After the protagonist retired, the heroine quit - Reviews

After the protagonist retired, the heroine quit
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Tie Yanran because WOW. The Jade-Faced Mad Demon. Where do I even start. On paper, this character should be a one-note villain — stern enforcer, scary mask, gets the job done. But the author subverts every expectation. The description of Tie Yanran is almost unsettling: moist and delicate skin, ears 'exquisite as jade,' a face under the mask that seems better maintained than women who 'maintain their skin year-round.' The narrator (Xiao Yu) literally thinks, 'I would believe it if you told me he was a woman!' And yet, when Xiao Yu confronts this, the text forces us to recall that Tie Yanran's chest was flat. So male. Definitely male. But the author keeps playing with this ambiguity, and I'm here for it. Then there's the interaction itself. Xiao Yu slaps his shoulder like an old friend. Tie Yanran reacts like he's been electrocuted. He stammers. His mask shakes. His ears flush red. And then he agrees to let them go — but not before dropping this ominous warning about indecent publications and making sure Xiao Yu knows he's being watched. This is NOT a simple cop-and-criminal dynamic. There's history here. Xiao Yu's internal monologue reveals he genuinely doesn't know Tie Yanran, but he plays along because spirit stones and survival depend on it. The performance is flawless on the surface, but the physical reactions betray something — nervousness? attraction? recognition? — that neither character can name out loud. And the side characters add flavor too. Leng Ren faking tears to secure a discount is both hilarious and reveals a world where everyone is performative. These people aren't just buying porn — they're building relationships, loyalties, a whole underground economy based on trust and mutual benefit. Xiao Yu himself is fascinating. He's running a black-market operation while hiding his true identity, negotiating with law enforcement, maintaining friendships, all while worrying about money for himself and Bai Yan. He's competent, calculating, and deeply lonely.
... Read More
Alright I need to be honest about something. I came for the spicy business and the tension with the masked enforcer, but what actually got me was how quietly sad Xiao Yu's situation is. Think about it. He's a dead man. He faked his own death to escape something — presumably terrible, given his reaction when he contemplates being found. He can't go back to his old life. He can't reveal who he really is. And yet he's running a whole operation, making friends, joking around, pretending everything is normal. The moment that wrecked me was when he hands Leng Ren the photo album as 'compensation' for his fabricated grief. One second this man is wailing about his bankrupt sect, the next he's thanking Brother Yu with an excited expression, zero trace of the tears. Everyone plays a role. Everyone performs. Xiao Yu is the best actor in the room, and he's exhausted. But then there's this other thread — the one with Bai Yan. His 'nest egg for his wife was also destroyed in a fire.' He's short on money to support Bai Yan and himself. Bai Yan bought a love potion and someone is teasing Xiao Yu about it. 'Watch your kidneys tonight!' The implication is obvious and it lands with a weird tenderness. Despite everything — the fake death, the danger, the financial strain — he has someone. Someone he's trying to protect and provide for. And Tie Yanran. God, the Tie Yanran moments. When Xiao Yu whispers into his ear about his 'private collection,' when Tie Yanran's ears flush red — there's this charge between them that has NOTHING to do with business. It's awkward and electric and completely unacknowledged. Xiao Yu walks away thinking 'that was easy, guess that's just how men are' while the reader is screaming because NO, that was not just how men are. The emotional core of this passage is loneliness masked by commerce. Everyone is buying and selling, but what they're really trading is connection. And Xiao Yu, the dealer, is the most disconnected of all.
... Read More
There is a deeper layer to this story that keeps revealing itself with every read, and honestly? The banana scene in that banquet hall might be the most important symbolic moment in the entire opening arc. Xiao Yu casually peeling and eating a banana while discussing his own murder—that is the visual thesis statement of the whole narrative. A mortal man in the divine realm, surrounded by gods and heavenly agents, more concerned with his snack than his impending death. It says everything about his character: he's seen too much, he's done his job, and honestly? He's over it. The banana is his rebellion. The banana is his dignity. The banana is basically the universe's way of saying 'some things are more important than fate itself.' And then there's the Hongtian Chessboard—the heavenly board where Dao messed up the protagonist's birth date. A cosmic bureaucracy run by incompetent gods making mistakes. The whole setup satirizes the idea of destiny, of grand designs, of everything being 'meant to be.' Turns out the entire world's timeline was screwed up by a typo. Not a grand design, not a prophesied hero—just... administrative error. Xiao Yu was the band-aid on a clerical mistake. But the real symbolism, the thing I can't stop thinking about, is 'Gathering Demon Island' as Xiao Yu's destination. A place where heavenly secrets are in disarray, where the Dao itself is jumbled and lawless. He's not running to freedom—he's running TO chaos. The one place where even the Heavenly Dao can't reach him is literally a zone of cosmic disorder. His home IS the antithesis of the system that exploited him. And the island greeting him like an annoyed relative? That's the theme crystallized: belonging isn't found in order and destiny, it's found in beautiful, grumpy, rule-breaking messiness.
