Butterflies Fly Over Winter - Reviews

Butterflies Fly Over Winter
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk about that opening dream because it's not atmospheric window dressing—I'm pretty sure it's the key to everything. Chu Yiqi wakes up from a nightmare where a furious blurred figure is yelling at her, and the only thing that grounds her is a cold hand grabbing hers. The hand feels REAL in the dream. Temperature, grip, everything. And she doesn't pull away. That's the detail that sticks with me—she shouldn't be able to feel temperature in a dream, but she does, and her instinct is to hold on, not run. Then she wakes up at 4 AM in summer feeling cold from the inside out. The physical sensation carrying over from dream to reality is such a smart storytelling choice. The trauma isn't just psychological—it's somatic. And then the plot sets up this perfect trap: a GROUP VARIETY SHOW. Six women, forced proximity, cameras presumably rolling, and TWO of them who just happened to be the most famously couple-y pair in the industry before abruptly splitting two years ago. The other members are already gossiping about it. Their manager Su Luojian knows the truth and stays silent. The setup is essentially: here are your exes, here is an audience, go figure it out. The Script Kill game they're playing is also interesting meta-textually—lost memory, staged accidents, a boyfriend/girlfriend situation that could be either. The story is literally mirroring its own themes inside the scene. I'm convinced the variety show format is going to force confessions that can't stay buried. The plot is a pressure cooker and the lid is about to blow.
... Read More
I need to talk about the Sanskrit on Xi Ai's costume because this is such a deliberate choice by the author. When Chu Yiqi notices the Sanskrit — or Buddhist scriptures — on Xi Ai's shawl instead of patterns, she thinks: it's unclear whether this is God's mark or an inescapable bondage. THAT is the entire thematic question of this story condensed into one detail. The book is called Butterflies Fly Over Winter, right? Winter is suffering, endurance, coldness. But butterflies are transformation, fragility, beauty that doesn't belong in winter. And then there's this entire performance by Xi Ai about divine perspective — people who can't know suffering don't believe in gods, and then gods themselves suffer under restraint. The layers. And the topic they're forced to choose from: fight or don't fight. Is it better to be the golden mean, or to pursue and struggle? The author is literally putting the philosophical spine of the novel on display and making the characters debate it like it's a high school essay topic — except it's not. It's their entire lives. I also can't stop thinking about the title itself. Butterflies over winter. Something beautiful attempting to exist in something hostile. That's Xi Ai. That's Chu Yiqi. That's everyone in this story, really.
... Read More
What I love about how the author handles conflict here is that almost nothing explodes on the surface and yet I am on the edge of my seat the entire time. The stakes aren't about winning a competition or survival—they're about something much more intimate and therefore much more dangerous. Take the live stream punishment scene. Chu Yiqi draws the slip, realizes she has to perform something she wrote herself, and her internal voice is literally screaming at her: 'You should just leave. Stay away from her!' But she doesn't leave. She stays. She performs. She lets Xi Ai drag her into it. The conflict here isn't between them and the audience or even between them and each other—it's inside Chu Yiqi's head, this war between self-preservation and the pull she feels toward someone she clearly cares about but keeps pushing away. And Xi Ai's conflict is equally compelling. She notices Chu Yiqi's hostility, she reads it correctly, and she doesn't try to fix it or confront it directly. She just... maintains distance. But the reader can see she's curious. She's watching. The memory of that French student telling her she shouldn't be in music plays into this too—she's been fighting external doubt her whole life, and now Chu Yiqi represents an internal obstacle she can't strategy-her-way out of. The stakes feel real because they're not stated outright. No one says 'I need to prove myself' or 'I'm afraid of getting hurt.' It's all in the glances, the silences, the way Xi Ai stares at her medicine bottle after the live stream ends and laughs silently. What is she laughing at? Herself? Chu Yiqi? The absurdity of both of them being so careful around each other when clearly neither of them wants to leave? The tension comes from knowing something is going to break and having no idea when or how.
