A Fairy Tale for a Wicked Woman - Reviews

A Fairy Tale for a Wicked Woman
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this scene where Edith snaps at the butler is one of my absolute favorite character moments. The way she literally goes demon-face when he screams at her—"Miss Edith! You must go."—and she drops the flask, steps on the glass, and then SMILES? That is such a rich character beat. She's clearly a controlled, methodical person (we see her carefully organizing reagents, transferring samples), and then THIS happens. The image of her stomping on broken glass while forcing a smile and saying "...Fine. I'll go. For your sake, butler, this better be important" is comedic gold AND deeply revealing. And then there's Ariel and Eric. Ugh. The way she observes him, "carefully observing his actions" when she thinks he's fallen asleep... she needs him so desperately but would never say it out loud. Her internal monologue is SO sharp—"A kind-hearted, tender man is rare enough, but one who's beautiful as well is even harder to find." She's calculating and strategic, yes, but she genuinely relies on him. The dynamic between them feels like two people who care about each other deeply but express it through practical concerns rather than sentiment. She asks if he regrets letting go of the Veritatis woman, and his response—"Don't worry about me. Just think about your health. You need to stay by my side for a long, long time."—hits different. That's love language. Meanwhile, Edith and the Marquis have this weird history. "What she said" about reforms at the Academy... Brote as a child reciting in a low calm voice... it's clear Edith has been trusted with important information for a long time. The Marquis clearly values her judgment, even if he worries she's involved with the wrong people.
... Read More
Okay let's talk about the wedding scene for a second because I literally gasped out loud when Brote shut Eric down. She doesn't waver, she doesn't cry, she just looks at him like he's completely irrelevant and says "From now on, I would appreciate it if you showed proper respect to me as the Duchess of the North." Like BOOM. Done. Shut it down. The way the author builds to that moment is masterful — Eric grabs her wrist, pleads with her, says he thought she'd be fine without him, and for one heart-stopping second I actually thought she might cave. But she doesn't. She twists free and publicly humbles him in front of the entire wedding party. But here's what really got me — the narrative structure around this scene. The author weaves in flashbacks to young Brote's abuse while simultaneously moving forward through the wedding and the journey north. You get these brutal childhood memories (the Count burning her favorite fairy tale book, her falling down those endless spiral stairs) cutting between the present-day drama. It's not random — it's showing us exactly WHY Brote is the way she is. She learned early that pleading gets you nothing. That crying makes things worse. So she went silent and strategic. And then there's the Duke himself. He barely speaks in this entire batch but his presence is everywhere. "There's a little rat." That's it. Two words and suddenly Eric's world implodes. I'm also obsessed with the mystery thread — five dead wives, rumors of murder, Edith digging through Northern newspapers. The plot is piling tension on top of tension and I am HERE FOR IT.
... Read More
Okay so the prophecy stuff. I need to unpack this because I think I got played and I'm not even mad about it. Early on, the text establishes that the narrator has a book—a physical object, leather-bound, now blackened and burnt, containing a story about Brote and Eric and Madame Poporani. The story within the story: a queen's daughter kidnapped, living as a commoner, meeting her betrothed, falling in love, the fiancé being wicked, the knife at the wedding, the poison. Classic gothic romance beats. Except—except—the narrator says at one point "Just as he had said, Vivi brought up the prophecy. But I knew this situation wasn't the prophecy he had mentioned." Wait. What? She knew the difference? So the book contains prophecies, but not all prophecies in the book are actual prophecies? Or the book predicts things that turn out to be wrong? Then Rondo appears and says: "That book. The young maid will approach you saying there's a secret in that book. She'll say there was a prophecy that descended before the King, too." Okay. So the prophecy has layers. There's the prophecy in the book (which we've been reading?), and there's another prophecy that descended before the King (which may or may not be real?). And Vivi is the messenger who might be telling the truth or might be repeating lies she believes. Meanwhile there's this entire subplot about the North versus the South, about claiming the Veritatis family to be with Eric, about Madame Poporani's death being connected to a sponsorship at an orphanage that turned into an epidemic. "That she went to the orphanage for sponsorship and perished miserably from an epidemic? There couldn't be a greater falsehood." FALSEHOOD. So someone is lying about how she died? Was it murder? Was it the book? Was it the prophecy? The deepest plot twist I think is this: the narrator thinks she's reading a book, but the book might be reading her. Every time she opens it, she finds something new. The burned pages. The teal wax seal. The laurel tree symbol. These aren't just artifacts—they're clues in a puzzle that includes her as a participant, not just an observer. The prophecy descended before the King, yes, but maybe it also descended to her. Maybe that's why she's in Manderley. Maybe that's why Rondo knows her name. And what about Derien? The chapter cuts to him—"Butler... I made a mistake, didn't I?" He's watching someone. Waiting for someone to doubt him, to investigate, to believe. Is he the one who wrote the book? Is he the Count? Is he the benefactor from the story? The structural parallel between Brote in the book and the narrator in the present is too precise to ignore. I think the real plot here isn't about solving a mystery. It's about realizing you're already inside one.