His White Moonlight Turned Out to be Me - Reviews

His White Moonlight Turned Out to be Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's something really special about how the author uses ordinary spaces to carry emotional weight. We start on a walking path—just a path!—and somehow it becomes this charged corridor where Xu Yu notices Su Yuanjiu looking up at his head, where the question about Xiao Xuyu opens up a whole layer of hidden life (the studio upstairs, the Lego set waiting in silence). The author keeps these moments grounded in physical space. Su Yuanjiu taking a step back when he realizes he's asking too many questions? That tiny spatial gesture—physically creating distance to respect an emotional boundary—says more than paragraphs of internal monologue could. Then the elevator scene. Xu Yu alone in an elevator, the most claustrophobic of modern spaces, and that's when the realization hits: he forgot to mention his apartment number and Su Yuanjiu somehow already knew. He messages it immediately. The elevator, the private entrance at JSS, the makeup room mirror where he sneaks glances at Yun Jie—all of these are liminal spaces, thresholds between one self and another. The filming location itself becomes a stage where his composure literally collapses. The concrete floor, the sand on his scraped hands, the crowd of crew members closing in—it's vividly cinematic, and I kept mentally casting the scene like I was watching it unfold on screen.
... Read More
The pacing here is actually remarkable for what it accomplishes in roughly ten thousand characters. The author takes us through four distinct emotional beats without a single wasted moment. First, the show itself—handled almost entirely in summary. We get the result (Xu Yu last place, rival first place) and move on immediately because the point isn't the competition, it's the aftermath. Then the backstage explosion—Yun Jie's three-minute curse session provides comic relief and emotional catharsis while also establishing that yes, this system is corrupt and yes, everyone knows it. The rain scene is the structural pivot point. Everything slows down here. The noise stops, the rain starts, and we get the Su Yuanjiu messages—the quietest, most important moment in the entire chapter. Then Ji Zhouchuan appears and the energy shifts again. This character encounter is perfectly placed because it comes right after the emotional low point and functions as a natural lift. Xu Yu was down, then his crush shows interest, now the mood has lightened and Yun Jie can actually reflect rationally on the situation. The next morning transition back to Lincheng is abrupt by design—we don't need the travel sequence, we need the song release. And the song release chapter is structured exactly like a tennis match between hope and anxiety: Xu Yu sends to two people casually, hesitates with Su Yuanjiu, overthinks his phrasing, checks notifications, gets replies, and finally the emotional resolution lands. Each section serves the next. Nothing drags.
... Read More
These chapters are structured like a conversation that keeps derailing itself—and that's exactly what makes them so effective. The author starts with what seems like a casual hangout between friends, drifts into gossip about viral videos and shipping culture, then pivots to contract business, and somewhere along the way, everything starts to feel deeply wrong without anyone in the scene being able to articulate why. The transition from the bar conversation to the JSS contract signing is where the real masterstroke happens. We spend several paragraphs with Zheng Xue talking about internet culture, about Su Yuanjiu, about Kapow network ships—all of it seemingly random filler. But it's not. It's all building toward the revelation that Xu Yu is being drawn into the same world of performance and public scrutiny that Su Yuanjiu already inhabits. By the time we reach the makeup room, everything clicks into place. The chapter endings are particularly well-handled. Instead of big cliffhangers or action set pieces, the author uses these small, quiet moments of disorientation. Xu Yu realizes his face has changed. He can't recognize himself. The makeup artist reaches for his hair. These are the kind of beats that don't scream for attention but instead lodge themselves in your brain and won't leave. And the jump cuts! We go from 'three days later' to 'a few days later' to the actual meeting without much transition. It mirrors how life actually feels when something major is happening—you don't get chapter markers or dramatic pauses, you just keep moving forward while everything beneath the surface is falling apart. The structure itself becomes a reflection of Xu Yu's experience.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say first—this chapter is a masterclass in slow-burn escalation, and I am NOT okay. The author basically plays with tension like a violinist plays a bow, and I am here for it. The whole thing starts with Xu Yu watching these fan-made videos of himself, right? All these twenty-second clips of him saying "Gege" to different people, and he's just sitting there trying to process what people see in him. That's already a fascinating psychological beat. But then—AND THEN—he goes downstairs for beef balls, comes back under that orange sunset with tofu-like clouds (I need those words in a novel forever), sees Su Yuanjiu at the pavilion, and the whole energy shifts. The most stunning plot turn? Su Yuanjiu asking him to stop calling him "President Su." Like. After everything that's built up between them—the car ride awkwardness, the unspoken thing hanging in the air this entire arc—Su Yuanjiu just drops this quiet little request and Xu Yu's entire world tilts. He tries "Su..." and then shakes his head because it doesn't feel right. He literally doesn't know how to bridge this gap between professional distance and whatever this is becoming between them. And Su Yuanjiu laughing awkwardly and coughing sorry? That is the most human moment I have ever read. The man who appears to have everything under control loses his composure over a damn title. The pacing here is absolutely perfect—the author doesn't rush it, doesn't over-explain, just lets the silence do the work. And Xu Yu's dream ritual of chanting "don't dream about Su Yuanjiu" three times before sleep? Chef's kiss. It frames everything. He's been fighting this thing in his head and the plot has been building toward exactly this kind of raw, unguarded moment ever since. This chapter is the pivot point I didn't know I needed.