... Read More
There's a symbolism running through these chapters that I keep coming back to, and it's this: everything here is trapped by design. Demon Gathering Island. Once you enter, you cannot leave. Not even someone at Transcendence level can escape. Gong Wuyao has been there for five hundred years and her cultivation and figure haven't changed — is that preservation or stagnation? She's the eternal deputy, the permanent second, the woman who holds power without the title. The island keeps her exactly where she is. Xiao Yu is the protagonist stand-in. He has meta-knowledge of the plot but no real authority. He can predict what will happen but he can't control when it happens. When Xia Nianmo appears early, his entire understanding of narrative order fractures — and the island won't let him fix it because he can't leave to go find another path. Xia Nianmo herself is a mermaid — a creature of water who has been pulled into a place where water is poison. The Chaotic Forbidden Sea's waters corrode with strange dao marks. She survived, but survival here means she's trapped on land, dependent on the Thousand-Year Water Pearl which is now inside Xiao Yu's body. She needed water to survive and she took it from the person she used to love, without fully understanding what that meant. The fox is another layer. It was at Fox Auntie's Spirit Fox Peak. Xiao Yu used to buy new breeds for her — folded-ear, mist-snow, crimson flame. He curated that world. Now he watches Gong Wuyao pet this particular fox and feels envy. Not romantic envy. Existential envy. The fox gets to be held. The fox gets to choose comfort. Xiao Yu has to negotiate his way through every interaction. And water itself — water as life, water as dependence, water as the thing that connects and separates them all. Xia Nianmo drinks from a cup, then from Xiao Yu's mouth. The Thousand-Year Water Pearl flows from him to her. Water is transaction and intimacy and power. The sea is where they all came from, and the sea is what keeps them from going back.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about the sleeping arrangement scene because I am not okay. Xiao Yu trying so hard to maintain master-disciple boundaries while Bai Yan is just... already fully invested. She literally pulls him by the arm and there's this whole internal panic from him—virgin in two lifetimes, what does that even mean, bro—and then she presses her entire body against him like a koala and he just gives up. I was simultaneously squealing and crying. But then THE ENDING. The moment she pretends to fall asleep, waits until he's actually out, leans over and whispers 'Welcome back, Master'—I literally dropped my phone. That was the most devastatingly tender thing I have ever read. She's been waiting for him. For YEARS. And he's so obliviously sweet, thinking about how he missed her youth, how she can't cultivate, how she only has a hundred years—completely missing the fact that SHE HAS BEEN WAITING THROUGH ALL OF IT. Meanwhile Li Yunshang over at Heaven Beyond Heavens is out here murdering people and seeing hearts in her eyes over some imposter senior brother and I'm over here having an emotional breakdown over two people who can't even share a bed without it being a whole thing. The contrast is killing me.
... Read More
Let me just lay out the stakes because they are PILING UP and I am not ready. Xiao Yu is a stand-in protagonist. His entire function in this story is to occupy the role that belongs to someone else — the real protagonist — who is presumably somewhere else living the actual story. But now the actual heroine has wandered onto HIS island, INTO HIS story, and the plot is destabilizing. The divine artifact arc that depends on Xia Nianmo existing in the right place at the right time? That's broken. The protagonist outside has no idea his leading lady is currently being hosted by a perpetually junior sect leader on an island you can't escape from. Gong Wuyao brought this girl here. She made the decision without consulting Xiao Yu's existential crisis. She's offering hospitality and protocol but she's also created a problem she may not fully understand. Five hundred years on this island and she's still treating newcomer management as a administrative task rather than recognizing that a mermaid holy maiden has just crashed into the one person who might actually care. Xia Nianmo's conflict is visceral and immediate: she's dehydrated, she's stranded, she just consumed something intimate from a man whose face she recognizes but whose name she hasn't yet spoken. She's also a Holy Maiden — someone with political weight, a clan behind her, expectations upon her. She can't just fall apart. She has to assess, calculate, and decide what to do with the fact that the person who once saved her is now right there and she used him to survive. And the physical danger is real too. The Forbidden Sea's waters are poison to mermaids. She survived that and ended up here. What else is out there? What brought her? The text mentions she was caught in a current — that implies force, not chance. Something pushed her there. Meanwhile Xiao Yu is standing in the middle of all of it with a mental spreadsheet of plot disasters and nowhere to put it. "We're doomed" isn't even dramatic at this point. It's just accurate.
