An Early Engagement - Reviews

An Early Engagement
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me peel back the layers here because this chapter is NOT just a girl stressing about her fiancé. The central symbol is Psyche. She's the mortal woman who loved a god, couldn't help looking at him, made a mistake, and faced consequences. Shirley is LITERALLY wearing her costume while having an internal crisis about whether her feelings are inappropriate. The myth isn't decoration — it's a mirror. Then there's the question of arranged marriage vs. genuine choice. Terban dismisses the engagement because it was 'decided without any regard for your feelings,' but then admits he's perfectly fine with his own predetermined match. Is he being hypocritical, or does he genuinely not feel the conflict Shirley feels? Maybe the theme is that some people can accept arranged fates and some can't — and neither is wrong. The dolls. Every gift Damian gave her reflects himself back at her — the pink-haired doll with her eyes, the dancing figures in the music box. He's been building a version of their future in objects while she's been trying to figure out if she actually WANTS that future. And the line that haunts me: 'What if we had met after becoming adults?' What if the real tragedy isn't the arrangement itself, but the fact that they never got the chance to choose each other freely? The story seems to be asking: does duty matter if the heart hasn't had a chance to speak?
... Read More
Can we talk about Melissa's voice because this girl does NOT hold back. While Shirley is over here blushing and stammering and saying 'I'm a person, not an animal!' like it's the most reasonable response to 'have you thought about his body?', Melissa is just casually drop-bombing sexual topics like she's ordering coffee. Her dialogue is SO distinct from Shirley's—it's short, sharp, almost clinical. She says things like 'Same difference' and 'You'll know once you try it' with this completely flat affect, like she's discussing the weather. And then she smiles mischievously at the end when Shirley asks if she's done it herself. The voice contrast between these two friends is what makes their scenes work. Shirley talks in spirals—longer sentences, emotional tangents, lots of exclamation points and self-interruptions. Melissa talks in bullet points. Damian's dialogue though... even in this excerpt we get a taste of how different he sounds now. His lines are sparse but loaded with double meaning. 'Wouldn't we know if we could be a real married couple... if we did it?' That's not just dialogue—that's a line that does THREE things at once: it's provocative, it's logical in a twisted way, and it shifts the power dynamic completely. The author clearly knows how to write each character's voice separately, which is rare. Usually every character sounds like the author. Not here.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say—this section is a masterclass in escalating tension. The whole chapter chain basically rides one collision: Shirley gets kissed by a stranger, Damian witnesses it, and everything implodes. But what really made my jaw drop was how the plot twists on itself. She calls off the engagement? In a moment of raw panic? And then Damian turns it around and says 'let's call it off' like it was always his way out? That reversal is chef's kiss. I was expecting him to beg, to cry, to fall apart—but no, he flips the script and suddenly Shirley's the one running away. The subplot with the mothers was also unexpectedly important. Their casual conversation about Shirley thinking Damian was a girl, Damian dressing as a girl—this quietly recontextualizes their entire history. It's not just 'arranged engagement,' it's 'they've been performing roles for each other since childhood.' And that rabbit ending? Such a weirdly hopeful button to close on after all that chaos. Like the story's saying: maybe there's still something gentle waiting for her.
... Read More
There's so much happening beneath the surface of these chapters and the symbolism is practically shouting at you if you pay attention. The frog pond is the central image and it's layered in ways that took me a while to unpack. Shirley throwing pebbles at frogs—that's not just nervous energy. She's disrupting something peaceful, something that doesn't deserve it. The frogs croak in annoyance and scatter. She's the disruption. But here's the thing: she's also trying to provoke a reaction, any reaction, because sitting still means having to think about what's actually bothering her. The pebble itself matters. Melissa tossed a pebble earlier and created 'gentle ripples.' Shirley's pebbles are violent, desperate, aimed at the center. Both women are throwing things into water, but one is playing and the other is drowning. Then there's the scene from the ball—the two engaged people having sex in the lounge while their fiancés dance above. That's not just shock value; it's the thematic core. These people performed perfection perfectly. They came back from their affair 'elegant and courteous, like a pair of swans.' The symbol of swans—graceful on the surface, paddling furiously underneath—is everywhere in this text. Shirley and Damian look like swans to everyone else. Damian wiping sweat from Shirley's face, shielding her from the sun, holding her hand—he's performing the perfect fiancé role so well that even she's starting to believe the performance is the person. The sunburn is another symbol I can't stop thinking about. Shirley's pale skin doesn't tan—it burns. She avoids sunlight but sat outside anyway, lost in thought. The sun reveals what's hidden. Damian notices her red cheeks before she notices anything else. He sees her when she's trying to disappear.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the structure of these chapters because the author really knew what they were doing. The way this sequence is built—starting with Melissa's wild conversation, then dropping us into Shirley's isolation by the pond, then slamming Damian into the frame—it's like a masterclass in controlled escalation. The Melissa scene operates on a totally different energy than everything else. It's fast, breathless, almost comedic in its bluntness. Shirley asking 'How do other people even know about these things?' and Melissa deadpanning 'They know because they've done it'—the pacing here is like a stand-up routine, quick hits, no pauses. And then Melissa bails to go practice piano, leaving Shirley alone with her thoughts. That abrupt exit? It's deliberate. We need her isolated for what comes next. Then the pond scene hits and the tempo completely shifts. Everything slows down. The pebbles, the lily pads, the frogs croaking in annoyance—each detail gets breathing room. The author is forcing us to sit in Shirley's headspace, to feel that stillness and unease. When she recalls the scene from Count Fer's ball, the narrative expands into a flashback but it's woven in so smoothly you barely notice the transition. 'That scene, which she couldn't share with anyone—not even Melissa'—bam, we're back in her isolation. And then Damian appears. 'Plop, plop' goes another stone. The rhythm breaks. His dialogue is shorter, simpler than Melissa's, but each line carries more weight because we've been sitting in Shirley's silence for so long. The final cut-off line—'I said it's'—is the worst (best) cliffhanger I've encountered in a while. It doesn't feel manufactured; it feels like the story genuinely interrupted itself, like real life.
