Okay so the prophecy stuff. I need to unpack this because I think I got played and I'm not even mad about it.
Early on, the text establishes that the narrator has a book—a physical object, leather-bound, now blackened and burnt, containing a story about Brote and Eric and Madame Poporani. The story within the story: a queen's daughter kidnapped, living as a commoner, meeting her betrothed, falling in love, the fiancé being wicked, the knife at the wedding, the poison. Classic gothic romance beats. Except—except—the narrator says at one point "Just as he had said, Vivi brought up the prophecy. But I knew this situation wasn't the prophecy he had mentioned." Wait. What? She knew the difference? So the book contains prophecies, but not all prophecies in the book are actual prophecies? Or the book predicts things that turn out to be wrong?
Then Rondo appears and says: "That book. The young maid will approach you saying there's a secret in that book. She'll say there was a prophecy that descended before the King, too." Okay. So the prophecy has layers. There's the prophecy in the book (which we've been reading?), and there's another prophecy that descended before the King (which may or may not be real?). And Vivi is the messenger who might be telling the truth or might be repeating lies she believes.
Meanwhile there's this entire subplot about the North versus the South, about claiming the Veritatis family to be with Eric, about Madame Poporani's death being connected to a sponsorship at an orphanage that turned into an epidemic. "That she went to the orphanage for sponsorship and perished miserably from an epidemic? There couldn't be a greater falsehood." FALSEHOOD. So someone is lying about how she died? Was it murder? Was it the book? Was it the prophecy?
The deepest plot twist I think is this: the narrator thinks she's reading a book, but the book might be reading her. Every time she opens it, she finds something new. The burned pages. The teal wax seal. The laurel tree symbol. These aren't just artifacts—they're clues in a puzzle that includes her as a participant, not just an observer. The prophecy descended before the King, yes, but maybe it also descended to her. Maybe that's why she's in Manderley. Maybe that's why Rondo knows her name.
And what about Derien? The chapter cuts to him—"Butler... I made a mistake, didn't I?" He's watching someone. Waiting for someone to doubt him, to investigate, to believe. Is he the one who wrote the book? Is he the Count? Is he the benefactor from the story? The structural parallel between Brote in the book and the narrator in the present is too precise to ignore.
I think the real plot here isn't about solving a mystery. It's about realizing you're already inside one.