... Read More
I am absolutely losing my mind over this one line. "Don't dream about Su Yuanjiu. Don't dream about Su Yuanjiu. Don't dream about Su Yuanjiu." Say it three times and it sounds like a spell, right? But it's not a spell to keep him away—it's a spell he's already under. And I love it. The whole texting scene is just... chef's kiss. Su Yuanjiu says "Call me" in person and then the very next day he's double-texting asking about the song. He says he's been looking forward to it since their chat. Xu Yu thought he was just being polite, but he wasn't. And the moment Xu Yu sends that recording and Su Yuanjiu replies "I'll cherish it"—I physically cannot. This is the kind of quiet, gentle romance that gets me every time. No grand gestures, no confessions under fireworks. Just a guy who actually wants to hear his friend sing, and another guy who sends a voice memo at 11pm because he can't sleep thinking about it. And then right after, Yun Jie drops the bomb about how on Kapow Network, Xu Yu is ALWAYS the shou in every single edit with Su Yuanjiu. Meanwhile Xu Yu is sitting there like "we're not close, we just ran into each other." SIR. THE INTERNET KNOWS. The readers know. Only our boy has no idea he's already someone's entire fantasy life. That dramatic irony is killing me.
... Read More
I have to address the dialogue in these chapters because the author has done something genuinely interesting with how these two men talk to each other. Their conversations are full of things unsaid, and the author trusts the reader to catch them. Look at the exchange where Su Yuanjiu asks Xu Yu about the elevator door jamming, and Xu Yu responds with something deliberately neutral, and then Su Yuanjiu says almost nothing, just a quiet yeah and a look, and suddenly the reader understands that both of them are feeling the exact same panic and neither will admit it. The author writes dialogue the way real people actually speak when they are trying not to reveal everything. Short sentences. Interrupted thoughts. Pauses that speak louder than paragraphs would. What I find remarkable is how each character has a completely distinct rhythm even when they are both being restrained. Su Yuanjiu speaks in measured, deliberate fragments, as if every word costs him something. Xu Yu, on the other hand, tends to deflect with humor or silence, and when he does get serious it is almost accidental, like the words slip out before he can catch them. Their dynamic has always lived in that gap between what Su Yuanjiu controls and what Xu Yu cannot contain. The author also does something wonderful with the secondary characters. When Yun Jie appears, her dialogue is sharp and fast and completely different in texture from the two leads. She is the only character allowed to be direct, which makes every moment she shares with Xu Yu feel like a relief valve releasing pressure. But the real achievement here is how the narration itself mimics their emotional state. In the quieter scenes, the prose becomes almost clinical, matching Xu Yu's tendency to intellectualize his feelings. When the emotions break through, the sentences themselves loosen and expand. The author is not just writing dialogue, they are writing psychology through syntax.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Su Yuanjiu because honestly this man is doing the most and I love it. He's sitting in his office at JSS building, watching these fan edits of some guy named Xu Yu on his tablet, and he's not even hiding it anymore. He re-watches the same video three times. He turns the barrage comments ON just to see what everyone else thinks. He searches Xu Yu's height because apparently 178cm is a big revelation. And then—plot twist—he casually messages Ji Zhouchuan like "Do you know Xu Yu?" as if he hasn't just spent twenty minutes deep-diving into this person's entire online presence. The way he registers on Kaoyou Network himself just to leave one comment that says "Cute"? That is such a specific energy. Like he could've just asked someone, but no, he wanted to do it himself. Also the Xiao Feng detail—she catches him smiling at his tablet right before a meeting and says nothing. Some coworkers would've said something. Xiao Feng just... lets it happen. I feel like we're going to see more of this dynamic. Is Su Yuanjiu going to actually meet Xu Yu? Is that the plan? Because messaging a mutual acquaintance to set up an intro after binge-watching someone's content feels like a strategy, not an accident.
