Evil Mother - Reviews

Evil Mother
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Long De's voice because holy god, he is unforgettable after one scene. The narration literally says he speaks "like someone on triple speed." And the author doesn't just tell us this once—they make us experience it. Every paragraph of Long De's dialogue is a breathless cascade of logic, connected clauses, and rapid-fire deductions. You can hear him. Not metaphorically. I literally read that explanation about Killer One and Killer Two out loud and ended up gasping for air halfway through. And the contrast with Meng Jin is perfect. Meng Jin processes slower. He thinks in reactions, in feelings, in hunches. Long De thinks in systems. When Meng Jin says "imitation doesn't make sense," Long De doesn't just disagree—he reconstructs the entire framework of the argument in real time, addressing both of Meng Jin's points before Meng Jin even finishes thinking his second thought. The humor in this is also not accidental. Meng Jin's internal monologue about Long De's English being "also at triple speed" and his speculation about whether Long De could do German or Arabic just as fast? That's the author letting us breathe between the intensity. It's comic relief that also characterizes both men perfectly—Meng Jin deflects with humor, Long De operates on pure velocity. And the casual English phone call in the middle? The narrator doesn't even translate it. We're supposed to feel excluded. Meng Jin can't understand a word. We can't understand a word. It's a small moment of alienation that says everything about their world difference without a single exposition dump.
... Read More
There's a scene in this chapter that I keep coming back to, and it's not the most dramatic one. It's the moment Meng Jin and Zhao Yunzhi are crouched in the greenbelt, watching He Saibing's window, waiting for Liu Er to go upstairs before making their move. The voice-activated lights flick on in the stairwell, telling them where Liu Er is. This is surveillance, patience, procedure. And then everything explodes. The lights in He Saibing's room go out. A shadow at the window. A piercing scream. The two men take three steps at a time up the stairs. The door is shut tight. An eerie silence. Meng Jin presses his ear against it. Nothing. This is where the scene writing becomes almost cinematic. The author strips away everything unnecessary and leaves you with sensory fragments: darkness, silence, a locked door, a scream from somewhere unknown. When they kick the door in and Zhao Yunzhi flicks on the light, the reveal hits like a physical blow. Two bodies. Blood. Knives still gripped in their hands. The text tells us Zhao Yunzhi has never seen such carnage before and shudders. That detail matters—it grounds the horror in a specific character's experience rather than floating in abstraction. Then the screams continue, coming from the bathroom. Locked from the inside. He Saibing is in labor. The door won't budge because Meng Jin sprained his ankle kicking it open earlier. Zhao Yunzhi smashes a chair against the wood. The door flies open. She's on the floor. A pool of thick liquid beneath her. Water broken. Two clueless men who have to find birthing videos online and follow along while doctors guide them over the phone. The visual contrast between the crime scene and the birth scene is staggering. Blood and new life occupying the same space, the same apartment, the same moment. The setting stops being just a location and becomes a container for everything the story has been building toward. This isn't worldbuilding through description—it's worldbuilding through collision. The apartment holds the dead, the dying, the newborn, and the investigators all at once, and it feels impossibly alive.
... Read More
Let me be honest: the dialogue in this batch isn't what makes it work. It's the SILENCE. The things these characters DON'T say are doing far more narrative labor than any spoken line. Take Jennie's famous midnight exchange. The caller speaks zero words. Jennie answers with six: "Never contact me again if you want to stay alive." That's it. No name, no context, no elaboration. And yet this single line transforms the entire novel. We now understand that Jennie has a secret life, that she's communicated with someone before, that whatever arrangement she had with this person is fraying. The brevity is devastating. This is dialogue as ice pick. Zhao Yunzhi's lines are functional, grounded, almost documentary — which perfectly suits his role as investigator. "Someone's definitely lying." That's the kind of line that doesn't try to be clever; it tries to be true. And it works because the scene around it does the heavy lifting. But Li Zizi's dialogue is where the author shows real range. The Shen Kuo bedroom scene is pure stream-of-consciousness provocation — lewd questions, casual lies, a complete disregard for consequences. "Hey, tell me the truth, could he get it up when he was with you?" This is such a specific voice, so unselfconscious and brutally materialistic, that it instantly separates Li Zizi from every other character in the book. She doesn't perform; she exists. And that's almost more dangerous than Jennie's performances. Shen Kuo's dialogue is equally distinctive — he speaks in questions, in deflections, in sexual bravado that masks genuine anxiety. "What if the police find out we lied?" This is a man who thinks loud talking equals control. Which is adorable and tragic. Ms. Huang is a ghost character who never appears but whose presence is felt in every interaction. Jennie's button press, the pre-arranged routines, the unspoken understanding that certain calls go through her first — this is worldbuilding through implied dialogue. The author has created an entire relationship system that operates almost entirely through absence. And the children calling Jennie "Mommy Yang" — that single phrase carries more emotional weight than any monologue could. It's the most honest line in the entire batch.
