Divorce by Agreement - Reviews

Divorce by Agreement
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The glowing blue stone necklace is the first symbol that demands attention. It hangs from a black cord around Xie Xuanqing's neck — right over his heart, right where Jiuxia reaches for it. When she yanks the cord and it snaps, she's not just stealing an object, she's severing a tie. The text tells us directly: "If he loses that necklace, don't you think our tie will be broken for good?" What tie? We don't know yet. That's the point. The necklace is a promise, a contract, a bond that hasn't been explained but is clearly sacred. Then there's the blood. Zhu Lian mentions it casually, almost as an afterthought: "You carry his blood… and still don't know who I am?" Xie Zhuo's blood. What does it mean that Jiuxia carries it? The text earlier establishes that unless he fed me blood when I ascended, our marriage bond would be considered severed. So the blood exchange was a ritual, a binding, a choice — and now it's become a weapon, a clue, a mystery that connects Zhu Lian to both of them in ways none of us understand yet. The Pangu Axe appears repeatedly as an unspoken threat and an unattainable goal. Xie Zhuo won't give it up. Jiuxia believes Queen Mother of the West can wield it to slice through space-time. It represents ultimate power, ultimate escape, ultimate control over fate itself. And Xiaxia's porridge — that's the smallest symbol but possibly the most heartbreaking. Something warm, nourishing, made with intention, shattered on the floor because the recipient decided to make an example of it. And the final image: Zhu Lian dissolved into dark mist, barely holding human form, yet still smiling. He's wounded. Xie Xuanqing was wounded by the same kind of battle. The demons and the immortals are all hurting, all surviving, all connected by threads we haven't fully seen yet. The story isn't about good versus evil — it's about people who've been burned and are now burning everything else.
... Read More
There's a scene in the flashback where she waits outside the door all night in pouring rain and he won't let her in, and the image of that blue stone glowing 'like moonlight above storm clouds — silent and desolate' is honestly one of the most cinematic moments in this entire novel. The Queen Mother of the West could probably do this kind of thing but honestly the imagery here hits different because it's SO personal. The setting of Kunlun itself — year-round snow, the Immortal Residence, Blackwater River to the west where the corpse was found — it all feels layered and alive. Every location has weight. The mountain where the current scene happens, the residence where she waited in the rain, the riverbank — they're not just backdrop, they're emotional anchors. The black-red aura of the formation lingering in Kunlun's cool air, the shadow that obliterated instantly when Zhu Lian appeared... the world feels dangerous in a way that's constantly present, not just during action scenes. What I love is how the author uses weather as emotional punctuation. The rain that night. The storm cloud imagery attached to the stone. The cold. The snow. It's all connected.
... Read More
I need a minute. Just a minute. Xie Xuanqing says the exact same thing Xie Zhuo said five hundred years ago: 'If you're happy, don't learn too much.' And the narrator remembers it, remembers saying the same thing back to him when he asked if she was happy in Kunlun, remembers promising to take him around to try good food, remembers the rain that night and him locking her OUTSIDE after coming back covered in blood with that glowing blue stone. "I just wanted you to be happy. Not knowing makes it easier to be happy." And she thought — she actually thought — that he saw her as a useless caged canary. That line broke something in me. Because re-reading it now, with everything we know, it's not condescension. It's TERROR. He came back covered in blood, couldn't look at her, couldn't let her in, and his first instinct was to protect her ignorance. That's not treating someone like a canary. That's loving someone so much you'd rather they hate you than know what you've done. And she's still sitting there two hundred chapters later, having severed the bond with her own hands, still defending him to his face even after he used the necklace — the necklace she thought was about REMEMBRANCE — as a prop to cut them apart. She's furious. She's heartbroken. And she's still not afraid. That's not love. That's obsession. Or maybe those are the same thing.
... Read More
There's so much going on symbolically here and I want to unpack it because this story is layers deep. The Pangu Axe—obviously named after the mythological tool that split heaven and earth—is being used to split TIME and FATE. He's trying to chop the root of their destiny itself, which is such a violent metaphor for what divorce actually is: not just ending a relationship but trying to erase the entire foundation it was built on. And the Red Thread of Fate that connects them—she's offering to help cut it, to sever it 'from the very root,' which mirrors his desire to use the axe. Two different tools, same impulse: obliteration instead of reconciliation. Then there's the barrier around Kunlun. The Pangu Axe protects it. Their marriage protected something too—maybe not as literal as a geographic barrier, but it protected them both. Her as a god-marrying-a-monster outcast, him as... whatever he is. And now he's removing the guardian artifact while simultaneously trying to remove himself from her life. The mountain setting matters too. Kunlun is a sacred peak, a place of immortals, and they're at the FOOT of it in a desolate bamboo forest with thin spiritual energy. They don't belong in the mainstream anymore. They're at the margins, which is where they always were together.