... Read More
"In that moment, Xi Ai even felt that the little bit of charm she had deliberately projected was nothing; unconscious beauty was the best kind." I am not okay. I am literally not okay right now. This entire chapter is just one long exercise in emotional whiplash and I did not sign up for this. Let me just sit with what happened between them. Chu Yiqi leans in, three words about to fall out of her mouth, and then she stops. She pulls back. She sits down unnaturally. She drinks water. And Xi Ai — perfect, composed, Movie Queen Xi Ai — just watches her do it with this expression that the narrative describes as complicated, dazed, and then somehow amused all at once. The line about unconscious beauty being the best kind? That is the book telling us everything without saying anything at all. Xi Ai has spent her whole life performing. She knows which angle to turn her face for the camera, she knows how to project charm deliberately, she knows the game. But Chu Yiqi — Chu Yiqi just exists in a moment and somehow her natural, unfiltered presence completely undoes Xi Ai. That is devastating. And then the scene they are supposed to reenact — the look from South of the South, the tragic final scene. Xi Ai closes her eyes and POINTS AT IT like it is destiny. Like she knew this was coming. Like she has been waiting two years for Chu Yiqi to see her perform grief on command while wearing a butterfly pendant on her wrist. I need to lie down.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the author understands something most writers don't. They know when to *not* resolve tension. Look at the structure. We open mid-performance, Xi Ai delivers a line that sounds like it's from the play but might actually be from her life—"They say I'm the one who went mad"—and the bullet comments immediately spiral. But the author doesn't confirm anything. Doesn't clarify what's real and what's performance. Just lets the ambiguity hang there like smoke. Then comes the coughing fit. Comic relief, right? Wrong. It's the physical manifestation of Xi Ai almost saying something she can't take back. "Can you go act in another BE?" — a rejection almost slipped out. She chokes on the words. Literally. And then the game. Thirty seconds per round. First to laugh loses. Both of them are failing spectacularingly because they keep looking at each other instead of the provocateur. The pacing here is brilliant because it mirrors their internal state: controlled on the surface, losing composure by seconds. "It's easy to smile when you're looking at your crush." Xi Ai almost says this. Thinks about it. Doesn't. The chapter ends not with a confession or a confrontation but with a decision: Xi Ai will keep looking at the camera instead. And the reader is left sitting in the silence that follows, wondering how long they can keep this up before something breaks.
... Read More
I need to talk about Chu Yiqi because honestly she is the whole mood and I am obsessed. On the surface she's the cool, aloof ACE who barely participates in the group chaos. She stands at the kitchen door holding the camera. She says one-word answers. She pretends not to see Xi Ai smiling at comments. But then we find out that when the injury news broke, she was "holding a trumpet and had already fought 800 rounds of black posts about Xi Ai." This changes EVERYTHING about how I read her character. Every time she seems distant or aloof in these chapters, I now read it as her channeling that energy into protecting Xi Ai from the shadows. She's not cold—she's fighting wars so Xi Ai doesn't have to. And the hair tie moment?? Let me just say it: Chu Yiqi instinctively raised her hand to tie Xi Ai's hair, then caught herself mid-gesture and handed her the hair tie instead with a business-like "tie it up." But the narration tells us this is "a subconscious habit formed in years long past." She has done this before. She wants to do it again. She's restraining herself in real time and it is the most romantic thing I have ever read. Xi Ai's response to that moment—her eyes curving into a smile where the camera couldn't see—is equally telling. She KNOWS. She knows Chu Yiqi was about to do something intimate and she lets it go, but she's delighted by it. The mutual awareness between them is off the charts. Then there's the thing Chu Yiqi does AFTER the livestream: she privately messages Meng Yike to say SHE dropped by to get medicine and asks Meng Yike to tell Xi Ai it was HER idea. She's orchestrating care for Xi Ai while making sure Xi Ai never knows it was Chu Yiqi. This is either the sweetest thing or the most complicated thing I've ever encountered. Probably both. Their dynamic is literally summarized in the floor-sitting backstory: Chu Yiqi used to steal Xi Ai's Bluetooth headphones and run away, and now she takes the initiative to sit next to her and says "Sit over here" discreetly. The power dynamic has flipped completely and neither of them calls it out.