Evil Mother - Reviews

Evil Mother
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The factory scene is probably the most Cinematic moment I've read in years. I don't even care if that sounds dramatic — it reads like a film director's shot list. Pouring rain. An abandoned factory. A woman standing over the body of the man who tried to save her child. Blood mixing with rainwater flowing down a dirt road. And this silent baby wrapped in a thin blanket being left at an orphanage on a chilly autumn night. The author doesn't need fancy descriptions because the images are already devastating. What struck me most is how the weather mirrors everything — the rain during Lin Kun's death, the chill of the night when the baby is abandoned, and then contrast that with the crystal chandelier in Jennie Yang's mansion where Liu Er lies on a sofa moments later. From abandoned factory to luxury living room in two paragraphs, and that transition tells you everything about how much of this world is built on hidden violence and erased history. The mansion feels sterile and cold despite its opulence, which makes perfect sense given what happened inside those walls metaphorically. Jennie Yang wiping away rain from her face is the exact same gesture as her wiping away the baby's existence — two acts of cleaning that are really acts of destruction.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this scene for a second. Meng Jin is out in the field, doing police work, very much in his element, and then this girl appears. Tang Xiaoguo. Small, delicate, always smiling, bright sunny energy. Meng Jin does that instant assessment thing—seven or eight out of ten—and for half a second I thought, okay, maybe this is actually going somewhere. He doesn't hate the idea. He's not opposed to getting to know her. And then Zhao Yunzhi says "Why haven't you left yet, Sis?" and the light just... goes out. Like a flickering bulb. She's RELATED to him. The metaphorical light goes out immediately. Meng Jin is done before it even started, and honestly? Same. I respect it. Don't mix work and personal life, period. But Zhao's situation is SO much worse. He's standing there flustered, clearly worried Meng Jin's going to chew him out for having his sister show up at a crime scene. And she's just... hovering. Asking about the victim's identity like she can't read the room. "Has the victim's identity been confirmed yet? That's not classified, right?" Zhao literally pleads with her to leave. "Sis, you should go now. Don't keep your date waiting." And there it is—she's on a blind date TOO. They're both set up today. The universe has a sense of humor. And then later, the body moving scene. Zhao is absolutely suffering, practically marching to his death pushing that stretcher, while Meng Jin just watches him suffer in silence. There's something almost tender about how Meng Jin pushes him, even if he's being harsh about it. Like, yeah, I scolded you but I'm still making sure you're here, still making sure you learn this. You think I WANT to be this mean? I didn't even mean to come out so harsh. Something about mixing his personal life with work just made everything fractious. I just... I want them to have a moment. One genuine moment where they're not captain and recruit but just two people trying to figure each other out. Please.
... Read More
Okay so this whole arc with the couriers is actually insane when you connect the dots. Meng Jin notices that Guo Tiandi worked as a delivery guy, and suddenly everything clicks—there was a courier who called Liu Tianshi before the murder, and another courier who delivered the photo of Lin Kun's murder to the police station. It's like the author is planting breadcrumbs and then suddenly pulling the rug out. I love how the plot keeps layering itself. And then the crazed reporter angle! At first you think he's just some attention-seeker doing a stunt for clout, but then it turns out Guo Tiandi actually asked him to approach Jennie Yang. But here's the thing that got me—Guo Tiandi explicitly told the reporter he didn't want media attention. Why would he ask for help AND then refuse publicity? That contradiction should've been a red flag, but even the reporter didn't catch it. And that ending... "A529"? Someone is manipulating Guo Tiandi from the shadows and he's completely oblivious. This plot is a maze and I'm obsessed.