... Read More
This chapter does something I really respect—it knows when to sprint and when to let you breathe. It opens with Fu Jiuxia's internal crisis, the realization that she's been approaching this wrong, and she bolts. The pacing is breathless here. She's running through a snowy bamboo forest shouting Xie Zhuo's name. Fast cuts. Short paragraphs. Emergency energy. Then—the confrontation. It slows down. The bamboo leaves rustle. The moonlight is hidden. Dialogue becomes the engine instead of action. Long, layered exchanges where each line builds on the last, escalating from quiet negotiation to full-blown emotional explosion. "You were the one who messed up." "What did I do wrong?" The tension ramps up syllable by syllable. And then—WHAM—she transitions into this completely different tonal register by deciding to hire a fox demon to distract Xie Xuanqing. The pacing shift is so abrupt it's almost comedic, and that's the genius of it. After the emotional intensity of that fight, we need a release valve, and the author gives us one that's both funny and deeply revealing about how Fu Jiuxia processes her pain: she throws herself into a ridiculous scheme instead of sitting with her feelings. Then the chapter ends on an almost mundane note—her arriving at the cave, noticing Xie Xuanqing still working on that half-finished flute. A quiet button on top of a chaotic sequence. It's the narrative equivalent of taking a deep breath before the next wave hits.
... Read More
The imagery in this thing is actually insane. Let me just highlight a few moments because the author knows how to paint a picture. First, the Mount Buzhou confrontation—Queen Mother of the West literally watching them argue their way into a granted divorce after they 'knocked the mountain even more askew.' The casual worldbuilding of 'these two fought so hard they physically damaged sacred geography' is brilliant. Then the Hall of the Matchmaker scene—the green scissors, the trembling servant, the red string of fate shimmering into view when Jiuxia picks them up. That visual of the thread swaying in the wind, the trees of longing rustling... cinematic as hell. But the real showstopper is the Kunlun Summit sequence. A black rift tearing at the moon and stars 'as if trying to devour the entire sky.' Xie Zhuo holding the Pangu Axe 'casually, as if he were playing with a toy.' And then the finale—his silhouette carving 'a bright path through the clouds like a heavenly river—beautiful, yet distant.' Every scene has this epic, mythological weight to it, but it's grounded in such specific sensory details. The cold ground, the sharp eyes, the smell of wine on three-day-old breath. The world feels lived-in and ancient, and the romanticism of it all is unmatched.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how Xie Xuanqing sniffed her and then asked what she ate? Like, that moment right there — the safe distance between them vanishing, his nose nearly brushing her neck, the goosebumps — and then he's like, "What did you eat?" instead of some romantic or threatening response. The subversion ischefd'oeuvre. The entire scene plays out like a trap being set, but the trap snaps shut on the reader's expectations instead of the characters. And then the chili pepper moment. She grabs it, shoves it straight into his mouth, and he actually eats it. Doesn't yell. Doesn't throw a fit. Just chews slowly, swallows, and says, "You shouldn't eat it on its own." Then when she pours wine down his throat, he chokes but the narration specifically calls out that he was "trying to suppress the coughing on purpose, as if he didn't want me to feel embarrassed." And THAT'S when the protagonist realizes: this isn't just acting. If he's faking not hating spicy food and wine, his body must genuinely hate it. But he's enduring it for her. The realization hits like — I don't know, it's one of those moments where the plot quietly recontextualizes everything that came before. Then the next day, she tries to use Xie Zhuo as a weapon against Xia Xia by having him smash all the gifts, and he literally can't bring himself to do it. He gets distracted and taken away instead. The plan completely backfires. Of course it does. That's the plot logic here — every scheming move the protagonist makes either fails or reveals something she didn't intend to learn.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is SO characteristic and I love it. Xie Zhuo's voice is basically absence—you notice what he DOESN'T say. The narration literally points this out: other immortals thought he was mute because he only ever said 'Mm,' 'No,' 'Alright.' But with her? He said more. Even if it was just 'No, don't, can't do that, stay inside.' Those short, commanding, negative sentences. Every single one was actually him trying to keep her safe. The line about divorce day being when he spoke the most words of his life? That broke me because it recontextualizes EVERY conversation they ever had. He wasn't cold—he was TRYING. And now he's standing in a bamboo hut built from sliced bamboo, refusing to meet her eyes, communicating through threats and silence and cheek pinches, and it's devastating because we finally understand what was happening the whole time. But Fu Jiuxia's voice is just as distinct—her internal monologue is ALL CAPS energy in normal text form. "Was sneaking spicy food or stealing drinks really that unbearable to him?" "Then all the more reason we should've split earlier!" She's making jokes to stay brave, using humor as armor, and it's so human. The contrast between her frantic inner voice and his icy exterior is the whole dynamic of the book compressed into dialogue.