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how both of them keep betraying their own walls without even meaning to? Because that is the entire point of this dynamic and I am obsessed. Chu Yiqi says she initiated the breakup, she acts distant, she keeps positioning herself as just a teammate—yet her HAND automatically fishes shrimp paste from the spicy pot and puts it in Xi Ai's bowl. Like, she doesn't even THINK about it. It's muscle memory. Two years apart and her body still knows exactly how Xi Ai likes her food. And then there's the ring scene from the flashback—remember? Xi Ai gives Chu Yiqi a ring, and Chu Yiqi pulls out the EXACT SAME STYLE from her own bag. "Mutual exchange of rings." Not an engagement. Not even a confession. Just two people who knew each other so well they could mirror each other without speaking. Meanwhile Xi Ai pins their chat at the TOP of her phone. TOP. After a breakup. After being dumped. And then when their eyes meet and Chu Yiqi snaps at her to watch where she's going, Xi Ai's immediate reaction isn't hurt—it's AMUSED. She teases her. She keeps playing. The cat scene absolutely destroyed me though. Chu Yiqi shoves a cat into Xi Ai's arms like she's doing a favor, then gets genuinely dejected when Xi Ai hands it back. So she uses the cat's paw to tug Xi Ai's hair—a ridiculous, childish gesture—and when Xi Ai resists, she sees that tiny flicker of disappointment in Chu Yiqi's eyes and SURRENDERS. Places her hand on top. That's not revenge. That's not indifference. That's two people who built a life together and can't unbuild it, no matter how hard they try.
... Read More
Okay let's talk about the nickname thing because this is where the author really shows us who these people are. Xi Ai calls her "Teacher Chu." Not because it's respectful. Not because it's professional. Because it's *hers*—a private joke, a tease, a way of claiming territory without actually claiming anything. The others call her that too now, but the text makes it clear: when Xi Ai says it, the tone is different. It carries history. "In fact, most of the time she didn't call her what the others did; she always used her full name." Except for that one title. The one that sounds like respect but tastes like salt. And Chu Yiqi—she's so painfully aware of it. She knows exactly what Xi Ai's doing. She calls her out on it constantly, but never crosses the line into vulnerability. Their entire dynamic is this exhausting dance of near-confessions and deliberate misdirection. The flashback scene is everything. Chu Yiqi leaving the practice room, coming back ten minutes later with takeout for two. That's not romance-novel behavior. That's *habit*. That's someone who knew exactly how to take care of another person before they had a reason to. "If that beat feels awkward, you can modify the movement slightly…" She was already coaching her. Already thinking about Xi Ai's art before she even admitted she cared about Xi Ai's happiness. These two are disasters. Beautiful, talented, devastating disasters.
... Read More
Okay, so I need to talk about this thing between Xi Ai and Chu Yiqi because it is SO good. The author doesn't even try to make them get along right away, and that's what makes it feel real. Think about it—Xi Ai literally notices Chu Yiqi's anxiety during the orientation meeting and thinks 'I don't like that kind of aura.' She doesn't pretend to be fake nice. And Chu Yiqi? She looks at Xi Ai with pure rejection from the very first moment. That's not acting, that's genuine friction between two people who clearly have history. But here's what gets me—the dorm scene. They're assigned to the same room, facing each other on bunk beds, and there's this 'invisible barrier' between them. Invisible! Not even dramatic, just... there. And Xi Ai doesn't even try to close the distance. She just accepts it: 'those on different paths cannot make plans together.' That's such a Xi Ai thing to think. She's not petty, she's just done. Yet look at the small details. When Zhou Yangxi offers Chu Yiqi chocolate and ignores Xi Ai, Xi Ai casually asks 'What about me?' and then forces Zhou Yangxi into a hundred-word description. That's not jealousy, that's... I don't know, something else. And then at night, when everyone says goodnight and Chu Yiqi is the last to respond with this tiny 'Mhm...' and Xi Ai replies with an even softer 'Mhm...'—that silence says everything. They remember each other. They always have. Also, the flashback to France where Xi Ai absolutely Destroyed that guy who told her drama students shouldn't meddle in music? Yeah, she signed up for this show right after because 'if you say I can't do it, then I will insist on choosing this path.' She's been fighting for her place her whole life, and Chu Yiqi represents someone who already had hers handed to her on a silver platter. No wonder there's tension.