I need to talk about Edith and Ludwig because this is the most complicated relationship dynamic I've read in ages and I am NOT okay.
On the surface, this looks like a power imbalance story—a prince who tortures people at dinner and a woman who serves him water afterward. But the text keeps undermining that reading in the most interesting way. When Ludwig brings Edith in to handle Esteban, he's not just using her as a tool. He's recognizing that she understands something he doesn't: how to speak to someone young and scared without crushing them completely.
The prince watching Edith with 'kind eyes, as if watching a puppy he had raised'—that image haunts me. Is it genuine care? Is it possession? Probably both. And honestly, that ambiguity is what makes this relationship work.
But let's talk about Edith for a second, because her confession scene is absolutely devastating. She tells Ludwig about being called a field mouse, being hung upside down, being strangled by Henrietta until that sister learned the exact pressure needed to make her pass out without leaving marks. And she says it CALMLY. Like she's reading a cookbook. The trauma is so deep it's become infrastructure—just part of the walls she lives inside.
Here's what wrecked me: after telling him all of this, she says, 'I fear that after hearing these stories, Your Highness might also think little of me and torment me, but on the other hand, I hope that by revealing these inner thoughts, you might recognize me as a loyal subject.' She's performing vulnerability as strategy. She's been so violated that even her intimate moments are transactional. She's asking a man who tortures people for breakfast to be sympathetic, while fully expecting him to be anything but.
And Ludwig's response? He asks about her birthday. He offers her a gift. He says 'I'm not a man who spends money out of sympathy'—which is simultaneously the cruelest and most honest thing he could say. He's saying: I will give you things, but not because I feel sorry for you. Because you're useful. Because you're MINE. There's a difference, and apparently he thinks it matters.
Meanwhile, back in the Köhler household, Neil is seething. 'Edith, whom he hadn't seen in a long time, was breathtakingly beautiful.' He blames his father. He's already planning how to take responsibility for the sin of bringing her into that house. This is dangerous romantic thinking—the kind that leads to more disasters. He wants to be her rescuer but he's also part of the machinery that imprisoned her.
The triangle between Ludwig, Edith, and Neil is going to be absolutely vicious. Ludwig sees Edith as a valuable acquisition who chooses to stay. Neil sees her as something he failed to protect. And Edith? She's calculating which man's cage gives her the best view of the exit.