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are ABSURD and I love that the author never lets you forget it for even one second. Brote is being sent north to marry a Duke whose FIVE previous wives all died under mysterious circumstances. She knows the rumors. Edith knows the rumors. The whole kingdom knows the rumors. And still — she goes. Not because she's naive, but because she has NO choice. 'If he left, she would be married off to the Northern Duke like merchandise.' That's the reality she's operating under. But the internal conflict is what really gets me. Brote despises Eric showing up at her wedding, but underneath all that anger there's this devastating realization — HE had a CHOICE. He could walk away and she couldn't. He gets to come back whenever he feels guilty. She gets sent to a frozen wasteland with a potentially murderous husband and she can't even say no. Then there's the Count's abuse as a child — not physical violence but something colder. The deliberate ignoring. Throwing her beloved book into flames. Making her feel like her very existence is an annoyance. When she says in her head 'What does it matter now, Eric?' — she's not just rejecting him, she's rejecting the version of herself that once hoped for love from people who couldn't give it. And the blank book from her mother. 'Every action has its price, and that price is determined not by you but by fate.' What is Lady Brandon playing at? She sends her daughter an invitation, arranges an engagement to Eric, then hands her a book with nothing written in it. Is it a test? A trap? Something else entirely? The external stakes are life-or-death (murderous Duke, hostile family). The internal stakes are identity and survival (who is she when no one loves her). And the author is masterfully stacking both until I can barely breathe.
... Read More
The visual language in these chapters is absolutely cinematic. Let me start with the roses. They appear at least twice and each time they're described as impossibly red—"the roses blooming profusely outside the window were as red as the tea. Like they would never wither, like flowing blood." That's not just decoration. Those roses are a ticking clock, a reminder that everything beautiful in this mansion is also something that bleeds. And then she thinks about making a bouquet from them, which is such a weird, almost unhinged detail that makes me wonder if she's planning something or just fantasizing about a normal woman's domestic act she'll never get to have. Then there's the festival scene—this moment where she slips away from her own life for like twenty minutes and gets hit by this wave of sensory overload. The flower scent so intense it makes her head ache, the crowded square, the open sky described as "lighter than dawn and spotted with white patches, yet still brilliantly blue and impossibly high." It's almost too bright, too alive, and it physically hurts her. She hunches over like she can't breathe, and then just as quickly it passes, which makes me think this might not be entirely psychological. "Brote, look at this. If you turn your back and throw a coin into the fountain, your wish will come true." The fountain memory is perfect—because what wish could she possibly throw in there now? She's about to marry an old man she's never met and leave everything behind. And the sky stays impossibly blue above her the whole time, indifferent to the fact that her life is being rearranged without her consent. The contrast between the vibrant, alive world outside and the suffocating mansion interior is doing so much heavy lifting here.
... Read More
Okay so this part had me absolutely glued to the page. Let me just say—Brote walking on the red carpet a day early? That is the single most atmospheric way to set up a wedding that already feels like a funeral. The author clearly knows how to build dread without ever raising the stakes with actual action. You just feel it coming. And then EDITH'S EXIT. I am not okay with this. She hugs Brote, packs her bags, and just leaves on what should be the happiest day of Brote's life? What kind of person does that to a friend?! But also—I get it? Like, Edith saw something and decided she couldn't be there anymore? Or maybe she was genuinely heartbroken for Brote and couldn't pretend? Either way, it hits different. Then Oscar shows up. Of course he shows up. The man literally drops a velvet pouch of money on his bride-to-be's step and tells her to run away. BROTE. He could've said ANYTHING. Instead he just hands her cash and pleads? And she shuts him down by dropping the coldest truth bomb in the book: "In just two seasons, Oscar, you too will no longer be a child. You'll become an adult responsible for Veritatis. That means becoming someone who can easily sell off your sister." I SCREAMED. That line alone is worth the price of admission. It reframes EVERYTHING about this family. The Count didn't raise his children with love—he raised them to be assets. And Brote just accepted her price while Oscar is still figuring out what the game is. The Duke himself? Introduced as wrinkled, scarred, one-handed, with "red eyes that seemed to have evaded the passage of time." The man is a walking mystery wrapped in tragedy and he's about to marry her. I NEED to know what happens next.
