Doing This Kind of Thing with My Childhood Friend - Reviews

Doing This Kind of Thing with My Childhood Friend
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's a scene earlier in the text — or rather, a memory Ellen holds — where Madame Mendel comforts her on a birthday, and 'the melted candle wax had covered the whole cake, drawing complaints from her brothers and Felix.' This small detail keeps coming back to me because it encapsulates everything about this story: warmth that leaves a mess, love that's imperfect and sticky and real, and the fact that even the people who complain about it still stay. The shawl is another one. Ellen is walking away from the church, already half a ghost in her own life, and her shawl has slipped. Felix notices. He fixes it. He doesn't make a scene. But the gesture — caring enough to touch someone who's trying desperately to be left alone — it says everything neither of them can say out loud. The cold isn't just weather; it's the emotional chill of a daughter being sold into a marriage she didn't choose, standing at her mother's grave. And then there's the concept of 'family' itself, which the text interrogates relentlessly. Ellen says to her father, 'We may be close, but he isn't family' — referring to Felix. But she's wrong. Felix IS family in every way that matters. Madame Mendel raised her. Felix grew up with her. He defended her. He remembers her birthdays and first periods and boxing demonstrations. The Sawyers owe the Mendels a debt, yes, but the real debt is emotional — it's the kind that can never be repaid. The Earl's grief at the requiem mass is the loudest silence in the text. He loved his wife so much that he refuses to take a new wife, and now he's sacrificing his youngest daughter to some arrangement he can't seem to stop. The man who was once devoted is now the one issuing commands. The tragedy isn't just Ellen's — it's everyone's. I think that's what sticks with me most: this story isn't about one girl's arranged marriage. It's about how grief changes the people left behind, and how love and obligation are sometimes the same thing wearing different faces.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is genuinely masterful and I need to talk about how the author controls the rhythm. It starts at full emotional throttle. Ellen is breaking down to Lillian about her arranged marriage—high stakes, real pain, the kind of scene where you're sitting on the edge of your seat. The dialogue moves fast, Lillian fires question after question, and Ellen's answers get quieter and sadder each time. Then comes the Felix revelation, and the chapter drops us into a flashback. The flashback is brilliant pacing because it actually SLOWS everything down. We sit with young Ellen waiting on that sofa. We hear the muffled voices through the slightly opened door. The cookies feel heavier with each second. She leaves without confrontation, without explanation. Two weeks of avoiding him. The pace here is agonizingly slow, and it should be—this is the moment her whole world cracks. Then BOOM. We're cut to the present and the ensemble room. Professor Lopez dismisses class, students groan about their nails, and suddenly we're eavesdropping on salon gossip. The tonal shift is jarring and intentional—it's like the universe is saying 'yes, your heart is broken, but also here's some very practical information about the Belnua Salon.' It's almost comedic relief but it's not funny, it's desperate. Ellen's internal monologue spirals from 'if I go there... me too?' to remembering her brother's secret picture book. The narrative doesn't give us a breath between devastation and this bizarre coming-of-age moment. And it ends on another cliffhanger—Lillian's 'There's one way.' After all that emotional weight, the story pivots again. This author does NOT let you sit in sadness for long, and I respect that commitment to momentum.
... Read More
Let me just say this once: the way Felix interacts with Ellen is everything. On the surface he's being his usual annoying self — teasing her about being short, making jokes, humming as he walks away. But look at what he actually DOES. He notices her shawl has slipped down. He walks up to her, brushes his hand near her neck, straightens it, and says two words: 'It's cold.' Ellen's reaction? She tenses up. Not because she's angry — because her heart is pounding. 'Hoping her pounding heart would calm down quickly, and so that the heart she had only just managed to close would not open again.' SHE CLOSED HER HEART. FOR HIM. And Felix — Felix sees right through it. He's been patient, yes, but his patience has 'gradually been nearing its limit thanks to Ellen, who had been noticeably avoiding him for the past few months.' He doesn't push. He doesn't demand. He just shows up, fixes her shawl, cracks a joke, and walks away while humming. The self-control is honestly painful to read. Meanwhile Ellen's entire internal monologue is a war zone. She thinks Felix is 'the source of the trouble' and she wants nothing to do with him, but then Felix mentions Madame Mendel and suddenly she can't walk away. She has to go. Because Madame Mendel is the one who took her in, who stayed by her side through her first period, who held her while she cried. And Felix knows all of this. He's the bridge between her and the mother she never had. The fact that he uses that knowledge so casually — 'Even if we're not family, you can do at least that much, can't you?' — hits different. Because he's right. They're not family by blood, but they're something more complicated than that. I need to know what happens when they actually have to talk about the marriage.