... Read More
Okay, let me start with the most memorably absurd scene in this entire batch. Xiao Yu wakes up and a 'beautiful young lady' is sent to serve him during his bath. His internal monologue about maids being sent in during baths like something from a novel — and then discovering the person has an Adam's apple. The comedy writing here is peak. But what's really interesting is how the plot uses this misunderstanding to reveal backstory organically. Qingyan isn't just comic relief — she's a childhood companion who knew Xiao Yu when he was raising Bai Yan on Demon Gathering Island. The plot threads are connecting nicely. Liu Shicheng is still in Sword Prison, creating tension that Xiaoyu needs to resolve. Tie Yanran's rigid sense of justice makes negotiation difficult, but the tavern incident showed he's capable of bending his rules for people he cares about. The whole 'immortal beauties photo album' subplot where Xiao Yu debates whether to give it to Tie Yanran is hilarious internal conflict — he's worried about ruining his 'noble image' in front of the kid he helped raise. World-building continues to expand through these character interactions. The Zhengqi Jue technique requiring males with strong justice conviction, Tie Mansion's connection to a super-clan, the Divine Mechanism Peak where Qingyan trains — all of this is woven naturally into conversation rather than exposition dumps. The genius rankings miscellany Xiao Yu discovers adds another layer to the power system. I'm particularly intrigued by the Whirlwind Young Master anecdote — these unofficial records of cultivators' embarrassing moments feel like they could become important plot devices later.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is absolutely lethal. Let me just highlight a few exchanges because I cannot stop thinking about them. Gong Wuyao: "You can just call me Sect Leader Gong. No need for that 'deputy' prefix." Xiao Yu: "Sure thing, Kung Fu Sect Leader." That man is playing with fire and he knows it. Every time she corrects him he doubles down harder, and the fact that she lets it slide every single time tells you everything about how deeply she's used to losing this battle. But she also holds all the actual power — she summoned him, she sets the terms, she controls his assignments and his performance evaluations. He dresses it up as mockery but he's always the one who ends up folded. Then there's Xiao Yu's internal monologue which is where the real voice lives. "Did she grow a third leg or something?" That's the kind of thought that makes you laugh out loud at 2 AM. His brain is a chaotic marketplace and every thought is screaming to be heard simultaneously. The contrast between his panicked external face and his wildly sarcastic internal commentary is chef's kiss. Xia Nianmo when she first wakes: "Where... am I?" Soft, uncertain, almost fragile. And then twenty seconds later she's introducing herself in full ceremonial title with calm grace. The shift from vulnerable to composed is so sudden it's almost comic — except it's not. It's survival. She's a Holy Maiden who has crossed the Chaotic Forbidden Sea and learned nothing about this place. Still, she puts the armor back on immediately. The dialogue does double duty here: it sounds natural AND it reveals character architecture. And Gong Wuyao's delivery when she explains the island to Xia Nianmo — "quite practiced after having explained to Xiao Yu and the Hundred Flowers Sect disciples before" — this woman has an SOP for hosting newcomers and she is not embarrassed by it. That's competence. That's a woman who has been deputy leader for five hundred years and survived by being prepared.
