Back To The Years When My Dad Was The School Heartthrob - Reviews

Back To The Years When My Dad Was The School Heartthrob
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The alley scene is everything. I need to just stop and appreciate how the author paints this picture. Shen Kuo walking through this narrow tenement alley with his bag of yellow pears, the setting sun casting this golden glow on him, kids playing with paper airplanes everywhere, families cooking on coal stoves in the open... it's so vivid I could smell the cooking smoke and the damp alley air. And then this woman hanging her laundry starts trash-talking about some 'sickly person' at home, wishing they'd just die. It's brutal. The contrast between this warm, lived-in community space and the cruelty of that one neighbor is striking. You can feel the tightness of this alley—everyone knows everyone, everyone's watching, but there's also this sense of shared struggle. Meanwhile, Lu Yan's world is all fancy mansions and dinner tables with people playing passive-aggressive games. The author really knows how to use setting to show class differences without just telling us. That bike ride through Beicheng before it was fully developed—'the area had not been developed yet, so it seemed particularly small'—it gives this sense of a city in transition, which mirrors Lu Yan's own transformation. I keep coming back to that image of Shen Kuo in his white shirt, copying math problems, bathed in sunset light. It's cinematic. I can see the movie shot.
... Read More
Okay so the whole Shi Ya situation with the room is honestly so well done. Lu Yan immediately recognizes it's intentional—she's supposed to take Aunt's old room, basically get slotted into her aunt's place like she's some replacement doll. And Lu Yan's internal response? 'In that case, she absolutely couldn't let this girl have her way.' That's the moment the whole power dynamic shifts. She doesn't play nice. She doesn't back down. She just asks Grandpa directly if she can sleep in her own old room, and boom—Shi Ya gets tossed to the guest room like she never belonged there. What I love is how the author doesn't make this a big dramatic confrontation. It's quiet, almost casual, but devastating in its implications. Lu Jian's reaction tells us everything: he's not a philanthropist, he's not a fool, and the legitimate daughter gets what's hers. Meanwhile, Shi Xuexian's face-changing ability is honestly comedic—she goes from fake-motherly to dark-faced in two seconds flat. And that paternity test subplot? Genius. Every time Shi Xuexian brings it up and Lu Jian shuts it down, it's not just about trust—it's about control. He won't let anyone question his claim to Lu Yan. The plot here is layering power dynamics like a proper drama should. How long before Shi Xuexian's schemes actually backfire on her?
... Read More
The arcade scene is SO vivid I could practically smell the smoke and stale coins. Row houses, narrow alleys, excavators and tractors everywhere, the noisy rumble and dust on main streets being developed into high-rises. It's this in-between moment of a city transforming, and Lu Yan—someone from the future—navigating it all with her puffed rice tubes and zero cash. The arcade itself is described with such specific detail: the standing machines, about ten of them, the gambling nature where winning spits out actual money and losing swallows it. The tattooed owner with his ill intentions, the crowd of young people and students, the contrast between Lu Yan's iPad-gaming skills and these ancient, clunky machines. And then Shen Kuo appears in that white T-shirt, sunlight hitting his skin, bangs brushing over dark eyes. The visual of him rolling up his sleeves, operating the controls with both hands, completely expressionless while coins pour out like a waterfall—that's cinematic. Pure cinematic. The author doesn't over-explain the era, just drops us into the sensory details and we're there. The puffed rice tubes too—'a vendor scooping millet into a greasy machine, and after a few seconds, the machine spit out a string of white puffed rice tubes. They smelled sweet and fragrant.' This is the kind of writing that makes you miss a time period you never even lived through.