... Read More
'I wish there were.' Those two words from Ellen when Lillian asks if there's something between her and Felix absolutely destroyed me. But honestly, Lillian is the absolute MVP of this entire passage. Let me count: She immediately picks up on Ellen's distress. She deduces it's an arranged marriage within TWO QUESTIONS. She tries to matchmake Ellen with Felix—not because she's being annoying, but because she genuinely sees that Ellen has feelings and Felix clearly cares too. And when Ellen shuts it down? Lillian doesn't give up, she just keeps pressing with actual evidence: 'Classes in diplomacy and public administration are far away from the ensemble room. And yet your childhood friend used to come looking for you every single break over that ten-minute distance.' That line is CHILLING in the best way. Lillian knows Felix better than Ellen seems to realize. She also drops this bomb about Felix being famous for not exchanging a single word with classmates, especially girls. So Ellen's special treatment wasn't just sibling nagging—it was something else entirely. And then Ellen confesses that Felix is going to marry Daphne, and Lillian just... freezes. Can't even respond. That silence says everything. This girl has been running on empty for years, holding onto a childhood promise that apparently meant nothing to the other person, and now even that tiny hope is gone. I need to know what Lillian's solution is. If it involves revenge or scheming, I am fully on board.
... Read More
Okay so the setup here is basically a classic arranged marriage plot but layered in SO much more. Ellen just got told by her father that her marriage is already decided, and she absolutely loses it at the requiem mass. The timing is brutal — her mother just died, everyone's mourning, and her dad drops this bomb about forcing her into a union. But then what happens next is the part that really gets me. She makes a dramatic exit, runs away from the church, and immediately bumps into Felix. Like, of course she does. She tries to bolt again, he follows her, and then she uses 'my mom wants to see you' as some kind of final escape hatch. The way Felix responds to that — his mood shifts instantly, that playful voice comes back — it's like her mention of Madame Mendel literally rewires him. And then the whole shawl moment. He walks up, fixes her shawl, says 'it's cold,' and immediately pivots to a joke about eating her share. The tension just deflates in the most frustrating way. I love how the plot uses physical proximity to show everything that can't be spoken aloud. Also — the Earl Sawyer going from furious thunderbolt-to-Ellen to bright smile for Felix within minutes? That's not subtle and I love it. The author is telling us exactly where power sits in this family. The chapter ends with Ellen back at the dorm, alone in the dark, muttering about how tragic her life is. No audience, no relief, just her with the weight of it all. That contrast between the charged moment with Felix and the cold isolation afterward — chef's kiss.
... Read More
This section is basically the plot hitting the point of no return and I am HERE for it. Let me trace the arc. Ellen arrives at the party with a plan: find a one-night stand before her arranged marriage locks her away forever. She's awkward, out of her depth, and immediately rejected by Asiel's classmates. The status quo is established—she's alone, unwanted, desperate. Then Felix appears. Not just appears—'the person she had absolutely not wanted to meet today, no, the person she absolutely must not meet.' That double negative is doing a lot of work. It's not enough that he's bad for her emotionally; his presence actively threatens her plan. She can't have a meaningless encounter when her childhood friend is watching, because part of her still wants HIM. The flashback to their childhood is essentially Plot Exposition disguised as nostalgia. We learn why pistachio cake matters, why Felix always apologizes first, why Ellen is angry at someone she's known for twenty-one years. But it also plants a crucial detail: Felix has NEVER seen her this angry before. Not when she ruined his presentation materials, not when she broke his pen. This is new. This is escalation. Then Ellen drops her plan on him: 'To fall in love in a single instant. To spend one wonderful night.' And Felix—FELIX—actually gets angry. The steady, patient, cake-bringing Felix loses his temper. That's a plot twist disguised as an emotional beat. The chapter ends with Ellen revealing she's engaged, Felix's face hardening, and everything we thought we knew about their relationship destabilizing. The central question shifts from 'Will they get together?' to 'What happens when someone who's always been available finally stops being available?' I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
The way this section moves is actually really clever and I want to talk about it. We start IN MEDIA RES at the party, Ellen alone, awkward, trying to drink champagne. The tension is immediate—you can feel her desperation and embarrassment. Then BOOM, Felix appears and everything changes. But instead of resolving anything, the author yanks us backward with 'The first time he truly felt the power of pistachio cake was around the age of nine.' That flashback is two full chapters worth of backstory compressed into what feels like minutes. A spilled drawing, a wooden sword, a deal with an elder brother, and the birth of a tradition. It's perfectly paced—the emotional beats land because we'd already been primed by the argument. Then we snap back to the present and the pacing EXPLODES. Felix asks her to leave, she refuses, he tries cake, she says no, and then she drops the nuclear bomb: 'To fall in love in a single instant.' The confrontation goes from awkward childhood friends to raw emotional violence in about five exchanges. The chapter ends on a cliffhanger—'Ellen asked in an irritated voice as she swept back her long hair. When she raised her head, she saw Felix's face growing harder by the second.' He already heard her say she's getting married. What happens next? I love how the author uses time jumps not as a crutch but as a weapon. Every flashback makes the present more painful. Every return to the party raises the stakes. It's like watching a pressure cooker build—until something has to give.