The Middle Ages Were Frustrating, So I Became the Pope - Reviews

The Middle Ages Were Frustrating, So I Became the Pope
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Edward III here, specifically because even though he doesn't physically appear in this chapter, his presence is absolutely everywhere and it's one of the most interesting narrative choices I've encountered. The author doesn't just name-drop Edward III as a plotting device. They build him into the scene through In-ho's analysis, and the result is a portrait of a rival so vivid you'd swear he was sitting at the table. 'Edward III is currently in a desperate situation... He desperately needs authority and prestige.' That's not speculation—that's In-ho reading his opponent's psychology like a text. And the terrifying thing is that he's probably right. What fascinates me is the symmetry the author keeps building between Philip VI and Edward III. Both are relatively new kings (Edward took power in 1330 after a coup, Philip in 1328 after a succession crisis). Both need military glory to legitimize their rule. Both are trapped by their circumstances and making calculated moves. In-ho explicitly notes this: 'In some ways, Edward III and Philip VI were strangely similar.' This isn't just worldbuilding—it's setting up a double mirror where both kings reflect each other, and In-ho stands between them like a conductor. But here's where it gets personal for me. Reading In-ho's internal monologue about how he's operating: 'The original Pierre Roger, Clement VI, would never give such an answer. Will this even be acceptable? But... there is no other way.' This is the first time we've gotten direct access to In-ho's fear. He's not a confident omniscient protagonist; he's a transmigrated person improvising with incomplete information, hoping his historical knowledge maps correctly onto this reality. The vulnerability here makes him infinitely more human—and infinitely more compelling. And the relationship between In-ho and Philip VI is evolving in real time across these pages. At the start, Philip is confused and slightly dismissive ('Wait a minute... My noble friend. What do you mean?'—). By the end, he's gripped in agony over the Scotland decision, looking at In-ho with 'agonized voice.' In-ho has gone from advisor to someone whose proposals are simultaneously brilliant and devastating. Philip trusts him enough to listen but fears him enough to flinch. That's a relationship built on the sharpest possible edge. I also keep coming back to this line: 'The lords and Philip VI felt that In-ho's expression was endlessly wicked, but none of them spoke it out loud.' 'Endlessly wicked'—that's not a neutral description. That's the moment the other characters realize they're playing with someone who operates by different moral rules. And the fact that they CAN'T speak it? That's the political reality of the story: the smartest person in the room is also the most dangerous, and everyone is too calculating to call it out.
... Read More
'In-ho had transmigrated into Clement VI, before he had even become the pope. Roughly 16 years remaining until the outbreak of the Black Death.' I need to just sit with that sentence for a moment. SIXTEEN YEARS. The single most devastating thing about this setup isn't that he woke up in the past—it's that he has a COUNTDOWN. Every chapter he reads, every conversation he has, there's this invisible timer ticking away in the background. The Black Death isn't some distant threat; it's a horror movie playing on loop in the reader's mind while the characters go about their business completely unaware. But here's what makes the stakes genuinely suffocating: Clement VI isn't even Pope yet. He's just the Archbishop of Rouen. He has influence, yes, but he's still climbing. The real power structure involves Philip VI of France, the complex relationship between the Papacy and secular monarchs, the Doctrine of the Two Swords—the whole medieval political ecosystem. Our protagonist is theoretically aware of all this because he studied it, but knowing history and NAVIGATING it are two wildly different things. One wrong word to the wrong lord, one misread factional alliance, and boom—he's dead in 1331 with his time loop broken. And then there's the Black Death itself. The text explicitly shows In-ho's frustration: Clement VI historically did NOTHING meaningful about it. He 'merely focused on burying the victims and conducting pastoral activities.' The author is making us watch a modern person scream internally at medieval incompetence, and that creates this almost physical anxiety in the reader. Every time something trivial happens, we want to shake the character and yell 'THE PLAGUE IS COMING, YOU IDIOT.' That's the kind of dramatic tension that keeps you reading at 2 AM.
