Don't Propose, Please! - Reviews

Don't Propose, Please!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — the way this chapter set up the entire Costance/Vivi dynamic was *chef's kiss*. You've got all these loose threads from earlier that suddenly snap together. The library rumors? The daily visits? The meaningful glances that everyone notices except Vivi herself? It all clicks into place during that dinner scene, and then — BAM — the hotel room reveal at the end of Chapter 9. I literally dropped my phone. The pacing here is wild. It goes from a group dinner that could have been a generic rom-com setup and slowly isolates just the two of them, stripping away all the noise until it's raw and awkward and so tense you can hear the jazz music changing tempo and just *feel* it. And then waking up at the Clinton Meteor Hotel? The blood on the sheets? My brain was going a million miles an hour. Did they sleep together? Is she hurt? Is he worried because he cares or because he feels guilty? The author doesn't tell you anything, and that is exactly why I can't stop thinking about it. Also — the subtlety of Costance asking "if anything like that happens again, please inform the police" when someone was following Vivi? That's not just concern. That's possessiveness masked as chivalry, and the text makes you feel every layer of it.
... Read More
This author writes dialogue the way some people paint — with restraint, with negative space, with everything unsaid doing more work than the spoken words. Look at this exchange: "But aren't you running late?" "So he was teasing me." "It would be better to hurry, Vivi." Three lines. Three beats. And the entire emotional architecture of their relationship is in what's NOT there. Costance says he likes books, she catches him, he pivots into teasing, she realizes she's been played, deflates, and he watches her do it with this quiet amusement. Nobody says "I like spending time with you." Nobody needs to. The protest scene is another masterclass. The protesters don't speak like real political activists — they speak like people who've rehearsed their lines and just want an audience. "Are you saying reading is more important than peace?" That's not dialogue, that's propaganda. It's designed to trap her in a false binary. And Vivi's response? She doesn't get caught in it. She reframes. What I love about the narration is how it mirrors Vivi's internal voice. Things like "What tyranny is this? The one who should be reported to the police is not the protesters but the tyrannical director who orders the youngest around" — this is such a specific, sharp, slightly hysterical inner monologue. She's stressed, underappreciated, and her thoughts spill over into comedy. It makes her feel alive. And the whispered moments between Costance and Vivi? "Vivi." Just her name. Over and over. Each time it means something different. Concern. Intimacy. Warning. Desire. One syllable doing ten jobs.
... Read More
The narrative pivots from Vivi's hotel morning straight into a childhood flashback and THEN comes back to the library gossip session. At first I was like wait what but actually this structure works really well. The flashback explains WHY Vivi is so emotionally guarded around men and intimacy—her father literally couldn't care less about her or her mother. It recontextualizes everything. Then we cut back to the present and the library is buzzing about OTHER people's romantic adventures while Vivi sits there dealing with her own incomprehensible situation. The pacing here is clever because it uses the lighter gossip scenes as relief before dropping heavier emotional beats. But I will say the transition back from the flashback to the library was a bit jarring—I had to reread to make sure I knew which timeline I was in.
... Read More
Let me just say: this novel is about what we do with inherited violence. Not the violence we choose, but the violence that chooses us—the weapons our fathers build, the secrets they keep, the absence that becomes the only thing passed down. The cross in the cathedral is doing heavy lifting here. Vivi visits it regularly. It's her anchor, her confession booth, her attempt at purification. But the man she actually wants to talk to—the one whose scent makes her freeze—is hiding outside her sanctuary. Costance is the ghost at her peace. And the cathedral itself is full of ghosts: the mysterious donor who won't show his face, Eugene whose father is apparently connected to the very lab he wants to destroy, and Vivi herself, who has been erasing her own existence to survive. The stained glass, the statue of the goddess, the dry well surrounded by children's footprints—all of it is imagery about empty spaces that were once full. The well has no water. Costance has no face. Vivi has no mother. Eugene has no father he can name. The NOK One weapon has no creators left to hold accountable because they're either dead or hiding behind laboratory walls. And the Peace Love Contest—this is the brutal irony that nearly made me laugh out loud. They're organizing an ART COMPETITION about PEACE in a world that just used a weapon capable of destroying countries. Children drawing and writing about something they've never experienced while their adult protectors are busy making weapons and running laboratories and calling them XXs behind their backs. "Because of your father, you won't live well either, little girl." The Marquis says this and means it literally—Vivi's father built the thing that made her life impossible—but the phrase echoes everything. The XX designation, the unnamed mother, the mechanical heart, the lab that might explode. All of it circles back to one question: what do you owe the people who made you, and what do you get to destroy because of them?
