"Lies."
Just one word. That's all Raphael says when Estelle pleads with him about not wanting to stay in the Duchy, about her father using her as a tool. One word and it completely dismantles everything she's trying to present. He doesn't argue, he doesn't negotiate—he just CALLS her out and leaves her speechless. This guy is terrifying and fascinating in equal measure.
Let's talk about Raphael for a second because this man is a WALKING red flag wrapped in golden hair and deep blue eyes. The text describes him as having traces of blood on his cheek after slaughtering bandits, dismounting from his white horse like some kind of dark fairy tale prince. His aura alone overwhelms Estelle. And yet, we also learn that he was caught sobbing in the library, muttering to himself about a mother who wasn't even his real mother. This duality is what makes him so compelling.
The moment when Estelle overhears him crying in the library is the turning point of their entire dynamic. Before that, she saw him as cold and indifferent—"no interest at all" in her gaze. After that, something shifts. She feels a secret bond forming with him, a shared understanding of being tools in their father's machinery. His line to her, "You're in the same situation as me," is deceptively simple but it changes everything. It's the first time he acknowledges their connection beyond the sibling facade.
And then there's the power shift that happens after he discovers they aren't related by blood. The text says his demeanor changed openly, that he started wearing "the mask of an older brother" while physically closing the distance between them. This is such a layered character moment—Raphael goes from cold observer to someone who actively pursues Estelle, but he does it while maintaining the veneer of familial duty. He claims her first time when she's off guard, and then systematically builds this trap where she can never leave.
But what's really chilling is that Raphael genuinely seems to believe he can change everything for her. The text notes: "If only she would open her heart, he could change everything in this Dukedom for her." This isn't just obsession—it's genuine devotion twisted through his warped worldview. He's not purely malicious. He's a person who was raised as a weapon, adopted as a tool, and now he's latching onto the one thing he actually wants with the only tools he knows: control, possession, and physical dominance.
Estelle's response is equally complex. She tells him she hates it, that she's disgusted, but the narrative makes it clear she's lying. Or maybe she's lying to herself. The more she pushes him away, the more he persists, and the more her body betrays her resistance. This push-pull dynamic between them is the engine of the entire story.