His White Moonlight Turned Out to be Me - Reviews

His White Moonlight Turned Out to be Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The stakes in this section are quiet but devastatingly high, and that's what makes it so effective. On the surface, nothing dramatic happens. Two guys walk and talk. But look closer. Su Yuanjiu has been deliberately NOT revealing himself as the composer of that song. Why? What does he stand to lose? The power dynamic between them is already skewed — Xu Yu is the artist, Su Yuanjiu is the producer, and neither has fully acknowledged what the other means to them beyond that professional frame. When Xu Yu watches the vlog, he's consuming a version of Su Yuanjiu that feels intimate but isn't. He's emotionally invested in someone who may not even know he exists on this level. That's a different kind of stakes — not life-or-death, but heart-or-no-heart. And Su Yuanjiu's choice to move back to Yunhe Lake? 'It's a bit complicated.' He won't explain. But the fact that he's choosing to re-enter THIS space, where Xu Yu lives, where they already collided once — that's him walking toward something he can't quite name. The tension isn't in explosions, it's in restraint. Every unspoken thing between them is a stake being placed on the table.
... Read More
Let me talk about the electric chemistry between Xu Yu and Su Yuanjiu because WOW. The way the author writes Su Yuanjiu's behavior during that interview is absolutely delicious. While everyone else is asking normal questions, Su Yuanjiu is just... watching Xu Yu. The text specifically notes he adjusted his suit once, picked up a pen twice, wrote once, looked at his phone three times—and the rest? Staring. Polite staring, sure, but the fact that Xu Yu noticed this so clearly in his peripheral vision tells us everything about how intense this gaze was. You don't miss that kind of attention. And Xu Yu! He's experienced in interviews—'he had experienced numerous similar meetings and handled them with ease'—but something about this situation throws him off. He doesn't just recognize Su Yuanjiu; he immediately closes the door and retreats. That's not normal interview nerves. That's personal history, unresolved tension, maybe even some hurt or confusion from that party encounter. But Su Yuanjiu? He doesn't act hurt or awkward at all. When he walks out and approaches them in the hallway, there's this quiet confidence. 'May I know your name now?'—that line hits different because it implies he already knew Xu Yu's name before but chose not to use it during the interview. He was playing some kind of game, observing from a distance, and now he's claiming this interaction for himself. Yun Jie is this fantastic foil character too. She's the energetic, superstitious manager who believes in fist bumps and lucky moments. But she's also perceptive—she spots Su Yuanjiu immediately and understands the significance. Her reactions (the sleeve tugs, the whispered explanations, the car scream) give us an outside perspective on how absurdly important this situation is. What I love most is how neither Xu Yu nor Su Yuanjiu actually says much about their history. We only know that Su Yuanjiu was 'awkward' at a party and hit on Xu Yu. But the way he watches him during the interview, the way he initiates conversation in the hallway, the fact that he insists on walking to the elevator together—this is someone who's been thinking about this moment. The relationship feels charged with unspoken history, and I can't wait to see where it goes.
... Read More
There's something almost clinical about how the author writes this scene that makes it hit harder. You've got the medical kit opening, the bottle of water, iodine, cotton swabs, gauze—all these sterile objects stacked against the very human mess of Xu Yu biting his lip and gripping Yun Jie's arm. The setting isn't described in lush detail, which I actually think is the right call. You don't need to know what the location looks like when the camera is already zoomed in on knees and hands and blood. What stays with me is the silence after everyone disperses. 'Now, only Su Yuanjiu, Yun Jie, and Xu Yu remained.' That's it. Three people, one injured leg, and the entire chapter pivots on the space between those three. Later in the car, the author gives us Yun Jie stomping her feet and Xu Yu silently looking at his phone—same location, completely different energy. The world of this story feels lived-in because the spaces between big events are where the real texture lives.
