The dialogue in this chapter is deceptively simple. On the surface, it reads like procedural workhorse writing—efficient, functional, moving the investigation forward. But if you listen closely, every line carries weight that has nothing to do with its literal meaning. The author trusts the reader to hear the subtext, and that's what makes this conversation feel so alive.
Take Fang Yuan's early lines. "Who do you think I am!" —that's not a genuine question. It's theatrical deflection, the kind of thing someone says when they've already been caught wanting to steal a case file and are trying to recover face. And Chen Xiaonuan's response, "Are you planning to steal their case?" —she's not accusing him; she's teasing him. The smirk in her narration tells us everything. This is the rhythm of people who know each other so well that a single question contains a whole history of previous attempts, previous scoldings, previous forgiveness.
Fang Yuan's retreat is perfect: "I was just saying… Just talking." The ellipsis does the work of showing his shame, his memory of past reprimands, the way he shrank from bravado to apology in two breaths. And Zhang Yibao's deadpan response—"Thanks for the incredibly useless clue" —followed by Fang Yuan's utterly unbothered "You're welcome" —this is comedy gold, but it's also character architecture. We learn who these people are through how they bicker.
But then the tone shifts, and the dialogue changes too. When Pei Qinghuai says "I feel a strange familiarity with this case, like it's trying to tell me something," his voice doesn't match the earlier casual banter. There's a gravity to it—a sense that he's reached something beneath the surface. And Cheng Ye's response, "Don't overthink it," is both care and command. He's protecting his colleague from his own intensity.
The forensic dialogue—the actual case discussion—is where the author earns their keep. "All girls, and they don't seem to be connected." "They're all pretty." These are the kind of lines that sound stupid until they aren't. Fang Yuan's joke about the victims being pretty seems like filler, but it's actually the hypothesis that will eventually crack the case. The author plants the seed disguised as comedy, which is a masterclass in structural economy.
Cheng Ye's phone call with Pei Qinghuai is a study in efficient characterization through dialogue: "You need to come back early, we have a new case." "Got it, I'll be back right away." Hang up. "No need to rush…" [already gone]. "That was quick." In six exchanges, we understand that Pei Qinghuai works alone, that he's surrounded by files in his own home, that he doesn't wait for permission, and that Cheng Ye has learned to accept this about him.
The final exchange—"Ten minutes before Li Yixin disappeared, she talked to a woman" —is almost clinical in its simplicity. No drama, no flourish. Just a fact dropped onto the table like a stone into still water. The reader and the characters alike feel the ripples before they see the depth.