claire's voice is what makes me sit up. Her dialogue is economical, direct, almost clinical. 'I can't speak falsely.' Three words that define her entire character. And when she clicks her tongue and shakes her head at Allegri's expense? That tiny gesture tells you everything about her complex relationship with authority. The author's narrative voice is restrained but sharp, never over-explaining, letting actions and dialogue carry the meaning. Every line feels earned.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are wild because they operate on two completely different levels and the author never lets you forget either one. On surface level, it's a magic competition. You get hit by magic, your HP drops. Aaron takes a water arrow to the gut and his HP plummets from 63 to 37. One hit basically halves his remaining health. The author keeps the status window visible periodically which is a great technique—every time we see those numbers, we're reminded that this is real, concrete danger. 'Even without receiving a proper attack, my HP was close to half' because he's been running up a mountain. Physical exhaustion matters as much as magic attacks. But the deeper stakes are what really get you. Aaron isn't just competing for a prize. He's a magic-less person in a world that equates magic with worth, and every step he takes is walking into territory where people assume he's cheating or dangerous. The professors literally start discussing whether he's a worshipper of the demon king Astaroth. That's not just a rivalry, that's existential threat. If they decide he's a black mage, he's done. Not third place—gone. The tension during the summit scene is suffocating in the best way. Aaron drinks a disgusting apple-flavored slime potion for a two-minute power boost, knows he can't use his poison mist because it'll confirm every rumor, can't even use Ifrit's Breath openly because that also looks demonic, and yet Tay and Claire are firing magic at him simultaneously. He's literally forced to run while calculating three steps ahead. And the wind is AGAINST him for the mist, which is such a small detail but it raises the stakes so much. What I find most gripping is that Aaron knows he's walking a razor's edge between 'clever underdog' and 'suspicious outlier.' Every potion he uses could be the one that tips people over into full accusation mode. The competition is secondary. Survival is primary.
... Read More
Okay so let me just... wait. Let me catch my breath here. The curse-breaking scene absolutely wrecked me in the best way possible. Think about it: the Nevan family had been dealing with this skin disease curse for generations, right? Mages and healers threw everything at it and failed. And then Scarlet just walks in with TWO POTIONS and it's done. Like, boom. Game over for a century-long curse. But what really grabbed me was the economic plot thread underneath all of this. Scarlet doesn't just cure Violet out of the goodness of her heart—well, partly—but she also immediately pivots to the business angle. Eight potions left. Eight! And the nobles are literally throwing gold bars at her. That transition from emotional healing to marketplace drama was so smooth I almost didn't notice it happening until I was already watching Lily's eyes sparkle at the sight of gold. Then Aaron takes that gold and does something genuinely clever—he doesn't just pocket it. He invests it back into his department. The Herbology building renovation plotline is such an underrated move. Instead of buying fancy gear or personal luxuries, he hires dwarven craftsmen. Which leads to this hilarious negotiation scene where Rihart the dwarf goes from skeptical to absolutely gawking at the gold bar advance. One gold bar as a deposit! That's the kind of scene that makes you laugh out loud. But the plot twist that really stuck with me was the Tay conversation. Everything seems fine—money's made, building's being renovated, life's good—and then Tay shows up asking how to get stronger. And Aaron's internal monologue about those endings... the self-destruction ending, Lily's death... he knows things Tay doesn't. The dramatic irony here is THICK. We're watching a protagonist who has seen multiple futures and is actively trying to change them, while everyone else thinks this is just a casual lunch conversation. The plot structure here is actually really smart because it moves from micro to macro. Starts with one girl's curse being lifted, expands to a merchant group making money, then to departmental infrastructure, then to the protagonist's deeper knowledge of story endings. Each scene opens up a bigger picture without losing the personal stakes. That's solid plotting.
