Elegant Yet Vulgar - Reviews

Elegant Yet Vulgar
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say this outright: Lavian is a commodity in this story and everyone involved knows it except maybe her. The Elder family sold her to Marquis Batl to clear debts—half upfront, half after the wedding. When the groom dies before the wedding is completed, the deal is void but the family is still ruined. So what do they do? They ship her portrait to the nearest wealthy man who might take her off their hands. The proposal lands on Klen's desk and he immediately recognizes it for what it is: "This wasn't a marriage proposal. Anyone could see it was clearly a transaction, a contract." But here's what haunts me—the symbolism of the VEIL. It's placed over her head by maids who call her an angel and a goddess, but it also obscures her face. She becomes an image, not a person. Then she appears in the newspaper photo in BLACK, still beautiful, still an object of fascination for strangers. Even Klen looks at her portrait—a smiling painting—and decides her value lies in her bloodline and her vulnerabilities, not in who she actually is. The postcards. I cannot unsee this detail. A street child is selling POSTCARDS of Lavian at her own husband's funeral, and Klen calls it "poor taste" while buying one anyway. The entire Empire is consuming her tragedy as entertainment. And Asellan—oh god, Asellan. He sees her in black and thinks it proves they're DESTINED. His romanticism is its own kind of violence. He hasn't met her as a person; he's fallen for the IDEA of her, the way she looks in mourning, the narrative of loss. Everyone wants something from Lavian. Nobody seems to ask what she wants. The novel keeps circling this question without answering it, and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
Okay so this section is WILD. I just… I need to process this. The wedding day, the BIG moment, and what happens? Marquis Batl DIES. Right there on the threshold. Not after the vows, not after anything—just collapses like some kind of dark comedy joke. And the narrator doesn't even hesitate: "The wedding of Marquis Batl transformed into a funeral." One sentence. That's it. Three pages ago this girl was putting on a veil and the maids were calling her an angel, and now she's already a widow. The pivot is so fast it made me spit out my tea. But then—plot twist number two, because of COURSE there is one—Klen von Leschel receives a marriage proposal for her. The guy literally just saw her face in a newspaper and within, what, twenty minutes? decides to go to the capital and propose. He looks at her portrait, closes his eyes, thinks about it for about three seconds, and goes: "A high-ranking noble with good bloodlines, and I can even hold her weaknesses against her." This man is not subtle. I LOVED him immediately. And Asellan? The fourth in line for the imperial throne, the romance hero type who's been pining since before this chapter started, crumples his father's letter and says "Lavian, this time for sure!" He literally sees the groom dying on the wedding day and interprets it as DIVINE SIGN they're meant to be together. Bro, please. The plot is moving so fast and stacking conflicts like a Jenga tower. One wrong move and everything topples. I can't stop reading.
... Read More
I have to address the dialogue in these chapters because the author's ear for distinctive voice is absolutely razor-sharp and it deserves more credit. Let me start with Klen because his dialogue is a whole vibe. He says things like 'Are you sure you'll be alright sober?' and 'The well-bred lady has a lewd side' and 'I think I've already heard your thanks.' This is a man who weaponizes casualness. Every line sounds offhand but it's precisely calculated. He's never just saying something—he's testing the water, seeing how she reacts, adjusting his strategy in real time. And the narration matches his voice perfectly. When Klen is observing, the prose gets sharper, more clinical: 'Her face was unreadable.' 'He pulled his robe to hide the scar.' Short sentences. Efficient. But when the narrative slips into Lavian's head, the voice changes entirely—more hesitant, more sensory, more desperate. She chews her lip, she picks at her nails, she notices his Adam's apple moving as he swallows wine and suddenly the room is too hot. Her internal voice is all impulse and sensation; his is all calculation. Then there's Lilian, whose dialogue is pure instruction, pure doctrine. 'Don't chatter on about things other than what you're asked. Only respond to questions.' No warmth, no hesitation, no question marks. She speaks in commands because that's all she knows—commands were how she survived. And Lavian's actual spoken dialogue throughout all of this is just 'Yes' and 'I understand well' and 'I'll do my best to satisfy you.' Three phrases. That's it. And somehow the fact that she says almost nothing while her mother fills the room with words IS the most powerful dialogue choice in these chapters. The silence between her words screams louder than anything Lilian says.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this dinner scene because WOW. The Elder family is honestly horrifying in the most fascinating way. Let me start with Klen's inner monologue — that line, 'A noble fox? Perhaps closer to a haughty cat,' is just so deliciously sharp. He's watching Lavian perform like it's theater, and he knows it. But here's what gets me: Klen himself isn't any better. He sneers at the dessert, at the family, at everything, yet he's the one using them too. 