... Read More
Okay so this whole premise is wild. Lu Yan comes back from her past life with all these memories and immediately starts plotting. She needs to fix the grudge between her dad and Shen Kuo, but instead of just blabbing about it, she goes full strategic mode—decides to transfer to Beicheng No. 3 High School to stay close to Lu Zhen and figure out what the hell happened between him and Shen Kuo. That's smart. Like, actually smart. She's not just sitting around moping about her past life trauma; she's using it as intel. The whole independent admission exam setup is a great plot device too. Everyone thinks she's gonna fail because she's 'mentally challenged,' but she secretly studies her ass off and then absolutely destroys the competition with a 614. That moment when Shi Ya opens the envelope expecting her own name and it's actually Lu Yan's? Chef's kiss. The author really loves a good underdog reveal, and it works. Though I gotta say, the whole 'she was an idiot before but now she's a genius' thing is a bit convenient. Did she really just unlock all this academic potential overnight? Feels like the plot is bending a little too hard to give her the win, you know? But hey, it's a rebirth story—convenience is kind of the point.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this one scene because I literally had to put the book down and stare at the ceiling for a full ten minutes. When Lu Yan ends up on the back of Lu Zhen's motorcycle — the first person EVER to sit there, not even his girlfriend got that privilege — and she wraps her arms around his waist and presses her cheek against his back... I swear to god. I felt every single year of missed father-daughter time in that moment. The text says: "During Lu Yan's childhood, her father had never ridden a motorcycle with her because the family owned luxury cars, and she was usually chauffeured around in style." And then later: "her father had always been very busy with work and rarely had time to spend with her. The only time he would rush to her school was when she got into trouble, where he would angrily scold her, sometimes even hitting her." This is the kind of detail that just DESTROYS you. She's literally experiencing the father she never really had as a child, and he's this wild, reckless, hot-tempered young man who doesn't even know she's his daughter yet. Meanwhile, she's holding onto him like her life depends on it — partly because she's starving and desperate, but also because this is her CHANCE. She gets to know him before the bankruptcy, before he became the stern cold CEO she remembered, before his wife died and he hardened himself completely. And then there's the mother question. Lu Yan asks about her mom with this quiet desperation — "just curious to know what my mom was like. After all, she passed away before I was born." And Lu Zhen's response is this barely-contained grief: "My girlfriend is the purest in the world." The fact that he keeps his dead wife as this sacred, untouchable memory while his actual daughter stands right in front of him and he has NO IDEA... I can't. The dramatic irony is suffocating. Also can we talk about how Lu Yan is basically faking her way through this entire situation? She's calling him "Dad" while scamming him for money, and the fact that he's gradually softening because she reminds him of his lost sister — that's such a beautiful emotional pivot. He's projecting his grief onto her, and she's leaning into it because she needs him. It's manipulative on the surface but the underlying tenderness is real. She genuinely wants this connection. She's been starving on the streets of Beicheng for three days and all she wants is to find her father. The vulnerability underneath the scam is what makes it hurt so good.
... Read More
There's a quiet thematic richness beneath what might initially read as a straightforward rebirth romance, and I think the author is playing with some genuinely interesting ideas about identity, belonging, and the spaces between lives. The opening image of Lu Yan trying to buy a triangular rice cake with future money is thematically loaded. She's a person out of time — literally unable to participate in the economy of her current moment. The hundred yuan bill that won't be valid for another ten years is a perfect symbol for her entire existence: she has value, but no one can recognize it yet. She's real but invisible. The vendor's rejection isn't just a comedic beat; it's the central condition of her rebirth. She is, as the text repeatedly emphasizes, a "nonexistent person who hadn't been born yet." This theme of non-existence runs through everything. She can't go to the police. She can't prove who she is. She has to SCAM her way into her own father's life because there's no other path. The rice cake — warm, simple, earned through performance rather than identity — becomes the first real sustenance she gets in this timeline. It's humble and honest in a way that her future wealth never was. The motorcycle is another loaded symbol. In her original life, her father never rode a motorcycle with her — they had luxury cars, drivers, distance. The motorcycle represents something her father abandoned: spontaneity, freedom, physical closeness. When Lu Yan wraps her arms around his waist, she's not just holding on for safety — she's claiming a intimacy that was denied to her in her first life. The motorcycle is the vehicle (literally) through which she rewrites her relationship with him. And then there's Shen Kuo, introduced in shadow beneath the pool hall lights, arranging balls with long slender fingers. He's described as having a "commanding presence just by standing there doing nothing." If Lu Zhen represents fire and chaos and wealth, Shen Kuo represents cold calculation and patience. The text tells us he went from nothing to immense wealth in ten years — he's the dark mirror of Lu Zhen's trajectory. Their collision in that pool hall isn't just personal; it's the collision of two forces that will determine the fate of an entire family. The imagery of light and shadow in that scene — bright overhead lights on the pool tables versus the dimmer surroundings where Shen Kuo stands — feels deliberate. He exists in the margins, and margins are where he'll strike from. The recurring motif of ears is also striking. Lu Zhen's red earlobes when he's angry, Lu Yan's "obedient earlobes turned slightly pink from anxiety" — ears as markers of inherited resemblance, of blood connection that Lu Zhen notices before he has any rational reason to. Biology speaking before identity.
