Diary of Raising a Mermaid - Reviews

Diary of Raising a Mermaid
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
So the stakes in this section are doing a lot of heavy lifting and I want to break down why it works so well. On the surface level you have Lance vs. his own confusion—why did he turn into a mermaid? What happened at Sunset Bay? These are personal stakes that drive his motivation. But then you layer on Wensir's deteriorating condition, which adds urgency. Every day they spend in the shallow sea is a day Wensir gets weaker. And then there's the deeper conflict: humans and sea monsters are at odds, and Lance is hiding his true nature from a sea monster. That's a ticking time bomb. The author is playing with multiple conflict layers simultaneously and they all feed into each other. When Wensir grabs Lance's arm and asks what he really wants to do at Sunset Bay, it's not just a jealous moment—it's the collision of all these conflicts. Lance can't tell him the truth because humans and merfolk are enemies. Wensir can't press too hard because he might lose Lance. And meanwhile there's this whole parallel storyline with Wen Yu on the experimental ship, dealing with his own identity crisis and bodily deterioration. The merging of those two narratives is going to be huge. What I love most is how the author maintains suspense without relying on cheap cliffhangers. The tension comes from dramatic irony—we know things the characters don't. We know Lance is human. We know Wensir is sick. We know the jellyfish has its own agenda. Every interaction between these characters is loaded with unspoken meaning, and that's what keeps you turning pages.
... Read More
So here's the thing about this section—the author could have made Lance's learning-to-hunt sequence drag forever. Three whole hours of him missing, bumping into coral, trying again. But instead we get these sharp little beats: the blue flames scattering, the flickering glow, Lance's clumsy failures, then suddenly he's a blur and he's got the fish. It's edited down to the essential moments. I didn't feel like I was waiting. I felt like I was watching something unfold in real time. Then the black storm hits and the pacing goes from chill to full-throttle survival in one paragraph. Wei Er just says 'let's go' and suddenly we're in the anemone with the water turning blood-red. No warning, no slow build. And then the storm passes and Lance immediately tries to sneak away? That's the kind of character-driven pacing that keeps me hooked. He's not just reacting to the plot, he's making choices. The jellyfish encounter is where things get weirdly funny after all that tension. One minute Lance is terrified of the storm, the next he's sitting on a coral bone munching jellyfish tentacle while eavesdropping on underwater monster chat. The tonal whiplash is real but it works because Lance's personality—curious, impulsive, slightly unhinged—carries it. And then the tentacle snatching the jellyfish away? Back to danger in a heartbeat. The author knows exactly when to punch you and when to let you breathe, even if just for a second.
... Read More
I need to talk about the atmosphere in this section because the author is really crafting something special with the worldbuilding. The deep sea scenes are cold and dark but there's this weird warmth to them because of Lance and Wensir's interactions. The coral bone with its shaped little fish and twinkling stars—that's such a vivid image. It immediately establishes this underwater world that feels alive and mysterious. Then you have the blue-ringed octopus moment, which is both educational and thrilling. Lance almost gets poisoned because he thought it was a big fish, and Wensir has to physically grab his tail to pull him back. It's a perfect example of how the environment itself is a character—dangerous, beautiful, unpredictable. The stone bed scene is another standout. Wensir casually covers a flat stone with seaweed and calls it a bed. This is a merman who has adapted to his environment in such practical, almost domestic ways. And then the nightmare sequence shifts everything—the cruise ship, the sea monster tearing through steel like paper, Lance drowning. That's when the worldbuilding expands beyond the underwater realm and connects to the human world. The experimental ship with Wen Yu adds another layer of atmosphere—clinical, cold, decaying. The contrast between the organic warmth of the deep sea and the sterile horror of the experimental ship is striking. Even the jellyfish scene has its own weird beauty, with two mutated jellyfish swimming together in what the narrative describes as a loving embrace. The world feels lived-in and strange, and every location has its own texture and mood.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Wei Er and Lance's dynamic because honestly it's the best thing in this book. The way Wei Er watches Lance hunt for THREE HOURS without intervening? That's not just patience, that's someone who genuinely wants to see the other person grow. And then when Lance finally catches his first fish and brings it to him like a proud toddler, Wei Er divides it and keeps the best piece for himself while giving Lance the rest. Lance thinks it's about mermaid hierarchy but come on, we all know what's really happening here. It's a power move disguised as a snack sharing moment. The healing scene though—when Wei Er touches Lance's wound and asks 'Does it hurt?' and Lance is just genuinely delighted that mermaids can regenerate? That's the kind of tenderness that sneaks up on you. Wei Er isn't loud about caring, he shows it through actions. Stroking Lance's hair during the storm, pulling him back into the anemone, the way his 'mocking yet almost sinister' smile appears when he says 'no rush' about leaving. This guy is absolutely invested. And Lance calling him 'Little Black' then immediately correcting himself? The fact that Lance is learning social cues in real time around Wei Er? I'm dead. Who else is shipping this so hard??