... Read More
I want to talk about how the author structures this entire chapter around the festival, because it's genuinely brilliant storytelling. You start with Shirley convincing herself that her parents' story about misfortune was nonsense — 'Misfortune for us? That's ridiculous.' She's trying to reframe everything, to tell herself that she and Damian are fine, that they're closer than ever. It's almost desperate self-persuasion. Then the festival kicks in. Music, dancing, bonfires — everything is loud and bright and full of life. The author uses the public celebration as a backdrop for increasingly private, intimate moments. First the dancing in the square where they're surrounded by people but clearly enjoying themselves together. Then the alleyway incident where they're hidden in darkness. Then the confrontation with the other women. Each beat pulls them further away from the crowd and deeper into something unresolved between them. "It should be better here," Damian says when he leads her to the quieter path. But it's NOT better — it's infinitely more complicated. The alley incident forces them both to confront physical proximity they weren't expecting. The memory of the coming-of-age ball reveals this pattern that's been repeating since they were younger. And then Shirley's jealousy explosion at the end? That's the plot turning point. She's been holding it together this whole chapter and then she snaps. The structure also mirrors their internal state perfectly. The chapter starts with Shirley declaring everything is fine, ends with her shouting 'I hate everything' into her pillow. The external plot hasn't changed much — they're still engaged, still at a festival, still technically together — but the internal landscape has shifted dramatically. That's good writing.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this scene because it wrecked me in the best way. The whole dancing sequence starts out so light and joyous — Shirley is spinning around, laughing, completely uninhibited, and Damian is right there with her being all mischievous and holding her close. It feels like a dream, doesn't it? Like anything could happen between them. And then BAM, they stumble into this alleyway and hear this incredibly explicit couple going at it, and suddenly the whole mood shifts. Damian covers her eyes, pulls her against his chest, and there's this moment where Shirley is basically trapped in his arms while the noise of someone else's intimacy echoes around them. "Haa..." That one sound Damian makes — he presses his forehead against hers, covers her ears, tells her to look at him. Not at them. And Shirley just... melts into him. Her face buried in his chest, listening to his heartbeat. I keep coming back to that image. She's flustered, embarrassed, caught between the sounds around them and this overwhelming sense of safety in his arms. It's so tender and so complicated at the same time. But then the jealousy hits later — when she finds him surrounded by all these women throwing themselves at him, and he's just... polite. Calm. Not pushing them away. That's when everything collapses. She slaps the cup out of his hand and runs. Not because she wants to be dramatic, but because she can't BEAR it. And then when he catches up to her and won't let go, she's all fists and feet but she's also secretly leaning into his touch when he nuzzles her neck like a puppy. The push-and-pull here is SO good. She finally says "I hate everything" into her pillow and pulls the blanket over her head. I felt that in my bones.
... Read More
I have to talk about Shirley and Damian because honestly this whole section wrecked me in the best way. On the surface it's this innocent-looking romance setup—childhood friends, betrothed since birth, everyone thinks they're perfect—but underneath? It's this trembling, terrified girl standing by a pond throwing rocks at frogs because she's genuinely scared her whole life will just be performance. Remember that scene where Melissa drops the bomb about testing compatibility? Like, Shirley's already sitting there flustered and then suddenly she's thinking about what she saw at the ball—the two engaged people doing it in the lounge while their fiancés danced upstairs. That moment where she connects the dots that 'even now, there's no passion'? I physically recoiled. Not because it was shocking but because it was so painfully relatable for anyone who's ever wondered if their relationship is just… obligation wearing a fancy suit. And then Damian shows up. His hand on her head, cool against her burning skin. 'You don't like getting sunburned, do you?' He becomes her shade without even realizing why she's outside in the first place. This guy who wipes her sweat with his sleeve like it's the most natural thing in the world. Shirley thinks 'A perfect groom. A kind friend.' But here's what kills me—she's questioning whether she can spend her entire life with someone who treats her like glass. Is that love or is that just comfort dressed up so nicely she doesn't want to see through it? The ending where he touches her cheek and says 'I said it's'—then cuts off—left me gripping my phone. She's physically close to him right now, safe, loved even, but emotionally? She's so far away. That gap between what she has and what she wants? That's the real story.
