Even Though I Know I Shouldn’t Act Like This in Front of the Duke - Reviews

Even Though I Know I Shouldn’t Act Like This in Front of the Duke
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so, I have to talk about the subtle connection forming between Melissa and Ellin. It's not dramatic or loud, but it's there. When Ellin looks at that strange black stone and says it looks like 'a mother embracing a newborn baby,' something shifts. Melissa feels a chill—because no one else has ever seen it that way. That moment felt so intimate to me. Here's this older woman who's been dismissed her whole life (poor Charlotte!), meeting someone who actually *sees* her, understands her on some level without words. And then later, when Melissa asks about Dominic and Ellin blurts out that whole story about secretly loving him from afar... Melissa actually gets teary-eyed! I loved that. It shows she's not just some cold duress; she still feels things deeply. Meanwhile, there's this underlying tension with Silvia—her disappointment is palpable, you can feel her hurt that Melissa isn't more outraged. But the real emotional gut-punch for me was the Castia flashback. That moment where Ellin finds Dominic bleeding, and he calls her name before passing out... chills. Pure chills. It reframes everything. This isn't just a contract marriage; there's trauma and history there. And now she's walking through the market, pale and shaken, and Royce catches her. The author really knows how to weave these emotional threads together without making it melodramatic. It's all in the pauses, the glances, the things left unsaid. God, I love when books do this well.
... Read More
The pacing here is so deliberate and effective. We start with Silvia's visit—tense, formal, full of unspoken rivalry. Then immediately cut to another carriage arriving, which creates this neat parallel structure. Ellin enters the same house, sees the same stone, but reacts completely differently. That contrast alone builds so much intrigue. But then—the author drops a literal bomb in the middle of Ellin's present-day thoughts. One minute she's walking in the sun, the next we're in a flashback to Castia with gunshots and bleeding and a mysterious man. It's disorienting in a good way; you're right there with her, losing your footing. And then we snap back to the crowded street with Royce blocking her path, and it's like the reader is also gasping for air. The chapter ends on that unresolved note—'Why do you keep avoiding me?'—which is a perfect mini-cliffhanger. No chapter summaries, no neat wrapping up. Just forward momentum into whatever comes next. Some people might find the transition jarring, but I think it's genius. It mirrors how memory actually works—intrusive, sudden, emotionally raw. The author trusts us to keep up. And the alternating between past and present lets us piece together the mystery gradually, which is way more engaging than dumping it all at once. Solid structure work.
... Read More
Okay, let me just—where do I even start with this chapter sequence? The plotting here is genuinely *excellent*. You've got multiple threads weaving together and the author doesn't drop a single one. The biggest twist hit me when Rosana actually revealed her hand about Edward's hospital bed. I knew she was manipulative, sure, but the sheer audacity of threatening to discharge Edward the same day she'd fought to get him hospitalized? That's not just villainy, that's calculated cruelty wrapped in a smile. The fact that Ellin has her brother held hostage like this while being forced into a social situation she dreads—this is layers of pressure stacked on top of each other, and it makes every scene with Ellin feel suffocating in the best way. And then there's the Duke Linderto thread. When he says "I remember everything. Even how you seduced me"—chills. Actual chills. He's not just confronting her about that night, he's flipping the entire power dynamic. She thought she could slip away and pretend it never happened, and he's making it very clear that he absolutely will not let that slide. The Dominic-Jonathan subplot is also doing heavy lifting here. I love that Dominic agreed to this marriage deal but hasn't even told his mother yet. That ticking clock is going to explode somewhere, and I can feel it. The whole setup of a fake party as a way to soften a future shock? That's a narrative grenade waiting to go off. My only concern—the pace of revelations is so fast that I sometimes feel like I'm barely catching my breath. But honestly? I can't stop reading. The terrace cliffhanger alone had me immediately clicking to the next chapter. "His breath"—the sentence literally cuts off and I am NOT okay with that.
... Read More
Dominic's voice in these chapters is EVERYTHING. The way he speaks is so distinctly HIM—dry, sarcastic, deliberately provocative, but never crossing into outright cruelty. Listen to this exchange: "How do you plan to repay it if you won't forget?" When she thanks him for helping her and her brother. That's not just banter, that's DOMINIC being DOMINIC. He's testing her, provoking a reaction, keeping her off-balance. And then later when she suggests separate rooms and he shuts it down with "I'm sorry, but that's not possible"—his tone is clinically polite but there's zero warmth. The author gives him this perfect deadpan delivery that makes every line land. But what's interesting is how Ellin's voice contrasts. She stammers. She qualifies everything. "Um... thank you so much, Duke." "Then perhaps we should use separate rooms. It seems uncomfortable for you too, Duke." She's constantly hedging, constantly apologizing for existing in his space. Yet when she's alone in her own head, her thoughts are wild and unfiltered—full of romantic fantasies and sharp self-corrections. That gap between her external dialogue and internal monologue is where the comedy and heart live. And Monica the maid? "You had your wedding and first night. You must have been exhausted." That line is delivered with such casual warmth it almost hurts, because the reader knows NOTHING of the kind happened that night.