... Read More
"For most people, free time was a luxury, but for him, it was torture." I keep coming back to that sentence. It hit me harder than any action sequence would have. Meng Jin is so wired for crisis that stillness physically pains him. He can't sit in a coffee shop without categorizing other customers like a detective—which is either his occupational hazard or his coping mechanism, probably both. What struck me emotionally wasn't the murder. It was the mother-son phone call at the beginning. Mrs. Luo telling him what to wear, what shoes, what topics to discuss—with such specific, almost anxious care. She's not just a nagging mom trope. She's a woman whose son hasn't brought a partner home in years, and she's trying to engineer one into existence through strategic outfit selection. There's love in that, even if it comes wrapped in nagging. And Meng Jin's reaction to his blind date history? He's self-aware enough to laugh at himself but not cynical enough to quit. "He worried that if he got too enthusiastic, he might overwhelm the girl, and if he took the initiative, he might scare her off." This is a man who has analyzed his own social failures so thoroughly that he's paralyzed by the analysis. That's not funny—that's aching. So when the homicide call comes and he's suddenly alert, suddenly alive, suddenly himself? It's almost tragic. The job that made him successful at being a detective is the same thing that makes him a failure at being a date. And he knows it. I could feel him sitting in that coffee shop, pretending to relax, checking his watch every forty-five seconds, dying inside, and then—salvation in the form of a dead body.
... Read More
Okay so let me just... unpack what happened in this chapter because my brain is still rewinding. We go from Jennie Yang setting up a frame-job to two dead bodies in an apartment to a woman giving birth on a bathroom floor and somehow all of it connects. How does the author keep doing this? How does every chapter escalate like this? The setup is almost comically elegant. Jennie Yang lures Guo Tiandi into taking Liu Er's blame by offering to pay for Guo Yingying's heart surgery. Simple. Effective. She's played him before and knows exactly where his buttons are. And then—plot twist within a plot twist—Guo Tiandi figured it all out. He knew about the blood relationship. He knew she was lying. And instead of exposing her, he lets her hang herself with her own words by making her admit she's his mother. Then the scene shifts to Meng Jin and Zhao Yunzhi outside He Saibing's apartment, and BOOM. Two dead men. Knife fight. Emergency birth. The pacing in this chapter is absolutely ruthless. There is no breathing room. You go from psychological manipulation to a crime scene to a medical emergency to forensic hair-plucking from a newborn baby in the span of a few pages. I swear the author has a vendetta against my sleep schedule. And the He Saibing testimony? Oh, it's fascinating because it doesn't quite add up. Lin Jiancai appears conveniently, saves the day, dies in the process, and she had this whole explanation ready about why he was there. But as the narrative itself points out, it seems like they anticipated Guo Tiandi's move. Was Lin Jiancai part of the plan? Was this all a counter-trap? The chapter ends on that question mark and I am NOT okay with it. Also can we talk about how Meng Jin and Zhao Yunzhi went from stalking an apartment to midwifing a baby? That's not foreshadowing, that's just the author saying "hold my beer" and sending two detectives to improvise a delivery. I love it. I don't understand it, but I love it.
... Read More
Let me talk about how this section moves, because the rhythm is honestly kind of masterful. We open with the aftermath of underground fighting—immediate stakes, immediate danger. Guo Tiandi quits, gets threatened, has to earn his freedom. Half a month of training, then the biggest fight of his life against a Thai champion. Seven fractured ribs. ICU. A month of unconsciousness. That entire sequence from decision to near-death happens in what feels like three pages. It's breathless, punchy, and I couldn't look away. Then we cut to the hospital—a complete tonal shift. The pace slows down dramatically. Nurse exposition, his sister crying, her skipping school to care for him. The author gives us space here, lets us feel the weight of what happened. And then GUO YINGYING ANNOUNCES SHE'S BEING ADOPTED. Boom. Just like that, everything he just endured becomes background noise to this new gut punch. "I choose to go home," Guo Yingying said without hesitation, as if she had already made her decision long ago. That's a devastating line because it shows how quickly she adapted to a fake life without him. The adoption gets dissolved, she returns, they swear never to separate—then comes the police station scene. The pacing suddenly SHIFTS AGAIN to something lighter, almost comedic. Tang Xiaoguo showing up, the officers teasing Meng Jin, the banter about journalists and secrets. It's a deliberate tonal release valve after all that heaviness, and it works. The story knows when to breathe and when to suffocate you. But I will say—the transition from the stabbing back to the hospital, then immediately to the adoption return felt a little compressed. I wanted more time with Guo Tiandi processing that attack before moving to police procedure. Some parts dragged slightly, others moved too fast.