... Read More
I need to talk about Philip VI because this man is the most interesting character in this entire scene and honestly he's suffering so much right now. Look at him. He walks into this council meeting wanting to launch a Crusade, probably dreaming about glory and holy conquest, and instead In-ho completely hijacks his entire agenda and turns it into a financial instrument. And the worst part? Philip VI is the one who benefits the most from this. The narrative literally says: "The one most pleased by these words was Philip VI." He should be standing up and cheering, but instead he's sitting there with this agonized face because In-ho just suggested letting England invade Scotland. That duality is everything. Philip VI is a king who 'knew his political standing was lacking and worked hard to make up for it'—the narrator tells us this explicitly—and yet here he is, being outmaneuvered by a man who is technically just an Archbishop but somehow wields more political power than all the lords combined. There's something deeply satisfying about watching a legitimately insecure king slowly realize that the only way to strengthen his position is to hand the reins to someone else. And then there's In-ho himself, and wow. The way he reads the room is almost supernatural. When Philip VI groans about Edward III, In-ho doesn't just offer a solution—he offers a complete psychological profile of his rival. "Edward III is currently in a desperate situation... He desperately needs authority and prestige." This man understands his enemies better than his enemies understand themselves. That's not just intelligence; that's a particular kind of cold, clinical empathy that makes In-ho genuinely intimidating as a character. What strikes me most is the contrast between In-ho's calm, almost playful delivery and the sheer violence of what he's proposing. He slaps the table confidently, smirks when challenged, speaks in gentle analogies—and meanwhile he's orchestrating something that will redraw the map of Europe. "The lords and Philip VI felt that In-ho's expression was endlessly wicked"—and they're right, but they can't bring themselves to say it out loud. That moment of shared recognition without verbal acknowledgment? That's peak political fiction. I also love how Philip VI and Edward III are described as 'strangely similar'—both new kings, both needing military victories to legitimize their rule, both trapped by their circumstances. In-ho sees this symmetry and decides to exploit it rather than exploit one side against the other. That's a different kind of genius than what we usually see in these novels. He's not playing favor—it's more like he's conducting an orchestra and making sure every instrument plays its part.
... Read More
'If his suspicions were correct, this situation was far more serious than he thought.' 'In-ho groaned.' 'I'm screwed.' OK so this protagonist has the emotional range and vocabulary of every overworked Korean grad student ever, and I am HERE for it. The voice is what sold me immediately. You'd expect a transmigrated protagonist to have this gravitas, this Shakespearean weight of destiny—but no. He's just a tired 26-year-old whose first thought after discovering he's literally a bishop is 'damn it, why is this vestment so uncomfortable' and 'I would rather have a suit.' The internal monologue is where the real flavor is though. The comparison to coming up with excuses when his mom catches him secretly using the computer? That's such a specific, culturally grounded detail that makes him feel like an actual human being rather than some generic isekai vessel. And the way the narrative voice shifts between his sharp political analysis and his completely unglamorous inner complaints creates this constant comedic tension. One moment he's quoting Hans Morgenthau on political power, the next he's annoyed about his coffee cup leaking. The external dialogue works too—there's a nice contrast between the formal, almost theatrical speech of the court servants ('Lord Pierre Roger!' 'Our liege will be furious!') and In-ho's increasingly bewildered internal reactions. You can feel the culture shock building with every exchange. The author doesn't overdo the archaic language; it's just enough to establish the setting without turning into a history textbook. And the humor lands because it's earned through character, not just random quips.