... Read More
The author really understood what they were doing with the masquerade imagery and I am HERE for it. Shirley dressed as Psyche — the mortal woman who couldn't resist looking at her divine husband, who was swayed by her sisters' deceit and ultimately inflicted 'irreversible wounds' on Eros. Every single element of her costume screams 'I am the girl who almost ruined everything through curiosity and impulsive words.' Damian as Eros. The god of love. Wrapped in white feathers with a heart-shaped arrow pinned to his chest. And when he makes that cynical remark about Eros being 'just a reckless kid running around shooting arrows, wrapped in his mother Aphrodite's skirts' — you can feel how much that stings him personally. The whole ball setting is dripping with irony too. A masquerade where the thrill is meeting someone unknown, but these two are the ONE couple everyone immediately recognizes. Their matching costumes make them stand out even more than if they'd shown up in regular clothes. The masks don't hide them — they announce them. And then there's Shirley's room, filled with every gift Damian ever gave her. The diamond-encrusted doll with pink hair and green eyes that looks exactly like her. The music box with the dancing porcelain figures. The wall clock. Countless dolls in glass cabinets. All carefully chosen to match HER tastes. Every single one a monument to someone who paid attention. That imagery of a girl surrounded by proof she's loved, hating herself for wanting something she can't name, is cinematic perfection.
... Read More
okay this scene with Damian letting go and then coming back... i felt absolutely wrecked by it. like, first he asks, he pushes, she's terrified, and then he literally just... stops. he releases her hands, gets off the bed, says goodnight. and that moment? that empty space where his weight just vanished? shirley grabs his sleeve. of course she does. she can't let him go. but then it goes even further - she whispers "trust" and he kisses her, really kisses her, and it's not the tentative childhood-kisses-at-a-ball thing at all. it's aggressive, consuming, she's gasping for air and he has gills apparently. the CP chemistry here is so layered. shirley's entire emotional journey in this chapter is about realizing how much she's been taking his softness for granted. melissa's voice in her head saying "damian would say it's fine no matter what" - that guilt is what makes her hold on. and Damian? he's playing a dangerous game. asking for permission as a formality while already having trapped her. that predator-prey dynamic isn't just physical, it's emotional too. he's testing whether she actually wants him or just wants the safety he provides. "i would never hurt you. trust me." said while pinning her wrists above her head. the contradiction is everything.
... Read More
Underneath this steamy bedroom opening and the seemingly lighthearted tea party, there's this really interesting exploration of how tradition consumes individual desire. The prenuptial engagement—the idea that two people's futures were decided before they even existed—is treated almost casually in this world but the text keeps coming back to it like it IS the central problem. Shirley's anxiety isn't really about sex; it's about whether she can love someone whose life was mapped out before she drew her first breath. Her mother's obsession with her father's face becomes this weird proxy for the whole system—beauty as the only currency in arranged marriages, looks as the measurable proof of a good match. The ring itself is a powerful symbol here. They exchanged rings when they were seven years old. A tiny band on a tiny finger, promising a future neither child could understand. Now those rings are about to mean something actual and physical and Shirley is terrified. There's also this recurring motif of bodies—Damian's body growing larger, hotter, more imposing; Shirley's body reacting before her mind catches up. The body knows what the mind resists. And then Melissa literally connecting 'being a person' to 'doing it' in one breath—showing how in this aristocratic world, personal identity and physical intimacy are the only things that might make an arranged marriage feel real. The deeper question the book seems to be asking: can love grow inside a contract, or does the contract kill the love?
... Read More
I need to talk about this scene for a bit because my chest actually hurts. Shirley slaps Damian. A SLAP. After he chased after her, mask askew, disheveled, clearly distraught, and she just—slapped him. And then she runs. And the worst part? The absolute worst part is that Damian doesn't follow. He just stands there. Like he's been turned to stone. I kept re-reading that moment and realizing: this is the first time we've seen Damian truly stripped of his composure. He's always been the steady one, the reliable one, the one who carries her literally and figuratively. And here she is, reducing him to silence with one word. But then—and this is what got me—when she's alone later, she's the one falling apart. She replays the kiss. She replays his face. She replays the slap. And the text says she couldn't imagine living without Damian. That's not obligation talking, friends. That's love. Terrifying, confusing, inconvenient love. And Damian? He's terrified because for the first time, the one person who was supposed to never leave might actually leave. The CP energy here isn't sweet or fluffy—it's desperate and raw and I lived for every second of it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or