... Read More
At this point, the stakes feel impossibly high, and I love it. On the surface, it's a divorce story. But now? Now it's about survival, identity, and whether love can survive truth. Xie Xuanqing's secret isn't just a fun reveal—it's a landmine. If she finds out he's a clan-murdering demon, does she still want him? And what about the external threat? Zhulián is loose in spirit if not in body, threatening to 'tear that little immortal girl to pieces.' Xie Zhuo is sealing him away while his body is probably breaking down. Meanwhile, she's trying to use the very same seal as a ticket home. The conflict isn't just 'will they get together?' It's 'can any of them survive what they're fighting for?' And the internal conflict is killing me. She's torn between gratitude, guilt, attraction, and her original goal of returning to her own time. Every time she feels close to him, she reminds herself: we're divorced. But then he says 'I will protect her' and her resolve cracks. What's the price of going back? Does she abandon him? Does he stay trapped in that cave dimension forever? The author isn't letting anyone win easily. Even the small moments—like her lying about not wanting to leave—are stacked with consequences. Because if he knows she was planning to go, will he push her away? Or will he beg her to stay? Either way, someone gets hurt. That's the tension I'm living for.
... Read More
Let me tell you about pacing because Chapter 1 is a textbook example of 'here's a normal day, oh wait, everything is on fire.' It starts slow—domestic complaint energy, best friend coffee talk, the relatable fury of restricted diet for five centuries. You're settling in, thinking this might be a light rom-com premise, and then BAM—divorce at the Matchmaker's hall. Still manageable. Still contained. And then she goes back to Mengmeng's place, has a quiet philosophical moment about fate and time, falls asleep... and WAKES UP FIVE HUNDRED YEARS IN THE PAST with her ex-husband holding a reality-splitting weapon. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it WORKS. The author uses that quiet midnight conversation with Mengmeng as the last moment of peace before everything detonates. Chapter 2 then ramps up the mystery at an almost aggressive pace—time travel revealed in the first few paragraphs, the Pangu Axe explained, Xie Zhuo's true nature starting to peek through the cracks. It doesn't let you catch your breath between revelations. And the cliffhanger? He steps off a cliff into a cloud sea and says he's going to 'sever his own fate.' No explanation. No comfort. Just pure narrative violence. I have seventeen tabs open and I haven't slept in two days.
... Read More
I keep coming back to one detail: when past Fu Jiuxia walks away after saying "I already like you," Xie Zhuo doesn't call her back. He just stands there. Frozen. And later, holding that basket of bamboo shoots, he asks "Why'd you stop?" and when she says it's because there's no chili, he goes completely silent. He remembers. Of course he remembers. He remembers every single reason she stopped liking him, and he couldn't fix a single one. But here's what actually wrecked me—when he says "I don't like you" to past Fu Jiuxia, she thinks it's the scripted line. But then she realizes: "That sentence wasn't meant for the past me, and yet it was. From another angle, it had to be meant for me." Because the future Fu Jiuxia has been pushing him away for five hundred years too, and he's still here doing this impossible mission with her. He never left. And then the way he carries her past self out of the courtyard without a word. No complaint. No drama. Just does it. He's been silently holding onto this woman for five centuries, pretending he doesn't care, while she's been doing the exact same thing. The real tragedy isn't that they fell out of love. It's that they both loved each other so badly they forgot how to show it.
... Read More
What strikes me most about this chapter is how brilliantly the author weaponizes marital history. Xie Zhuo and the protagonist aren't just divorced—they're divorced across five hundred years of regret, betrayal, and unresolved tension. The current dynamic is fascinating: she still harbors genuine care for him (evidenced by the three months of nursing him back to health), yet her default mode is defensive sarcasm and emotional self-protection. Meanwhile, Xie Zhuo operates in a strange liminal space—he knows everything about their shared history but can only express it through cruel theatricality. The most revealing moment comes when he refuses to hit anyone she cares about. After listing Mengmeng, Wu Cheng, Huanhuan, Li Shu, Gu Chengzhi, and even the Queen Mother of the West as potential targets, she draws her sword and stakes her life on stopping him. His immediate concession—"I won't go"—speaks volumes. Despite claiming he never saw anyone else in five hundred years of marriage, he demonstrates he still cares about her wellbeing more than his plan. This contradiction makes him deeply compelling. Her past self, conversely, represents everything she's lost: trust, openness, emotional availability. When past-me punches Xie Zhuo in the eye without flinching, it's a heartbreaking mirror of what their relationship once was. The line "I really, really, really liked you back then" lands like a hammer—because the reader now understands that past-self's fierce affection was genuine, unguarded, and ultimately betrayed. What makes this character study so rich is that both versions of the protagonist are equally valid: the current one is hardened and pragmatic, but past-self wasn't foolish—she just loved harder.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or