... Read More
The dialogue in this batch is honestly hilarious because it's so layered. That dinner scene where Lu Yan says she wants to go to Beicheng No. 3 'to study with Lu Zhen' and also 'help Grandpa look after him a little'—she's being so earnest while everyone else is calculating. Shi Ya's fake laugh, her excuse about 'a joke my friend told me,' the way she says 'Yanyan, the exam is really hard, so make sure you work hard!' like it's a compliment when it's clearly not—that's masterclass passive-aggression. And Lu Jian! He's so done with everything. 'Live your own life, and don't worry about that brat.' Short, direct, tells you everything about his relationship with his son. The conversation between Shi Xuexian and Shi Ya about 'pretending to be pitiful' is gold too. These two are literally coordinating their manipulation tactics like it's a business meeting. But my favorite exchange has to be when Lu Yan says 'No need for connections, I can take the exam myself' and Shi Xuexian's face 'darkened slightly.' The silence after that is so loud. And then Lu Yan's quiet 'I'm pretty amazing' when she sees her score—so understated but full of satisfaction. The author really nails how these characters speak differently. Shi Ya sounds bratty and sharp, Lu Jian sounds tired and authoritative, Lu Yan sounds deceptively simple.
... Read More
Can we just sit with the pear scene for a second? Lu Yan bites into Shen Kuo's pear like they're already best friends, and his response is this tiny, almost imperceptible pause. 'Wash the pear first.' That's it. That's the whole romantic tension in four words. He's not some smooth talker, he's just... present. And when she offers him the rice puff, he refuses at first—'No'—so stiff and uncomfortable, but then she just shoves it into his mouth anyway and he eats it. The text says 'He rarely had such enjoyable gaming moments, especially with his arch-nemesis's sister.' That line hit me like a truck. This boy who never allows himself luxuries—snacks, fun, anything—lets this clumsy girl feed him puffed rice and share her pears, and he doesn't even fight it that hard. And then Lu Zhen comes and ruins everything. The moment where Lu Yan sees Shen Kuo bend down to pick up those scattered pears, dusting them off, with 'restraint in his eyes'—I literally had to put the book down. That's not just anger, that's someone who's used to being treated like garbage quietly accepting it. And Lu Yan's realization that her father was once a thug? That shatters something in her. She called him disappointed, she called him out, and he just... tapped her head and walked away. The emotional whiplash in these chapters is unreal.
... Read More
The pacing here is actually really well controlled. You've got this whole section where Lu Yan is studying—waking up early, staying up late, buying textbooks at Xinhua Bookstore—and instead of dragging, it feels purposeful. The author doesn't waste time; we get the essence of her grind and then we're right into the exam results. And the reveal! It's structured like a classic underdog story but with this extra layer because we know she's reincarnated. The tension builds naturally: will she pass or fail? Will Shi Ya's mockery be justified? And then—bam—614 points. Top of the class. The timing of the admission letter delivery is perfect too. Shi Ya is celebrating, thinking she won, and then the envelope has Lu Yan's name on it. That's a great structural beat. But I gotta mention the ending feels a bit abrupt. The text cuts off mid-sentence with 'The woman tried to chase...' and while I get that this is batch 5 of maybe many, it's still a little jarring. Also, the transition from the exam results to Lu Zhen giving her the bike to her following Shen Kuo happens pretty fast. It's like the author couldn't decide whether this section was about academic triumph or romantic tension setup. Both are good, but they compete for space a bit.