... Read More
I keep coming back to this idea of reflection—literal and metaphorical—throughout these chapters. Xu Yu can't look at himself in mirrors. His face keeps changing. He borrowed money from his brother to pay off some penalty, presumably related to abilities he never wanted. And now JSS wants him as a male lead in commercials, meaning he'll be reflected on screens for the whole world to see. The Su Yuanjiu viral video is another layer of this mirror motif. A man becomes famous through being watched, edited, re-edited, turned into content for other people's consumption. And Xu Yu is about to step into that same machinery. The parallel is almost too on-the-nose, except the author isn't being heavy-handed about it—they're letting the imagery speak for itself. Zheng Xue's crush on Xu Yu's brother adds another dimension. It's about wanting someone you can never truly have, about performing acceptance when you're actually devastated. 'After hearing it twice, he helped Xu Yu make the decision directly.' That sentence contains an entire tragic arc—self-acceptance, resignation, and the painful clarity that comes from being loved by someone who doesn't love you back. The contract itself is symbolic too. Xu Yu is signing away something, whether he understands it yet or not. The 'poor performance' joke from Yun Jie isn't just comic relief—it's prophecy. What happens when your face changes every day and you have to perform in front of cameras? When your voice keeps shifting and you're expected to sing? The contracts, the mirrors, the performances—they all connect to this central question: what does it cost to be seen, and what parts of yourself do you have to lose along the way?
... Read More
Okay so this entire chapter sequence is built around one simple premise—two people going to a job interview—but the author twists it into something way more interesting than that. Let me break down why this works so well. First, there's the setup. Yun Jie gets this phone call about JSS, and you can feel her excitement immediately. She's the kind of manager who believes in superstitions and fist bumps before important meetings. That's charming character work, but it also sets up the emotional tone—they need this win. The author doesn't spend much time on exposition though; we just know contract termination is coming and this ad deal could smooth their path forward. Quick, efficient, moves the story along. Then comes the meeting room moment—which is honestly one of the best plot reveals I've read recently. Xu Yu walks in, sees someone, immediately steps back, and closes the door. What? Why? The reader is instantly hooked. And then his explanation—that this is the guy who hit on him awkwardly at a party a few nights ago—adds this layer of personal history that makes the scene feel lived-in and real. It's not just a business meeting; it's a collision of past and present. But here's where the plot really elevates itself: Yun Jie drops the bomb about Su Yuanjiu being the founder and owner of JSS. That's a classic misdirection—the reader thinks they're dealing with some middle-manager interviewer, but the actual boss was sitting quietly in the corner the whole time. And then the reunion in the elevator? Chef's kiss. Su Yuanjiu doesn't just acknowledge Xu Yu; he initiates the entire interaction, asks for his name properly this time, and insists on walking together. The power dynamics are completely flipped from what we expected. The ending leaves us with Yun Jie freaking out in the car—that scream she lets out tells us everything. This isn't just a successful interview; it's something much bigger. The plot has shifted from a straightforward career move into something more personal and complicated. I'm genuinely curious what Su Yuanjiu's intentions are and how this changes everything for Xu Yu.
... Read More
'Put in your best effort.' That's it. That's the line. Three words spoken into a phone, half a world away from the person he's protecting, and it contains more emotional weight than entire chapters of worse-written books. What I love about Su Yuanjiu's voice is that he barely says anything at all. Look at how he speaks throughout this whole passage — short, clipped, almost dismissive on the surface: "No need, go to the living room." "Then it's yours." "Let's continue later." But he MEANS all of it. He's giving Xu Yu the Lego, he's cooking him a full meal, he's refilling his soup, and when he finds out someone is trying to humiliate Xu Yu on national television? He doesn't hesitate. Doesn't make a speech. Just walks into a soundproof room and says 'Put in your best effort' like ordering dinner. That's the voice. That's the whole character. The author never lets him explain himself — we're supposed to READ the love in what he DOES, not what he SAYS. And Xu Yu? His dialogue is softer, more self-doubting. 'What was I doing just now? Getting mad at Su Yuanjiu? What was I thinking?' He's always circling back, questioning his own reactions. Their voices perfectly complement each other — he's all quiet certainty, Xu Yu is all anxious spiraling. Together they're devastating. The writer also has this incredible sense of humor buried in the mundane. Xu Yu writing a 'Concert Ticket Voucher, Valid Forever' and then internally panicking about how childish it is — 'What was wrong with him today?' — that's the kind of character voice that makes you fall in love with a book in five seconds flat.