... Read More
This section moves like a sprint disguised as a stroll. We open with something almost domestic—Ellin and Marie shaking out a bedsheet in the garden, blue grass, fluttering linens—and within three paragraphs Janice arrives to destroy the mood. That's the structural move of this entire book: it will show you a moment of peace and then twist the knife. The pacing inside the mansion scene is rapid-fire dialogue, almost breathless, with Janice landing blow after blow until Ellin just tunes out. Then the visual shift—from bright outdoor clothes and lace parasols to the green muslin dress her stepmother forces on her. The dress itself becomes a plot device in two paragraphs: it belonged to Janice, Janice never shares anything with Ellin, and now Rosana is making Ellin wear her sister's discarded clothes while announcing the viscount's visit. The escalation is surgical. Ellin's outburst—slamming the dress to the floor and running out—is the first release of tension, and the author doesn't let us rest. We cut immediately to the viscount outside, then to Dominic watching from a carriage, then to the revelation that she has a sick younger brother in a convent hospital. Three perspective shifts in what feels like twenty minutes of real time, and each one deepens the mystery instead of confusing us. The chapter ends on Ellin holding a metal box with treasured objects—a photo locket from her mother, a scarf—wondering if the duke remembered her at all. That final image is a perfect button: quiet, intimate, and full of questions. From chaotic runaway to silent grief in one beat. The author trusts us to hold all those threads without summarizing. I trust the author right back.
... Read More
"She was a woman I always met at art auctions." Wait, the former Duchess of Linderto is an art collector? That detail hit me differently than I expected. I was sitting there thinking this is just another marriage-of-convenience story and suddenly the world feels bigger. Like, okay, these people move in circles where high society women compete over artwork the way other people compete over property. That line about Melissa "neglecting her family to mingle with artists" paints such a vivid picture of a woman who chose passion over duty, and now she's back and clearly still has that same fire. The garden scene after rain — fresh grass scent, Ellin and Isabella walking like they're sharing secrets — it's so cinematic. I could literally see it: two women side by side, one young and fragile-looking, one sharp and experienced, talking in hushed voices while the rest of the household schemed behind them. And then BOOM, the letter arrives. The white flowery letter that seemed to emit fragrance. That description alone made me pause and re-read it. It's such a small detail but it adds this whole sensory layer to the moment. The text shifts from the Nilson household to the Linderto mansion, and you can feel the tonal change immediately. One is all frantic energy and greed, the other is quiet elegance with undercurrents of something heavier. Melissa wiping that antique stone — "I couldn't sleep for days thinking about meeting you" — talking to an OBJECT like it's alive. That tells you everything about what kind of woman she is.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are so cleverly layered I can't even. On the surface, it's a wedding night that goes completely sideways—bride and groom barely speak, she falls asleep on the sofa, he carries her to bed in the middle of the night, and neither addresses it the next morning. That's already delicious tension. But underneath that, there's SO MUCH more at stake. Externally: Dominic's mother Melissa is watching like a hawk. He explicitly tells Ellin they can't separate rooms because any gap in their performance will make her suspicious. This marriage has to look perfect for a year, and one wrong move could unravel everything. The stakes are reputation, power, possibly war. Internally: Ellin is falling for a man who treats this like a contract, and she's terrified of it. Every time Dominic gets close, she panics—not just from attraction but from the fear of wanting something real. Dominic is equally conflicted. He initiates closeness (the hair grab, the near-kiss) then deliberately pulls away and goes back to work. He's fighting his own instincts. And the cliffhanger-level moment at the end—Ellin wakes up in HIS bed with no memory of how she got there, assumes he left early, and the reader is left DYING to know what actually happened. Did he really just carry her? Did he watch her sleep? The maid's comment about "you must have been exhausted" implies something happened that neither of them will acknowledge. The tension here is unbearable in the best way possible.