'Trying to lure me with their finest bait. I have no reason to make a losing deal.' He sees right through the game and he's still playing it. That's not some innocent observer — that's a predator who knows he's a predator. Then you have Lena. I hate her. I genuinely hate her. She walks into the bathroom humming like nothing happened, after deliberately sabotaging Lavian's chances, and says 'Help me, sister. A lowborn like me...' The audacity is breathtaking. And what does Lavian do? She agrees. Not because she wants to — because she can't imagine any other move. The father is the worst, obviously. 'Yes, so your sister would shine more!' He literally used Lena as a prop to make Lavian look better, and then when that backfires, he's ready to sell Lavian off like livestock. 'If you're going, hurry up' — said like he's ordering a delivery. This is a family where love is transactional and children are currency. Lavian internalized it so deeply that her first instinct is still to sacrifice herself. That's not devotion. That's survival conditioning. The most chilling moment? When Lavian thinks about her grandfather's teachings. She has to literally dig through her diary to remember them. Her entire identity has been hollowed out and replaced with duty. She's not choosing — she's performing the script she was written to play. And yet... she stands up to her father for the first time. 'I'll go find the baron!' It's barely a whisper of rebellion, but for someone who's never looked her father in the eye, it's a earthquake. Who will she actually be when she finds Klen? Because the girl who just cried alone in a bathroom is not the girl who said those words in the dining room. There's a gap there and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I'm genuinely obsessed with how every line of dialogue in this chapter does double duty. Nothing is just what it seems. Take this exchange: "Didn't you say you'd try?" "That......" And then Klen just starts untying his robe. No explanation. No preamble. The silence between her incomplete sentence and his action says everything — he's tired of her hedging, tired of the formalities, tired of pretending this is just a contract. He could have said a dozen things, but he chooses to let his body speak. And Lavian's voice throughout is just *chef's kiss*. She's narrating her own emotional annihilation in real time. "I'll be faithful as your wife. I'll do everything necessary for you to get what you want. That's what I exist for." Said so flatly, so cynically, and yet you can literally hear the small hope she's trying to strangle with her own words. She's performing the perfect daughter-wife-husband's-property and simultaneously HATING every second of it. Klen's dialogue is different — shorter, sharper, always testing. "Are you telling me to have affairs or not to? Could you at least make your words consistent?" He's always prodding, always looking for the crack in her armor. And the best part? He finds it when she finally drops the act and says something true, even if she doesn't know she's being true. The wine-kiss scene has some of the most charged dialogue I've read. "From the bottom to here, nothing has risen without passing through my hands. It feels quite good to have something tainted by my touch according to my preference." That's not romance. That's ownership expressed through language so beautifully venomous you almost forgive it.
... Read More
I need to talk about Klen because WOW. The first time we see him, he's walking away from Lavian after she thanks him for saving the slaves, and he just drops this line: "Do you really want to die? You don't want to die." And then he walks away. No softness, no comfort, just... that's it. He saw through her immediately. She was about to sacrifice herself for those slaves, and he knew it in one sentence. Then later, when he's reading the newspaper and sees her funeral photo in black, a street kid tries to sell him postcards and he says "What poor taste" and basically scares the kid into running away. This man has ZERO chill and I am OBSESSED. His entire approach to the marriage proposal is transactional from beginning to end. Amelia tries to warn him that the Elder family is sinking, that their reputation is shot, and he literally says: "Isn't that better? A high-ranking noble with good bloodlines, and I can even hold her weaknesses against her." He's not looking for a wife. He's looking for a SHIELD. Someone to legitimize his merchant origins in high society. Lavian, to him, is a CONTRACT. And yet—I keep expecting something else. The way he looked at that portrait, the way his hand paused before opening the album completely... I feel like this man is going to be spectacularly wrong about how this ends. Meanwhile Lavian sits in that bridal room, veil on, bouquet in hand, completely hollowed out. When Seian bursts in crying "Marquis Batl has died!!" the bouquet FALLS. Not a dramatic throw, just... drops. Like her whole world just lost gravity. And she doesn't even get to grieve before a new marriage proposal is landing on Klen's desk. These people are Pawns and I want to shake them all.