... Read More
Let me break down what's actually happening in these chapters because the plot mechanics are surprisingly intricate. On the surface, this is a romance with a misunderstanding—but the layers are interesting. Vivi deliberately created a situation where she embarrassed herself (throwing up, being drunk) because she WANTED Sir Costance to be repulsed. Her stated goal: "If they avoided each other with this misunderstanding, everything would be resolved. Then I can work comfortably again." So she's actively trying to END the romantic tension. That's a fascinating character motivation. Most romance protagonists want the love interest; she wants the opposite, which immediately makes her sympathetic despite her manipulative behavior. But then the plot SUBVERTS her plan. Instead of being disgusted, Sir Costance apologizes. He blames HIMSELF. He leaves a note with a valuable commemorative bill. He waits two hours in the cold. The more she tries to push him away, the more he invests. Meanwhile Julia operates as both comic relief AND plot complication. She keeps trying to促成 (push forward) the romance while also genuinely caring about Vivi. Her line about the apology being unfinished shows she understands the situation better than either protagonist. The newspaper guy encounter is a nice minor subplot that does double duty: it creates physical danger/tension AND it reveals that Vivi has a public reputation ("the beautiful librarian") that exists independently of Sir Costance. It gives her some identity outside this romance. The cliffhanger ending—with Costance finding her peeking from behind the flowerbed, the protective stance, the "who are you?" to the stranger—sets up the next major confrontation perfectly. The plot is building momentum and I'm fully invested.
... Read More
"Do you miss your mother?" "No. I just feel sorry for her. I hope she's living well." I am not okay. I am literally not okay with this line. This is the kind of sentence that sits in your chest for three days. This girl—who we know is Vivi—has been abandoned by her mother, neglected by her emotionally dead father, called an XX by nobles, and her response to the question about her mother is: I hope she's living well. Not I wish she'd come back. Not I hate her for leaving. Just... I feel sorry for her. Because her mother is just like her. Alone. Unwanted. Existing. And then Rene hugs her and says "Your father is just not good at expressing himself. But surely, deep down, he loves you." And Vivi pushes her shoulder and asks again, like she needs to hear it one more time, like if she hears it enough times it might become true. "Do you really think my father is just bad at expressing himself?" And then Tiago saves her by saying it's time to sleep and she whispers "Could you tell my father good night for me?" and then the narration says: But the girl already knew. Her father didn't love her mother or herself. SHE ALREADY KNEW. She knew and she still asked Rene to tell him good night. That is not a child who needs reassurance—that is a child who is trying so desperately to believe in something that love might be possible in this family. And then LATER in the cathedral, she watches Eugene coloring furiously, trying to impress her, trying to earn her attention, and she thinks about her father—the man behind the blackboard in Eugene's drawing, the chemist, the man who created or was connected to NOK One—and the whole thing just... collapses. The father she's mourning, the father Eugene is trying to destroy, the father who might be the reason her mother left, the father whose mechanical heart she imagined—it's all one person and she's standing in the middle of it and she doesn't know which direction to run. "I thought of my mother after hearing that. I hope she's doing well." And I'm over here crying for a girl who just wants someone to stay.
... Read More
So I just finished reading through these chapters and I need to process how the author handles the pacing because honestly it's really well done. The first chapter opens mid-crisis—we drop right into the library confrontation where Vivi is clearly trying to engineer a misunderstanding. She WANTS him to be offended. She wants to create distance. But then he apologizes instead, and that immediately shatters her entire plan. That's a great structural choice because it flips the power dynamic in one move. Then the second chapter starts with a time jump and immediately gives us that note reveal—the whole secret meeting setup. But here's where it gets interesting: the author makes us WAIT. We know he's waiting at Atlantis. We know she's hesitant. And instead of just cutting to the meeting, we get this whole detour with the street performer and the card game. That detour actually serves two purposes: it builds suspense (how long will he wait?) AND it introduces the newspaper guy subplot naturally. If the author had just had Vivi walk straight to the café, it would've been flat. The wandering, the hesitation, overhearing the gossip about him waiting—that all stretches the tension until she's literally running at the end. "She ran." Two words but they carry so much. And then the chapter ends mid-scene with him finding her behind the flowerbed. Classic cliffhanger energy without being cheap about it. The pacing between chapters also works well—the first one is more claustrophobic (library, enclosed space, whispered conversations), and the second one opens up to streets and crowds before closing back down to that intense one-on-one moment at the end. The only tiny thing: the transition from the card game back to the café scene feels slightly rushed, but it's minor.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is honestly reckless and I am here for it. You go from a quiet library scene where Vivi is just trying to shelve books to a full-on military officer intervention to a makeup crisis to a high-stakes dinner date in roughly the span of a few hours. The author does not give Vivi a single moment to recover between escalations. Chapter 6 starts with the librarians already mid-disaster, the men cornering Vivi, the forehead question hanging in the air. Then Chapter 7 drops you straight into the dinner with no transition, no breathing room. The food arrives, people are introduced, and within seconds Julia is actively trying to pair Vivi with Finn like she is running a matchmaking algorithm. The pace never lets up. There is no downtime, no quiet moment where Vivi can process what is happening to her. And that is exactly what makes it so engaging—you are riding the same breathless wave she is. What I appreciate most is how the author controls the tension through conversation rather than action. There are no explosions, no chases, no dramatic confrontations. Just people sitting around a table saying things that mean other things. Costance telling Vivi her makeup is beautiful while pretending he was just looking at her face generally. Finn calling her old while everyone else chimes in. Julia describing this as a competition for two spots. All of it is surface-level polite conversation with subtext running at maximum capacity. The chapter ends on a lingering stare from Costance while food arrives and nobody eats. That is a perfect cliffhanger. Not a dramatic one, but the kind that makes you immediately open the next chapter because you need to know what happens when they finally say something honest.