... Read More
I keep coming back to that one word: warmth. "When I touched it, there was still warmth..." It becomes this incredible symbol that holds the entire thematic weight of these chapters. Warmth represents everything the story is asking us to consider. Is it the warmth of life—evidence the child wasn't truly dead? Is it the warmth of the Holy Spirit? Is it the warmth of a mother's love transferred through her grip on her child? Or is it, as Benedict XII darkly suggests, the warmth of a demon trying to bewitch you? The same physical sensation contains every possible interpretation, and that's the point. The story is fundamentally about interpretation—about how we choose to read the world, how we decide what counts as miracle and what counts as blasphemy. In-ho's entire defense rests on this ambiguity. "Frankly speaking, I cannot distinguish whether that warmth came from the child or if it was the warmth of the mother." He's admitting uncertainty while simultaneously using it as his strongest argument. The warmth was real regardless of its source, and that reality compelled action. Then there's the Beatific Vision itself—the direct encounter with God. This theological controversy about WHEN souls see God perfectly mirrors In-ho's personal crisis: can he see a path to salvation even when doctrine says none exists? The question of whether the dead child's soul could be reached through baptism is the microcosm of the macrocosmic debate he's about to tackle in Paris. And what about that line: "I am a priest before I am an archbishop"? It's a declaration of identity that cuts against institutional authority. The story keeps asking: who gets to define truth? The Canon Law? The Pope? Or the person standing in front of a dead child feeling warmth they can't explain? The answer, I think, is deliberately left uncomfortable.
... Read More
Can we talk about In-ho and Philip VI for a second because this relationship is absolutely tragic in the best way? On the surface, they're friends. The king calls him "my friend" repeatedly. He laughs, he shares wine, he's planning cathedrals in In-ho's honor. But every single interaction between them has this undercurrent of mutual calculation. In-ho drinks terrible spiced wine and smiles. Philip watches him do it and knows he's being played. They're both performing friendship while holding knives behind their backs. The most heartbreaking moment isn't dramatic at all — it's when Philip asks In-ho to sit and drink with him, and In-ho thinks: "'He's cheerful. That cheerfulness is a problem for me, though.'" That internal scream. The man who just dismantled the entire Franciscan Order on live TV can't bring himself to say no to a glass of bad wine from a king who could have him executed tomorrow. And Philip — oh, Philip is lonely. He's drunk, singing songs about his mistress, waving his glass, pretending everything is fine. But when he finally dismisses the attendants and goes silent, the mask drops. He admits he's afraid. Of Edward III. Of war. Of losing everything. He turns to In-ho not as a subordinate but as someone he trusts, and that trust is built on convenience and desperation. There's no romance here, no familial bond, but there IS something deeper. Two men trapped in a dying world, using each other to stay afloat. In-ho needs Philip's authority to save Europe from the Black Death and the Hundred Years' War. Philip needs In-ho's mind to hold his crumbling kingdom together. They're friends in the way survivors are friends — bound by necessity, tested by betrayal, sustained by something that might actually be genuine if you squint hard enough. I don't know if either of them realizes how much they need each other. I definitely know they'll hurt each other eventually. But god, I can't stop watching.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the plot architecture here because this section is genuinely brilliant. The whole thing starts with this impossible situation—a dead child, a desperate mother, and In-ho faced with either following doctrine or doing something heretical. And he chooses the heretical path, but with such a calculated emotional argument that it basically weaponizes mercy. What I love is how the plot immediately pivots. You think he's won? Nope. The next chapter is essentially a trap wrapped in an opportunity. Benedict XII summons him to the Papal Court and frames it as a chance to redeem himself, but it's really sending him to defuse the most dangerous theological time bomb in medieval Europe—the Beatific Vision Controversy. It's a classic move by a former Inquisitor who knows exactly how to turn a problem into a test that could get you killed. The confrontation scene between In-ho and the Pope is where the plot really shines. Benedict XII corners him with Canon Law, the Council of Carthage, all these logical arguments that should crush any defense. But In-ho doesn't fight fire with fire—he shifts the entire battlefield to emotion and faith. "If we must abandon our universal compassion and love to follow Canon Law... what difference is there between us and the Pharisees?" Boom. He turns the Pope's own scripture against him. And then the twist within the twist—Benedict XII isn't trying to destroy him. He's testing him. "There is one way I can acknowledge that you have performed a miracle." The Pope is essentially saying: prove yourself worthy of mercy by solving an unsolvable problem. It's a brilliant narrative payoff because everything leads back to that opening moment—In-ho risking everything for two souls, and now his own future depends on resolving a controversy that has stumped theologians for decades. The ending hook is perfect. "For In-ho, this was no different from an Open-book Exam." We know how this controversy ends in history. The author is setting up dramatic irony where the reader has information the characters don't. Absolutely delicious.