... Read More
I keep thinking about the stakes here and they're deceptively high. On the surface it's just 'guy makes potions, girl sells them.' But actually—actually—Scarlet's entire position at the academy is hanging by a thread. Every day she's there, she's absorbing mockery: 'Normally, kids with no talent in magic quit after about a year.' 'Since she's the merchant's daughter, money isn't a waste, right?' These aren't just insults—they're threats to her future. If she can't prove herself, the whole family structure shifts, and she's fighting for her place in it. Aaron recognizing this and essentially handing her the tools to fight back—that's not just kindness, that's strategic. He knows what she stands to lose, and he's investing in her winning. The contract with the merchant group isn't just a business deal; it's a lifeline for both of them. He gets distribution, she gets validation. But the tension isn't over—it's just entering a new phase. The masquerade ball is coming, Lily has to perform in front of nobles while hiding her condition, and if the potions fail or someone discovers the truth about their source... the whole delicate ecosystem could collapse. Scarlet's line 'I guarantee it. This potion will bring innovation to the market' sounds confident but it's also a bet. A big one. And Aaron's bet on Lily is the riskiest of all. Asking someone who's spent their life feeling inadequate to stand in front of powerful people and speak about themselves publicly? That's terrifying. But watching her hesitate and then nod anyway—that's where the real stakes live. Not in battles or drama, but in a frail girl choosing to trust someone enough to be seen.
... Read More
'Don't make such expressions in front of me.' ''Then what expression should I make?'' ''I'd like you to speak without smiling.'' ...I'm dead. This exchange is so much. Scarlet, who we've established has this genuinely warm but slightly flustered dynamic with Aaron, literally gets put off balance by a smile. And then she BLUSHES. Like full tomato face. Meanwhile Aaron is over here using warmth as a calculated tool — 'Since senior gave good words, I unconsciously smiled' — and Scarlet falls for it so hard she can't even maintain her composure. The chemistry between them isn't explosive or dramatic; it's this quiet, almost domestic tension where one person is strategically kind and the other is genuinely touched without fully understanding why. What's interesting is the power dynamic flip. In every other relationship Aaron has, he's either the unknown quantity or the dangerous prodigy. With Scarlet, he's just... someone who cleaned up a cafeteria mess and got praised. That normalcy seems to disarm her more than any grand gesture would. And Aaron knows it. That line 'Since you're someone working for me, I have to take care of you, right?' — surface level sounds like duty, but read it again and it's something softer, something almost tender. Scarlet's reaction tells you everything.
... Read More
I keep going back to how distinctly each character sounds in this text, and I want to highlight a few moments. Aaron's voice as narrator is sharp and observant but never pretentious. Lines like 'I couldn't understand why she was looking with those eyes' while referring to Lily's sparkly expressions—there's a warmth there that isn't forced. And his internal commentary about the potion scheme being like a game? That's a specific kind of intelligence, someone who sees systems and patterns but also enjoys the chess match. Scarlet's dialogue is where it gets interesting. She switches registers constantly—business mode with Lily ('There's no one here who isn't assigned an important task'), flustered deflection with Aaron ('What a nonsensical question'), and then full commanding presence when addressing Tristan ('I guarantee the potion's performance'). That range tells us everything about who she is without the author needing to describe it. The supporting characters aren't forgotten either. Lily's earnest 'I must deliver this!' to the butlers showed her growth arc in three lines. And Tristan's coughing interruptions mid-speech? Brutal storytelling choice that makes you feel his desperation without a single exposition dump. The product descriptions Aaron creates are also a vocal fingerprint—those clinical, detailed potion effect blocks feel like they come from someone who takes their craft seriously. It contrasts nicely with the more emotional dialogue around them.