... Read More
I want to spend a minute on how the author uses physical spaces because this is genuinely one of those books where the SETTINGS do heavy lifting. The National Library isn't just a backdrop—it's essentially a character. There's this whole sequence where Vivi is alone after hours, turning off lights one by one, and the text says: "Darkness and emptiness settled in the space." But then immediately pivots to HER emotional emptiness. The library mirrors her inner state. That's not accidental writing. The library has layers too—there's the main hall with Sir Costance's reading room, there's the return bin hallway, there are the stacks where Julia hides gossip, and there's this sense that it's a place with rules and hierarchy. Dictionaries can't be borrowed. The director has keys. People have designated routines. It feels like a real institution, not just "a building with books." Then you have Atlantis café—which the text establishes as "the most famous café in town" with colorful flowers and spacious interiors. It's clearly a social hub where reputations are made and broken. Half the town shows up there just on the rumor that Sir Costance is waiting. That single detail tells you everything about this world's social dynamics. And the street scene—the flickering lamppost, the card game clown, the families eating at outdoor restaurants, the cold wind—all of this creates a vivid texture that grounds the romance in actual physical reality. This isn't some abstract fantasy playground; it's a place where people actually live and move and bump into each other at flowerbeds. The newspaper office next door being established as a real location is such a small detail but it makes the world feel complete. Like this place exists beyond the romantic plotlines.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this scene because my hands are literally shaking. Sir Costance—this guy, this impenetrable, polite, perfectly composed Naval Officer hero—just FULLY BREAKS DOWN in front of Vivi and I cannot recover from it. Let me set the scene for you. They end up at this tiny reservoir in Canary Village, no streetlights, freezing cold. He notices she's shivering and practically RUNS to a souvenir shop to get her a red blanket. Red blanket, by the way, which is such a loaded detail because it's warm, it's bright, it's him trying to wrap himself around her without actually touching her. Then she asks him the question—'Do you like me, Sir?'—and he just... says it. 'I like you.' Not a grand declaration. Not poetic. Just three words, and then his face goes through something I can't describe. And then he cries. A man who wouldn't blink even with a sword pointed at him. Tears falling onto his own hand like he didn't even realize they were there. This is the most vulnerable I have EVER seen a romance hero be, and it completely undid me. What hits me hardest is the asymmetry here. She's the one who rejected him, who said 'Ever,' and yet SHE ends up crying two days later while HE doesn't show up to the library. He gave her everything—his honesty, his tears, his warmth—and she sent him running. And then she's the one left staring into empty space where he used to sit. 'I find you a bit overwhelming, Sir,' she told him. And wasn't that just the most devastating thing to say to someone who had just bared his soul? I'm still not over it.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the author gives Costance this incredibly specific voice? He speaks in this formal, polished way — proper sentences, measured responses — and then drops things like: "Our manager has a rather difficult personality. When that personality affects me, I tend to soothe it with drinks." That is the funniest line in the entire book. A nobleman talking about soothing his difficult personality with alcohol, and Vivi's reaction — she literally bursts out laughing — it's the first time we see him being playful, being human, dropping the stoic mask even slightly. The contrast between his formal register and the self-deprecating content is what makes the dialogue pop. And Vivi's dialogue is perfectly calibrated too. She starts stiff and careful, giving polite deflections, but the alcohol loosens her up and suddenly she's being sly: "You must be a strong drinker." Then more sly: "Sir, you say such cheesy things so casually." Her voice shifts in real time across the scene, and you can trace the exact moment she stops performing and starts being herself. The group dinner dialogue is also doing heavy lifting. Every character has a distinct flavor — Finn's teasing, Elvin's probing, Julia's theatrical storytelling, Georgia's gentle corrections. You never confuse who's speaking. The author clearly knows these people inside out.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are hilariously low on paper and incredibly high in practice. It is a dinner. Four men, four women, jazz music, coffee and alcohol. That is it. And yet the entire sequence plays out like a battlefield. Julia literally uses the word competition. She says there will be fierce competition for those two spots and she is not wrong—every glance, every introduction, every casual comment is a tactical move. Vivi's internal conflict is the real focus here. She spent the morning trying to maintain distance from Costance, telling herself she does not want to be seen with him, deliberately lying about her preferences to create space. And now she is sitting across from him at a narrow table while he looks at her like she is the only person in the room. The conflict is not external—it is the collision between what she thinks she wants and what is actually happening to her. The moment that captures the entire stakes dynamic is when he grabs her wrist. She thinks something is on her face. She reaches for a handkerchief. He stops her and says: "There is nothing on your face, so you do not have to wipe it." Then immediately follows up with: "Actually, it is the first time I have seen you with makeup, so my eyes kept going to you." That is the entire conflict compressed into two sentences. She is trying to hide. He is refusing to let her. And neither of them is going to win.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or