... Read More
I need to talk about Li Feiya because she is the most complicated person in this whole mess. Here she is, this woman who apparently waited two years as Lin Kun's girlfriend, and when we finally meet her, she's mid-level management with a watch she keeps checking and thirty minutes to give us. She says the line that breaks everything open: 'Lin Kun never really liked me.' But then comes the twist—she wasn't just dumped, she was used. She spent two years taking heat from classmates, letting people think SHE was the one who rejected him when actually he rejected HER. And for what? 'I spent over two years as his shield, gaining nothing but a bad reputation in the end.' That bitterness still drips from her. She laughs it off, sure, but listen to her voice when she does it. Then the real gut-punch: she reveals he wasn't disgusted by her, he just wasn't interested in women at all. But here's what kills me—she catches him masturbating and suddenly her whole worldview implodes. She goes from thinking he's some perfect gentleman to questioning whether something is physically wrong with him. The shame she feels, the violation of trust... and yet she doesn't even report it. She just quietly investigates, asks doctors, becomes a detective in her own life. What kind of person stays with someone who doesn't want you, defends them publicly while privately crumbling? Maybe she was in love with the idea of him, not the man himself.
... Read More
There's a whole section about Long De's name blindness and I kept coming back to it. Here's a man with a photographic memory—remembers everything except names. His classmates get mad, call him “lacking in virtue” behind his back, and he just... absorbs it. The irony is almost poetic. He remembers facts but not the labels we use to define people. And then there's the dream. Meng Jin dreams of Long De mocking him, but in reality Long De never did. The dream is a symbol of Meng Jin's own self-sabotage—he's been punishing himself for years for a debt that was never owed. The youthful setbacks he's brooding over? They exist mostly in his head. “Everyone changes, only he remained stuck in place.” This line is the thesis of the entire emotional arc. Long De has westernized, matured, moved on. His aura is different. But Meng Jin is still the high school boy losing at tests, still checking his appearance in rearview mirrors, still competitive over a decade-old fixation. The child in Hosei Bing's womb is also symbolic—a future that exists before anyone has decided whether it should. It's potential life, vulnerability, something worth killing and hiding for. The murderer chose protection over vengeance. That's a thematic choice that suggests love or duty can be just as violent as hatred. I think this book is really about who gets to define the past… and who gets erased from it.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this author handles pacing because it's honestly impressive. We start in a morgue with an autopsy, transition to a car chase (kind of—Tang Xiaoguo tailing them), then to a high-stakes corporate building, and we're halfway through and already at the wife's doorstep. That's four distinct scene types packed into roughly ten chapters and it doesn't feel rushed at all. The author uses some really smart structural choices here. Notice how each scene ends on a question or revelation rather than a clean resolution? The torn photo makes us wonder. No missing person report makes us suspicious. The Wuling Hongguang following them creates ongoing background tension. Jennie Yang's coldness makes us question everything. Each mini-cliffhanger propels us forward without needing a massive action set piece. The dialogue-heavy scenes actually work in the pacing department too. The phone call between Meng Jin and Tang Xiaoguo—short, brutal, effective. Three sentences and the pursuer is neutralized. No filler. And then Zhao being completely blindsided by how his captain handled it? That's comedic timing that breaks the tension just enough before plunging right back in. What really sells the pacing is how the author knows when to slow down. Dr. Jin's examination of the body—she lingers on details like the gold teeth with actual excitement. That moment of专业化 enthusiasm grounds the scene before we speed right back into the investigation. It's like breathing. In, out, in, out. And by chapter 10 we're at the most dramatic confrontation yet. The author clearly understands that momentum doesn't mean rushing—it means never letting the reader settle.