... Read More
There's this recurring theme of things being hidden that I can't stop thinking about. Scarlet's mana circulation problem was literally invisible—she looked fine on the surface, just 'bad at magic,' but underneath there was a whole hereditary blockage that no one saw. Aaron is the only one who could read it, and that's kind of the whole metaphor, isn't it? People misjudging others because they can't see past the surface. Then there's Lily—frail, sickly-looking, constantly apologizing for existing. She's hiding her condition not just from the world but from herself. 'I'm just an ordinary person' isn't modesty, it's internalized shame. And Aaron sees through that too, not by reading a status window but by recognizing that someone who needs help the most often deserves to be seen the most. The potion business itself is built on concealment. Scarlet explicitly says: 'It's a strategy to maintain anonymity and increase the product's value.' Scarcity = worth. But there's an irony here—the more hidden the creator is, the more the work speaks for itself. The potions succeed on their merit, not on a celebrity name attached to them. It's almost a critique of how we value things in this world. And the sleep potion itself is symbolic in a way I didn't expect. Sleep is the great equalizer—you can't fake it, you can't bluff your way through exhaustion. When Scarlet drinks it and finally sleeps, she's not the merchant heiress or the cursed Obier daughter or the girl who can't do magic. She's just... a person who got to rest. The potion strips away all her identities and gives her back something basic and human. That's why she comes back softer, isn't it? Because for the first time in forever, she wasn't performing.
... Read More
'I made a potion. I made a sleep bomb.' — three words that changed everything. The protagonist's narrative voice is what makes this book work, honestly. It's casual, self-deprecating, and razor-sharp all at the same time. He's the kind of narrator who can make you laugh out loud and then immediately follow it with something genuinely unsettling. Right after describing his triumphant survival, he's internally panicking about whether he made the right deal with Allegri. That tonal whiplash is intentional and it's what makes him feel so real. Let me highlight a few moments where the dialogue and internal narration are doing incredible work: When Allegri asks how he made the potion, the protagonist's response is almost dismissive: 'I used mandragora root and chrysanthemum steeped water.' Casual. Barely a thought. But the reader knows exactly how much terror was involved in those three seconds of decision-making. The gap between his outward calm and inner chaos is where the humor lives. And then there's the scene where Allegri's reaction shifts from disbelief to genuine interest. The professor's dialogue is appropriately academic — formal, measured, full of questions. But the protagonist's responses are deliberately minimal. 'Yes.' 'So I added lard.' 'Water and oil don't mix.' Each answer is a complete thought delivered like a hammer strike. This contrast between the professor's verbose enthusiasm and the protagonist's terse precision creates a dynamic that's both funny and compelling. The protagonist's internal monologue is where his voice really shines though. Lines like 'Grad students are no different from slaves! Run like a dog when the professor calls, go wherever told... I'm at the point where alcohol might give me liver cancer!' are pure comedic gold, but they're also character-building. We learn about his past, his fears, his coping mechanisms — all in a single breathless thought. Even the narrator's framing choices reveal personality. The occasional use of rhetorical questions, the self-interruptions ('Could I make something with this? Before that thought fully formed, hurriedly dumped...'), the parenthetical asides — these all create a voice that feels like someone talking directly to you, like you're sitting across from them at a café and they're passionately explaining something they just experienced. The author also does something clever with how the protagonist addresses the reader indirectly. There's an implicit conversation happening — he's explaining things to us as he figures them out, which makes the exposition feel natural rather than forced. When he describes the sleep bomb's mechanics, we're learning alongside him, not being lectured at. One thing I really appreciate is how the protagonist's voice evolves as the story progresses. At the start, he's mostly reactive — startled, confused, scrambling. By the negotiation scene, he's already shifted into strategy mode. His internal voice becomes more calculated, more deliberate. The casual humor is still there, but it's tempered by a growing awareness that he's not just playing a game anymore. Every word matters. Every decision has consequences. This narrative voice is going to carry a lot of weight throughout the story, and I'm genuinely excited to see how it develops. The foundation is solid.