Butterflies Fly Over Winter - Reviews

Butterflies Fly Over Winter
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about how this author controls tension like a god. Chapter after chapter, the pacing is deliberate—never rushed, never dragging. It builds through accumulation of tiny moments rather than big dramatic events. A shrimp paste placed in a bowl. A hat offered. A cat paw held. These are the cliffhangers here, and they work. The flashbacks are deployed perfectly too. The hotpot triggers a memory of ANOTHER hotpot from two years ago—same food, different mood, same people, different world. And then within THAT memory, the ring scene. It's nested. Layered. Like peeling an onion and crying at every layer. What I love most is how the author uses silence as a pacing tool. The walk home after the cat scene: they don't speak much, but the narration tells us they're "a little more natural than when they had first met." Two years of history compressed into a single comparative sentence. No dramatic confrontation. No forced resolution. Just... forward motion. And then—the semi-final barbecue flashback at the END. The text literally cuts off mid-thought: "the tone and feelings were already d—" and we're left hanging. Not a proper cliffhanger, but something worse. An INCOMPLETE memory. The narrator refuses to finish the sentence, as if the emotion is too raw to articulate. The variety show subplot with Nie Chuiying reading fanfiction and getting caught on camera, the Super Topic shutdown drama, the group chat messages—all of these threads run parallel to the main emotional arc without overwhelming it. The author knows when to tighten the focus (the cat scene) and when to let the background hum (Weibo notifications pinging). It's disciplined storytelling that trusts the reader to hold multiple layers at once.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this scene for a second. The play reading. Xi Ai is performing, and she's so deep in it that her eyes are red at the corners. Chu Yiqi feels something—pity, regret, bitterness—and without thinking raises her hand. A tear falls. Warmth on the back of her hand. And then Xi Ai... stops. Snaps out of character at some point Chu Yiqi didn't even notice, reaches out instinctively, and stops just short. That gap between their hands. That's the whole story right there. "She felt it must have been the former." That smile—whether real or performative, Xi Ai never clarifies. Chu Yiqi assumes it's genuine. I'm still not sure either. What kills me is how both of them are simultaneously drowning and pretending the water's fine. Later, during the party game, Xi Ai keeps looking at Chu Yiqi instead of the screen. Everyone notices. The bullet comments are losing their minds. But when they actually lock eyes? They both look down at the exact same moment and start nervously fixing their hair like adolescents. "Love is restraint." The fans say it. But it's not restraint, is it? It's terror. Terror of what happens if they stop pretending this is just camaraderie. Xi Ai almost says something once—"Then why don't you look at me instead?"—and catches herself mid-sentence. The tragedy isn't that they don't love each other. It's that they remember loving each other so vividly, and they don't know how to be that version of themselves around each other anymore.
... Read More
I need to appreciate the dialogue in this section because it's genuinely excellent. The debate about fighting versus not fighting doesn't read like a philosophy lecture — it reads like two people who actually LIVE different lives colliding. Xi Ai's voice is direct, sharp, sometimes almost cruel: "What is the difference between this and a high school composition?" She's impatient with abstraction. She wants to get to the point. And when she delivers her argument about people trapped in prison blaming those who fight — that's not rehearsed rhetoric, that's someone speaking from actual experience. Chu Yiqi's voice is quieter, more measured, but not weak. "As long as you don't fight, no one in the world can fight with it." She's drawing from a different well — maybe strategy, maybe survival, maybe a lifetime of learning that visibility equals danger. Her dialogue is sparse but weighted. The exchanges between them have this incredible rhythm. Xi Ai attacks, Chu Yiqi absorbs, Xi Ai pushes harder, and then Chu Yiqi goes silent. That silence IS her response. The author understands that what people DON'T say is often the most honest thing about them. And the humor! "How abominable!" when the memory kill is proposed. Zhou Qingxi being Zhou Qingxi — mouth faster than brain. These small moments keep the dialogue from becoming too heavy. The author knows when to let the characters breathe.
... Read More
I need to talk about how OBSESSED this book is with screens. Every major beat in these chapters involves a phone or a camera. They fall into a ditch WHILE playing on their phones. The entire live stream subplot is about performance versus authenticity. Xi Ai washes her face, puts on light makeup, and suddenly feels relief because she doesn't look like a zombie. But then she's STILL performing—reading mean comments and clapping back at them for an audience that includes people who are literally watching her do it. The brooch is interesting too. Xi Ai flicks it at Chu Yiqi like a projectile, and Chu Yiqi slides it back without a word. It's a tiny object passing between them—like a tennis ball in a match neither of them agreed to start. What does it represent? Affection? Annotation? A message that can't be spoken aloud? And the live stream itself—Su Luojian wanted them to "act naturally" so it wouldn't feel awkward with staff around. But isn't that the whole joke? They're performing naturalness. There are cameras everywhere. Xi Ai almost got caught in her pajamas looking grumpy. The fans are screen-recording everything. Reality is so layered in this book that I'm not sure any of it is accidental anymore. The title itself—Butterflies Fly Over Winter—feels like it's about transformation under impossible conditions. These characters are constantly being watched, constantly performing, constantly trying to be real in a world that only values the curated version. And yet... The moments that hit hardest are the ones with no audience. The brooch sliding back. The thumbs-up behind everyone's backs. The silent understanding when neither of them says a word.