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about this plot because holy shit. The setup is brutal and I love it. Ellen just finds out she's being married off to a complete stranger—no name, no face, no age, not even whether she's the first wife. Like, that is some next-level villain energy right there. And it's not because her family is failing; they literally built the steam locomotive line that everyone is freaking out about. So it's not financial ruin, it's just... an old promise? A father's word? That's even more infuriating because there's no dramatic reason, it's just patriarchal nonsense wrapped in tradition. But the real gut punch comes later when Lillian brings up Felix, and suddenly we get the flashback. This is where the author really nails the plot structure—Ellen overhears Felix saying he can't marry yet because 'His Majesty is watching,' which clearly means Princess Daphne. The timing is devastating. Ellen leaves behind those cookies and jam and never looks back, and the narrative doesn't even let us forget it. She hid in bathrooms to avoid him. Two weeks without seeing him. And now Daphne is apparently the one he's supposed to end up with, and Ellen is supposed to marry someone else entirely. The plot twist here isn't some big reveal—it's the slow realization that everyone involved has been making choices based on assumptions, and now everything is collapsing. Lillian at the end says 'There's one way' and we're left hanging. I am HERE for it.
... Read More
The scene where Ellen accidentally overhears her classmates talking about the Belnua Salon graduation party is one of the most vividly awkward things I've ever read. Let me paint this for you: You've got this elite music academy where students are dying to go to wild graduation salons, and Ellen is sitting there at the piano, trying to act natural while her brain short-circuits. Her classmates are openly discussing how the Belnua Salon has a perfect gender balance and couples 'just catch each other's eye, get a thrill, and head straight up to a hotel.' One girl even asks for tips on how to have a successful orgasm. And Ellen—the naive, sheltered noblewoman—who only learned about physical intimacy from secretly reading her brother Julien's pornographic picture book—starts imagining... well, you know. The imagery here is so sharp. The 'plainly intertwined man and woman' from that picture book at the bottom of Julien's secret box. The cookies and jam growing 'shabby' in her hands as she overhears Felix and his mother. The way the narrator describes Daphne's face at the academy—not angry, just 'enduring it because she was an Imperial Princess and had to preserve her dignity, when what she really wanted was to tear out all my hair.' That last line gave me actual chills. It reframes every cold glance Ellen received from the Princess as something far more personal and human. The academy world itself feels lived-in. There are recitals, ensemble rooms, supervising professors who actually scold students about their manicures, salons where people go to find partners. It's a wealthy, rigidly structured society where a girl can be worth millions in political value and still have zero agency over her own future.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how FELIX tried to use pistachio cake as a peace offering and Ellen straight up rejected it?? Like I get that she's hurt, but that was literally the moment everything shifted between them, wasn't it? The flashback revealed SO MUCH. Remember when Felix spilled juice on her drawing of her mom and she said 'you and I are breaking off forever now' at age nine? And then his brother literally set up a deal where Felix loses their sword practice every day until he makes it up to her? The pistachio cake wasn't just dessert—it was their language. Every fight, every apology, every time one of them needed the other without saying it out loud. And now Ellen looks at him and says 'Even if you died and came back, you still couldn't.' What?? That's not just anger, that's grief. She's mourning something that hasn't even officially ended yet. What struck me most was Felix's reaction when she refused the cake. The text says: 'he could not even force himself to keep pretending to smile.' For the first time, we see him genuinely angry, not just trying to manage her emotions like always. He's spent twenty-one years being the steady one, the one who apologizes, who brings cake, who follows her around. And she just… shut him out completely. The tragedy is that both of them want the same thing but neither can say it. Felix still treats her like the little girl who cried over a drawing. Ellen still hopes he'll choose her, even as she tries to find someone else at this party. They're both trapped in the roles they've played since childhood. I need to know what happens next. She told him she's getting married—that line hung there like a guillotine. His face was 'growing harder by the second.' What does he do now? Does he let her go? Or does he finally stop being the nice childhood friend and do something reckless?
