Some appreciate the novel, others loathe it, and some even consider mediocrity a masterpiece due to their obsession. As for me, I don't fit into those categories. I would rate this 3 stars, but fanatical praise forces me to give it a 1-star rating. My review is based on logic, common sense, and a realistic perspective. Have we truly embraced mediocrity as excellence and mediocrity as bad? - DarkBerserkerAA
To begin with, this light novel is overrated. The storytelling loses interest around Volume 16, and the dialogue quality deteriorates in Volume 9 due to excessive harem-related humor. Despite being an adult Earth-origin character with a profession, the main character lacks a relatable human personality. However, there are moments where it shines, particularly in Volume 1, introducing a captivating premise and allowing readers to envision the potential of the Desumachi world. The descriptions are vivid, warm-hearted scenes abound, and the lighthearted atmosphere prevails. The main character's boldness in brothels (though irrelevant) and his pursuit of justice as a hero can be entertaining, but it becomes excessive.
In terms of storytelling structure, it starts strong in Volumes 1 and 2, grows in Volumes 3-5, reaches maturity in Volumes 6-8, and then begins to decline. From Volume 9 onwards, it becomes sturdier but loses vitality, with branches growing in Volume 10, followed by a stagnation in Volumes 11-12 and decay in Volumes 13-15. By Volume 16, it's barely alive, and the story fails to reach its full potential.
The world-building, while decent, isn't elaborated upon here to avoid spoilers.
The main character disappoints with his lack of genuine humanity. He's easily manipulated, overly cautious, and doesn't reveal his true strength, even though he's overpowered. He treats the world as a game and appears thick-skinned, making him unsympathetic. His character development is underwhelming.
The harem aspect is disappointing – it's more like a domestic arrangement than a true harem. The author seems to intentionally frustrate readers, leading to speculation about the author's own desires. The main character's relationships with fiancées are shallow, driven by weak motives.
The comedy tag is misleading; it's more situational humor than a consistent source of laughter. It serves to support the slice of life theme rather than standing on its own.
Action and adventure are present, but the fights are average, lacking excitement. The novel leans more towards a slice of life style, akin to "Shokugeki no Kumo desu ga Nai ka" or a food-centric story.
Morality-wise, the protagonist accepts slavery without much resistance, violating the principles of freedom. His hypocrisy is a significant moral issue. Characters in the story are either hostile or quickly become friendly, often based on superficial interactions.
Comparing it to "Overlord" and "Kumo Desu ga Nani Ka," Desumachi ranks lowest among the three, receiving a score of 5, while Overlord scores 9.5 and Kumo Desu ga scores 9.
In conclusion, this light novel is worth a try, but I advise stopping at Volume 9 to avoid disappointment. Enjoy the first nine volumes, but approach the later parts with caution.