... Read More
There is a scene in these chapters where Jennie Yang tiptoes downstairs at night and sees Liu Er standing in blood at the bottom of the stairs, and I have never felt so vividly cold in my entire reading life. Let me break down why this works so well. The author doesn't give us a long atmospheric description. What they give us is razor-sharp visual framing: two dim ceiling lights, darkness behind him, vague furniture outlines casting shadows. It reads like a crime thriller storyboard. And then the next beat — she recognizes him — and the chill deepens because the horror isn't a stranger. It's her own son. The rain earlier, when Liu Er was waiting for the delivery driver, sets this whole tone. Overcast skies, ten o'clock rain, the mundane act of buying food turning into the moment where a woman with a knife stands at someone's door. The world of this novel feels suffocatingly real — factory floors, suburban homes, stairwells, online delivery uniforms. There's nothing fantastical about it, which makes every violent act land with more weight. The scar on Guo Tiandi's arm, round like a five-cent coin, is another image that refuses to leave me. A coin dropped into fire, pulled out with tongs, burning a child's arm — it's almost too precise, too cinematic. The author knows how to use physical details as emotional landmines.
... Read More
I need to sit with Jennie Yang for a minute because this woman is... something else. She is the kind of antagonist who doesn't just oppose the protagonist, she OPPRESSES the very concept of goodness in the room. Let's look at what she did. She manipulated her own son into taking the blame for someone else's crime. Not because she had to. Not because she was cornered. But because she saw it as BALANCING A LEDGER. The text says it directly: "The debt of giving life was greater than the sky itself. She had given him life, and he owed her. Two years in prison to repay that debt—he wasn't losing out." This woman does not have a moral compass. She has an accounting spreadsheet and her son is a line item. And yet—AND YET—the narrative gives us this glimpse of her looking at the son she raised, the son she spoiled, feeling this urge to strangle him. Why? Because he reminds her of Guo Tiandi. The good, loyal child she abandoned. The one who would never have threatened her with her own weakness. She chose wrong. She built wrong. And now she's got a wolf she raised instead of the dog she wanted. That's not even a redemption arc. That's a tragedy she wrote herself. Then there's the Lin Kun connection, which adds another layer. Jennie claims Lin Kun told her everything about Li Feiya—that he shared intimate details, the red mole, the humiliation. Whether that's true or another manipulation is unclear, but it serves a purpose: it destroys Li Feiya's pride and reasserts Jennie's control over the narrative. Lin Kun is dead, his family is dead, and Jennie Yang is still pulling strings from somewhere. The relationship between Jennie and Guo Tiandi is the spine of this entire chapter. Everything else—the murders, the birth, the investigation—flows from the fact that this woman gave birth to a man she doesn't understand and then tried to sacrifice him. And he understood her so well that he turned her own scheme into proof that she was his mother. THAT is a mother-son relationship for the ages.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is surprisingly sparse but absolutely devastating in what it leaves out. Take Meng Jin's opening line: 'Guo Tiandi used to treat you well, but now he wants to abandon you, leave you behind. Is that right?' That's not just dialogue, that's surgery. He doesn't ask gently. He doesn't soften the blow. He rips the bandage off in one sentence and watches his friend finally crack. And Guo Yingying's response — 'It's not my brother's fault. I can only blame myself' — that's the voice of someone who has spent years internalizing trauma as personal failure. You don't need more words after that. What's striking is how little Guo Tiandi speaks in this entire passage. We learn about him through Guo Yingying's narration, through actions, through silence. When he asks her to get hair samples from Liu Er and Jennie Yang, he's 'vague in his explanation.' When she presses him after the DNA results, he gives an evasive answer. That vagueness IS his voice — a man who carries too much to put into words. The one piece of direct dialogue that stands out is Liu Er's assistant taking the blame and getting only a one-year sentence, and Liu Er himself escaping punishment by blaming everything on him. The injustice is crystallized in that simple detail — no dramatic monologue needed. And then there's that folk saying dropped into the narrative: 'A femme fatale brings disaster.' It's attributed to Liu Er himself, which makes it bitterly ironic. He's blaming Guo Yingying for his own destruction while simultaneously being the cause of it. The author's choice to put this traditional saying in the mouth of a desperate criminal adds this layer of dark commentary on how society already blames victims. Brilliant use of voice.