... Read More
I've been thinking about the recurring motif of confined spaces in these chapters and it's honestly kind of brilliant. The makeup chair. The elevator. The car. Each one is a smaller and more private enclosure than the last, and Xu Yu is progressively more trapped in them with Su Yuanjiu. It's almost like the author is building a pyramid of intimacy through architecture. But the thing I keep coming back to is the HAIR CLIP. The XY initials. The makeup artist asks about it casually, Xu Yu says he just bought it because he liked it, but we KNOW — or at least Suspect — that this isn't true. It's a token from someone. A piece of clothing he keeps near his face, holding back his hair, close to his skin. And then he hands it to Yun Jie on the set like it's nothing, like it's just an accessory. But the fact that it survived two years without replacement tells us it means something. There's also the contrast between Xu Yu's public and private self that runs throughout. On set, he's the polished idol — confident, camera-ready, professional. But the moment Su Yuanjiu enters the frame, that mask slips. "Whenever Xu Yu's gaze shifted towards the computer, his expression became evasive." That's not professionalism failing; that's someone who can't maintain composure when the person they're complicated about is watching. And the music room! The soundproof room where Xu Yu practices alone — that's his sanctuary, his true self. No cameras, no audiences, just him and the music. It's interesting that Su Yuanjiu never gets to see that version of Xu Yu yet. He sees the public product, the carefully curated idol. But Xu Yu's real voice lives behind that closed door.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how the author set up this entire fan-culture subplot and I did NOT see it coming until it hit me like a truck? So you have Yun Jie casually mentioning Kapow Network, and Xu Yu acting like this is the first he's hearing of it. But here's the thing—he actually DID search for Su Yuanjiu's vlog. He just didn't watch it. That detail is so telling. He's curious enough to look it up, but apparently not curious enough to actually see what the internet has made of him. Meanwhile Yun Jie is over here losing it because apparently Su Yuanjiu dominates every editing project on that site. Like, he's not just popular, he's algorithmically unavoidable. Then there's the whole "White Moonlight" fan club name reveal. His own cousin started the trend, fans latched onto it, and now they're calling themselves White Moonlight because they want to believe they live in his heart. Xu Yu laughs and asks if they can really do that, and I'm sitting here like—sir, you literally already sent him your song. You're already there. The question is whether Su Yuanjiu knows. The competition subplot is lurking underneath all of this too. The show details, the rehearsal schedule, Yun Jie dreaming about Xu Yu's concert—all of it is building toward something. But the real plot twist here isn't on stage, it's off it. The narrative has already rewritten their relationship in the digital world, and our protagonist is blissfully unaware.
... Read More
I need to sit with the dream scene for a minute. Xu Yu actually built the Lego set after talking about Legos with Su Yuanjiu—that detail alone is devastating in its subtlety. He doesn't build Legos on a whim. He completes something that Su Yuanjiu mentioned, and then he dreams about Su Yuanjiu cooking for him, and then somehow on the couch, and then Su Yuanjiu calls him "Little" in a way that leaves nothing to the imagination but also everything to the imagination. The vagueness is the point. The author could have gone explicit but chose instead to tell us all he remembered was the voice. That restraint hits harder than any graphic description would. And then the next morning—waking up startled, body reacting before his brain catches up, the embarrassment rolling in like a tide. "What's wrong with you?" he asks himself, and honestly who wouldn't ask that? This isn't just attraction. This is someone who has spent who-knows-how-long convincing himself he doesn't feel this way, and his subconscious has filed a formal objection. The WeChat exchange afterward where they casually share their apartment numbers is almost casual enough to not matter, except it matters enormously. Two men in the same building who have never been more physically or emotionally exposed to each other, pretending this is no big deal. My heart cannot handle this slow burn.