... Read More
Let me just say this: Wensir is one of the most fascinating characters I've encountered in a while and I need everyone to understand why. On the surface he's this cold, possessive merman who grabs Lance's arm and yells at him, but then you see him fall into these unconscious states where Lance has to practically drag him along for three days. And what's the reason? The shallow sea doesn't agree with him. He's literally deteriorating because he agreed to come here for Lance. But here's the thing that gets me—when Lance suggests they part ways at Sunset Bay, Wensir immediately says no way. He won't let Lance go alone. That's not control, that's... I don't even know what that is. It's something messier than love and something more than duty. And then the jellyfish scene! Lance goes to the super jellyfish and says he'll go alone if it takes Wensir back. He's starving, he's exhausted, his scales have dulled, and he's willing to sacrifice his own goal because Wensir's health matters more. That's not a naive little fish anymore, that's someone who has genuinely grown to care about another being. The relationship between these two has shifted so much from the coral bone incident to now. It's no longer just captor and captive. Lance is feeding Wensir, singing to him, kissing his forehead. And Wensir—despite his anger and his secrets—keeps bringing Lance back when he tries to swim ahead. He says you're going the wrong way and then points the correct direction. He's the master but he's also the one making sure Lance survives. These two are codependent in the healthiest and unhealthiest ways simultaneously.
... Read More
I am not okay with how funny this text is. The jellyfish scene alone deserves its own award. Let me just quote this exchange because I can't paraphrase it without losing everything: [Really? What does a mermaid look like?] [You don't even know that… The cuteness of the little cutie cannot be described; I want to stuff him into my skirt.] SKIRT. THE JELLYFISH SAID SKIRT. And then when Lance literally bites its tentacle: [Owwww, there's really a mermaid, the mermaid bit me!] [Really? Really? Wuwuwu, I also want to be bitten by a mermaid.] I was wheezing. This is the kind of humor that makes you read a dark, post-apocalyptic underwater survival story and suddenly you're cackling at a jellyfish's romantic advances. But what's really impressive is how each character's voice is distinct. Lance's internal monologue is all wide-eyed wonder and impulsive decisions. Wei Er/Wensir speaks in these short, loaded sentences—'No rush.' 'I can.' 'That's not the point.' He says so little but it always hits. And the sea monsters? They have this chaotic group-chat energy that feels like eavesdropping on a really weird Discord server. The dialogue between Lance and Wensir about whether Lance can join the group chat is also great because it reveals their whole dynamic in three lines. Wensir knows Lance would 'drive them crazy.' He's not wrong.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this nightmare sequence because it absolutely wrecked me. Lance dreams about the black-tailed mermaid dragging him into the abyss, right? And at first I was like oh this is just a weird dream from his mermaid transformation. But then—BAM—he wakes up and Wensir is holding him, their tails intertwined. The dream wasn't random, it was his subconscious processing the reality of what Wensir is and what he represents. That line where Wensir says he has to hold Lance while sleeping because he might drift away? That's actually heartbreaking when you think about it. Wensir is so possessive, sure, but it's also this desperate need to keep Lance anchored to him. And then the whole cold war that follows—Lance insisting on going to Sunset Bay and Wensir getting genuinely angry for the first time. The tension between them is delicious. Lance is lying about his real motivation, and Wensir clearly knows it but can't bring himself to say it. Their whole dynamic is built on these unspoken things, and that's what makes it so aching. I kept waiting for one of them to just say what they actually feel, but neither will. Classic. Also the part where Lance is humming that made-up song to soothe Wensir while he's unconscious? That's peak soft content and I am not okay.