... Read More
Okay so I just re-read this dinner scene like five times and I CANNOT get over Lavian's internal monologue. Like, she's been through literally hell with previous husbands dying and society calling her a witch and here comes THIS man—baron, rich, cobalt blue eyes, no wrinkles on his entire face—and her brain just short-circuits. I love how the narrative keeps zooming in on her trying to play it cool while internally spiraling: *Why is he young? And even handsome... Is this a dream?* And then the delicious irony of it all—she spent chapters mourning the death of her previous husband, secretly relieved she didn't have to marry him, and now she's being shopped to yet another man by her own father who literally says "This is all for your own good" while treating her like livestock. The cruelty of blood ties is such a perfect phrase for what she's experiencing. But what really got me was the dinner scene dynamics. Lena elbowing Lavian on purpose and then laughing it off while the parents use it to make Lavian look pitiful and Klen... Klen just watches everything with this predatory calm. He notices she has no intention of refusing. He's displeased by it. Meanwhile he's also completely captivated by her, having thisdéjà vu he can't explain. The tension between them is SPECTACULAR. "Whether young or old, what does age matter?" — this line absolutely wrecked me because it's Lavian trying to convince herself and failing so hard.
... Read More
So here we are — Klen just told Amelia to spread a rumor that he fell in love with Lavian at first sight, and I am NOT okay with this. Like, the absolute audacity of this man to manufacture romance while he's sitting there coldly dismissing Lavian's actual letter as hypocrisy. The parallel storytelling in these chapters is doing SO MUCH work. We cut from Lavian nervously writing to Klen → to Klen finding the postcard of her at a funeral → to the Emperor revealing that Klen might actually be HIS SECRET SON. Wait. What? Eight years ago at a swordsmanship tournament, a pocket watch, Lentia (the emperor's lover?) saying the palace is crawling with vipers... this plot has layers. And don't even get me started on Asellan. The dude shows up to his father demanding to know why he can't marry Lavian, and we get this whole backstory dump about how Duke Antoine used to be close with Chelino before Lilian married the wrong guy. It's like every male character in this story has unresolved business with the Elder family and they're all just waiting for their moment. The wedding itself is being rushed like lightning striking beans but the rumor mill is turning it into some romantic fairy tale. The dissonance between what's actually happening and what everyone's being told is delicious. I want to see how this explodes.
... Read More
I am NOT okay with how these chapters handled Klen and Lavian's relationship and I need to scream about it. Let's start with Klen. The man is a CONFUSION. Here's someone who just spent an entire night teaching Lavian how to feel, how to make sounds, how to stop holding back—and then the NEXT MORNING he can't even sit next to her without becoming ice cold? What is WRONG with this man?? And yet... I kind of understand him. When she touches his scars, when she traces them like they're something beautiful instead of something shameful—that's the most intimate thing anyone has EVER done for him. And she doesn't even realize it. She just sees scars the way she sees her own blade wound, as something familiar, something that proves you survived. That's the thing that killed me. Lavian thinks they're similar because they both carry pain. But Klen's pain is visible—he has the scars to prove it. Hers are invisible. She's never had to earn hers protecting anyone. And when she reaches toward him, when she almost lets herself hope that maybe SHE could be someone he'd want to protect too? The author destroys that moment with one question: 'What are you doing?' Meanwhile Lavian's internal journey in these chapters is WILD. She goes from terrified (of sex, of Klen, of this whole arrangement) to something dangerously close to tenderness, and then back to self-reproach so fast. The part where she's lying awake thinking about whether she has to do this every day? THAT'S HER Coping Mechanism talking. She makes everything about survival, about endurance, because feeling anything else is terrifying. But the morning scene? When Klen defends her to the Count like nothing happened? That's NOT nothing. That's him choosing to maintain the performance even though last night cracked something open for both of them. These two are stuck in this beautiful tragedy of mutual attraction masked by role-playing.