... Read More
This chapter operates on two different time scales simultaneously. The first half—Xu Yu discovering Su Yuanjiu through videos—moves at internet speed: click, scroll, watch, repeat. The ten-second challenge accelerates further; the countdown structure mirrors the reader's impatience. Each numeral on screen becomes a beat. Then the dream disrupts linear time entirely. It unfolds slowly, almost languidly, with stargazing and grass and a kiss that lingers past the waking moment. Xu Yu's morning afterward drags—half an hour on the balcony, strumming guitar, deleting the video. The author lets these moments breathe instead of rushing to the next plot point. The call to Zheng Xue arrives like an exhalation. Their conversation has a different rhythm—natural pauses, interruptions, food being eaten between lines. When Xu Yu reveals the contract termination, the pacing tightens momentarily, then relaxes again as Zheng Xue eats quickly and asks about the songs. The chapter ends not with a cliffhanger but with a question mark hovering over Xu Yu's choice: which song for the show? Two recorded tracks. One decision that will determine how he presents himself publicly. The author trusts the reader to feel the weight of that silence.
... Read More
There's a reason the wound keeps appearing in these chapters, and it's not just plot convenience. Xu Yu's scraped knee is the physical manifestation of something much deeper — the accumulated injuries of a life spent navigating broken relationships, familial rejection, and the slow erosion of trust. Let me start with the most obvious symbol: the wound itself. It's bandaged, healing, but not fully recovered. The author makes sure we see it from multiple angles — Zheng Xue observing it, Xu Yu photographing it, Su Yuanjiu studying it on a screen at midnight, Chen Jinping providing the medical perspective. Each person sees something different in that wound. Zheng Xue sees drama potential. Xu Yu sees embarrassment. Su Yuanjiu sees an opportunity to care. Chen Jinping sees a medical case that shouldn't be handled at midnight. The wound becomes a Rorschach test for everyone's relationship with Xu Yu. But the deepest symbolism is in that three-way corridor intersection. Three passages meeting at a single point, and Xu Yu literally walking through it. Two brothers — one blood, one choice — and he's caught between them. Xu Sheng represents the family he was born into, the obligations and resentments that come with biology. Su Yuanjiu represents the family he's choosing, the connections he's building through vulnerability and mutual care. The corridor doesn't force him to choose; it simply provides the space where the choice becomes visible. There's also the recurring motif of avoiding elevators and special access. Xu Yu deliberately chooses not to use Su Yuanjiu's connections for the reshoot. He wants to earn his place through normal channels, to not be indebted. This speaks to a larger theme about autonomy versus dependency — can you build genuine connection without power imbalances? Is receiving help always a compromise of dignity? The author seems to be asking these questions without providing easy answers. The television show angle — "My Song, Your Song" — is worth examining too. Xu Yu doesn't plan to watch his own episode. He's performing his art but refusing to witness it. There's something profoundly sad about that, and it connects to the broader theme of self-perception versus external perception. How do you know yourself when you're always performing for others? And then there's the water imagery that keeps surfacing subtly. Melon seeds being chewed and spat out, the dampness of a healing wound, the midnight hours that feel like a liminal space between wakefulness and sleep. Water as both cleansing and corrosive — the same force that heals wounds can also erode the foundations beneath them. The chapter structure itself mirrors the thematic content. We move from domestic scenes (Zheng Xue's apartment) to professional spaces (the filming location) back to transitional spaces (the car ride). Home, work, transit — the three zones of modern existence, and Xu Yu is always moving between them, never fully settling in any single one. That restlessness is the thesis of these chapters.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the imagery in this section and what it's really saying about Xu Yu's situation. The Anding Building display is described as something you can see whenever he looks up from his documents — a constant presence hovering over his late-night work, the same work that was probably part of why his contract felt like a cage in the first place. But now it's different. The message isn't a demand or a schedule or a reminder of obligations; it's a celebration. And the fact that it glows red, brighter than the stars, during the night hours — that's symbolic in a way the author probably intended even if unintentionally. Red in Chinese culture means luck, celebration, joy. The city lights coming on around them as spring continues, the sunlight on the day of termination being gentle rather than harsh — the external world is responding to his internal shift. The most powerful symbolic moment though is probably the contract termination itself happening on a day with perfect weather. It's almost cliché if it weren't so effectively understated. He walks out of the main entrance, hands in his pockets, watching the lawyers drive away. Three years of captivity ending with him just... standing there in the spring sun. The contrast between the constrained, document-filled nights before and this open, bright afternoon is the theme of the entire section distilled into one image: freedom isn't always dramatic. Sometimes it's just walking out of a building and deciding to get hotpot.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or