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely relentless and I have zero complaints. Let me break down why it works so well. It opens at MAXIMUM tension — Aaron standing before a room full of hostile professors, steam rising from a mysterious potion, seven to three odds against him. You're leaning forward, wondering if he'll actually pull this off. And he does, but not through brute force. Through BARGAINING. That's the first breath of relief. Then—cut to Tay outside the auditorium. Sudden shift. Are they fighting? Is there drama? Nope. He just wants something. The tension deflates beautifully, almost subverting expectations, and then immediately reloads when he reveals WHY he needs the potion. Lily. The stakes go from academic debate to human life in one beat. That's skilled pacing right there. Lily's blood-coughing scene is the emotional peak — quick, brutal, unavoidable. You gasp, you feel the horror, and then... the potion works. Relief floods in. She's fine. She's smiling. She says she could fly. The emotional arc completes in what feels like seconds but carries enormous weight. And THEN — just as you're still riding that high — Aaron pivots to BUSINESS. 'I felt something from this process today.' From saving a dying girl to plotting commercial distribution in the same paragraph. The pacing doesn't let you rest, and honestly? I respect it. The author knows exactly when to speed up and when to let a moment breathe. The transition from the intimate Herbology room to meeting Scarlet Obier feels natural too. It's not jarring — it's the logical next step. Aaron solved one problem, now he's solving the next. The chapter ends on a note of ambition and potential rather than closure, which is perfect because the story is clearly expanding outward. If I had one tiny note: the scene with the professors felt slightly rushed compared to the Lily treatment, but that's a minor observation. The overall structure — confrontation, resolution, personal stake, emotional payoff, new ambition — is textbook perfect pacing.
... Read More
'It might be better to drink it anyway.' That line hit me harder than it should have. Just that tiny admission from Scarlet—someone who'd spent years being told she was useless, someone carrying the weight of her family's expectations alone—who was actually just tired. So tired she'd swallow something made by a guy she barely trusted because maybe, just maybe, it would let her rest. I kept coming back to that image of her in bed, feeling that 'strange floating sensation,' and then the next morning waking up genuinely refreshed. There's something almost sacred about it. For someone who hasn't slept soundly in who-knows-how-long, that first good night's sleep isn't just physical—it's emotional relief so deep you don't even realize how much you were drowning until you surface. And Aaron, of all people, gets it. He says 'As someone who had suffered from insomnia, I could empathize with the emotion she was feeling.' Not pity, not condescension—just 'I know what that feels like.' That moment of recognition between two people who understand what it's like to lie awake staring at the ceiling, that's the kind of quiet emotional beat that sticks with you. But then—then the whole thing escalates. Scarlet trying her magic for the first time properly, that flame orb growing larger than herself, and her eyes literally sparkling. She almost jumps for joy like a child. The girl who'd been mocked relentlessly, who'd been told she was forcing herself through academy just to burn family money—she's standing there with this enormous fireball and you can see every ounce of suppressed hope finally breaking through. She's not just using magic correctly; she's feeling what it's like to not be broken. That scene made my chest ache in the best way.
... Read More
I need to talk about Professor Allegri because honestly he is the most human character in this whole section. Here's a guy who dreamed of becoming a professor, gets his life ruined by the Ariadne incident, goes reclusive—yet somehow still shows up, still cares enough to wipe his sweat and help a first-year student dispose of a man-eating plant. That's commitment. And then Aaron, who just secured his safety and materials, immediately starts deflecting any real acknowledgment of what they went through. The line 'Thanks to you, I disposed of it smoothly. Thanks to you, I can get through this without issues'—it's performative gratitude, and Allegri knows it but pretends not to. Their dynamic is this weird mentor-student thing where neither is really stepping into the role properly. Allegri keeps asking if Aaron can really not use magic like he's searching for some kind of hope, some reason this kid isn't just another tragedy. And Aaron? He uses him. Gently, I'll give him that. He's not cruel. But he's strategically distant. When Allegri offers him the research assistant position, the immediate 'No' is telling. Aaron doesn't want to be tied down to anyone—he's playing a solo game here. And yet I found myself rooting for Allegri anyway, just hoping this guy gets some peace.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or