... Read More
There's so much symbolic weight packed into the objects and settings in this chapter. Let me unpack a few. The Linderto carriage itself is a powerful symbol. It's described as having navy velvet with gold studs, 'soft as sitting on a cloud' — but Ellin feels like she's 'wearing someone else's clothes.' The carriage represents everything she's been excluded from: wealth, status, protection. Yet even as she enters it, she doesn't belong. It fits the physical space but not her identity. She's an imposter in someone else's life before the life has even officially begun. The clothing shop scene operates on the same symbolic level. Clothes = identity = social position. The duke is literally dressing her in a new identity, wrapping her in blue silk and white lace. But these clothes were chosen for her, not by her. They're armor against her enemies (Janice especially) but they're also cages. Janice's pink hat that 'could shine if it found the right owner' is a perfect micro-symbol. She's beautiful but misplaced, loud but tasteless, ambitious but directionless. Ellin sees this clearly while Janice remains oblivious — a role reversal that mirrors the larger theme of appearances versus reality. And the wedding dress Ellin will eventually wear? It will be the ultimate symbol of her contract — something supposed to represent love and union, but here it's just another transaction. Dominic feels guilt about this but pushes it aside. The tragedy isn't that she's marrying a cold man; it's that he's capable of guilt and still chooses the deal over her feelings.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the stakes in this story escalated faster than I expected and I am HERE for it. We go from 'stepmother yells at you for embarrassing the family at a party' to 'you're being sold to an old lecher' in basically two scenes. And the father—THE FATHER—just SLIPS INTO HIS OFFICE when his daughter comes looking for him. Cowardly. Pathetic. The fact that he led the charge in having her stripped of her position and sent away to care for her great-aunt, and then abandons her the moment she pushes back? That's not just neglect, that's active betrayal by someone who was supposed to protect her. But what really made my pulse spike was the escape scene. Ellin runs out of that house and literally throws herself into traffic. A horse rears up, she nearly gets trampled, and she keeps running 'as though she couldn't see anything.' She'd rather die than marry Viscount Mackenzie. That's not teenage drama, that's survival instinct. And then it starts raining and Dominic watches her from his carriage like this is the most absorbing thing he's seen all week. He's a DUKE. He could have someone stop a horse from hitting her with a word. Instead he sits there, palms sweating, telling his driver to follow her without letting her notice. The tension between 'I should protect her' and 'I'm going to use her situation to get what I want' is doing actual work here. He later tells himself he'll 'compensate her sufficiently' like she's a business transaction. We know he's lying to himself. The reader sees it. That gap between his calculated plan and his actual behavior? That's where the suspense lives.
... Read More
Oh my god, Rosana. Just. Rosana. This woman went from practically ignoring Ellin to treating her like she hung the moon in about thirty seconds flat. Can you believe it? One minute she's sending her stepdaughter off to some nouveau riche old man as a second wife, cold as ice. The next? "Dear! Ellin!" practically vibrating with greed because suddenly Ellin is marrying a DUKE. The look on her face when she saw that carriage... "Her eyes widened" — yeah, no kidding. She looked at Ellin like she was looking at a gold mine. But here's what really got me — Rosana's internal monologue is SO honest and so nasty. She literally thinks: "I don't know what possessed the duke, but she'll probably be kicked out soon anyway." She can't even hide it. She's simultaneously thrilled about the social climb AND convinced Ellin is a fraud who won't last. That's not just mean, that's a whole personality. And then there's Isabella, who embraces Ellin like she's actual family while everyone else is calculating. "You seem to have lost weight from not eating our home cooking" — said with actual worry. The contrast between how the Nilsons treat Ellin versus how her great-aunt does? Chilling. It makes you realize how alone Ellin actually is in this situation.
... Read More
"If you don't like it, I have no intention of forcing you." This line from Dominic changes EVERYTHING about the conflict structure. Before this scene, Ellin's conflict was entirely external — abusive father, predatory stepmother, a viscount trying to buy her, her sick brother depending on her. She had two options: submit to the marriage or flee and hope to find work. Both paths led to hardship. But now the Duke introduces a THIRD option that simultaneously raises and reframes the stakes. What's fascinating is that Ellin's internal conflict is almost as intense as the external ones. She thought the Duke was a fairy-tale fantasy — "someone she had imagined and secretly loved" — and now that fantasy has materialized with actual power and wealth behind it. The temptation isn't just practical; it's deeply personal. She admits to herself that marrying him was "one of her many wishes." And yet she still holds onto reason long enough to organize his terms in her head: "So he's offering me tremendous compensation in exchange for a one-year contract marriage?" But the real question hanging over all of this is: why does the Duke need a wife so urgently? The text drops this casually — "I need someone to marry. As soon as possible" — but says NOTHING about his motivations. This unanswered question is the story's biggest ticking clock. Every chapter after this will be charged with the uncertainty of whether this agreement will save Ellin or completely upend her life in ways she can't foresee. Dominic's offer solves her immediate problems but introduces entirely new ones. That's excellent stakes management.
... Read More
There are so many symbols stacked into these chapters I barely noticed on the first read. Let me highlight a few that got me. The wine—Ellin specifically asks for a glass to help her sleep, to numb the anxiety. But Dominic insists on TWO glasses and sends Monica to get the finest bottle. The wine becomes this shared ritual, this bridge between two people who are supposed to be strangers but are suddenly sharing something intimate. When Ellin gets slightly drunk and nods off, it's the alcohol that lowers her guard enough for Dominic to carry her. The wine literally enables the moment where his true feelings leak out. The bed itself is enormous—Dominic even jokes it's big enough for three people. It symbolizes the vast emotional distance between them, the space they're pretending doesn't exist. Yet by the end, he places her gently in it and sleeps at the far opposite end. That physical distance in a room meant for closeness is heartbreaking. And the greenhouse memory—that's the recurring symbol of their true dynamic. In the greenhouse, SHE was the bold one. SHE initiated. SHE surrendered. Now she's demure and flustered in the bedroom. Dominic's question "Where did that bold lady go?" isn't just teasing—it's him acknowledging that he saw something real in her during that moment, and he's not sure he likes that she's pulling back now.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or