... Read More
Okay so the atmosphere in this section is genuinely top-tier. First of all — the North. I went in expecting some generic frozen wasteland trope, but no. The author literally describes it as unexpectedly GREEN. Pointed coniferous forests everywhere, wind that seems to carry a blue tint under the white sky, a blue-green maze garden. That imagery hit me so hard I had to pause because it's such a deliberate subversion of the cold-isolated-mansion cliché. It's beautiful but still... off? Like nothing here is what it seems. But the real standout scene has to be the descent into that hidden library. You've got the curtain at the end of the corridor — why is a library hidden behind a curtain?? — then the small wooden door you have to stoop through, the flickering magic lamps that take forever to light up, and then the absolute silence of going deeper where even the magic fails. The description of reaching down into that darkness with only Vivi's crimson light bobbing ahead, the acrid-sweet-bitter scent hitting you, the sound of her heel echoing: thud, thud, thud. I swear I could hear that. And then the reveal — giant oak barrels stretching into infinity, candlelight twinkling behind Vivi like she's standing under a sky of fireflies while kneeling and begging. The contrast between the beauty of that image and the absolute dread it sends through you? Chef's kiss. This author knows how to make a setting feel ALIVE and threatening at the same time.
... Read More
Can we talk about Edith for a second though because she's carrying so much emotional weight in these chapters and barely anyone notices except the reader? She's sitting there with Marquis Hopper drinking pink tea that's 'sickeningly sweet' and he's looking past her at empty space. She knows exactly what he's thinking about - some girl who's gone, who 'acted like she knew the future but didn't know her own.' Edith clicks her tongue when she catches herself doing it, which is such a small detail but tells us everything about how she's trying to become someone new while being haunted by who she used to be. And then Brote's moment collapsing onto the bed after finally letting her guard down. The text says 'I just... wanted to live well. Here, in this new land. In the North where no one knew me. Without anyone doubting anything.' That's not a hero's declaration. That's someone who's exhausted from performing competence every single day. The fact that she immediately starts worrying whether she was too friendly with the knight or whether Miriam looked down on her - she's so fragile underneath all that calculated behavior. The friendship thread between these two women who've never met but are both playing roles is something I didn't expect to care about this much. Edith thinks Brote is lazy and worthless and Brote probably thinks Edith is perfect and untouchable. Both are wrong and both are right.
... Read More
The sensory detail in this section is INSANE. Let me just breathe for a second. "The stars shone brightly overhead, like a black sea of night unfurled above me. Breathing in the faint scent of roses surrounding the annex." I could literally smell that garden. The author didn't just describe a setting—they made the air itself feel alive. And the roses aren't just decoration; they're everywhere. Picked to color the entire mansion red. Swollen blossoms described as "ready to fall," their scent shifting from fresh to intoxicatingly sweet—to the point where Brote gets dizzy from it. These flowers are supposed to distract from the scandal, to make everything look like a fairy tale. But they also feel overwhelming, almost suffocating. The portrait scene gave me actual chills. Brote walking through the dark salon, fingertips tracing the wall, finding the golden frame with its rose patterns. "Gradually, the roses carved like deep scars became visible." That line. Those roses aren't decorative—they're carved like wounds. And then the dress in the painting: "what appeared black but was actually a purple dress." Purple. Gloomy. Unhappy. And Brote looking at her own reflection in that portrait, seeing her mother's face becoming her own. "I wondered if there was some curse flowing through our bloodline." The house itself feels like a character. The Veritatis estate with its annex, corridors, rose gardens, vaulted ceilings—all of it built on money and arranged marriages and women who were traded like currency. Even the wedding preparations feel wrong: the white veil, the red bouquet, the bishop's voice, the heavy bridal makeup. Everything is costume and performance. And then the Duke himself appears—"physically impaired," with thin thighs, a deeply wrinkled hand struggling with the ring, dark freckles, sunken cheekbones. Not a monster. Not a beast. Just... an ordinary man aged beyond his years. Brote feels relief that he isn't repulsive. I felt relief for her. She had braced herself for a nightmare and got something bearable instead.