... Read More
This book's dialogue is FIRE and I'm not even being dramatic about it. Lillian's voice is instantly recognizable and I would defend it with my life. Take this exchange: 'You don't lack anything.' 'He said it was an old promise. That's all he said.' 'That's just an excuse. Doesn't he just want to marry you off quickly?' Lillian doesn't do subtlety and neither does the prose. When she asks if Ellen did something wrong to her father—'Did you secretly squander the family fortune or something?'—and Ellen says 'I'd rather it were that. Then at least I wouldn't feel wronged'—that is a line that lives in my head rent-free. The raw honesty of it, the way Ellen can't even imagine a scenario worse than financial ruin because at least then there'd be a logical reason. The nobility treats her like defective merchandise and won't even explain why. And Lillian's matchmaking advice? Pure comedy gold: 'The newlyweds next door to us were friends since childhood too. But those two are so heated that every weekend when I go home, all those moaning sounds……!' 'Lillian!' I nearly fell out of my chair. The audacity. The complete lack of filter. And then she goes full prosecutor mode: 'As if he were watching whether his wife was cheating on him or not.' The dialogue between Ellen and Lillian feels like two real friends who have known each other for years— interruptions, unfinished sentences, Ellen deflecting with 'It's cold' when her face goes red, the awkward silences. Meanwhile, the narrator's voice has this wry, knowing quality that undercuts the drama with sharp observations. When Ellen thinks about Daphne's unspoken rage, the narration says: 'No, perhaps Daphne had only endured it because she was an Imperial Princess and had to preserve her dignity, when what she really wanted was to tear out all my hair.' That's not just dialogue—that's the author's voice whispering directly to us, and it's perfect.
... Read More
The party scene is one of those settings that feels so alive I could walk right into it. Let me set this up for you. A grand hall, champagne glasses lined up 'endlessly across a long table,' groups of young people in various states of mingling and pairing off. Late arrivals have already found partners. The background noise of conversation, clinking glass, the rustle of formal clothing. And Ellen—alone, in a dress she didn't know the dress code for, surrounded by people who look at her like she's a puzzle they can't solve. The contrast with Felix is brutal. He walks in dressed 'very well,' confident, familiar with the space. Ellen's described in this moment of humiliation where Asiel's male classmates all turn their heads and ignore her in unison, as though 'they had made a promise.' You can feel the collective social rejection like a physical push. But the most vivid image is probably that wrist grab. 'An unfamiliar warmth touched her skin.' The text lingers on the physical details—pale skin, thick knuckles, veins and fine blood vessels standing out. Her small delicate hand beside his intimidating one. This is written with such sensual precision that you forget, for a moment, that this is FELIX. You feel the romantic tension before Ellen does, and then the author yanks it away by revealing his face. The closed room from the painting, the heated atmosphere, the gentle hand stroking hair—that memory Ellen has is juxtaposed against the cold, crowded party hall. She wanted intimacy and got spectacle. She wanted destiny and got Felix Mendel, the one person who makes everything worse. This setting isn't just decoration. It's a social gauntlet, and everyone in it is being measured, judged, and filed away into categories. Ellen's outfit, her lack of drinking experience, her unfamiliarity with the social dance—all of it marks her as an outsider in a room full of people who've known each other their whole lives.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or