... Read More
Zhao Yunzhi's voice is honestly one of the best-written supporting characters I've encountered in this genre. Give me a medal. His lines are so distinct that even without dialogue tags, I can tell it's him. 'I'm practically a grumbling husband by now, Team Meng, you owe me one' — this is a man who has zero problem weaponizing humor to get what he wants, and the narrative itself seems to love him for it. What's brilliant is how the author uses Zhao's dialogue to reveal Meng Jin's character by contrast. Meng Jin is terse, measured, almost clinical in how he processes information. Zhao is chaotic energy wrapped in casual jokes. When Zhao says 'He doesn't know what we've found anyway. Whatever you tell him is what goes. Team Meng, you're too honest,' it's not just exposition—it's genuinely cutting because it's TRUE. And Meng Jin knows it. His reply 'Zhao Yunzhi, you're too sly' mimicking Zhao's own tone back at him? Chef's kiss. That's a character who respects intelligence even when it's aimed at manipulating him. The court scene with the courier is where the dialogue really shines procedurally. Every line serves dual purpose—revealing character AND advancing the investigation simultaneously. The courier yelling 'I earn one yuan per package' while being arrested is both hilarious and tragically realistic. You can hear his voice. You can see his face. That's skilled writing, not accidental. Even Deputy Chief Liu's single line 'Meng Jin, take a look at this' carries weight because of how the author has established his gravitas. One line and the whole room shifts energy. The author doesn't waste words on unnecessary exposition in dialogue scenes—which is rare and appreciated. Every conversation here feels like it's happening in real time.
... Read More
"Even the brightest places have corners untouched by light." I have to just sit with this line for a second because it hits different every time. This whole passage is basically a portrait of someone watching his old rival casually improve his life, and trying really hard not to hate him for it. Meng Jin's jealousy toward Long De is so understated you'd miss it if you weren't paying attention. He doesn't lash out. He doesn't even admit it to himself directly. He just… recalibrates. "Just give up, let it go. There's nothing wrong with being second." And that's the tragedy, right? This is someone who's accomplished something real—he's a cop, he solves cases, he has a partner who checks on him. But when Long De appears, suddenly all of that feels small. Long De studies "high-tech cutting-edge subjects" and Meng Jin deals with "the dregs of society." The gap isn't just professional—it's existential. What kills me most is that Meng Jin still reaches out. He still agrees to the call. He still needs Long De's help even though it reminds him of everything he isn't. That's not weakness—that's actually a kind of courage I don't think the text gives him enough credit for. And Zhao Yunzhi noticing his mood shift? That tiny detail—that someone close enough to read him without him saying a word—made me stop and just… feel something. The friendship between these two is the steady ground underneath all this drama, and honestly, it might be the most realistic relationship I've read in a while.
... Read More
"I was like a pet dog, learning whatever my master liked." I need to talk about this line. This line. It sits at the center of everything that makes this chapter hurt. On the surface, Li Zizi is laughing. She's playful, almost teasing as she describes her imitation of Jennie Yang. But Meng Jin sees it—he notices the bitterness and helplessness hiding behind her smile. And the reader should notice it too. This is a woman who sold herself, who negotiated her own commodification, who knows exactly what she's doing and hates herself for it. Yet she's also smart enough to weaponize her performance. She becomes what men want, and in doing so, she gains power over the very system that exploits her. The tragedy is that Liu Tianshi told her he loved his wife. Twenty years of faithfulness. And yet—he had a mistress. Of course he did. Men are liars, she says, but the real lie is the one he told himself. He wanted to be both the devoted husband and the passionate lover, and Li Zizi was the convenient vessel for his selfishness. And here's the thing that gets me: she kept the villa. "This villa is under my name now." That's not just material wealth—that's survival. She's building something permanent out of something temporary. And now that he's dead, she's ready to cash in on the scandal. Fame brings fortune, she says, but what she really means is: I survived. I'm still here. The question hanging over all of this is whether Meng Jin will see through Li Zizi's performance the way she saw through Liu Tianshi's lies. Because there's something genuine in the way he asks her about Jennie Yang—not to trap her, but to understand her. And when she laughs, truly laughs, for the first time in the chapter, it feels like the first honest moment she's had since Liu Tianshi died.