... Read More
Okay let's talk about what just went down because this guy literally walked into chaos on purpose and I am so here for it. In-ho's whole plan is this elaborate geopolitical chess move where he tricks Edward III into getting his war funds tied up through the Crusade Preparation Fund while secretly letting England annex Scotland... wait, no. He pretends to let it happen behind closed doors while publicly distracting him. Then he goes TO Scotland himself to militarize it. So basically he's walking into the middle of a ticking bomb with one year until Edward III invades and saying 'I got this.' And then the FIRST thing that happens when he arrives is that the royal court is literally screaming at each other about whether to surrender. "Wouldn't it be better to just surrender in advance and protect our territories!" What a joke these lords are. Meanwhile the seven-year-old king is holding onto his crown like it's the only thing keeping him grounded, which is honestly both hilarious and heartbreaking. What I love about this plot turn is that In-ho KNOWS exactly how dangerous this is. He looks at the shabby castle, talks to a guard who literally warns him 'you could die without a sound,' and still walks into that room full of panicked men. That's not bravado — that's a man who's calculated the odds and decided to bet everything on his one edge: modern military training in the 14th century. The line 'The game had already begun. All that remained was to follow the set opening, just like in chess' gave me actual chills. This is a guy who sees history itself as a game board and he's about to make his first real move. And chapter ends with him stepping into a room full of people who are ready to throw hands at the Regent. What could possibly go wrong? 😂
... Read More
I need to talk about Benedict XII because this man is genuinely terrifying and I love him for it. He's introduced as this frail, inflexible old man whose presence alone makes In-ho feel like he's standing in front of a massive cliff. That's some serious atmospheric character writing right there. But what's fascinating is the dynamic between him and In-ho. Benedict XII clearly knows In-ho better than anyone—maybe even better than In-ho knows himself. When he says "I also know you are not someone who acts recklessly," he's acknowledging that In-ho's impulsive baptism wasn't impulsive at all. It was a calculated risk dressed up as compassion. The Pope plays this incredible game during their confrontation. He pushes and prods, asks loaded questions, threatens the Inquisition—all while subtly giving In-ho room to maneuver. Watch this exchange: "I didn't call you here to listen to such excuses. You are in a very precarious situation right now." He's stating the obvious while simultaneously telling In-ho that the situation IS precarious. Then he pivots: "Speak honestly. Why did you do it?" And when In-ho launches into his passionate defense, Benedict XII doesn't shut him down—he engages. He counters with Canon Law, with theology, with the Council of Carthage. But he never once suggests sending him to the Inquisition. Why? Because Benedict XII needs him. "You are still not cleared of the charge of violating Canon Law. It is because I believe that if you have such a shameless tongue even in front of me, you will be able to clean up even the absurd remarks of the Previous Pope." Translation: you're useless to me dead, and too dangerous to leave unchecked. The relationship between them is this beautiful tension between mentor and student, predator and prey, judge and defendant—all happening simultaneously. And Benedict XII's final line about the Beatific Vision Controversy being his test? That's not mercy. That's a wolf offering a lamb a map to find its own way out of the forest.