... Read More
The opening act here is pure modern folklore—social media as plot device. Xu Yu discovers Su Yuanjiu through a series of increasingly intimate videos, and the author uses this as a deliberate narrative escalation. The cooking video draws attention, the ten-second challenge video locks him in, and then the dream sequence takes over completely. That progression from casual scroll to obsession to subconscious invasion is structurally tight. What struck me most is how the dream functions as a plot twist disguised as fatigue. Xu Yu tells himself it was "just a dream" three times, but the kiss he receives in it—Su Yuanjiu saying "close your eyes" in a deep voice—carries enough weight to derail his entire morning. The repetition of that phrase is telling; he's trying to convince himself, not just narrate. The subplot with the contract termination is interesting because it arrives like a second act turn. Xu Yu reveals he terminated his deal because Zhou Jie used fake relationships for publicity and harassed him when he refused private meetings. This reframes everything—the loneliness, the obsession with Su Yuanjiu's image, the way he downloads that video against his better judgment. He's been playing by someone else's rules for so long that catching genuine attention feels destabilizing. The show recording deadline adds a ticking clock. Three weeks until episode two airs. Yun Jie is pushing him to choose a song. That constraint gives the middle section momentum even when Xu Yu's sitting on a balcony strumming a guitar. The author knows when to let scenes breathe and when to tighten the screws.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely masterful and I want to dissect exactly why it works so well. We open with Su Yuanjiu in the car, listening to Xu Yu's song without identifying himself as the composer. That's an information delay — the reader knows, but Su Yuanjiu is withholding, and it creates immediate intrigue. Then we cut to Xu Yu's POV, going about his day, and only when he's walking home does the narrative begin to converge. The vlog sequence is where the pacing really shines. It's almost slice-of-life in its rhythm — cooking, shopping, coffee, silence. The author deliberately slows down here, making us experience the scene the way Xu Yu experiences it: absorbed, lingering, wanting it to never end. And then — BAM — 'Xu Yu locked his phone and put it in his pocket after watching.' The scene ends abruptly, like coming out of a dream. Then the meet-cute at the pond. Quick dialogue. Back and forth. And then the walk — which is where the pacing opens up again into something more expansive, more breathable. The author knows exactly when to tighten the screws and when to let the reader breathe. Every transition feels intentional.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about the Xu Yu and Su Yuanjiu dynamic because it is doing things to me. The entire emotional core of these chapters lives in a phone screen. Xu Yu waits three minutes outside in pouring rain, gets cursed at by his manager, encounters his music crush, and through all of that—the one moment where he actually smiles is when Su Yuanjiu texts him 'Duet or not, you're still excellent.' Just like that. The man doesn't even know the full situation and he still manages to be the person who makes Xu Yu feel better. But the real killer scene comes later when Xu Yu is about to send his new songs to Su Yuanjiu and he literally opens the chat history and reads Su Yuanjiu's 'always looking forward to it' message several times before sending anything. Several times. He was nervous about whether the enthusiasm was genuine or just polite. And then he overthinks the phrasing of his own message—'What is Mr. Su doing?'—wondering if it has some hidden implication that Su Yuanjiu wouldn't understand because the man doesn't even have Weibo. This is the most anxious, tender, painfully relatable thing I have ever read. The emotional stakes aren't about love confessions or dramatic revelations. They are about one person carefully curating their vulnerability and sending it into a void, hoping it lands. When Su Yuanjiu replies 'Yes' to 'Do you want to listen?' and then 'I'll listen right away'—that is the emotional climax of the entire chapter. No fireworks. Just someone showing up exactly when needed.
... Read More
There's a running thread of fear in this chapter that I don't think gets enough credit. Xu Yu is afraid of pain—he admits it (sort of), Yun Jie confirms it dramatically. He's afraid of ghosts—he sleeps with the lights on, apparently. He's afraid of people knowing how he really feels, because he immediately pulls his hand away from Su Yuanjiu like it was burned. And then there's the deeper fear underneath all of it: the fear of being seen as weak, of not being taken seriously, of being reduced to 'that guy who got hurt' instead of the talented musician Yun Jie says he wants to be known for. The injury itself works as this great metaphor because it's something that can't be faked away. You can pretend you're fine when you're standing, when you're performing, when you're in control. But once there's actual blood and someone's touching your wound, the performance falls apart. Su Yuanjiu sees through it immediately—not with pity, but with this quiet insistence thatXu Yu rest. 'We can't risk reopening the wound.' Is that just about the knee, or is it about something else too? The light imagery at the end is small but deliberate—Yun Jie mentions earlier that Xu Yu sleeps with the lights on, and now we're in a car with the door closed, private space, where he finally lets his guard down enough to laugh. Maybe the lights-on thing isn't just about ghosts. Maybe it's about the same thing that made him grab Su Yuanjiu's arm: the terror of being alone in the dark with your own thoughts.
... Read More
'May I know your name now?' 'Goodbye, Mr. Xu.' Haha, oh my gosh. Yun Jie's dialogue is genuinely hilarious. She mimics Su Yuanjiu's polite question with such delight, then adds the formal goodbye like she's replaying the scene for an audience of one. Her voice is high-energy, slightly exaggerated, always performing even when she's alone in a car. Compare that to Xu Yu's communication style. It's minimal but precise. 'Nothing much.' 'I can't tell you.' 'Okay.' 'Enough, Yun Jie.' He doesn't waste words. Even when he's explaining something personal—like the crossed-out letters on his guitar—he's concise: 'That is XY with a mistake in the middle that was crossed out.' No flourish, no explanation. Just facts. Su Yuanjiu's voice, though we only hear it through a phone call, matches this economy. 'This is my phone number.' 'Manager Chen will contact you.' 'We'll talk next time.' Three sentences, zero filler. The interview flashback showcases another voice entirely—the group dynamic where everyone choruses 'Yes, he can~' like a Greek chorus responding to Xu Yu's silent rebellion. The humor lands because the author gives each character a distinct speech pattern. Yun Jie performs. Xu Yu states. Su Yuanjiu commands.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or