... Read More
"This was the first time Lance learned that storms could happen in the deep sea." I literally gasped reading this. The author takes this moment—Lance hiding in the sea anemone while the world outside turns apocalyptic—and makes it feel like a blockbuster movie scene. The seawater turning dark red like blood, the white coral bones scraping black, the blue flame fish getting shredded by whirlpools full of razor-sharp debris. And meanwhile Wei Er is just lying there casually stroking Lance's hair like they're at a picnic instead of a underwater apocalypse. But what really sells the worldbuilding is how the author plants the human-world connection without making it feel like exposition. The radiation explanation comes naturally from Wensir, and then BAM—Lance's flashback to the cruise ship, the aurora, the giant tentacle crushing everything. That transition from the storm's noise into Lance's memory is seamless. The blue-green aurora dancing before the tentacle falls? Chilling. It makes you realize this underwater world isn't just some fantasy setting—it's Earth's future, or maybe its replacement. And the giant jellyfish with its translucent body and the way it floats like a hot air balloon? The visual contrast between the dark, violent storm and this absurdly cute jellyfish that just wants to touch the mermaid's face? The author's range is insane.
... Read More
Let's talk about what Lance is actually up against because the stakes keep escalating and I am NOT ready. First it's the tentacles that grabbed him and turned him into a mermaid in the first place. Then it's the black storm that could crush him. Then it's the jellyfish that tries to abduct him (with genuinely poisonous tentacles, by the way—Wei Er had to cut it loose). And then RIGHT AFTER that, more giant tentacles burst from below the coral bone and drag the jellyfish away like it was nothing. The text says: "several giant tentacles suddenly burst out from beneath the coral bone, wrapping around the super giant jellyfish and dragging it away with a swish." A SWISH. This thing just casually snatched a SUPER GIANT jellyfish like it was a snack. And Lance is just sitting there realizing that outside the coral bone, there are sea monsters with ill intentions AND monsters with neutral intentions AND monsters that are just absurdly powerful. The coral bone was supposed to be safe. It's not. But the real stakes are internal too. Lance wants to leave. He's been waiting for the storm to clear so he can escape. But every time he tries to go, something pulls him back—literally and figuratively. Wei Er keeps him close. The world outside is terrifying. And yet Lance keeps trying. That's the core conflict: freedom versus survival, and whether he can have both. The ending of this section with Wensir going rigid like a piece of wood when a tentacle approaches? Whatever is happening to him, I need answers NOW.
... Read More
Okay so I've been thinking about this black storm thing and I genuinely believe it's not just a weather event. The text tells us it's caused by radiation from a sunken nuclear power plant—a human mistake that poisoned the ocean. But symbolically? It feels like the old world's wreckage crashing into the new one. The white coral bones turning black, the blue flame fish getting shredded, the whole ecosystem being rewritten by something humans did without understanding the consequences. And Lance—he was HUMAN once. He was on that cruise ship. He saw the aurora and made this philosophical comment about how human extinction might just be the beginning for the next species. Then the tentacle came and he became part of this new world. The storm is basically the same force that transformed him: destructive, incomprehensible, but also generative. Without that radiation, without that cataclysm, there's no mermaid Lance, no underwater civilization, no Wei Er. The jellyfish wanting to 'stuff him into my skirt' is weirdly touching when you think about it too. This creature, born from a poisoned ocean, still finds beauty and wants connection. The sea monsters aren't just monsters—they're the children of Earth's mistakes, just trying to live. And Lance, caught between his human memories and his mermaid present, is the bridge between two worlds. That's heavy stuff wrapped in what looks like a lighthearted adventure.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or