... Read More
Let me set the record straight: the highest-stakes scene in these chapters involves someone asking whether a fictional shipping pair is real or fake at three in the morning. Nie Chuiying stayed up until 3 AM reading novels. Xi Ai got a call at 4 AM about CP theories. Yu Nianxi was scrolling videos at 2:30 AM and liked a post at 3:20. This is a group of people whose insomnia is DIRECTLY caused by obsessing over each other's relationships. And yet—the real tension isn't about any of that. It's about what happens when you're caught. When Su Luojian corners them and Xi Ai immediately snitches to deflect, only to accidentally expose her own midnight browsing habits. The stakes here are embarrassingly low and strangely high at the same time. They're performers. Their image is everything. Getting caught looking ridiculous on a live stream at 7 AM in your pajamas could cost them credibility. Credibility is currency in their world. But the scene that actually made my heart rate go up was the ditch moment. Two girls, alone, in the dark, both so distracted by their phones that they fall into... what, exactly? A construction ditch? Who digs a ditch on a sidewalk and doesn't put up a sign? And neither of them is mad at the situation—they're mad at themselves for caring more about their phone than the road. That's not slapstick. That's character. That's "we are too connected to devices and each other simultaneously" written as physical comedy. The author knows how to make small things feel enormous. A missed message. A brooch thrown across a room. A comment section war. These are the things that matter in their world, and the book treats them with the gravity they deserve.
... Read More
Everything in this chapter is framed as a game. Draw lots. Team assignments. Punishments. Red envelopes. Fanfic readings. It is all entertainment, all performance, all something to fill the silence between two people who have not figured out how to just TALK to each other after two years apart. But the stakes are so much higher than anyone is admitting, and the text keeps threatening to rip the game facade apart. Consider Chu Yiqi's three-word moment. She leans in. She is about to say something. And then she stops. Why does she stop? What was she going to say? The narrative tells us it was probably just competitive spirit, just the dynamics of winning and losing that defined their relationship since they first met. But we know that is a lie. Both of them know it is a lie. The external conflict is simple — it is a variety show, they are performing for an audience, there are rules and punishments. But the INTERNAL conflict is what makes this unbearable. Xi Ai has spent two years apparently moving on, building her career, becoming a Movie Queen. Chu Yiqi left the country for reasons she will not explain, came back, and now they are sitting across from each other pretending this is normal. The moment that crystallizes everything for me is when Xi Ai looks at the phone beside her — Chu Yiqi looking up the scene she chose — and feels a pang in her chest. She sees the butterfly pendant on Chu Yiqi's wrist. She swallows back a remark. That is the entire relationship right there: things said and unsaid, gestures made and withheld, two people who clearly still care desperately but have built this entire interaction around games and distractions and deflection. What happens when the game ends?
... Read More
CAN WE TALK ABOUT HOW OBSSESSED WITH EACH OTHER THEY ARE?? The way Xi Ai deliberately bites Chu Yiqi but uses the side WITHOUT her tiger tooth so it doesn't hurt? That's not accidental. That is a person who has been memorizing every detail about another human being for YEARS and is too terrified to admit it. And Chu Yiqi? "Are you okay?" She asks and then catches herself, adds "why does your Huya feel different?" She notices. She ALWAYS notices. Two years apart and she still knows the shape of Xi Ai's teeth. But the real masterpiece is how they perform for everyone else. "Teacher Xi" and "Teacher Chu" - these titles are such perfect armor, right? Professional distance on the surface but when Chu Yiqi says them with that slight smile, you KNOW she's doing it on purpose to make Xi Ai short-circuit. And Xi Ai plays along because if she stops playing, she might actually say something real. The cookie scene is peak character work. She steals the burnt cookie, watches Chu Yiqi suffer, eats it herself, then later offers another one. It's manipulation but it's also affection. It's the only language either of them knows how to speak. I'm emotionally compromised by these two.
... Read More
The dialogue in this book is absolutely *chef's kiss* and I need to dissect why. Let's start with the exchange that haunts me: > "Can I take that as concern?" > "Maybe." That's it. That's the whole meal. Chu Yiqi could have said anything—"yes," "stop being dramatic," "I don't know"—but she says MAYBE. Which means she's either too flustered to commit to the word "concern" or she's deliberately leaving room to pretend she didn't mean it that way. And Xi Ai's reaction—suppressing a smile, putting down the cold drink, walking away—tells us she understood exactly what was left unsaid. The nicknames alone are a masterclass in character voice. "Yuni Filling" for Yu Nianxi. "South Vegetable Garden" for Chu Yiqi ( CYJJ ). "Cute Duo" for Xi Ai and the leader. These aren't just funny—they're an entire language the characters share that excludes the audience, which is exactly how real friend groups work. Nie Chuiying's dialogue is pure chaos energy and I love her for it: > "I hate you. I'm switching to an alt account." > "We recognize all your alt accounts." > "…I'm doing it anyway!" She has no self-preservation instinct and the group enables her constantly. The fact that she tried to give Xi Ai mango despite knowing (or should have known) Xi Ai is allergic to it, and her internal monologue catching herself mid-disaster—"You're such a blockhead. You ship them so hard usually, but you don't remember at all that Qiqi loves eating mangoes"—is comedy gold written with genuine warmth. The livestream comments as a Greek chorus is another brilliant narrative device. The audience inside the story is constantly commenting, misinterpreting, shipping, panicking—and the characters selectively ignore or address them. When Chu Yiqi reads "They've been reminded" about the mango situation, she's not actually reading it aloud to the group. She's quietly confirming to Xi Ai that someone already handled it. The barrier between the livestream audience and the private reality of their relationships is constantly being negotiated. And Shi Yunshan's deadpan delivery of "Pancakes. Boiling noodles. Baking a cake. Egg tarts. Mochi." as a menu recital while the comments compare them to a crosstalk troupe—this author understands rhythm in dialogue the way a musician understands tempo.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or