... Read More
The red maple tree isn't just a location marker. It's a symbol, and I think it's about visibility versus concealment. The killer could've buried this body anywhere—deep in the woods, far from paths, in a place nobody would go. But they chose the ONE tree that everyone stops to photograph. The tree that creates the most picturesque scene. The tree that draws the most eyes. Why? Because the killer didn't want the body hidden. They wanted it found. They wanted the investigation to start. There's something almost theatrical about that choice, like they're making a statement or sending a message to someone who will understand what the red tree means. And the wrapping—layers and layers of smooth plastic, no folds, no twists. The killer has experience. Professional-level care in how they prepared that body. But they didn't wrap it to preserve it. They wrapped it to protect themselves. To keep evidence away. To make sure that when the time came, nothing could be traced back. The expensive clothes tell another story. This dead man lived in luxury, and now he's in the dirt wearing millions in fashion that went completely untouched. The killer didn't want his money. They wanted HIM gone. And yet they dressed him like he was going somewhere important, like he deserved some dignity even in death. Zhao scrubbing his hands afterward, trying to remove two layers of skin, feels almost symbolic too. He wants to wash away the experience, wash away the contact, pretend he didn't push that stretcher or unzip that bag. But you can't wash away what you've seen. You carry it. Every good detective carries it. And Meng Jin standing statue-still while Zhao does all the work—that's not cruelty. That's someone who's already carried it, already seen it, already crossed that line and come back. He's asking Zhao to cross it too. That's the real burden of this profession.
... Read More
Let's talk about stakes because they are NOT subtle here. He Saibing is pregnant, missing, and was in contact with both the murder victim and Jennie Yang. That's not a conspiracy — that's a target on her back. And the fact that she disappeared the same day as the murder? That's not coincidence, that's survival instinct or worse. But the real tension comes from Jennie Yang's silence. She knew about He Saibing. She was meeting with her at the Jinyue Hotel. And when He Saibing vanished, Jennie Yang told the police NOTHING. Why? What is she protecting? The unanswered question is so much scarier than any confirmed answer could be. Meng Jin is walking into dangerous territory with this investigation. He needs Tang Xiaoguo's help but can't officially let her join — impersonating a police officer carries real penalties, and he knows it. So he's balancing legal boundaries against the urgency of the case, knowing that every delay gives the real culprit more time. "The case is what matters. Speak first" — he's trying to keep focus but the stakes are rising with every revelation. And Zhao Yunzhi! Poor guy is stuck chasing some easier murder case in the south of the city while the real heat is here. His eagerness to make a mark is almost tragic — he sees this as a promotion opportunity while the actual killer might still be out there. The suspense is maintained so effectively because we keep getting fragments of information — a pregnancy, a vanished woman, a hiding journalist — but never the full picture. Every answer creates three new questions and I am OBSESSED.
... Read More
There's this recurring obsession with masks in this section that I can't shake. Li Feiya wears a mask when she helps the boy on the street—literally covering her face. She wears the mask of the dutiful girlfriend to extract information. She wears the bureaucratic mask for Meng Jin the second her alarm goes off. And Lin Kun has been wearing his mask the entire time, hiding who he really is behind this fabricated family drama. The whole story feels like it's asking: what happens when the mask becomes the face? Then there's the Red Maple Tree—a celebrity tree, a cash cow, untouchable because touching it would destroy its value. But what IS it a symbol of? Something beautiful that everyone agrees not to examine too closely because the truth might ruin the illusion? Liu Tianshi's murdered son hanging in the background like an unanswered question. Blood types that can PROVE or DISPROVE lineage but only tell half the story when you don't know the mother's type. The story keeps showing us that truth is always incomplete, always filtered through what people refuse to look at. The garden won't let us date the tree. The blood test can't confirm paternity without the mother's data. Li Feiya can't stop herself from digging even after she says her love is dead. Everyone in this narrative is half-blind, seeing just enough to keep going but never enough to stop. That's the theme, isn't it? Not the pursuit of truth—but the refusal to accept partial truths as final answers.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or