... Read More
The red maple tree. It appears once, almost casually, in Jennie Yang's testimony — "Was there a Red Maple Tree nearby?" — and then it disappears. But I can't stop thinking about it. A red maple tree. Red. The color of blood, of danger, of something growing slowly and then turning all at once. It sits near where Liu Tianshi and Jennie Yang stayed in New York in 2000, where something happened that may have altered the trajectory of their entire marriage and, indirectly, the fate of everyone connected to this case. The tree is a ghost in this story. Like so many other things — like Long De's unreadable expression in high school, like the blood on Lin Kun's body that someone hasn't tested yet, like Liu Er's empty room where a murderous son once lived. The novel is full of absences. People are missing. Evidence is delayed. Truth is withheld. Even the civil registry search fails because Lin Kun died before the system was digitized — a metaphor for how the past refuses to be easily accessed or understood. Then there's the theme of public face versus private reality, which the author explores with surgical precision through Jennie Yang. "Mama Yang" to the world — charitable, compassionate, devoted. A murderer's mother in private — broken, complicit perhaps, or at least ignorant of the monster she raised. The charity foundation is almost ironic in its generosity; she gives everything to strangers' children and couldn't save her own. Is that fate? Is that failure? Or is it something the author is saying about the impossibility of controlling who people become? The American trip itself feels symbolic — a honeymoon that became something else, a journey to the most "bustling metropolis in America" where they saw everything but perhaps missed what was happening right beside them. New York as a place of surfaces, of noise and lights, where two people can be together and completely alone at the same time. That city, that trip, that red maple tree — all of it circles back to a single question the author never stops asking: What do we really know about the people closest to us?
... Read More
I keep coming back to the description of this place. The American-style interior, clean and bright, open kitchen—sounds nice on paper but read between the lines and it's cold. Hotel-tidy. No personal belongings, no lived-in mess, just a phone charger and some receipts. This was a space designed for appearance, not for living. Liu Tianshi had money but he didn't have a home here. And then there's the conservatory. Li Zizi specifically chose to keep it despite Liu Tianshi wanting it torn down. She said Jennie Yang thought gardening was a waste of time. That single detail tells you everything about the power dynamics. Jennie Yang controlled the space so thoroughly that even a plant room became a battleground. Li Zizi keeping it was a tiny act of defiance in a house that wasn't hers. The yard being as big as a soccer field is such an unnecessary detail but it works. It makes the place feel isolated, echoey, like there's nowhere to hide and everywhere to be seen at the same time. And that hidden elevator behind the staircase—how many times have we seen this trope? But here it felt earned, not gimmicky, because the author had already established that nobody actually lives here anymore. Of course there's an elevator. Money doesn't solve loneliness.
... Read More
The stakes in these chapters escalate in this really terrifying way because they're not just about justice—they're about whether justice is even possible when power operates above the law. On one level, you've got the personal stakes: Guo Yingying losing her brother, Meng Jin losing his faith in the system, Jennie Yang hiding decades of manipulation behind philanthropy and public admiration. But on another level, the story is asking a harder question: what happens when the law's net is so vast and sparse that the real predator slips right through? "The law's net is vast and sparse, but nothing escapes"—and then the narrative immediately undercuts this proverb by showing exactly how it FAILED. Top officials calling. Political pressure. Jennie Yang appearing in media unscathed. This is the book being brutally honest about power structures. Meng Jin's decision to remove his uniform and walk into Fang Zheng Group as a private citizen is the ultimate statement about where institutional conflict ends and personal conflict begins. He literally steps outside the system to fight for something the system won't deliver. And Jennie Yang's response at the cliff—that she'd never tell him the truth even if he died right there—is the final escalation. She's not just winning; she's making his quest for truth meaningless. The conflict isn't resolved. It's transcended into something almost philosophical. How do you fight someone who controls the narrative itself?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or