... Read More
I need to talk about this kid because my heart is actually breaking for him. David II is SEVEN years old. SEVEN. And he's sitting on a throne his father died defending, while grown men argue about whether they should just roll over and let the English walk all over them. The text says he was 'desperately holding onto his loose crown with an expression like he was about to cry.' Just imagine that — a child king whose crown literally doesn't even fit his head anymore, and his whole kingdom is falling apart around him. And then there's Thomas Randolph, the regent. This guy is standing next to the kid, face pale, veins popping as he shouts at lords who are trying to overthrow his strategy. He's trying his best with zero resources and a population that's lost all faith. The text says his voice was hoarse — he's been screaming himself raw trying to hold this together. But what really got me was that moment with the guard. This random soldier, doing his job at a crumbling castle wall, stops to literally warn In-ho: 'No matter how noble an Archbishop you are, you could die without a sound.' And then he gives him actual strategic advice about how different Scotland is from France. This is a man who has accepted his country is doomed but still shows up to work every day. That's not despair — that's something way more complicated. And In-ho himself. Oh god. Here's a man who left his entire world — his rank, his training, his life — to come to a place he's never seen, in a time he shouldn't exist in, carrying the weight of preventing a hundred years of war. And his first thought upon arriving isn't 'I'm a hero' — it's 'I messed up volunteering for this.' The seasickness scene is almost comedic but underneath it is this massive loneliness. He can't tell anyone what he really is. He can only pray his military knowledge translates to a world that hasn't even invented half the things he knows. I'm already emotionally invested in these people and we've only met them. What is this book doing to me.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I respect it so much. We open with In-ho physically suffering — seasick, miserable, regretting every life choice that led him to this moment — and the author doesn't let up for a single second. The journey IS the suffering. Every wave, every smell, every 'Blergh' keeps building this sense of how brutal medieval travel actually was. You're not just reading about it, you're uncomfortable WITH him. Then we hit land and the scene shifts instantly. No 'and then they rode for a while' — we're immediately at the castle, and the author drops this gem: 'After passing a few settlements that were hard to even call villages, the Royal Castle stood there all alone.' One sentence tells you everything about Scotland's desperation. No fanfare, no exposition dump — just a kid riding toward a pile of rocks and realizing his French fairy tale is a lie. The guard conversation is perfectly paced too. It starts slow — In-ho asking questions, the guard being dismissive — then the silver coin flips the whole dynamic and suddenly we're getting world-building from a man who just wants to get paid and go home. The information drops feel natural, not forced. 'The king is 7 years old?' That reveal hits right when you need it. And then BOOM — In-ho walks into a screaming match and the chapter ends with 'What a truly funny situation' as everyone turns to look at him. The escalation from lonely seasick guy to central figure in a political crisis happens in roughly 3,000 words and I was completely gripped the whole time. The author knows exactly when to speed up and when to let a moment breathe. No dragged-out descriptions, no unnecessary filler. Every paragraph earns its place.
... Read More
This debate scene is layered with symbolism that I keep coming back to. The whole Beatific Vision controversy revolves around WHERE the soul goes — under the altar, in front of the throne, somewhere in between. And In-ho's masterstroke isn't even theological, it's political. He compares the space under the altar to the space under a king's throne, and suddenly sacred text becomes secular power dynamics. Philip himself says it: "It was very secular and much to my liking." That word — secular — is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. The entire debate is about whether the soul can achieve direct communion with God, and In-ho reframes it as a question of proximity to power. Who gets to stand closest? Who is truly seen? The martyrs aren't banished under the altar; they're the king's closest attendants. Brilliant. But the deeper symbol here is the lantern metaphor. One of the monks says: "Do we not possess the lantern known as the Bible? Although, even when looking at that lantern, it is highly questionable whether we are truly seeing it properly." This is the book winking at us. The Bible is the lantern — it illuminates, but it's also imperfect. Interpretation is the real battleground. In-ho wins not because he has better theology, but because he controls the narrative. And then there's the wine. Sweet, astringent, smelling of medicinal herbs. Philip adding cloves and nutmeg — Eastern spices, luxury goods — to mask the taste. The king is performing civility, performing warmth, but everything is slightly off. You can taste the rot underneath. That's Europe in 1328. That's a civilization holding itself together while the plague looms and wars brew on the horizon. The celebration is fake. The friendship is conditional. And In-ho drinks it anyway because survival sometimes means swallowing poison.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or