... Read More
Let me just say — the author knows how to pace a rebirth story and I am HERE for it. Chapter 1 opens with Lu Yan literally starving on a street corner, trying to buy a triangular rice cake with money from the future, getting rejected because the vendor thinks she's crazy. This is day THREE of her rebirth. We don't get exposition dumps about the mechanics of time travel or whatever — we just GET IT. She's hungry, she's lost, she doesn't exist yet, and she needs to find her father or she's going to die. The opening is brisk and effective. We learn her situation through action and internal monologue rather than info-dumping. The line "This was her third day since her rebirth. It wasn't as glamorous and extraordinary as it's portrayed in novels. Right now, she was starving and struggling to survive" — this is the author winking at us while also grounding the fantasy in real stakes. No glamour, just survival. Then comes the waiting sequence — three more days at the school gate. This could have dragged, but the author uses the gossiping girls as a clever device to deliver exposition naturally. We learn about Lu Zhen's reputation, his girlfriend Shu Mengfei, AND the ominous name Shen Kuo — all through overheard conversation. Three birds, one stone. The gossip also creates this delicious dramatic irony because WE know who Shen Kuo is (the future tycoon who destroys the Lu family) and Lu Zhen has no idea. The climax of the chapter — Lu Zhen appearing on his motorcycle, the confrontation, the scam, the ride — this is all packed into what feels like maybe ten minutes of story time but delivers massive emotional and plot payoff. The transition from street corner to motorcycle to pool hall happens with zero friction. Each scene flows into the next because Lu Yan's motivation is crystal clear: FIND DAD → GET MONEY/FOOD → SURVIVE. The chapter ends with Shen Kuo appearing in the pool hall, and the tension between him and Lu Zhen is immediate and visceral. The chair-smashing moment is a perfect cliffhanger — action, threat, and the introduction of the series' main antagonist all in one beat. I was not ready for that ending and I immediately opened Chapter 2.
... Read More
I need to talk about Shen Kuo because WOW. The way he just appears at the arcade, all broad shoulders in a white T-shirt, crouching down to pick pears like some kind of aesthetic forest spirit—then immediately gets dragged into Lu Yan's chaos. First he saves her from the scam, then he plays those arcade games like he's actually working a job, completely expressionless while coins waterfall out. And then Lu Zhen shows up and punches him. Just straight up. And Lu Yan? She throws herself between them like a tiny protective shield. 'How can you just hit someone without asking what happened?' The father-daughter moment after is actually heartbreaking in a weird way—Lu Zhen calling his own daughter dumb, saying her real father cared more about his career, and Lu Yan realizing her 'upright and composed' dad was once a thug. Meanwhile Shen Kuo is just there, silently picking up pears off the ground, dusting them off, with this restrained look in his eyes that made my chest hurt. The contrast between Lu Zhen's hot anger and Shen Kuo's cold silence is chef's kiss. And that devilish smile Shen Kuo gives when Lu Zhen threatens him? 'Fine.' Just one word. He's not scared. He's amused. I'm already obsessed with where this goes.
... Read More
Can we talk about Lu Zhen for a second? This kid is such a mess but he genuinely cares about his sister in his own weird way. He gives her a bike—like, a whole new bicycle—and I know it sounds silly but the detail about him picking pink because he thinks 'all girls love pink' made me laugh and also kind of feel for him. He's trying. He's this rebellious rich heir who barely comes home, but he remembers she never got to ride a bike because their dad was too paranoid about her safety. That's... actually sweet in a very Lu Zhen way. And then there's Lu Yan following Shen Kuo through that alley. The scene where she watches him walk home with a bag of yellow pears, bathed in sunset light, and these kids yell 'the bad guy's here'—it hit different. She's seeing him not as some enemy of her family but as this person who's struggling, copying math problems because he can't afford books, getting harassed by neighbors. And then she splashes that woman with muddy water. That wasn't just revenge; that was her choosing a side. She's protecting him in her own way, even though she doesn't fully understand him yet. The emotional thread between them is so delicate right now—she's curious, he's oblivious, and there's this whole history between their families that's hanging over everything like a storm cloud.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or