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about the Chu Yiqi character choice here because it is WICKED and I am obsessed. So everyone finds out Niē Chuīyíng is reading fanfiction that stars Xi Ai and Chu Yiqi as the romantic leads — seductive bottom and cool sickly top — and the reveal that CHU YI QI ACTUALLY WROTE IT hits me like a truck. Like. This woman spent two years away, presumably hurting, and what was she doing? Writing smut about her ex on the internet. That is either the most passive-aggressive power move in the history of breakups or the most devastating confession I have ever encountered. I genuinely cannot tell which. But what really got me is Chu Yiqi's demeanor when she says it. She is sitting there, biting her yogurt straw, looking completely innocent, saying things like "you can choose to send ten two-hundred-yuan red envelopes instead." This is not someone who is embarrassed. This is someone who looked at their messy history and decided to weaponize it as content. And then she turned around and did it AGAIN by making Xi Ai mimic that scene from South of the South — the tragic, heart-wrenching look at the end. Meanwhile Xi Ai's reaction to the whole situation is what killed me. She keeps laughing. She keeps deflecting. But there is this one moment where Chu Yiqi leans in close, almost an embracing posture, and Xi Ai lifts her hand slightly but doesn't move. She just waits. She lets Chu Yiqi decide whether to complete the gesture or not. And Chu Yiqi pulls back. The restraint is actually agonizing to read. What are these two even doing to each other, I beg you.
... Read More
There's this one moment where Xi Ai walks on stage and the text says: "the stage lights hit the center, illuminating Xi Ai's face... as if the expression of a deity observing all living beings. Indifferent, yet compassionate." Chu Yiqi is watching her and literally has this spiritual experience from a lighting setup. The author builds these incredibly cinematic moments throughout this section. Nie Chuiying's performance with the folding fan and the sound of ringing bells — the camel bells of the Silk Road echoing. The music blending with ethnic dance elements. You can SEE this. It reads like a film script in places. But my favorite atmospheric detail is probably the Sanskrit description again — not just the text on the costume but how it changes the feeling of the whole performance. At first it might seem ethereal and pure, but then the author flips it: it becomes suppressed, having no outlet. The same visual element, completely different emotional weight depending on your perspective. And then the ending scene — the hazy light like afternoon sun through gauze falling in front of Xi Yuan's eyes. That image of blurred, filtered light is such a perfect mood setter for everything that's coming. The story is always operating in this quality of light that's beautiful but distant, like something you can almost touch but can't quite reach.
... Read More
Let's talk about the meta layer because this chapter is essentially a Russian nesting doll of performances. Inside the novel, the characters are reading a play. The play's theme: "They say I'm the one who went mad. But I remember we loved each other. But who am I, after all?" The audience (both in-universe and us, the readers) immediately recognizes this as autobiographical. Or is it? Xi Ai performs it with such conviction that even Chu Yiqi—the person who supposedly knows her best—can't tell where the character ends and the woman begins. "Perhaps that critique was right—when a good actor's emotions are on point, they can influence the person they are acting with." This is the author's thesis statement. Performance and reality are indistinguishable for these two. Xi Ai spent years performing indifference. Chu Yiqi spent years performing professionalism. The question is: which version is the real one? Then there's the variety show game itself—a structured competition where the objective is literally to *not* react. To maintain control. And of course, they both fail, because the thing they're suppressing is the only thing that's real. The flashback to the barbecue photos serves as the structural anchor: this is what existed before the performances began. Before they had to become someone else to survive. The author positions it at the end of the chapter like a tombstone—reminding us that everything that followed was decoration. "Our Final Review is just that powerful, viral even before debut." The irony is surgical. They became famous for a moment of genuine connection, and spent years trying to erase it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or