... Read More
Let me just... process everything that happened across these chapters because the plot is MOVING and I am HERE FOR IT. Asellan secretly arranging for mages to chase after someone in the Eastern Empire because he 'cannot lose Lavian again'—wait, WHAT? There's a whole thread here about Lavian and Asellan that I need to understand better. Is Lavian already married before? Was she married to someone else named Asellan? Or is there some other connection I'm missing? Then there's Klen encountering Lavian BEFORE their arranged meeting—he sees her protecting that kitten in the rain, calls her a busybody, and has no idea she's the woman he's about to meet as her marriage prospect. The dramatic irony is PAINFUL and I love it. The dinner scene is the centerpiece here, and it does SO MUCH narrative work: establishes the power dynamics, reveals Klen's character through his observations, shows Lena's spite, demonstrates the Elder family's mercenary nature, and plants the seed of attraction/tension between Klen and Lavian—all while maintaining the surface politeness of arranged marriage negotiations. And Klen thinking about the veiled woman who asked him to kill someone while sitting across from Lavian? The plot threads are MULTIPLYING and I am obsessed.
... Read More
I can't get over the visual of Lavian in that bridal room. The text describes her veil settling over platinum blonde hair "which resembled transplanted moonlight." Transplanted moonlight. That line alone is worth the price of admission. She's sitting there, sky-blue eyes partially hidden by her eyelids, looking "both pure and somehow sorrowful" while her maids gush about how beautiful she is. The contrast between their excitement and her blank, emotionless face—she's physically present but completely gone. The maids have to tell her to quiet down because THEY'RE TOO LOUD for her state of mind. And then the scene shifts to that southern Empire café, and the atmosphere changes completely. Summer fragrances in March, people arguing passionately about the wedding-turned-funeral while holding newspapers, sellers passing around postcards of Lavian in black. There's this whole PUBLIC SPECTACLE happening around her tragedy, and Klen walks into it like he owns the place. The description of him—"striking looks rarely seen in the southern region," golden hair like sunshine, sapphire-blue eyes, innate nobility emanating from his entire being—is so deliberate. The narrator wants us to understand: this is a man who commands attention without trying. The contrast between the bridal room (quiet, tense, suffocating) and the café (noisy, gossipy, bright) is masterful. One is intimate claustrophobia, the other is public consumption. Both are about Lavian's body and fate being discussed by people who aren't her. The imagery of the cold wind invading the ceremony hall right after Count Elder starts screaming—"The space that had been filled with bright sunshine until just moments ago was now invaded by a cold, desolate wind"—that's not just weather, that's the story announcing itself.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about how this opening chapter basically hits you with two separate inciting incidents and I am NOT okay. First: the pre-wedding banquet. You've got this twenty-year-old girl being paraded around like a prize at her own engagement party by a man nearly fifty years older, and the nobles are openly mocking her family's desperation. The author doesn't even shy away from it — those lewd comments, the "fresh and beautiful bride" whispers, the baroness playing along. It's disgusting on purpose. You're supposed to feel sick for Lavian here. But then — and this is where my jaw hit the floor — she walks into the garden and bumps into an armed man with a dagger at her throat. And what does she do? She asks him to kill her. Not scream. Not cry. Just… calm as day, offering him her jewelry as a tip for the service. That pivot from social suffocation to actual mortal danger is brilliant pacing. The first half of the chapter drags you through etiquette and cruelty, making you feel every ounce of her entrapment. Then the second half swings into life-or-death territory and suddenly everything changes. The stakes go from "she's going to be miserable" to "she'd rather die right now." The only question burning in my head: who IS Klen? The way the narrator refers to him as "Commander" but he's out here rescuing slaves in disguise? There's a whole underworld layer to this world that hasn't been touched yet, and I am desperate to know more. Also — that parting line with the child calling her "big sister" hit me so hard I had to put the phone down for a second.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or