... Read More
Xia Nianmo looking at Xiao Yu with literal pink hearts in her eyes is both the cutest and most terrifying thing I've read all week. The visual of a Golden Core cultivator mermaid holy maiden standing behind Xiao Yu, gazing at his back with those expressionless puppy eyes, and then — boom — blushes, waves shyly, and the narrative explicitly tells us her eyes are shimmering with pink hearts. This girl has been waiting years for Ye Gongzi and now he's apparently standing right behind her and she STILL doesn't immediately connect the dots until she sniffed him. The smell recognition is such a weirdly intimate detail that somehow works perfectly for a fish-person romance. And then the moment where she asks about his legs after transforming from mermaid to human form — she does this little pose, one leg bent, basking in sunlight, skin glowing, and the narration goes out of its way to describe her figure and then immediately undercuts it with her face-planting into the ground. The tonal whiplash is intentional comedy gold. Xiao Yu's internal monologue about how mermaid tails are way more charming than two legs, and how trading that uniqueness for generic human form is like "okay I guess" — that's the most bro energy in fiction history and I love it. But beneath all the comedy, there's something genuine in Xia Nianmo's devotion. When she says "With Ye Gongzi by my side, I never need to worry or think hard" — that's not just dependency, that's trauma recovery. She's been through trials, she's been separated from her protector, and now he's here again and she's just going to follow him anywhere. Even the creepy thought about staying on the island forever and having mer-babies — yes, it's played for laughs, but it reveals how completely she's emotionally invested. Meanwhile Xiao Yu is just trying to survive the next twenty-four hours without being pulled into another protagonist-level crisis.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is wild and I mean that as a genuine compliment. You start in Liu Shicheng's room with this fairly intimate, almost melancholic conversation about loneliness and unfulfilled potential. It's got a slow, contemplative rhythm—two people talking, internal monologues, the weight of unspoken history between them. Then without any warning, you're at Divine Machine Peak and Liu Shicheng is sprinting away like his life depends on it. The transition is so abrupt it's almost jarring, which is exactly the right choice. Liu Shicheng's warning at the doorway—'are you sure you want to hire these guys'—builds genuine tension. You think something bad happened here. His slow backward retreat, the pupil constriction, the immediate sword-light escape—it reads like a horror setup. And then the payoff is a group of bodybuilders whose clothes explode simultaneously. The author commits fully to the absurdity with zero tonal hesitation. After that, the pacing settles into a different rhythm—the forced workout montage, the cultivation system exposition dump (which honestly could have dragged), and then the punchline of Xiao Yu breaking through in one morning and immediately failing at the clothes explosion joke. The structure here is essentially: build dread, subvert it completely, let the characters bounce around in the new reality for a bit, then land the final comedic beat. It's efficient and it never lets the reader get comfortable.
... Read More
Let me just say this out loud: the Protagonist Support System dropping at the end of this chapter is absolutely devastating for Xiao Yu's peaceful life. We spent fifty-plus pages watching him cling to his retirement, protect his routine, try to send Xia Nianmo away, and the final line — "YOU'VE GOT TO BE F***ING KIDDING ME!!!" — is the most honest emotional reaction in modern web fiction. The stakes shift dramatically here. Before, the conflict was low-key: keep this mermaid girl safe, get her off the island, don't let her disrupt the storyline. Manageable, right? Wrong. Because now Xiao Yu has been forcibly bound to a system that will likely drag him back into protagonist-level emergencies. The Heavenly Devil loophole that allowed him free passage is no longer enough — he's officially part of the machinery now. What makes the tension work so well is that the author makes you CARE about Xiao Yu wanting nothing to do with this. His fear isn't abstract — it's rooted in specific trauma. He's seen villains gain intelligence, elders skip straight to wiping out bloodlines, female leads bring trouble that he has to clean up. He knows exactly what happens to people involved in these stories, and he's been living in relative safety precisely because he stayed outside the narrative. Xia Nianmo's presence on the island was already a disruption — the original heroine orbiting a substitute instead of the protagonist means the story is already broken. And now the system is confirming that Xiao Yu's role isn't optional. The comedy of the earlier chapters makes the stakes feel real because we've seen what Xiao Yu is losing. His bamboo groves. His tavern mooching. His unpaid rent problems. The system doesn't care about any of that.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this dynamic because it's doing something genuinely clever. Xiao Yu is the most relatable person in this whole scene — just a dude who wanted a quiet retirement on Demon Gathering Island, living his best idle cultivator life, and suddenly a golden-core mermaid holy maiden shows up and decides he's her destined love interest. His reaction is peak "I didn't sign up for this." The moment where he actually grabs her face to physically stop her from confessing? That's not even comedic exaggeration, that's a man fighting for his emotional survival. He'd rather toss her back into the Sea of Forbidden Tides than deal with the romantic subplot. And yet, here we are. What I find really interesting is how Xia Nianmo has shifted from the original novel. In the source material she was poised, elegant, strategically brilliant — the kind of heroine who carries herself with quiet authority. But in this iteration? She's clumsy, adorably lost, dependent on Xiao Yu for literally everything. The mermaid clan trials that were supposed to be challenges she overcame alongside Ye Feng? In reality, Xiao Yu carried her through every single one. She's basically a mascot at this point, occasionally offering lap pillows as her only contribution. And yet — and this is the brilliant part — she's still absolutely convinced he's the right person. Her trust in him isn't naive, it's earned. He protected her, strategized for her, fought for her. She sees the competence beneath the reluctant exterior. Gong Wuyao's role here is also fascinating. She's basically the exhausted manager of this whole situation, tired from staying up late reading her own novel series, asking Xiao Yu to babysit Xia Nianmo as a favor. The line about being exhausted from reading novels hits different when you realize she's the one writing this story. Xiao Yu's desperation to send her away vs. Gong Wuyao's casual dismissal shows how the power dynamics work — Xiao Yu has zero leverage against anyone with actual authority.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or