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the dialogue in this book operates like a weapon. Every conversation between Brote and Oscar is packed with subtext so thick you could cut it with a knife—and I mean that literally because she specifically mentions she didn't hold a knife to anyone's throat. Let's start with Oscar's entrance. He doesn't say "I love you." He doesn't say "I made a mistake." He says: "Take this" and tosses her a pouch of money. Then: "Stop being pathetic here and leave." He can barely form the words of a proper plea. His sentences are fragmented, desperate, almost insulting—because if he's mean enough, maybe she'll actually run away with him? Or maybe he's so bad at expressing emotion that kindness feels impossible? And Brote's response? Cold. Precise. Final. "Oscar, enough." "You're no longer a child either." "Everything has its price. You don't get to choose that price. So accept it." She speaks in complete thoughts while he stammers. She's the adult in the room even though he's older. She's already accepted her fate and freed him from the guilt he's carrying. And it BREAKS him. "Oscar's face crumpled sorrowfully, as though he'd just heard words of curse from me." But the real masterpiece is the dialogue with the Count. Short, clipped exchanges: "Brote. Don't be foolish." "It's... love, Father. Please honor Madame Poporani's wishes." "Hah, Brote. Pity is not love." "No. Pity is also a form of love. At least for me." "...Foolish girl. Fine. Do as you please." The father calls her foolish, dismisses her reasoning, and lets her go—not because he cares about her happiness, but because it's easier than fighting. And Brote's internal narration confirms it: "the Count had never truly supported my engagement to Eric." This isn't a father blessing his daughter's marriage. This is a merchant closing a deal. And the Duke? His entire contribution to the dialogue is three lines: "I do." "That will do." and "Brote. Winter." Three phrases. Three shifts in power. He speaks less than anyone else in the book and somehow controls every scene he's in. The author is playing a long game with this character and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about that chandelier scene?? Eric wakes up from this nightmare and the image of the princess is GONE—he literally rubs his cheek where she kissed him and wipes it off like he's cleaning filth. That is so DARK and I need a moment. Earlier we see him groaning 'Eric!' as if he's dreaming about Brote, but then he opens his eyes and it's Ariel standing over him. The fact that he immediately associates the princess with cold sweat and then wipes away her kiss? That woman gave him her last breath, called him her everything, and he treats her memory like dirt on his cheek. Meanwhile Oscar is out here having his own crisis on the terrace, calling himself a hypocrite because he didn't stop his sister from going North. Both brothers are wrecks in completely different ways—Oscar paralyzed by fear and self-preservation, Eric actively rejecting the one person who loved him unconditionally. And the protagonist? She's lying in bed in the North, having woken up after four days unconscious, and she's already being handed dead women's clothes to wear. The emotional weight in this section is absolutely crushing. Everyone is trapped—by family duty, by guilt, by fear, by death. Nobody is free.
... Read More
Let me just say: the pacing in these chapters is absolutely obscene. Not in the sexual sense, though there is that energy too. I mean obscene like illegal, like against nature, like someone shouldn't be able to construct narrative tension this efficiently and still have room for poetic aside. Watch what happens from the first paragraph. "Grrr..." in an empty clearing. One sound. Then "Awooo-!" another. Then "Woof." and suddenly there's a pack. The howling doesn't escalate gradually—it multiplies. Each paragraph adds one more sensory detail until the clearing is full of darkness and sound and you're running before you've even processed why. That's structure doing work, not just description. Inside the spire: "Round and round, robbed of my sense of time and space in the darkness, I couldn't guess how much time had passed or how many floors I had climbed." This is where most authors would lose you—too much time in transit, too little destination. But the author keeps the stakes present: dogs below, shadows increasing, the physical act of climbing itself becoming a metaphor for escaping one threat only to encounter another. The staircase is neither relief nor danger—it's suspended animation. Then the room. The portrait. The entrance of Rondo. And suddenly the chapter shifts from survival thriller to psychological drama in one paragraph. "The man revealed himself in the light." That's a structural pivot so clean you'd swear it was measured. From external threat to interpersonal threat—the escalation is seamless because both are forms of being watched, being pursued, being trapped. The dialogue section that follows? Brutal in its pacing. Rondo speaks, narrator reacts, Rondo circles back with advice that might be manipulation, then pivots to prophecy. Each exchange advances three plots simultaneously: the immediate danger, the mystery of the book, the larger political situation with the North and the Academy. No scene breathes unnecessarily. No line exists purely for atmosphere unless that atmosphere IS the point—which it sometimes is. And that ending? "Throughout hundreds of seasonal changes, Manderley remained ever green." Cut from the spire to Derien in his office, watching the old man doze. Time jump, new POV, same tension. The chapter doesn't end—it fractures. Like the book itself, the narrative splits and multiplies. You finish this chapter wanting to immediately open the next one, not because you've learned something, but because you haven't learned enough yet.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or